Reformed Churchmen

We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879

Showing posts with label Calvinists in the Church of England. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Calvinists in the Church of England. Show all posts

Monday, March 19, 2012

Lee Gatiss: New Director of Church Society


Rev. Lee Gattis, Church of England,
a Reformed Anglican Prayer Book Man.
This is an excellent piece of news. 
Lee also understands the Protestant and
Calvinistic character of
old BCP Churchmanship

Indeed, some very, very good news.  While Lee finishes his PhD at Cambridge (I believe he got the ThM under Dr. Carl Trueman at WTS-P on Rev. Augustus Montague Toplady and old school Calvinism in the Church of England), he'll be running Church Society and centralizing operations at Cambridge.  Perhaps he'll meet the soon-to-be-ex CANTAUR when he, Roman Williams, repairs to Magdale College, Cambridge.  Lee understands the Protestant and Calvinistic face of old school Anglicanism.  As an exilic Anglican, deep inside Babylon for many years, we older folks need these young Daniels--these youngins bespeak to us old goats hope for better days and better presentations of the old biblical faith, doctrine, worship and quiet piety.  These young scholars speak afresh and anew.  May Lee's tribe--amongst the youth--be extended and may his tent be widened.


The Press Release is at:  http://www.churchsociety.org/press/PR_2012-03_LeeGatiss.asp

Press Releases


19 March 2012

New Director of Church Society

The Council of Church Society has announced today that the Revd Lee Gatiss has agreed to become the Society’s new Director with effect from 1st January 2013.

Lee is presently completing a PhD on Seventeenth Century biblical interpretation at Peterhouse, Cambridge. When he takes up the role of Church Society Director, he will remain in Cambridge, enabling the Society to develop its profile and work within the Cambridge churches, theological colleges, and other networks.

Lee is well known to the Society already as a speaker and writer and is a member of the Editorial Board of Churchman, as well as its Review Editor. He is also Editor of the Society’s Reformed Evangelical Anglican Library project (REAL).

In addition, Lee is a Visiting Lecturer in Church History at Wales Evangelical School of Theology and has lectured undergraduates and ordinands while in Cambridge, as well as speaking around the country and in various European cities (most recently Eger, Athens, and Nuremberg).

Prior to commencing his PhD, Lee was Associate Minister at St Helen's Church, Bishopsgate (2004 - 2009) and Assistant Curate at St Botolph's Church, Barton Seagrave with St Edmund’s, Warkton (2001 - 2004), a Church Society Trust parish.

Lee has a degree in Modern History from Oxford University, as well as Theology degrees from Westminster Theological Seminary (Philadelphia) and Oak Hill College. He is the editor of the internet journal Theologian (www.theologian.org.uk) and author/editor of many books and articles. He is married to Kerry and they have three children.

The Council of Church Society looks forward to working very closely with Lee in the ongoing development and shaping of the different aspects of the Society's activities.

In response to his appointment Lee commented that:

'I am delighted to accept this challenge and opportunity to continue serving Anglican Evangelicals at this crucial time in the history of the Church of England and Anglican Communion. Throughout its long history, Church Society has always been committed to what Her Majesty's coronation oath called "the true profession of the gospel... the Protestant Reformed religion." For the glory of God and the greater good of England and the world, it is my prayer that together we can strengthen and defend this precious inheritance as we make Christ known in our generation. I am thrilled to be playing a part in serving that vision as Director of Church Society."

Church Society Council

-End-


Wednesday, March 14, 2012

Cranmer's Curate: Oak Hill, Wycliffe Hall (Oxford) and Ridley Hall (Cambridge)

WHY OAK HILL STRUGGLES FOR SUPPORT
There are historical reasons why Oak Hill, the Reformed Anglican theological college in north London, struggles to get the backing of English conservative evangelicals. The roots of the current problem lie in the Oxbridge focus of late Victorian Anglican evangelical leaders such as J.C. Ryle.

