Reformed Churchmen

We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879

Showing posts with label Dever. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dever. Show all posts

Friday, October 26, 2012

SGM-Mahaneygate: Challies, Mohler, Duncan, Piper, Sproul, Carson, Dever, MacArthur, Grudemn, DeYoung, Trueman, Chandler

Co-defendant, C. J. Mahaney, in Child and Sex Abuse Lawsuit


Sage and orbital musings by Brent Detwiler about SGM-Mahaneygate.

http://www.brentdetwiler.com/brentdetwilercom/2012/10/26/random-thoughts-on-recent-events.html

Random Thoughts on Recent Events
Church Polity: This Sunday the Board of Directors will send the polity proposal they adopted to the SGM pastors. I think it will be a combination of Presbyterian and independent. They probably hope it will serve as a distraction from the class action lawsuit.

Challies: I wonder if pro-C.J. blogger, Tim Challies, will tell his readers not to read the lawsuit like he did my documents.

Mohler & Duncan: I wonder if Al Mohler, President of The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary (SBTS) and Ligon Duncan, noted Presbyterian churchman, will vilify the plaintiffs and call all the charges in the lawsuit slanderous? That’s what they’ve done in the past with anyone who speaks against C.J.

SBTS Trustees: What does the Board of Trustees at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary think now about the cozy relationship between C.J., SGM and the seminary now? I doubt they’ll make a 100k contribution like C.J. did in 2008 to help cover lawyer’s fees.

C.J.’s Circle of Friends: Will men like John Piper, R.C. Sproul, D.A. Carson, Mark Dever, John MacArthur, Wayne Grudem, Kevin DeYoung, Carl Trueman, Matt Chandler, et al., continue to actively support C.J. by having him speak in their churches, participate in their conferences, endorse his books, etc. It will interesting to see if any of these men grant an interview on the SGM website commending C.J. and SGM until the lawsuit is resolved.

Name of Church: Now would be a good time for any church with Sovereign Grace in their name to change it.

Molestation Policies: Churches need to have policies and procedures in place to protect against child abuse at all church functions (home groups, seminars, retreats), not just on Sunday morning.
   
Sex Offender Register: Every church should have a sex offender register on their website. Require this of your pastors.

Leave of Absence for President and Chairman: The SGM Board of Directors should relieve President Mahaney and Chairman Loftness of their responsibilities until the lawsuit is resolved - not as an admission of guilt but as a precaution.

Mahaney and Loftness Fired: If SGM, Mahaney, and Loftness are successfully sued for covering up child molestation they should be immediately fired by the Board of Directors.

Pastors Who Cover up Molestation: Every church needs to find out how their pastors have handled sexual and spousal abuse in their church in the past. Did they contact the police, etc. Demand an accounting. Church members must find out if sexual abuse was covered up.

Civil Versus Criminal Suit: Think of O.J. Simpson. He was not found guilty in a criminal court but he was found liable in a civil court. One article I read explained it this way. “The burden of proof in criminal matters is ‘beyond a reasonable doubt,’ which is much more difficult to achieve than the ‘preponderance of evidence’ standard used in most civil cases…. The civil justice system does not determine an offender’s guilt or innocence, but works to determine whether the offender is liable for the harm caused to the victim…. This burden of proof essentially means that one side’s evidence must be more persuasive than the other; this is far lower than the burden necessary in a criminal case.”

Monetary and Equitable Relief: “A plaintiff can either ask for monetary relief, or equitable relief. Monetary relief is when the plaintiff asks for a cash award to remedy the situation. Equitable relief is when the plaintiff asks for the court to order the other party to do or not to do something” (“The Difference between Civil Courts and Criminal Courts,” The Leadership Conference). If SGM or any of the defendants are liable, I hope the plaintiff’s ask for both kinds of relief. I assume they can require SGM to take action that prevents the cover up of child molestation in the future.

Liability Insurance: SGM has liability insurance but I don’t believe it covers the kind of malpractice alleged in the class action lawsuit. If I am correct, that means SGM will have to pay all lawyer fees and damages awarded by the court if found liable. That could bankrupt SGM. I assume individual defendants will also have to cover their own their own expenses and damages if found liable. May the innocent be vindicated and the guilty held accountable. I don’t want to see anyone harmed financially or otherwise who is not guilty.
    
Additional Defendants: More defendants should be named in the lawsuit. I can think of a few in light of recent revelations. I’m sure the attorneys are busy taking names and gathering information.

Ambassadors of Reconciliation: Ed Kober and Ed Keinath defended SGM in “Cases Involving Sexual Misconduct” on page 19 as found in their April 10, 2012, Ambassadors of Reconciliatlion Report to the Sovereign Grace Ministries Board of Directors. They said the following. “Some raising their concerns alleged that SGM consistently handles such cases in irresponsible ways. While we did not complete detailed reviews of cases involving sexual misconduct, we were able to review documentation in some situations that demonstrated the SGM leadership understood the gravity of the situations. SGM leaders offered care and concern, they sought professional legal and counseling help for SGM and key leaders involved, and in some cases they helped connect parties to Christian mediators.” This amounted to a complete vindication of Sovereign Grace Ministries. AoR should also be name as a defendant in the lawsuit. If the allegations in the lawsuit are true, then at least some of the plaintiffs made this clear to Ted and Ed. They did nothing but commend SGM in their report.
 
Stop Giving: How can anyone be donating money to Sovereign Grace Ministries? Last year they paid out over 400k to cover the cost for Ambassadors of Reconciliation and the corrupt Three Panel Review. This year they will pay out hundreds of thousands in attorney’s fees to fight the class action lawsuit. And fifteen months later, we still don’t know how much C.J. is compensated even though he promised to reveal it. Approach your pastors and find out if they are still giving your tithe money to SGM. Demand they stop. They should redirect the church’s giving to worthy individuals and organizations.
 
Start New Churches: If your church doesn’t leave Sovereign Grace Ministries, you should consider starting a new church comprised of people who are devoted to love our Lord Jesus in humility, integrity, and truth.

God’s Opposition: I’m sure C.J. and John are telling all their friends and associates that the lawsuit is full of slander. That they are not guilty of covering up child molestation. This much is certain, God continues to oppose the proud in SGM and only the proud in SGM are foolish enough to deny it (Jam 4:6-10, 1 Pet 5:5-6). Being good Calvinists, they shouldn’t blame the devil or people as primary agents. Yet C.J. and the Board present C.J. as the suffering servant who has been victimized by evil doers. They continue to deny God’s sovereign opposition. Pray for C.J. Proverbs 29:1 He who is often reproved, yet stiffens his neck, will suddenly be broken beyond healing.

My Bitterness: Eleven months out of the year I do okay dealing with temptations to bitterness. October is different. I should be 25 feet up a tree in my beloved deer stand dressed in camo. Instead, I’m on the ground before my computer screen addressing SGM. A bitter man with a bow is not a good combination. By the way, I desperately need some updated broad head arrows. Make a donation so I can put food on my table and overcome my resentment. Help the hungry and pray November allows for hunting. Remember the words of Jesus to Peter. Acts 10:13 A voice came to him, “Get up, Peter, kill and eat!”

Prayerfully Consider Financial Support 
 
My efforts are designed to help Christians judge righteously, think biblically, live courageously (and support hunting). Would you prayerfully consider a gift or donation? This work is aided by the kindness of appreciative readers. Click the donation button for more information. Thank you.
  

Thursday, July 12, 2012

SGM-Mahaneygate: "Meet the New Boss, Same Old Boss (CJ)"


http://thewartburgwatch.com/2012/07/12/sovereign-grace-ministries-meet-the-new-boss-same-as-the-old-boss/

Sovereign Grace Ministries: Meet the New Boss, Same as the Old Boss
"Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me."
Chinese Proverb

Wikipedia article
Won't Get Fooled Again (Wikipedia)

Several months have passed since we last focused on Sovereign Grace Ministries. SGM, perhaps more than any other ministry espousing reformed theology, has held to STRICT complementarianism. Could it be that what has occurred in SGM is merely a foreshading of what is to come in other like-minded ministries?

For those who may be unfamiliar with SGM and what has occurred in this ministry, I highly recommend reading our post Mahaney / SGM – Unprecedented Rescue by the SBC?

It will clue you in on the strong ties between C.J. Mahaney, Al Mohler, and Mark Dever. There can be no question that Mahaney has Mohler to thank for rescuing him from a desperate situation. Last April we featured a post entitled AOR Report – Just How Unhealthy Is SGM?

The Ambassadors or Reconciliation (AoR) were hired by the SGM Board to render an 'impartial' assessment of Sovereign Grace Ministries. AoR delayed issuing its report and released it just prior to the Together for the Gospel conference held in April. From what we understand,Ted Kober of AoR met with SGM leaders in Louisville. Does anyone know whether there was an Ambassadors of Reconciliation booth at the T4G bookstore? Were Kober and Co. there peddling their services to all the pastors in attendance?

The AoR report was woefully lacking, and it's fairly obvious that they did not want to bite the hand that was feeding them. Here are a few highlights from their report:
"Because we met with such a small percentage of members (less than 1⁄2 of 1%), our observations may not accurately reflect the entire association of churches. Nevertheless, we offer these observations as part of our report." Ambassadors of Reconciliation Report, page 13
After reading the report, I understand why so many did not meet with the Ambassadors of Reconciliation. For those who did come forward, here is what AoR representatives reported:
"Those most upset displayed to us anger or bitterness or hatred toward SGM and their former church leaders for events that took place ten to fifteen years ago. Some were so hurt or angry that they displayed tears, raised voices, clenched fists, and other physical demonstrations of anger. As we talked about bitterness or anger, several responded with raised or strained voices to our team members insisting that they were not angry or bitter." (p. 18, AoR Report) "Of the 250 different individuals that provided input to AoR, about half were estimated to be no longer directly associated with SGM. These included past SGM leaders, pastors, and members of SGM churches. Considering that SGM has approximately 28,000 people in its churches, AoR received direct information from less than one half of one percent of the total current membership. Accordingly, AoR was unable to conclude that the input it received accurately reflects the majority of viewpoints from people currently in SGM churches." (p. 5, AoR Report)
In that post, we analyzed AoR's findings about SGM in light of questions Ronald Enroth poses in his book Recovering from Churches That Abuse, Grand Rapids, Michigan, Zondervan, 1994. Here is a list of those questions that helps one determine whether a church is healthy or unhealthy?