Regularly select preacher at both Oxbridge universities in the 1870s, Ryle was instrumental in founding
Wycliffe Hall, Oxford in 1877 and Ridley Hall, Cambridge in 1881. Oxbridge was chosen as the strategic location for these residential clerical training colleges, laudably established as evangelical strongholds against the growing influence of Anglo-Catholicism in the national Church.

In the 20th century, the trajectory of Ryle's Oxbridge strategy led to the establishment of the Iwerne Minster ministry in the 1930s. This work was based on evangelistic holiday camps for boys from the top 30 English public schools. Iwerne's professed strategy was to reach the few in order to reach the many.
For more, see:
http://cranmercurate.blogspot.com/2012/03/why-oak-hill-struggles-for-support_14.html

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Urban Pastor: Evangelicals in the Church of England & Fanatics

The Urban Pastor, a Church of England cleric, brings a few notes about the situation in the Church of England.  We do endorse the idea that old Prayer Book Churchmanship puts a clamp on enthusiasts, fanatics and wild-eyed revivalists so common to the United States.  See:  http://theurbanpastor.wordpress.com/2012/03/08/economical-with-the-truth/.  Here's Urban Pastor:


"Interesting article from the Economist here. It’s about the alleged rise of evangelicalism in the Church of England. It doesn’t really analyse the increased marginalization of class or ‘conservative’ evangelicals, but you wouldn’t expect them to be aware of the complexity of the situation in the Church of England. I’m not sure I am! Or anyone is. But evangelicalism has increasingly come to be understood as an umbrella term covering over all manner of, let’s say, positions.

"If what Peter Brierley and his statisticians say is right, then the future of Anglicanism in this country is of declining numbers of Anglicans but an increased proportion of both clergy and laity who would describe themselves as evangelical. Whether that leads to increased influence in the denomination, brought about by sheer weight of numbers or perhaps by financial clout, remains to be seen. I’m not holding my breath. The trajectory of the Church of England is unmistakably clear. It would take a complete change of direction if evangelicalism was to be regarded as mainstream. God can do it, if He wants. And so there’s hope. But humanly speaking, the writing’s been on the wall for a while now. We press on (at the margins) in CCB. But others are more involved and will stay until they’re ejected. They wouldn’t be the first good guys to be excluded from the established church.
But despite that, you’ve got to love an article that begins with the following paragraph; not so much for the accuracy of the observation but the beauty of expression!
EVER since the 18th century, England’s established church has harboured a suspicion of religious enthusiasm. Anglicanism’s cosy ubiquity as a reassuring, if vestigial, presence in every English suburb and village is regarded as a defence against the sort of fanaticism that leads to social or ethnic conflict. But every so often in English church history, compromise and emollience have triggered a countervailing reaction: an upsurge in faith of a more passionate kind. Such a change may be under way now."
 For Urban Pastor's less cheerful conclusion, see the rest at:
http://theurbanpastor.wordpress.com/2012/03/08/economical-with-the-truth/

Monday, February 20, 2012

Why Bother with the Church of England?

http://theurbanpastor.wordpress.com/2012/02/20/why-bother-with-the-church-of-england/

Why Bother with the Church of England?

It was Friday night. I was looking for the Cardiff Blues game on the channels at the top end of the scale. And there it was; General Synod on the BBC Parliament Channel. I’d never seen it before. I was glued. I saw some familiar faces spread throughout the Church House debating chamber; Chris Hobbs (the St Thomas’ Oakwood one) had a natty crimson red v-neck sweater on. Even though supper was ready, Rosslyn couldn’t tear me away as I tried to follow a debate on various ammendments to a revisionist proposal concerning women and the episcopacy. In the end I just sat there in despair. This was the church that I belong to. And they don’t seem to like having people like me around! It prompted the question, ‘why bother with the Church of England?’


It’s one I revisit from time to time, especially given our precarious position on the edge of all things Church of England. This is Jonathan Fletcher’s answer. And it’s one I’m broadly happy with.