1. Does a member’s personality generally become stronger, happier, more confident as a result of contact with the group?
2. Do members of the group seek to strengthen their family commitments?
3. Does the group encourage independent thinking and the development of discernment skills?
4. Does the group allow for individual differences of belief and behavior, particularly on issues of secondary importance?
5. Does the group encourage high moral standards both among members and between members and non members?
6. Does the group’s leadership invite dialogue, advice and evaluation from outside its immediate circle?
7. Does the group allow for development in theological beliefs?
8. Are group members encouraged to ask hard questions of any kind?
9. Do members appreciate truth wherever it is found even if it is outside their group?
10. Is the group honest in dealing with nonmembers, especially as it tries to win them to the group?
11. Does the group foster relationships and connections with the larger society that are more than self-serving?

In recent weeks, Sovereign Grace Ministries has relocated to Louisville, Kentucky. Church planting certainly seems to be their focus, and it will be interesting to see whether there is a merger in the works between SGM and Sojourn Ministries.

Jim over at SGM Refuge has just provided an update about what is happening in SGM, and we thought we would share that information with our readers. Jim's post includes excerpts from a post over at SGM Nation entitled What the SGM Polity Process Tells Us About SGM.
Phil Sasser, pastor of Sovereign Grace Church in Apex, North Carolina – the SGM church Dee and I attended to hear C.J. preach – serves as SGM Polity Chair. He sent a letter to SGM pastors last month that states the following:
"Dear Fellow Pastors,

We have been encouraged by your response to the planned polity presentations in Louisville next month. Several pastors have indicated a desire to make a presentation, and we are looking forward to hearing from them. Many more have expressed a desire to listen to the polity presentations. In light of this, Tommy Hill and the SGM staff have found a suitable venue to accommodate additional seating for these presentations at the Legacy Hotel. As previously announced, the polity presentations will take place on July 10-11 and July 24-25. These presentations are only open to SGM pastors, the Leadership Team, and staff supporting the Committee. The Polity Committee has set aside two additional days (July 12 and July 26) in order to discuss and process what we’ve heard from you; these meetings will be with the Committee members only. SGM Board members have been invited to sit in on the Committee’s meetings, but only to listen. The presentations will begin at 8AM on July 10, so if you’re planning to attend we’d recommend you arrive in Louisville on the evening of July 9. At this point, we will assume that the July 24-25 meetings will have the same start time. If you wish to make a presentation, please send me your paper and indicate that you would like to present; and I will put you on the schedule. If you have a preference for when you would like to present, let me know and I will try to accommodate your request. Of course, you may elect to send a paper without actually making a presentation if you so desire… The Committee members will seek to make themselves available to talk to any Sovereign Grace pastor at any point in this process. The Committee’s work of formulation and writing will likely not begin until early August. We realize that we have established an aggressive timeline. At the same time, we are committed to doing a good job. If upon further review, we do not think that we can meet our objectives by the fall of this year, we reserve the right to adjust the timeline. Please know that we will do our very best to serve you in this process."
Here are two EXCELLENT observations (among others) over at SGM Nation that have been made in response to Sasser's letter:

"Truth be told – there was far too little time given to allow pastors to even consider the topic of polity in a meaningful way, much less, give themselves to study or write a paper. It's either poor management or cleverly designed process to minimize opposing views."
"SGM procrastinated on the polity issue for years and now they want to wrap it up in a matter of days, months… this is absurd – there's too little time for them to be in a hurry over something as important as this. This is about control – asserting it, maintaining it and propagating it for the next phase of SGM."

In case you're wondering what C.J. is up to, you might be interested to know that he will be returning to Kevin DeYoung's church this weekend to deliver the message on Sunday. He has aready preached there several times in the recent past. Of course, you remember Kevin DeYoung… one of the review panel members who judged C.J. fit for ministry (along with Carl Trueman and Ray Ortlund). For details about Mahaney's appearance at DeYoung's church, please consult Together for the Nonsense.
C.J. Mahaney's reputation is being rebuilt by all of his YRR colleagues, and many inside and outside SGM are sitting idly by and watching it happen.

Yes, the spin continues . . . May I recommend this post written exactly three months ago – Mahaney's Mind-Blowing Machination ?

Here is the most appropriate song I could find to describe what is currently taking place. Yes, meet the new boss, same as the old boss...


Lydia's Corner: Zephaniah 1:1-3:20 Revelation 10:1-11 Psalm 138:1-8 Proverbs 30:11-14

Friday, March 23, 2012

After Turmoil, Mahaney is Cleaning House at SGM

The last paragraph is a sage prediction of SGM's trajectory--and not surprising to us.  Old Mahaney is cleaning house in SGM. 

http://www.brentdetwiler.com/brentdetwilercom/2012/3/23/next-up-the-new-leadership-team-and-partnership-agreement.html

Next Up: The New Leadership Team and Partnership Agreement

I’ll get to these soon but first, I anticipate John Loftness will replace C.J. as Chairman of the Board. John is the senior pastor of Solid Rock Church in Riverdale, MD. C.J. fled Covenant Life Church in August 2011 for a 5 month hiatus at Capitol Hill Baptist with Mark Dever. Then in January 20112, he left Capitol Hill and transferred his membership from Covenant Life to Solid Rock.

Favors and Favorites
John will be handsomely rewarded by C.J. for his devotion to C.J. That’s the way it works. You become a favorite of C.J.’s by showing C.J. favoritism. Here is how John famously introduced C.J. at the Pastors Conference in November, 2011.

“I am here right now to give some context before CJ comes to give an update from his leave of absence. More than four months ago CJ volunteered to take this leave. The board decided to expand the board of three men by having all of the regional leaders in SG – I am one of those leaders – and so suddenly in a day I was transformed into a board member. I’ve known CJ for 33 years.

“Since leaving CLC and moving to Solid Rock four years ago our friendship has only deepened though we don’t see each other as much as we once did. I give you that background because of our history because the board asked me to serve as a liaison with CJ so he could get appropriate updates of our work and developments that might affect him. The board also thought it was wise and helpful if CJ could receive pastoral care from someone who knew him well and was familiar with all that was going on in Sovereign Grace. I consider it a great privilege to stand with my friend during this most trying time. We’ve met often, we’ve talked extensively about his soul, his leadership, and how to evaluate Sovereign Grace. So what you are about to hear reflects the content of many, many conversations over the last four months.” (John Loftness, Pastors’ Conference, November 9, 2011)

After this, John sat down and C.J. stood up. What followed was a complete disaster by all accounts. The four months of innumerable conversations produced no contrition or confession of any kind. See “The Transcript of C.J. Mahaney’s Remarks at 2011 Sovereign Grace Ministries’ Pastors Conference” and “C.J.’s State of His Heart Message – Reflection on Personal Sins.” John’s pastoral care was totally ineffective. In fact, if C.J.’s approach to all the pastors and wives was indicative of John’s counsel, then John’s input was downright harmful. John refuses to answer inquiries regarding his input and C.J.’s comments. No surprise, so does C.J. The SGM Board refuses to release C.J.’s message though requested by the CLC pastors and many others. A transcript exists in the public domain but not the audio. The Board doesn’t want people to hear C.J.’s sinful attitudes and tone more distinctly.

John’s church is also growing thanks to C.J. Riverdale, MD is 35 minutes from Gaithersburg, MD. Nora Earles (C.J.’s secretary), Paul Medler (the SGM event planner), Dave Mays (SGM Information Technology), Gary Riccuci (Dean of Students at the Pastors College), and Steve Whitacre (son in law and former pastor in Fairfax, VA) all attend along with others. Mike Bradshaw (son in law and former CLC pastor) and Brian Chesemore (son in law and former CLC pastor) attend Capitol Hill Baptist where they are doing internships. Some of these people will move with C.J. to Louisville. Some will continue working for SGM and remain but work remotely. Others will stay to help John as Chairman (if I’m correct) and the church.   

Lastly, read “Silencing a Voice for the Gospel” where John compares C.J. to Paul the apostle and points out I am a servant of Satan.

New Officers and Leadership Team

Well now, who will be the next President of Sovereign Grace Ministries? C.J. has sworn it won’t be him! But C.J. has sworn many things and broken his word. He could come back as President. If he doesn’t, it seems certain the new President put forth by C.J. as his successor will move to Louisville so C.J. is his pastor and tutor. That person could be a well-known and high powered outsider to SGM. Or more likely, a handpick insider who’d give up his sr. pastor responsibilities (e.g. Jared Mellinger).

If either of these scenarios occur, what happens to Dave Harvey? Dave is recovering after “the demands of the last eight months” and attending to “the emergence of some family matters” but per the SGM website he continues to be “responsible for church care, church planting, and international expansion for Sovereign Grace Ministries.” I don’t see that changing. Dave could be given a new designation like Vice President.

So what happens to Waldo if we have Chairman Loftness, President Insider/Outsider, and Vice President Harvey. How does C.J. fit into the picture? Well, he’s the puppet master or puppeteer. From behind the curtain, he pulls the strings and Loftness, Insider/Outsider and Harvey perform. Of course, there is one small problem, if anything like this happens it is illegal and unethical! Per the Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws, C.J. can have no influence upon the SGM Board or SGM Leadership Team greater than that of any other pastor. So how do C.J. and the Board circumvent these ethical obstacles. Easy, create a new position. Make C.J. President Emeritus. Then the three marionettes of Chairman, President, and Vice President can all be directed by President Emeritus. It will be like a three ring circus. Start the cavalcade and strike up the band! Let the show begin.
So where does this leave us? Someone other than C.J. will be the new Chairman and likely the new President but C.J. will functionally remain in charge as President Emeritus. And what about the new Leadership Team? Well, it is not going to be very new; but first, let me reiterate a couple things. In this structure some things have changed. The Chairman is no longer the President and the Board is no longer the Leadership (Apostolic) Team. They have been separated although some overlap will continue.

Old Board and Leadership (Apostolic) Team:
  1. Cabaniss, Craig
  2. Connolly, Mickey
  3. Gamache, Rick
  4. Greasley, Pete
  5. Harvey, Dave
  6. Loftness, John
  7. Mahaney, C.J.
  8. Osborne, Aron
  9. Prater, Mark
  10. Purswell, Jeff
  11. Shank, Steve
  12. Osborne, Aron
New Board:
  1. Boomsma, Ron
  2. Buckley, Pau
  3. Cabaniss, Craig (carry over)
  4. Connolly, Mickey (carry over)
  5. Loftness, John (carry over, Chairman?)
  6. McConnell, Ian
  7. Mellinger, Ken
  8. Pino, Al
  9. Sasser, Phil
New Leadership (Apostolic) Team – same as old plus a few additions
  1. Cabaniss, Craig (also on Board)
  2. Connolly, Mickey (also on Board)
  3. Gamache, Rick
  4. Greasley, Pete
  5. Harvey, Dave (Vice President?)
  6. Mahaney, C.J. (President Emeritus)
  7. Osborne, Aron
  8. Prater, Mark
  9. Purswell, Jeff
  10. Shank, Steve
Possible Additions
  1. Hill, Tommy
  2. Kauflin, Bob
  3. Mellinger, Jared (President?)
  4. Sasser, Nathan
During their 9 month tenure (Jul 2011-Mar 2012), the ten men on the old Board- Leadership Team took three critical votes. Each was unanimously in C.J.’s favor. There was no dissent. By so doing they secured a happy and prosperous future in Sovereign Grace Ministries. Their promotions and positions are secure. C.J. rewards favoritism and favorites. He punishes critics.

Here are those occasions.

Yes Men and No Men

Vote One: Board Unanimously Finds No Reason for Disqualification - July 13, 2011

“The board of Sovereign Grace Ministries has reviewed Brent Detwiler’s documents accusing C.J. Mahaney of sinful practices in the conduct of his ministry and finds no reason at this time to deem him unfit for ministry…. C.J. Mahaney is a qualified minister of the gospel and this board approves his pastoral and teaching ministry in Sovereign Grace and the wider body of Christ.”

This vote occurred six days after their selection as Board Members. See The Five Resolutions - July 13, 2011. Except for Joshua Harris who resigned over this issue, no one on the SGM Board had any misgivings that C.J. might not be “above reproach” after reading 600 pages of carefully documented charges.

Vote Two: C.J. Unanimously Returned to Office of President -

“After examining the reports of these three review panels, we find nothing in them that would disqualify C.J. from his role as President, nor do they in any way call into question his fitness for gospel ministry. Therefore the Board has decided unanimously to return C.J. to the office of President, effective immediately.”

Vote Three: C.J. Unanimously Nominated to New Board – February 27, 2012

“Some of you are surely wondering why C.J. Mahaney, Dave Harvey, and Jeff Purswell aren’t on the list. C.J. and Jeff were both unanimously nominated for the Board but asked to have their names removed from consideration. Both thought they would be able to better serve SGM at present if they were able to specialize in particular areas of their calling. Dave Harvey was also unanimously nominated for Board membership, but after considering the demands of the last eight months, the emergence of some family matters, and the care and counsel of his local eldership, Dave became convinced that Board membership was an unwise commitment right now.”

Here’s the conclusion of it all. Cabaniss, Connolly, Gamache, Greasley, Harvey, Loftness, Prater, Purswell, Shank, and Osborne proved their “loyalty” to C.J. They were “yes men” on every strategic vote. Furthermore, they have willingly lied, deceived and covered up in order to protect C.J. over the last 9 months.

You must understand, “no men” are not tolerated in C.J.’s world. Any “no” votes would have resulted in their removal. Real dissent is not permitted. Job security and advancement are predicated upon an idolatrous devotion to C.J. So too salary increases and bonuses. That is why you don’t find a single person on the new Board who has challenged, confronted or disagreed with C.J. in any meaningful way. The same will be true of the not so new Leadership (Apostolic) Team. The last person to differ with C.J. was Joshua Harris. See “The Cardinal Sins of Joshua Harris.” Until then Joshua was the President-in-training of Sovereign Grace Ministries. When C.J. turned 60 in 2014, he planned to turn SGM over to Joshua. Well, the heir apparent has been removed from C.J.’s will. He won’t be getting a penny. Sovereign Grace Ministries is C.J.’s ministry.

The New Partnership Agreement

This document used to be called the Membership Agreement. The name has been changed to make it sound nicer. The pastors and churches are partners now, not members, even though they don’t have any say in the governance and direction of the ministry. But “partners” sounds more participatory and mutually affirming. You know, we’re in this together. Friends forever.

The Board referenced this soon to be revealed document in its February 27, 2012 letter to all the SGM pastors.

“There are other measures meant to help SGM benefit from accountability to local churches that we expect will be reflected in the new Partnership Agreement. These include providing recourse for elders in the form of a grievance policy, the requirement that changes in the Statement of Faith be voted on by ordained elders, and the requirement that SGM executive staff serve on the staff of a local church.”

These three measures amount to very little and exclude all the critical issues being addressed by the 62 pastors who signed the March 7 “Stop and Listen” response to the Board of Directors. Furthermore, the old and new Boards are finalizing the content of the Partnership Agreement without the involvement of all the SGM pastors.

People often ask me when I think churches will begin to leave SGM. That’s not too hard to answer. They will leave after the new Partnership Agreement comes out because their pastors won’t be able to sign it with a clear conscience. On the other hand, some wishy washy pastors/churches may sign it under protest (which can’t be done with clear conscience) and then wait to see how the Board responds to the Ambassador of Reconciliation report, the recommendations from the Panel Reports, and the dissenting voices of pastors in the movement before making a decision to leave.

Ethics First, Polity Second

All of these reasons for leaving, however, badly miss the point. Sure, churches can leave over polity differences but they should be leaving over the corruption that is so systemic and evident! Theoretically, the new Board could radically change SGM polity but if they don’t deal with C.J., Dave, Steve, Mickey, Bob, Gene and the old Board; they are accomplices who continue covering up serious occasions and patterns of sin. All the churches in SGM should leave if these matters are left unattended to by the new Board. 

Innumerable ethics violations are by far the most compelling reasons to leave. That is why I’ve repeatedly and strenuously appealed to Ted Kober, President of Ambassadors of Reconciliation, to include charges of corruption in his report.
 
The old Board has confessed to absolutely nothing and C.J. to practically nothing. Here is the extent of C.J.’s confession to the movement. One single sentence appearing in “A note to those in Sovereign Grace Ministries” on deeply regret where my mistakes, leadership deficiencies, and sins contributed to the relational conflicts detailed in these [three panel] reports.” That’s it and all you’ll ever hear! It is so hypocritical! See “What Andy Pettitte and C.J. Mahaney Share in Common.” Neither the Board or C.J. have ever asked forgiveness of the pastors or the churches for anything. They never will.

Cleaning House

You must understand what is going on. C.J. is cleaning house. Joshua Harris is out. Mark Mullery is out. So is everyone else who signed the “Stop and Listen” letter or stood up to C.J., Dave or the old Board in any meaningful way. Such people have been silenced, marginalized and marked. They won’t be put in positions of leadership in SGM. It has always been that way. Disagree with C.J. and you’re gone. You’re blacklisted. Align yourself with C.J. and your rewarded. That’s why you won’t find anyone on the new Board or new Leadership (Apostolic) Team who has raised concerns for ethical misconduct, questioned C.J.’s qualifications, or challenged heavy handed practice and polity. I suspect 20% of the churches will be forced out of Sovereign Grace with the new Partnership Agreement. That is C.J.’s way of weeding out the undesirables. He won’t lose any sleep or shed any tears with their departure.

Wednesday, February 29, 2012

Mahaney/ SGM – Louisville, KY SBCers? Mohler/SBTS to the Rescue?

Deb at "The Wartburg Watch" is offering the following interpretation of Mahaney's convenient and hasty westward retreat from his home church--whence he fled--, Covenant Life, Gaithersburg, MD, towards Kentucky.  Mahaney had a temporary layover at Dever's community and then Solid Rock (SGM), MD.  We suspect that Mahaney got a preliminary whiff of possible fallout and debris from an impending report from the Ambassadors of Reconciliation (due end of Mar 2012).  The new school Baptyerian, Lig Duncan, once suprised RA, but his stock has dropped to about $0.25 from the old school standpoint.  As to the forthcoming T4G, 10-12 Apr 2012, we did a preliminary analysis last year:  one can expect a few cool $$ million in profits for the event.  Where the $$s go is anyone's guess.  On another note, for those advancing in years, we offer this.  Three benefits accrue in watching and researching Mahaney's history.  (1)  Ocular exercises, especially.  That is, "rolling the eyes."  (2) "Shaking the head."  It works the neck muscles to get those kinks out.  (3) "Laughter."  It works the cheek, face and throat muscles.  "Ya just gotta laugh a little." Nothing like watching a skilled enthusiast "enthuse." A modern mountebank of the first order.  However, there is one contra-indication:  do not watch or research Mahaney/SGM if one has blood pressure issues.  But back on point.  Deb says:  "For those of you who are sports enthusiasts, here is what Mohler and Dever have done on behalf of pastor-athlete Mahaney. They have RUN INTERFERENCE, meaning they have protected Mahaney from the criticism and correction he is rightly due from those whom he has hurt in Sovereign Grace Ministries. To put it another way, Mohler and Dever have done an end run around SGMers and prevented that from occurring. Now Mahaney is hiding out at Solid Rock Church until he makes the BIG MOVE" [emphasis in the original].


"I think preaching and pastoral ministry are where grace is most evident in my life and where my leadership is most effectively expressed. Others seem to agree."


We believe history is being made as high profile leaders in the Southern Baptist Convention MEDDLE in the affairs of another denomination, which self-identifies as a "family of churches".


Yes, I'm talking about Sovereign Grace Ministries (SGM). In case you haven't heard, C.J. Mahaney, who was recently reinstated as President of SGM, is assisting with the appointment of his successor and laying the foundation to PLANT a new church in another state.


As the saying goes, "bloom where you're planted", and the word on the street is that Mahaney is planning to relocate to Kentucky and set down roots there. There is also speculation that the offices of Sovereign Grace Ministries will be moved from Covenant Life Church in Gaithersburg, Maryland to Kentucky — most likely Louisville.


We have written extensively on C.J. Mahaney and Sovereign Grace Ministries, so if you are new to TWW, you might want to browse through our archives. Why is Mahaney leaving the state where he grew up and the church he pastored for 27 years? It appears the accusations of hyper-authoritarianism and spiritual abuse (among other things) by hundreds and hundreds of current and former SGMers (including many pastors) have reached a fevered pitch, and Mahaney believes his best option is to get out of Gaithersburg! The Ambassadors of Reconciliation have been called in to investigate the accusations, and they will be issuing their findings very soon. We will be sure to pass along any information that is made public.