Jonathan’s case for remaining in the Church of England has four key components


1. Theologically the Church of England is, in Jonathan’s estimation, the best presentation of the Reformed Protestant faith. We see that in the Thirty Nine Articles and the doctrine of the Book of Common Prayer. These are the foundation documents upon which the Church of England has been built. Theologically it’s home for reformed evangelicals.


2. Liturgically the principles that lie behind the content of Cranmer’s Services are thoroughly helpful in ministry. Though we may wish to update the language of the liturgy, the priority of ensuring that our meetings are biblical, accessible, congregational and edifying is right.


3. Historically God has used the Church of England to bring revival to this country. Jonathan acknowledges that the C of E is in bad shape at the present. But, as he reminds us (not from personal experience!) it’s been worse than this. Back in the 18th century. And God worked through it to bring the gospel to the nation.


4. Pastorally many people in this country look to the Church of England for the support they need to live for Christ. It’s perhaps especially the case that in Urban Priority Areas and rural settings people look to the Parish Church for spiritual encouragement. Jonathan is unwilling to leave sheep without a shepherd.


It’s a great little video. It’s only 5 minutes long. And it may be worth watching if, like me from time to time, you just want to jump ship altogether!

Monday, February 13, 2012

ACCEPT NO SUBSTITUTES: The 1928 American Prayer Book Is NOT the 1662 Book of Common Prayer

Robin Jordan is exactly correct.  For "men of discerning spirits," there are some obvious reasons that the new American Anglican entities essentially bury the 1662 Book of Common Prayer. The time has come for a rational, thoughtful, doctrinal, energetic, and--yes--full-throated exploration of the issues. We expect nothing from www.virtueonline.org, www.standfirminfaith.org, or www.anglicanink.com.   We want answers.  Robin's article, in brief, follows.

ACCEPT NO SUBSTITUTES: The 1928 American Prayer Book Is NOT the 1662 Book of Common Prayer

By Robin G. JordanThe 1928 American Prayer Book differs from the classic Anglican Prayer Book, The Book of Common Prayer of 1662, in a number of ways. A number of these differences are significant. They show that the doctrine and liturgical usages of the 1928 American Prayer Book and the classic Anglican Prayer Book are not the same. They belie the claim that the 1928 book is the American edition of the 1662 book, an erroneous view that the Prayer Book Society USA has championed for a number of years.

It is noteworthy that none of the Prayer Book commentators in the first half of the twentieth century—E. Clowe Chorley (1929), W. K. Lowther Clarke (1932), Edward Lambe Parsons and Bayard Hale Jones (1937), and Massey Hamilton Shepherd, Jr. (1950) make such a claim. In their works they draw attention to the substantial differences between the two books.

The 1928 American Prayer Book was compiled at a time when Anglo-Catholicism and Broad Church latitudinarianism were the dominant influences in the American Episcopal Church. As a consequence the 1928 book reflects these influences. The 1928 revision was far-reaching and even radical in the changes that it introduced in the American Prayer Book.

The 1662 Book of Common Prayer was compiled two years after the restoration of the Stuart dynasty after an interregnum of almost 20 years. During the Commonwealth Period the Church of England was without bishops and a Prayer Book. Upon ascending the throne Charles II would take steps to restore the episcopate and the Book of Common Prayer.

The Restoration bishops were Laudian High Churchmen. While they made a number of minor alterations and additions to the Book of Common Prayer, they were for a large part content to leave the Prayer Book substantially as it was during the reign of Charles I. The revised book that they submitted to Convocation, Parliament, and the King was remarkably moderate in tone. It is essentially the 1552 Prayer Book.


For more, see:
http://anglicansablaze.blogspot.com/2012/02/accept-no-substitutes-1928-american.html

Tuesday, December 20, 2011

UK Prime Minister: Commemorating 400th Anniversary of the KJV


Commemorating the version's 400th anniversary


Check against delivery version

Prime Minister:


It’s great to be here and to have this opportunity to come together today to mark the end of this very special 400th anniversary year for the King James Bible.