What was the straw that broke the camel's back in SGM? From our vantage point, it appears the 600+ pages of documentation that Brent Detwiler compiled (which an anonymous individual posted on the internet) put all of this in motion. As soon as Mahaney suspected Detwiler was going public in some way with his incriminating information, Mahaney voluntarily stepped down. That was in early July 2011. Seven months later Mahaney was reinstated as president of SGM.


Perhaps the most damning information that was revealed in Detwiler's documentation was Mahaney's attempt to blackmail his mentor Larry Tomczak if he did not leave the organization quietly back in 1998. Tomczak had a big problem with the shift toward Calvinistic theology, and, Mahaney threatened to go public with the confidentially confessed sins of Tomczak's son if Larry did not go away quietly into the night… Fifteen years passed, and Mahaney finally made an attempt to patch things up with Tomczak, who had been urging a reconciliation for years.

Why would Mahaney relocate to another state — Kentucky — as some are speculating? If the Bluegrass State is the Mahaneys' destination, there is a very good reason… Dee and I first began investigating C.J. Mahaney and SGM in the fall of 2008 — seven months before we began blogging. Exactly two months after we launched The Wartburg Watch, we wrote about CJ's significant monetary contributions to Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in a post called The Mahaney Money Machine. We were so new to blogging that not many people read the following "observation" included in that post:

"How did C.J. Mahaney become so popular among reformed Christians? As far as we can determine, C.J.’s secret to success is that he has friends in high places. We believe his recognition among the “Reformed Big Dogs” began when he befriended Mark Dever, Senior Pastor of Capitol Hill Baptist Church, in Washington, D.C. (a church not far from Gaithersburg where CLC is located)."

For more, see:
http://thewartburgwatch.com/2012/02/29/mahaney-sgm-unprecedented-rescue-by-the-sbc/

Also, Deb concludes with this bit of humour.  We leave you with a tune the Mahaneys may be singing.


Tuesday, February 28, 2012

CJ Mahaney Ditches Covenant Life (Gaithersburg, MD) and Heading West

SGM Survivors offers the following letter from Covenant Life (SGM) Church, Gaithersburg, MD.  Mahaney bolted months ago and has remained over at Dever's Anabaptist Church.  Now, that the dust-off and reburnishment of the image has occurred with a few in-house SGM panels offering an analysis, Mahaney is headed west.  One wonders if Mahaney will ever return to CLC.  What will NOT be happening, is that Sir Charles won't be writing or offering anything of significance or depth, as usual. 

Meanwhile, the old Southern Baptyerian, Ligon Duncan, a man whom Dever wouldn't give Holy Communion, gives an attaboy to Mahaney with this FB post.  Here's Lig, to wit: 

"Standard registration for T4G 2012 ends at midnight tomorrow (2/29). Then the price goes up by $80! Register in the next 24 hours or so. Hotels are filling up. Registration is well ahead of 2010. Some break out sessions are near max. Join us! In this video, CJ explains why we've upgraded our approach to panels." 

Watch old Mahaney the Enthusiast do his mountebanking gig on Together For the Gospel.  Mahaney's got another home now and a new crowd to feed his inner supply-needs for admiration.  Watch him here: http://t4g.org/media/2012/02/panels-the-new-t4g-format/#.T02gsL8AzAA.facebook

Anyways, here's CLC's letter to Mahaney's orphans.  http://www.sgmsurvivors.com/?p=3369#comments

Dear Members of Covenant Life,

We are writing to update you regarding another important moment in the events of the last eight months.

Last month when his leave of absence as President of Sovereign Grace Ministries ended, C.J. Mahaney wrote the elders of Covenant Life informing us of his decision to transfer his membership to Solid Rock Church. At that time we told C.J. that the elders would like to meet with him and discuss several concerns that we had for him, as well as hear his questions and concerns for us.

This past Friday, Grant, Josh and Robin met with C.J. along with two members of the Sovereign Grace Board and had an honest conversation. We began by asking C.J. to share his concerns and disagreements with our leadership over the past eight months, and then we shared our concerns and questions for some of his actions and statements during that same time. We felt the Lord gave grace for everyone to speak forthrightly and listen to each other. We believe this meeting was an important step, though it confirmed that we have different perspectives on what has unfolded since last July.
Having had the opportunity to meet with C.J., we have agreed, with sadness, to accept and support his membership transfer. C.J. has communicated to us that he no longer thinks the formal mediation he requested last fall is needed (this mediation was going to be led by Ted Kober and was to address differences C.J. had with the pastors’ public leadership in response to the release of Brent Detwiler’s documents). We are grateful that we’ve been able to talk together, and we expect there will be further dialogue.

Because we understand there will be questions on these matters, we have scheduled another “Coffee and Questions” night for [Time & Date Edited]. We’ve created a simple form to allow you to submit your questions in advance of the meeting.

C.J. has communicated his love and appreciation for Covenant Life and that he believes God is leading him into a new season of pastoral ministry. C.J. has told us that his time at Solid Rock will be brief as he plans to plant a new church in another state later this year. Details of those plans will be announced by Sovereign Grace in the coming months.

We pray God’s blessing on C.J. and his family. We will always be grateful for his service to this church.

If you want to talk further about this, we hope you can come to the “Coffee and Questions” night on [Date], and as always, feel free to contact your pastor.

Sincerely,
The pastors of Covenant Life

Monday, February 13, 2012

C.J. Mahaney Unsurprisingly Re-instated

The man, the myth, the legend, the scholar,
the enthusiast, the high school graduate
 and premier Baptacostalist...a man for the
history books
This is not surprising. Reformation Anglicanism investigated the issue for five months.  This Baptacostalist Apostle, Prophet, Moses, Paul and Emperor was the victim of his own large ignorance like those who followed him.   Many have left SGM. We are not surprised by Baptyerians like Ligon Duncan or Anabaptists like Mark Dever and Al Mohler. Here's a recent lamentation by a former Mahaney-ite, schooled in the authoritarianism of SGM's past, Brent Detwiler.  As an aside, for RA readers, do not waste a penny on any of the books by Mahaney or SGM-teachers.  Consistent with the distinctive of anti-intellectualism in doctrine, worship and piety, those books show it.  Those books won't appeal to "men and women of discerning spirits."  If one has been reared on the Bible, expository preaching, the Reformed standards, including catechetization and memory work, and involved in Anglican worship, one would have--in a nanosecond--sniffed this from 1000 yards out.  But, being a competent mountebank, Mahaney impressed those without discernment or the disciplines of depth.  He would cryingly whisper to the silence of a pin drop, wildly gesticulate, crisscross the stage, invoke wailing hand-waving, and tolerate worship of himself by many.  A word to discerning youth and learners: steer clear and pass the word.  Here's Brent Detwiler's recent lamentation about Mahaney.

http://www.brentdetwiler.com/brentdetwilercom/2012/2/13/reinstatement-of-cj-big-news.html
Reinstatement of C.J. Big News

Today I received the latest edition of World Magazine. Here is the write up on C.J.’s reinstatement. I am the sole accuser. No systemic problems.

“The board of directors of Sovereign Grace Ministries reinstated C.J. Mahaney as president of the Maryland based church-planting ministry. Last June, Mahaney began a voluntary leave of absence after former Sovereign Grace leader Brent Detwiler accused him of pride, deceit and hypocrisy. Mahaney said he only plans to resume the role of president temporarily, noting that he would like to return pastoral ministry and the pulpit.” (World Magazine, Feb 25, 2012)

Seven months ago, Ligon Duncan commented on his blog that SGM was taking the high road. Somehow the “outside review” never materialized and SGM ended up on the low road.

“It would have been very easy for the leadership of SGM to ignore and dismiss these charges, because so many of them are so evidently self-serving and spurious accusations. But instead, the leadership of SGM has taken the high road, or rather they have chosen to go the way of self-examination, submission to outside review and correction, self-abasement and repentance. It just makes me love and respect them all the more.” (Ligon Duncan, July 12, 2011)

Al Mohler spoke in similar fashion. Like DeYoung, Ortlund, and Trueman, he found nothing of concern in my documents. We all know what happened to the “independent investigation.” It was killed in its infancy by the SGM Board.

“’I always have had only the highest estimation of C.J. Mahaney as a man and a minister,’ Mohler said in an interview. ‘That continues absolutely unchanged. There is nothing in this current situation which would leave me to have even the slightest pause of confidence in him.’… Mohler said he believes Mahaney and the Sovereign Grace board are being prudent in planning an independent investigation from people outside the denomination to make sure those involved are above reproach…. ‘There is nothing disqualifying in terms of anything that is disclosed in this [the documents]’” (Peter Smith, newspaper reporter, July 12, 2011)

Expect more of this in the days to come. Together for the Gospel is coming up on April 10-12. John MacArthur is no longer counted among the five but expect Dever, Duncan, Mohler (and lesser lights) to heap praise upon C.J. for his humility and the SGM Board for their unbiased investigation.

Thursday, October 20, 2011

SGM-Mahaneygate: The Age of Supid, the SGM Board

 
Master Harvey surreptitiously shared his exquisite Mona Lisa of spin with the pastors of SGM on June 11, 2011. The unveiling would have made Leonardo proud. It is a brilliant masterpiece certain to be enshrined in the Sovereign Grace Museum of Art which could be moved to Philadelphia. The combination of tones, shapes, strokes, and blending create an exhilarating work of art that will dazzle patrons for perpetuity. Indeed, vertigo practically sets in when one gazes upon the intricacies of spin for too long. It is a powerful piece. The art novice cannot fully appreciate such a remarkable work. He needs the help of a curator.

And so begins my sixth reason for “Why Sending Out ‘The Documents’ Was Not Slanderous But Necessary“ (see blog posts for Sept 22, 24, 30).

Dave is a of master of manipulation. He has been acclaimed as such by many former church members and at least two former pastors. He has refined his craft over the years. It has not always been so evident but he now holds post graduate degrees in the fine art of spin. No one does it better in SGM. He’s even expanded his repertoire to include acting. You can check out his starring role in Video: Answering your questions from upon the reviews, he should probably confine himself to painting.

I find his most eminent and advanced work of spin to be his letter to the SGM pastors. May I serve as your curator in examining its contents?

I sent “Concluding Remarks” to C.J., Dave, Jeff and Joshua on June 8, 2011. It was my third major document. I said the following at the end of the manuscript. “Well, we have reached the end of the road. It is now time for me to share my concerns with the Sovereign Grace pastors” (p. 201).

I also said,

If you ever produce an alternative narrative (e.g. for the SGM pastors), please let me review it before you give it out to anyone. I’ve afforded you that opportunity throughout this process. I’ve welcomed your feedback and I’ve included all of it in my documents. In other words, if you send out a critique of me or my concerns please let me provide an accompanying statement. That is only right. (p. 193)

Of course that never happened. I hope people are beginning to realize that C.J., Dave and the SGM Board don’t play by the same rules they insist upon for everyone else. They’ve learned to play down and dirty.

I’ve not shared this Mona Lisa of deceit and spin before, because I was promised the opportunity to present my concerns for Dave to an objective panel of outside evaluators. That commitment was broken when the SGM Board put forward their bogus arbitration agreement on October 1. It excluded Dave.

So let’s begin. Behind my back on June 11, Dave Harvey warned all the SGM pastors about my documents (RRF&D, AFA, CR). In so doing, he totally ignored my request from two days earlier to please allow me to review their “alternative version” and provide an “accompanying statement.” Dave wrote the pastors in part, “If you haven’t received them already, you have hundreds of pages of documentation - Brent’s concerns for CJ - coming your way.” He then proceeded to discredit me and my writings while commending C.J. for his humility.

I had no idea Dave launched this preemptive strike with laser guided missiles loaded with deadly deceit. He ended his letter by saying “Gentlemen, it ain’t pretty…but it’s a faithful narrative [i.e., Dave’s perspective] of a sad tale [i.e., my conduct and writing].”

It is one thing for Tim Challies or Ray Ortlund to claim I slandered C.J. when I sent out The Documents. They are ignorant of the facts. They don’t know the inner workings of Sovereign Grace Ministries. It is a completely different matter when Dave and Jeff Purswell make the same claim. It was their deceitful gossip and slander in the form of this letter that factored into my decision to send out my writings and they know it. The holier than thou Board castigated me on July 13 (see Sovereign Grace Ministries Board of Directors announcement regarding C.J. Mahaney) while they broke all the rules. Dave and the boys feel right at home speaking falsehoods while silencing those who speak truth supported by compelling evidence and labeling them slanderers.

I found out about Dave’s correspondence three weeks after the fact on July 5. Needless to say, I was shocked, troubled and heartsick by this surprise attack; and more so, because the action was hidden from me both by the SGM Board and the Covenant Life pastors.

During those three weeks (June 11-July 5), I was working with the Covenant Life pastors and appealing for them to follow 1 Timothy 5:19-21. “Do not entertain an accusation against an elder unless it is brought by two or three witnesses. Those who sin are to be rebuked publicly, so that the others may take warning. I charge you, in the sight of God and Christ Jesus and the elect angels, to keep these instructions without partiality, and to do nothing out of favoritism.” I was acting in good faith and intentionally holding back on sending out my documents to the SGM pastors until I received a report on their time with C.J. from June 30. I was prepared to take no further action if I was assured they were exercising disciplinary oversight in C.J.’s life.

Instead I had to write this grievous email.

From: Brent Detwiler
Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 3:30 PM
To: Bo Lotinsky; Bob Kauflin; C. J. Mahaney; Dave Harvey; Gary Ricucci; Gene Emerson; Jeff Purswell; John Loftness; Ken Sande; Pat Ennis; Tommy Hill; Tony Reinke; Adam Malcolm; Ben Wikner; Braden Greer; Brian Chesemore; Corby Megorden; Dave Brewer; Don DeVries; Eric Sheffer; Eric Simmons; Grant Layman; Greg Somerville; Issac Hydoski; Jamie Leach; Joe Lee; Jon Smith; Joshua Harris; Kenneth Maresco; Mark Mitchell; Matt Maka; Mike Bradshaw; Robin Boisvert; Benny Phillips; David Bendinelli; Keith Jacob; Paul Palmer
Subject: Request for Mailing to SGM Pastors

Would some faithful and honest soul, provide me all the material Dave Harvey sent out to the SGM pastors about me around three weeks ago. Please include the cover letter and documents. Until this morning, I had absolutely no idea this was done. It was done behind my back. I called Dave. He did not answer so I left a message. I called the church office and gave the receptionist a message. I’ve received nothing from them as requested.

Since I could not get through to Dave, I left a voice message on his cell phone. I told him, he had become a master manipulator and it broke my heart. I also wrote the SGM Board and the CLC pastors.

From: Brent Detwiler
Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 4:03 PM
To: Bo Lotinsky; Bob Kauflin; C. J. Mahaney; Dave Harvey; Gary Ricucci; Gene Emerson; Jeff Purswell; John Loftness; Ken Sande; Pat Ennis; Tommy Hill; Tony Reinke; Adam Malcolm; Ben Wikner; Braden Greer; Brian Chesemore; Corby Megorden; Dave Brewer; Don DeVries; Eric Sheffer; Eric Simmons; Grant Layman; Greg Somerville; Issac Hydoski; Jamie Leach; Joe Lee; Jon Smith; Joshua Harris; Kenneth Maresco; Mark Mitchell; Matt Maka; Mike Bradshaw; Robin Boisvert; Benny Phillips; David Bendinelli; Keith Jacob; Paul Palmer
Subject: RE: Request for Mailing to SGM Pastors

I am sorely disappointed that none of you told me about Dave’s mailing against me after I emailed you approximately two weeks later on June 25 (see below). I graciously withheld sending out my material to all the SGM pastors in hope that you would take action with C.J. in keeping with 1 Timothy 5:19-21. But now again, I find myself a fool for trusting my SGM friends.

How stupid of me. I was “relieved, grateful and glad to hold on further action” when action had already been taken against me and no one ever told me so.

Dave, Jeff and Joshua responded with lame excuses. And of course, the expanded Board killed the prospect of any independent evaluation that included issues like this one. The “loudest statement” turned out to be no statement. It was silenced by them. They deny seeking to attack me but you can decide by evaluating their method, understanding the context and studying the content of Dave’s letter.

From: Nora Earles
Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 5:45 PM
To: Brent Detwiler
Cc: Dave Harvey; Jeff Purswell; Joshua Harris
Subject: FW: Request for Mailing to SGM Pastors

Dear Brent,

We’re sending along the attachments that you are requesting.
We know this has upset you and we can understand why. We have struggled for months to know how to effectively communicate with you. If you believe our sending this letter was unethical or sinful, please submit that issue to the evaluation panel along with the other complaints you have against us. We welcome the opportunity to have objective eyes and minds examine all we’ve done so we can see our mistakes and make needed changes.

In regard to what we mailed three weeks ago, we were not seeking to attack you in that communication to the pastors. We assumed from your statements that you were sending your documents to the pastors and felt it important that they hear some explanation from us. Sending C.J.’s confession of sin and stating that you have been sinned against by CJ was an attempt to make clear that there are real issues. And the loudest statement of this was our decision to involve an independent panel.

Dave, Jeff & Josh

Attachments
1. Confession to Brent - #1 – Dec 16, 2010
2. Confession to Brent - #2 – Mar 11, 2011
3. SGM Board Letter to Brent – Mar 11, 2011
4. E-Mail from Ken Sande to Brent – Mar 29, 2011
5. Letter from Dave and Steve – Apr 1, 2011

I wrote the following because so much about Dave’s letter to the SGM pastors was devious and misleading.

From: Brent Detwiler
Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2011 6:15 PM
To: C.J. Mahaney; Adam Malcolm; Ben Wikner; Braden Greer; Brian Chesemore; Corby Megorden; Dave Brewer; Don DeVries; Eric Sheffer; Eric Simmons; Grant Layman; Greg Somerville; Issac Hydoski; Jamie Leach; Joe Lee; Jon Smith; Joshua Harris; Kenneth Maresco; Mark Mitchell; Matt Maka; Mike Bradshaw; Robin Boisvert; Benny Phillips; David Bendinelli; Keith Jacob; Paul Palmer
Cc: Dave Harvey; Jeff Purswell; Joshua Harris
Subject: RE: Request for Mailing to SGM Pastors

Dave, Jeff and Josh,

If you were interested in justice, you would have included my responses to the documents Dave attached. In all my writings that is what I’ve done. I’ve never included just material that favors me. I’ve included your best arguments at every point. Dave put me in the worse possible light and C.J. in the best possible light. Dave’s letter is manipulative and misrepresentative.

Yes, I am upset and the three of you should be convicted. You proceeded when I retreated. That is unethical and you don’t need an evaluation panel to point it out.

And what possible excuse do you have for not telling me about the mailing to the SGM pastors when I have been acting in good faith and hoping that would not be necessary for the past three weeks. Indeed, I’ve been trusting the CLC elders to do their part and C.J. to do his part. That is, write up “a more thorough report” which was promised so we could meet and proceed toward reconciliation.

I have repeatedly expressed my desire and commitment to meet from the beginning and Dave deceptively makes no mention of this in his cover letter. Would you please include the cover letter from Dave. It was not provided. This kind of activity by you and C.J. is typical, paradigmatic, and systemic.

Brent

In contrast, here is the way I always conducted myself with C.J., Dave and the Board.

From: Brent Detwiler
Sent: Thursday, June 16, 2011 9:46 AM
To: Joshua Harris; Dave Harvey; C.J. Mahaney; Jeff Purswell
Subject: Crucial Comments

…I have done nothing behind your backs. I’ve been upfront about everything even when that put me at a strategic disadvantage. For example, I’ll be sending RRF&D, AFA and CR to all the elders at Covenant Life Church and a few others this week….

After my appeal to the elders failed, I sent out RRF&D, AFA, CR, and TUS on July 6 and 7. Here for example is my email to the pastors in Florida. I poked fun at Dave’s most famous line.

From: Brent Detwiler
Sent: Thursday, July 07, 2011 12:07 AM
To: Phil Courson; Mike Gilland; Shannon Day; John Lenfestey; Wayne Brooks; Jon Morales; David Traugott; Luan Nguyen; Joe Calabello; Ed Edwards; Jerry Cisar; Steve Brunson; Ryan Carver; Daryn Kinney; Danny Jones; Chip Chew; Aaron Law; Mike Nash; Jesse Phillips; Al Pino; Corey Schmatjen; Jason Stubblefield; Brian Brookins; Adam Greenfield; Michael Rizutti; Jesse Jarvis; Tim Merwin; Alex Bowman; Chris Dunlop; Benny Phillips
Subject: A Faithful Narrative of a Sad Tale

I found out this week about Dave’s email to you on June 11 regarding “a faithful narrative of a sad tale.” In case you’re confused, I am the sad part. Dave and the guys are the faithful part. I digress. Anyway, I’m sorry to keep you waiting. You can add this stuff to your summer reading list.