I know there are some who will question why I am giving this speech.

And if they happen to know that I’m setting out my views today in a former home of the current Archbishop of Canterbury…


…and in front of many great theologians and church leaders…

…they really will think I have entered the lions’ den.
But I am proud to stand here and celebrate the achievements of the King James Bible.

Not as some great Christian on a mission to convert the world.

But because, as Prime Minister, it is right to recognise the impact of a translation that is, I believe, one of this country’s greatest achievements.


The Bible is a book that has not just shaped our country, but shaped the world.

And with 3 Bibles sold or given away every second…

…a book that is not just important in understanding our past, but which will continue to have a profound impact in shaping our collective future.

In making this speech I claim no religious authority whatsoever.

I am a committed – but I have to say vaguely practising – Church of England Christian, who will stand up for the values and principles of my faith…

…but who is full of doubts and, like many, constantly grappling with the difficult questions when it comes to some of the big theological issues.
But what I do believe is this.

The King James Bible is as relevant today as at any point in its 400 year history.

And none of us should be frightened of recognising this.

Why?

Put simply, three reasons.

First, the King James Bible has bequeathed a body of language that permeates every aspect of our culture and heritage…

….from everyday phrases to our greatest works of literature, music and art.

We live and breathe the language of the King James Bible, sometimes without even realising it.

And it is right that we should acknowledge this – particularly in this anniversary year.

Second, just as our language and culture is steeped in the Bible, so too is our politics.

From human rights and equality to our constitutional monarchy and parliamentary democracy…

…from the role of the church in the first forms of welfare provision, to the many modern day faith-led social action projects…


…the Bible has been a spur to action for people of faith throughout history, and it remains so today.

Third, we are a Christian country.

And we should not be afraid to say so.

Let me be clear: I am not in any way saying that to have another faith – or no faith – is somehow wrong.

I know and fully respect that many people in this country do not have a religion.
And I am also incredibly proud that Britain is home to many different faith communities, who do so much to make our country stronger.
But what I am saying is that the Bible has helped to give Britain a set of values and morals which make Britain what it is today.
Values and morals we should actively stand up and defend.

The alternative of moral neutrality should not be an option.

You can’t fight something with nothing.

Because if we don’t stand for something, we can’t stand against anything.

Let me take each of these points in turn.

First, language and culture.

Powerful language is incredibly evocative.

It crystallises profound, sometimes complex, thoughts and suggests a depth of meaning far beyond the words on the page…
…giving us something to share, to cherish, to celebrate.
Part of the glue that can help to bind us together.

Along with Shakespeare, the King James Bible is a high point of the English language…
…creating arresting phrases that move, challenge and inspire.
One of my favourites is the line “For now we see through a glass, darkly.”
It is a brilliant summation of the profound sense that there is more to life, that we are imperfect, that we get things wrong, that we should strive to see beyond our own perspective.
The key word is darkly – profoundly loaded, with many shades of meaning.

I feel the power is lost in some more literal translations.

The New International Version says: “Now we see but a poor reflection as in a mirror”
The Good News Bible: “What we see now is like a dim image in a mirror”
They feel not just a bit less special but dry and cold, and don’t quite have the same magic and meaning.
Like Shakespeare, the King James translation dates from a period when the written word was intended to be read aloud.
And this helps to give it a poetic power and sheer resonance that in my view is not matched by any subsequent translation.
It has also contributed immensely to the spread of spoken English around the world.
Indeed, the language of the King James Bible is very much alive today.

I’ve already mentioned the lions’ den.

Just think about some of the other things we all say.

Phrases like strength to strength…

…how the mighty are fallen…

…the skin of my teeth…

…the salt of the earth.

… nothing new under the sun.