Seriously, I care deeply for my friend C.J. and count it a privilege to have served him and Sovereign Grace for so many years. I hope you find my writings helpful for the strengthening and preserving of Sovereign Grace Ministries for generations to come.

In conclusion, I present to you the Mona Lisa of spin by Master Harvey. Learn from it, but don’t imitate it. And don’t allow other SGM pastors to get away with cheap imitations. Granted, they are learning from the best but they must not imbibe Dave’s techniques. The painting is a fake when it comes to the truth. Look for real masters who are artists of integrity and learn from them.


Finally, this slanderous letter to all the SGM pastors was another reason I decided to send out The Documents.

From: Dave Harvey
Sent: Saturday, June 11, 2011 4:04 PM
To: Jeff Purswee; Joshua Harris; SGM Sr. Pastors
Cc: Tommy Hill
Subject: Confidential - From the SGM Board


Hey guys. I’ve got some family news I want to pass on, so grab a coffee or whatever cause this is going to take a few minutes. We (Jeff, Joshua & I - The SGM board) want to bring you in on a very difficult situation that has been unfolding for the last 18 months.[1] It’s an unfinished story, but I’m confident God is at work in some powerful ways. Let me explain.

Most of you know Brent Detwiler. Dear friend to some, faithful comrade to many, my first pastor – it was a sad day for all of us[2] when Brent left the Sovereign Grace family in 2009. We have spent many months in pursuit of reconciliation with Brent and offering the services of any qualified outside mediator he would prefer. I’m sad to report that our efforts appear unsuccessful[3] and Brent has informed us that he now wants to share his concerns[4] with the pastors in Sovereign Grace[5] as well as others outside of Sovereign Grace.[6] If you haven’t received them already, you have hundreds of pages of documentation - Brent’s concerns for CJ[7] - coming your way. Perhaps a little more context on this development would help.

Some months after Brent’s local leadership team asked him to resign[8] and the church closed down in January of 2010, CJ contacted him. The reason for this initiative was that in CJ’s ongoing efforts to meet with offended parties, he discovered that Brent had unresolved offenses with him.[9] CJ contacted Brent with the hope of meeting to discuss any concerns. But rather than meeting with CJ, Brent sent a 128-page document to convey the ways that he thought CJ had sinned as well as to call upon CJ to publicly confess.[10] Brent’s document arrived around March 17, 2010. In the document, Brent declined CJ’s request for a meeting and instead insisted[11] that CJ respond in writing.[12] At first CJ did not write back,[13] holding out hope for a personal meeting rather than the less personal and, in his and others’ mind, less helpful exchanges of lengthy written documents.[14] But Brent was reluctant to meet, and CJ decided to accommodate Brent’s request[15] and engage the document to see what God would say. So this is what transpired.

First CJ took the summer and fall of 2010 to meet with all the principal players involved in the various situations Brent described.[16] This included the Covenant Life board of elders, the Sovereign Grace leadership teams (the old one and new one), his wife, and others. In all of this, CJ’s desire was to discover where Brent was remembering accurately or seeing things clearly. As CJ pursued others’ perspective on Brent’s concerns, he saw with greater clarity ways he had, in fact, sinned against Brent.[17] Moreover, there were also areas where he had exercised poor leadership.[18] CJ was seeing some pivotal stuff, which only strengthened his desire to meet with Brent.

Next the board moved from involvement in the process to taking over the process[19] so that we could help evaluate Brent’s concerns[20] and also help CJ stand accountable for any sins he committed. In retrospect, we wished we would have done this sooner…this whole process is teaching us much about what it really means to be a board.[21] But regardless of our slowness,[22] CJ welcomed our role and the additional layer of help and accountability. Board members were also able to solicit counsel on how to proceed from leaders inside and outside of SGM.

On October 8, we then received a second document [A Final Appeal] from Brent numbering 165 pages. In it Brent was more expansive on his concerns about CJ and continued to insist upon a public confession.[23]

Convicted of his sin and more keenly aware of his weakness, CJ wrote to Brent acknowledging and confessing sin, seeking to address the primary categories,[24] and appealing for a meeting so CJ could convey his heart and seek Brent’s forgiveness. (This confession was sent on December 11, 2010. It is the first document attached.) However, Brent was unsatisfied with CJ’s specificity[25] and felt CJ needed to respond in more detail to Brent’s specific accusations.[26] Now for the record, because I was right there in all the meetings, CJ and the board were open to a public confession but we did not see the need for a broader confession[27] beyond those immediately affected.[28] However, before making a final decision on that, we thought, and the counsel we received confirmed this, that a thorough, objective mediation process[29] would be necessary to determine CJ’s culpability and the reasonableness of Brent’s demands.[30] But Brent still refused to meet with CJ[31] and declined an outside mediator.[32] He indicated that he would prefer to send along another document.[33]


Believing that a more thorough confession[34] might be a healthy exercise for CJ’s soul while also supplying Brent with something that seemed important to him,[35] the SGM board directed CJ to create a more extensive confession.[36] This confession was sent on March 11, 2011 and is the second document attached. Along with CJ’s confession, the SGM board also sent a communiqué written to (a) detail our perspective on the situation, (b) appeal for Brent to meet with CJ and any outside mediator, and (c) offer other options for meetings with various people (along with a mediator) to Brent. That document is attached as well.[37]

But there was also a concern emerging for the board. We wanted to clearly acknowledge and deal with any of CJ’s sin,[38] but it also seemed important to recognize that the entire situation was being framed by Brent’s sole perspective.[39] Equally important was that there seemed to be a number of areas[40] where Brent’s take on things was dramatically different than the others involved.[41] It seemed both biblical and logical to recognize that reconciliation doesn’t come by one man presenting his interpretation and standing on it[42] as the authoritative version of reality[43] but by two parties humbly interacting over recollections with honesty[44] and love.[45] But despite that concern, the board determined there were certain points of truth[46] in Brent’s documents that CJ needed to process and confess. CJ agreed with this. So our letter to Brent acknowledged agreement with some of Brent’s points and reiterated our appeal to pursue mediation.

In short, Brent would not meet. Out of concern over Brent’s apparent revision of certain points of history, Steve Shank and I sent along a letter to Brent dated April 1, 2011 (attached).[47] On March 29th, Ken Sande also sent a letter to Brent[48] (attached also). In all of this, Brent refused to meet with CJ, declined a mediator, and informed us that he would begin to prepare another document.[49]


Yesterday Brent responded with another 199-page document. In it he informed us that he would now be conveying his concerns to the pastors of Sovereign Grace and certain others outside of SGM.[50] So now you know why it’s necessary to download all of this information[51] on you.

Guys, we want to reiterate something here: there were ways that CJ sinned against Brent.[52] And we believe this has hurt Brent deeply. CJ also grieves over this reality, as does the SGM board. And that’s where we would counsel you not to react hastily to Brent or impulsively come to CJ’s defense.[53] CJ and the SGM board are not looking for vindication[54] nor do we desire to shift the focus towards Brent.[55] Our hope is for an open process of reconciliation for the good of God’s glory and all involved. So if there is any identification with CJ, let it be to identify with the pursuit of humility that he has displayed throughout this process.[56] And please pray for CJ and Brent as this situation unfolds.

Now it’s important that the board convey something else to you. The board has spent hundreds of hours examining these documents, meeting together, evaluating CJ[57] and attempting to persuade Brent to meet with a mediator.[58] We (the board) want you to know that CJ has submitted himself completely to the board and that submission has been evidenced by his vigorous soul-searching, his aggressive pursuit of Brent, and his overall posture of humility through careful listening and transparent confession.[59] The SGM board can think of nothing more to ask of CJ in the pursuit of reconciliation with Brent.[60] However, in order to ensure the most thorough and objective process possible, the board has decided to take the additional step of engaging an independent panel of mediators (external to SGM and our relational network) who are trained to evaluate such difficult situations, taking into account all relevant information, considering all perspectives, and providing objective feedback. We feel this is the best way to bring a God-glorifying resolution to these circumstances.[61]

As for this e-mail and the accompanying documents, please forward them no further than your pastoral team/elders/leadership team and ask them not to forward them at all.

Now I know that’s a lot to process so let me just wrap up with the SGM boards commitment to you:


1) We will be happy to answer any questions about anything.[62] Give us a few days to consult with the regional leaders (providentially, we have a retreat next week) and figure out the best way to process any questions or feedback. If you have any immediate or pressing questions though, please contact Jeff, Josh or myself and one of us will be back in contact with you.

2) We will continue to appeal to Brent for conciliation and mediation with CJ.[63]

3) We will initiate the independent review process to evaluate every piece of information relevant to this situation as referenced above.[64]

4) We will seek to faithfully fulfill our role of providing accountability to CJ.[65]

5) We will appropriately inform you[66] of any important developments and consider how we might use upcoming contexts like the Pastors Conference for an update.

6) We welcome any insights you have to offer or any counsel on how to proceed.[67]

7) We will continue to treasure[68] the investment that Brent made into SGM during his many years of leadership.

Gentlemen, it ain’t pretty…but it’s a faithful narrative of a sad tale.[69] Yet we are learning much and we cherish the hope of restored fellowship with Brent in the future.[70] Until then we labor, together, as partners, in a family, for the gospel.

On behalf of the board,
[Master] Dave

[1] “The “very difficult situation” had been unfolding for over a decade not 18 months. Dave did not provide the SGM pastors with the much larger context.
[2] I imagine Dave is in tears as he writes. J This sentence makes me laugh and cry. If it was “sad day for all us” you’d think I’d hear from the SG family including C.J. Not a chance. With very few exceptions, I heard from no one. I was cut off by long-time friends who were afraid to contact me. Given what they were hearing from C.J., Dave, Bob and Gene it was little wonder why. I was persona non grata.
[3] Out of the gate, Dave puts himself and the Board in a good light and me in a bad light. They are the ones interested in reconciliation but I am not. He doesn’t say why they were unsuccessful. It was due to the Board’s and C.J.’s unwillingness to provide a thorough response to my documents as promised and acknowledge the need for C.J. to make a public confession.
[4] Dave doesn’t say why I needed to share my concerns with the SGM pastors. For instance, “But the most serious issues I’ve brought to your [C.J.] attention have been ignored, repudiated or denied. Things like deceit, lying, covering-up, hypocrisy, lording, and favoritism. I take no delight in saying this, but you and Sovereign Grace Ministries cannot be trusted until these things are acknowledged.” (CR, p. 201)
[5] Again, Dave doesn’t explain the long process behind this necessary action. “Well, we have reached the end of the road. It is now time for me to share my concerns with the Sovereign Grace pastors. For the longest time, I never entertained this course of action. It was inconceivable. But we are at a different place today. You [C.J.] have refused to address or acknowledge many sins of a serious nature and the Board of Directors has taken insufficient action in its correction and discipline of you. Others [like Dave, Bob, Gene] have gone unaddressed as well.” (CR, p. 201) I had to tell the pastors having exhausted every possible recourse and having kept this information confidential for three decades.
[6] This “as well as others outside of SG” was slander by hype! Here’s what I wrote, “I also plan to make my thoughts available to a small group of former Sovereign Grace pastors or employees. Nine to be exact: Dave Bendinelli, George Harrington, Keith Jacob, Bo Lotinksy, Dan McIntosh, Paul Palmer, Todd Twining, Dan Walsh, Steve Whitman. I’ll ask everyone not to make hard copies for distribution or electronically forward any of my material” (CR, p. 201, footnote 443). Dave was trumping up charges. He tempts them to sin and think, “Can you believe it? Brent was even going to share with people outside of Sovereign Grace Ministries. I mean what a slanderous jerk!” In the end, I sent the documents to five of the nine men.
[7] Concerns not only for C.J. but for the movement and other key individuals in SGM.
[8] This statement was one of the reasons I included “The Untold Story” in the documents I sent the SGM pastors. Otherwise, they’d have absolutely no idea what really happen in reference to my resignation and the closing of Grace Community Church in Mooresville, NC.
[9] This is completely misleading. C.J. already knew there were offenses. Dave is putting C.J. in a positive light when the facts put him in a deceptive light. See RRF&D, pp. 1-3, 88-94.
[10] How incredibly callous, unwarranted and extreme of me! Asking C.J. to make a public confession must be comparable to the unpardonable sin.
[11] This conveys a horrible attitude on my part instead of a reasonable request.
[12] This too is completely misleading. I was eager to meet with C.J. Dave makes no mention of this. Nor does Dave explain why it was so important to me for C.J. to write in preparation for a meeting. If C.J. had written me in a thorough fashion we would have met. The reason we did not meet was C.J.’s refusal to be open and honest in print.
[13] “At first.” This is misleading also. It took ten months of constant appeals before C.J. finally wrote me on Dec 16, 2010.
[14] Dave sets this up as an either/or arrangement. Either a personal meeting or lengthy written documents. Of course this was a false dichotomy and misleading one. I wanted both to happen. First writing. Second meeting. Dave leaves this out entirely and deceives his audience in so doing.
[15] After fighting me tooth and nail. It was only in desperation and as a last resort that C.J. wrote me because “A Final Appeal” (Oct 8, 2010) was my final appeal. I was serious about my two conditions being met.
[16] Dave gives credit to C.J. that is not deserved. C.J. had no choice. He had to involve others or his goose was cooked – well done for that matter! One of the major charges against C.J. was his extreme independence and blatant lack of accountability. He had no alternative but to contact others.
[17] And against many others like Larry Tomczak. Dave minimized the depth and breadth of C.J.’s sins. He reduced it to Brent and C.J. rather than C.J. and a very long list of people. Again he misleads the pastors. It is dishonestly by omission.
[18] “Poor leadership.” You mean abusive leadership? You mean independent and self-sufficient leadership. You mean unaccountable leadership. Dave uses morally neutral language that doesn’t begin to convey the serious issues surrounding C.J.’s failed leadership.
[19] Dave doesn’t tell the SGM pastors that the Board cut off my access to C.J. and labeled my on-going concerns for C.J. as “fruitless.” They put C.J. under a gag order and didn’t allow him to answer my hard questions. C.J. was able to hide behind the Board.
[20] Dave only mentions “Brent’s concerns.” There is no indication that “Brent’s concerns” were also Dave’s concerns and those of many others over the past decade. Dave sets it up as Brent against C.J. and doesn’t mention the scores of people who’ve had the same kind of experiences with C.J. including Dave himself. Spin and more spin. It makes me dizzy.
[21] The real lesson the Board needed to learn was how to deal with C.J. and not treat him in a preferential manner.
[22] The real question is “Why was C.J. so slow in responding to me?” C.J. provided the answer. He acknowledged he kept the pressure on me for 10 months in hopes I would relinquish my two conditions for meeting. When this did not happen he finally capitulated and wrote. He tried to leverage me but I did not give in because I knew an open, honest and accountable response in writing was vital.
[23] Dave never explained why I felt a public confession was incumbent upon C.J. My request was not unreasonable. Throughout our history scores of men have confessed in public for far less serious sins. I needed to know if C.J. saw the serious nature of his sins and was therefore willing to confess them.
[24] This is entirely untrue. C.J. completely ignored 10 of the 15 categories of sin I brought to his attention. See “Concluding Remarks,” pp. 88-89.
[25] For good reason. See “Concluding Remarks,” pages 90-97.
[26] Why was I “unsatisfied”? Because C.J. promised to address all the issues I raised. Instead, he purposely passed over hundreds of important points, illustrations, and questions. That is why I added 400 endnotes to RRF&D and AFA and sent them to C.J., Dave, Jeff and Joshua on June 8, 2011. I didn’t expect answers to all 400 but I needed to show that C.J. was being extremely evasive and unaccountable.
[27] Finally, an answer after 16 months of asking. No public confession was necessary. I repeatedly asked C.J. and the Board if they felt public repentance was needed. C.J. never answered me and neither did the Board. I asked them time and time again but they refused to be open and honest with me. The same was true for a ton of other issues, questions, and illustrations. I was promised answers but they never provided them. That’s why we didn’t meet. I didn’t care if they disagreed with me. I repeatedly invited their critique and asked them to defend themselves. I did all of this with a view to meeting not publishing their answers. But in the same way they refused to be honest when they saw no need for a public confession, they refused to be honest about so many other things.
[28] “Beyond those immediately affected.” How many people does that include now? What is the latest count by AoR? Hundreds? This is silly. C.J. sins have affected all of Sovereign Grace Ministries and people throughout the movement have confessed publicly for far less serious sins for decades. What an example of favoritism by the Board. They give C.J. a special exemption. Even though he doesn’t qualify he still gets to play. There are no penalties when C.J. breaks the rules. His sins remain secret.
[29] That is now a joke. The adjudication process forced upon me was not “thorough” or “objective.” It was extremely limited in scope. Only one issue would be examined. Is C.J. qualified to be President and Chairman of SGM. I was promised a complete evaluation of SGM including Harvey, Shank, Kauflin and Emerson. It was also extremely partial. I was promised outside evaluators. Instead, they required a SGM Board Member be put on the five man panel. That’s like me putting Jim (Refuge) or Kris (Survivors) on the panel – no offense intended. Furthermore, a thorough examination of C.J. and SGM would take at least six weeks given the mountains of evidence to be presented. Not the four days presented in the proposal.
[30] My demands were horrendous! Honest answers and acknowledging the need for confession.
[31] I refused but I also appealed and reiterated my desire to meet. Of course, Dave does not acknowledge this and he doesn’t say why I refused. C.J. and the Board were not being open and honest with me. They would not answer my question about confession and they refused to provide me thorough and accountable answers to so much else.
[32] I wrote the following to Ken Sande the same day Dave sent this letter to SGM pastors! I could tell the SGM Board was attempting to frame me but I didn’t know they were about to unveil the Mono Lisa a few hours later. “Of course, they [the SGM Board] totally misrepresent my position. I’ve been very desirous of meeting with them and C.J. from the beginning. I’ve repeatedly communicated my eagerness to talk in person and pursue reconciliation; but, I’ve also set two conditions (i.e., a thorough response to the issues I raised and the need for public confession). They have steadfastly refused to provide the former or agree to the later. I wish they’d be honest and just say, “Brent, your conditions are crazy. We are not going to answer your questions, address your concerns, or deal with your illustrations in print. Yes, we promised to do so but we’ve changed our mind. We fully realize our decision ends the possibility of moving forward with reconciliation.” Instead they frame the issue in order to put me in the worse possible light. It is another example of manipulation and spin. It is part of a predictable pattern. I have lost hope. They cannot be trusted.”
[33] That was Concluding Remarks. Why? Because of C.J.’s stubbornness to follow through on his promise and the Board’s unwillingness to require any kind of public confession. There was also a lot of material left to cover. That is still the case. Hundreds and hundreds of pages could be added.
[34] You can’t have a “more thorough confession.” That’s a contradiction of terms but more importantly, it is another misleading statement. The facts show C.J.’s response on Dec 16, 2010 was far from thorough.
[35] Dave makes it sound like they were heroically going out of their way to accommodate me and “do something that seemed important” to me. “Seemed important?” Of course it was important and they knew why. All I was doing was asking C.J. to be a man of his word.
[36] This is terribly misleading also. The SGM Board did this in large measure because I was pressing them to hold C.J. accountable to follow through on his promise to provide a thorough response.
[37] This 2½ page response by the SGM Board to my 600 plus pages conveyed no concern for any problems in the movement or with other key individuals in the movement. It acknowledged no need for a public confession and didn’t address the lack of thoroughness in C.J.’s second confession. It expressed no concern for Jenny and me and what we’d been through.
[38] This is not true. Clearly acknowledge? Not to me. Not to the CLC pastors. Not to the SGM pastors. Not to CLC. Not to the movement. The SGM Board has never defined C.J.’s sins let alone made them clear to the public. Deal with C.J.’s sins? Really? By declaring him totally fit for ministry and above reproach a month later on July 13. The SGM Board has not dealt with C.J. They’ve coddle him. They’ve even expressed regret he ever took a leave of absence as President and see that decision as a mistake. Furthermore, they counseled C.J. to leave Covenant Life Church for Capitol Hill Baptist Church without ever talking to the CLC pastors. That’s really dealing with C.J. and holding him accountable! Only C.J. can just pick put and leave his church and pastors without talking to them. That’s an arrangement no one in the history of SGM has ever been granted.
[39] This was preposterous and Dave knows it. Many people have registered concerns for C.J. and the number grows every day.
[40] The SGM Board has yet to bring up even one area from “a number of areas.” This statement discredited the documents on a wide scale basis without offering any proof. According to Dave, my version was not only different from others but “dramatically different.” If so, that should be easy to prove. But where is the evidence? There is none. See Concluding Remarks, pp. 193-198.
[41] I have repeatedly asked to be shown where my “my take on things was dramatically different.” Except for C.J.’s denials and rebuttals which I included in CR, no one has contended with me. I am also happy to present my case against C.J. and the SGM Board in presence of all the SGM pastors and let them judge for themselves. I’d also be glad to have it streamed live on the internet for all the SGM churches. The SGM Board cannot be trusted to righteously decide C.J.’s future.
[42] This was a libelous comment about my supposed pride. Per Dave, I had the gall to stand against C.J., the Board and others. How arrogant! Again, I’ve repeatedly asked to be corrected with primary source material or other reliable evidence. None has been produced. I’ve done my best to write accurately and I am happy to be shown any errors. When shown, I’ll gladly change my perspective and correct my writings.
[43] I don’t think The Documents are infallible but they are credible, reliable, truthful and fundamentally accurate. I don’t mind someone discrediting me with facts and evidence but not with sweeping statements which are utterly unsupported here or elsewhere. That is cowardly and unfair. As the saying goes, put up or shut up.
[44] I’ve repeatedly asked them to be perfectly honest. Instead C.J. and the SGM Board have been dishonest on many occasions. That is one reason I asked them to interact with me in print before we met. And I believe that is one reason they refused to do so.
[45] “Love?” You mean like I’ve experienced the past 7 years? Anyway, I asked C.J. to interact “with honesty and love” in writing. When he did so, I looked forward to interacting with him in person. If he really wanted to meet in person, he would have followed through on his word to interact in print. Even if he didn’t prefer print, what harm was there in writing? I believe he was he afraid to open, honest and accountable.
[46] Wow, after all that how kind of Dave to acknowledge there were at least “certain points of truth ”
[47] If Dave were concerned about the truth he would have attached my response to his and Steve’s letter (see CR, pp. 197-198). I’ve always included “evidence” against me in my writings. Not Dave. The same thing occurred again with their October 13 blog post, An update on the adjudication process. I asked them to include my statement. They didn’t even mention it. You got it. Sovereign Grace Ministries…the most trusted name in Christendom…fair, balanced and unafraid.
[48] I think Ken now understands why I was unwilling to meet with C.J. until he interacted with me in print. I wonder if Ken hasn’t been troubled by the actions of C.J., Dave and the Board in recent months.
[49] Once again this is extremely slanted. I told C.J. and the SGM Board I would love to meet but they must agree to my two simple conditions. Dave nowhere states this in his letter.
[50] This is a totally misleading and alarming statement that gives the wrong impression. See endnote #6 for what I actually told Dave.
[51] I think Dave meant to say “propaganda.”
[52] My documents are not simply about how C.J. sinned against me. Far from it. They are about how he sinned against Dave Harvey, Paul Palmer, Bo Lotinsky, Larry Tomczak, Kenny Roberts, Joshua Harris, Grant Layman, Kenneth Maresco, to mention a few. This doesn’t include his sins against CLC and SGM. And there are so many other individuals C.J. has sinned against that I’ve not included in The Documents.
[53] Of course, this letter had that very effect because it was so misleading. In fact, pastors in SGM refused to read The Documents because of this letter from Dave. Some even sent me hate mail. Many like Mickey Connolly told their churches not to read them. In the twisted world of SGM, Dave can write a letter like this one, which is genuinely deceitful and slanderous, while condemning people for reading my documents which are credible and necessary given the spin, favoritism, and obstinacy.
[54] C.J. and the Board are not looking for vindication? That’s good to know. That means this letter from Dave has nothing to do with putting C.J. and the Board in a good light and me in a bad light.
[55] Of course not. But wait a minute. Let’s re-read this letter. It sure seems like the focus is on me. Oh well, I guess it’s my paranoia. And if my memory serves me right, didn’t Dave do a SGM blog post on July 13 where the focus was on me? If I’m not mistaken, I was totally trashed while C.J. was totally vindicated. I thought they weren’t concerned about vindication? Well, who knows? Along with my paranoia, I must be demented and schizoid and, oh no, vertigo is setting in again! The room is spinning. In fact, the whole SGM world is starting to spin. Help! If you too feel nauseated and want relief see Sovereign Grace Ministries Board of Directors announcement regarding C.J. Mahaney and read The Documents at BrentDetwiler.com for the truth. Praise God, the dizziness is back under control.
[56] C.J.’s actions have been reactive and due to external pressures. Never proactive. Dave’s description of C.J.’s initiative is unfounded. The real C.J. has confessed very little, left his church, repudiated his pastors, blamed Joshua Harris, refused to walk in the light, lined up support from Christian celebrities, blocked a real evaluation by signing the bogus Adjudication Agreement, is headed to a SGM church other than CLC, and may soon come back as President from which he can continue draw a big salary, write books, get royalties, hit the speaking tour, collect honoraria, tell the world how he has been mistreated and be adored in the Reformed world.
[57] And coming up with practically nothing. They’ve had no serious concerns for C.J.
[58] While I spent far more time writing the documents and trying to persuade them to provide transparent, revealing, and clear answers in preparation for a meeting.
[59] I sure hope the 18 pastors from CLC give an open and honest report of their dealings with C.J. to combat this hype.
[60] Put yourself in my gallery seat. Dave’s brush stroke is amazing. Breathtaking. Look, he’s putting the final touches on the ubiquitous eyes of Mona Lisa. The SGM Board can think of nothing more to ask of C.J. Every possible remedy has been pursued. Now the portrait is complete. The Mona Lisa of spin is finished. Her eyes of deceit follow you everywhere. Master Harvey, left out the only two things I ever asked for from C.J., Dave, Jeff and Joshua. But only the most discerning critic notices what is missing in the painting. If only C.J. and the Board had agreed a public confession was good and necessary, and if only the Board had been willing to have C.J. provide a thorough response to RRF&D and AFA, reconciliation could have occurred. But the novice never notice this accent of truth is famously left out of the portrait. It is marvelous for what it doesn’t include. In fact, when I re-read my first document, RRF&D, I am sickened by the extraordinary opportunity C.J. missed because he was unwilling to walk in the light with me and the public. So look at her eyes. In one is the love of reputation and in the other is self-preservation. Gaze in awe at Master Harvey’s Mona Lisa of spin. It is a work for the ages.
[61] I am grateful for the AoR Group Reconciliation process but it secures absolutely nothing because the findings and results remain strictly confidential and under the control of the SGM Board. In my case, I was promised a much different process. That was the opportunity to make an open and thorough case against C.J. and others within SGM to an outside panel of evaluators with the results published online. It was promised by the old Board and killed by the new Board. The “sovereign” Board gives and takes away when self-interest is served.
[62] Of course, this is a great way to do damage control and provide talking points.
[63] They should have been appealing to C.J. to humble himself in writing and in public which would have resulted in conciliation and mediation.
[64] What a cruel joke. The SGM Board reversed themselves and is no longer doing an independent review process. Furthermore, they send me an Adjudication Agreement that did not allow a process “to evaluate every piece of information relevant to this situation.” The situation referred to was my documented concerns for C.J. and other key leaders. The Board purposely confined the scope of the evaluation. It was limited to C.J. More deceit.
[65] By defending him at every turn and allowing him to flee his pastors at Covenant Life Church.
[66] That means a lot of “inappropriate” information will be concealed. I mean kept confidential.
[67] C.J. and the Board “welcome” input nowadays. It’s good for public relations. They have to appear humble and teachable. But this can be a con. C.J. would often “welcome” input but then totally disregard it. It must going from welcoming to following input and not just the stuff you want to hear. I don’t see evidence of that happening. They certainly haven’t acted upon any of my input. They either headed the other direction or welcomed it initially but only to reject it later.
[68] This must be a typo. I think Dave meant to say “trash” not “treasure.” Here’s why. During the five years following the August 20, 2004 meeting (see RRF&D, pp. 16-28), I endured harsh criticism and rejection by C.J. and those close to him. For example, Dave told me in August 2007, I did not represent the values of SGM in my preaching, leadership, or character. And Jeff Purswell told me in January 2008, there was no need for me to teach in the Pastors College any longer (see RRF&D, pp. 122-125). Dave and Jeff, and other agents like Bob Kauflin and Gene Emerson, spoke and acted on C.J.’s behalf. I was not treasure. I was trash. That’s why I wrote C.J. on June 21, 2010 and said, “I’d love to return to Sovereign Grace Ministries but change must occur in order to restore my trust and confidence in its integrity. Nor am I currently welcome by you or acceptable to you. Gene counseled people to force my resignation before any evaluation, Bob has pronounced me unfit for ministry and in need of a lengthy rehabilitation, Dave has forbidden me from visiting all Sovereign Grace churches until I change, and you have said we cannot serve together because of your disagreements with me over doctrine and practice. I am also reminded of Dave’s words to Jenny and me that I have not represented the values, leadership or doctrine of Sovereign Grace Ministries’ during my years of service. As a result, a sense of belonging in Sovereign Grace Ministries escapes me.”
[69] This famous line summed it all up! Dave’s account was a “faithful narrative.” My 600 pages of documentation were a “sad tale.” All the work, all the research, all the patience, all the appeals, all the documentation derided as a sad tale. I am now accustomed to this kind of ridicule by Dave but to fully appreciate his brilliance, you must contemplate the purposeful contrast. Dave’s rendition was faithful to the facts. His story was true and credible. My rendition was false and spurious. And my pathetic tale was also a tall tale. It was both pitiful and false. This kind of statement revealed Dave’s true state of heart. One of arrogance and self-righteousness.
[70] Pardon me but here in NC we have a lot of pig farms and this is pure hogwash. When I resigned from the apostolic team in November 2007, when my resignation as sr. pastor was unscrupulously demanded in June 2009, and when I left SGM in August 2009, nothing said or done conveyed the cherished hope of fellowship restored. This gets me laughing. Everything underscored how glad SGM was I had been fired and left the movement. Those are just the facts.