According to one recent study there are 257 of these phrases and idioms that come from the Bible.
These phrases are all around us…

…from court cases to TV sitcoms…

…and from recipe books to pop music lyrics.

Of course, there is a healthy debate about the extent to which it was the King James version that originated the many phrases in our language today.


And it’s right to recognise the impact of earlier versions like Tyndale, Wycliffe, Douai-Rheims, the Bishops and Geneva Bibles too.


The King James Bible does exactly that…

…setting out with the stated aim of making a good translation better, or out of many good ones, to make “one principall good one”

But what is clear is that the King James version gave the Bible’s many expressions a much more widespread public presence.

Much of that dissemination has come through our literature, through the great speeches we remember and the art and music we still enjoy today.


From Milton to Morrison…

…and Coleridge to Cormac McCarthy…

…the Bible supports the plot, context, language and sometimes even the characters in some of our greatest literature.

Tennyson makes over 400 Biblical references in his poems.


…and makes allusions to 42 different books of the Bible.

The Bible has infused some of the greatest speeches…

…from Martin Luther King’s dream that Isaiah’s prophecy would be fulfilled and that one day “every valley shall be exalted…


…to Abraham Lincoln’s Gettysburg address which employed not just Biblical words but cadence and rhythms borrowed from the King James Bible as well.


When Lincoln said that his forefathers “brought forth” a new nation, he was imitating the way in which the Bible announced the birth of Jesus.

The Bible also runs through our art.

From Giotto to El Greco…

…and Michelangelo to Stanley Spencer.

The paintings in Sandham Memorial Chapel in Berkshire are some of my favourite works of art.
Those who died in Salonika rising to heaven is religious art in the modern age and, in my view, as powerful as some of what has come before.

And the Bible runs through our music too.

From the great oratorios like J S Bach’s Matthew and John Passions and Handel’s Messiah…

…to the wealth of music written across the ages for mass and evensong in great cathedrals like this one.

The Biblical settings of composers from Tallis to Taverner are regularly celebrated here in this great cathedral…

…and will sustain our great British tradition of choral music for generations to come.

It’s impossible to do justice in a short speech to the full scale of the cultural impact of the King James Bible.

But what is clear is that four hundred years on, this book is still absolutely pivotal to our language and culture.

And that’s one very good reason for us all to recognise it today.

A second reason is this.

Just as our language and culture is steeped in the Bible, so too is our politics.

The Bible runs through our political history in a way that is often not properly recognised.

The history and existence of a constitutional monarchy owes much to a Bible in which Kings were anointed and sanctified with the authority of God…


….and in which there was a clear emphasis on the respect for Royal Power and the need to maintain political order.

Jesus said: “Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”

And yet at the same time, the Judeo-Christian roots of the Bible also provide the foundations for protest and for the evolution of our freedom and democracy.


The Torah placed the first limits on Royal Power.

And the knowledge that God created man in his own image was, if you like, a game changer for the cause of human dignity and equality.


In the ancient world this equity was inconceivable.

In Athens for example, full and equal rights were the preserve of adult, free born men.

But when each and every individual is related to a power above all of us…

…and when every human being is of equal and infinite importance, created in the very image of God…

…we get the irrepressible foundation for equality and human rights…

…a foundation that has seen the Bible at the forefront of the emergence of democracy, the abolition of slavery…

…and the emancipation of women – even if not every church has always got the point!
Crucially the translation of the Bible into English made all this accessible to many who had previously been unable to comprehend the Latin versions.

And this created an unrelenting desire for change.

The Putney debates in the Church of St Mary the Virgin in 1647 saw the first call for One Man, One vote…

…and the demand that authority be invested in the House of Commons rather than the King.

Reading the Bible in English gave people equality with each other through God.

And this led them to seek equality with each other through government.

In a similar way, the Bible provides a defining influence on the formation of the first welfare state.

In Matthew’s Gospel, Jesus says that whatever people have done “unto one of the least of these my brethren”…

… they have done unto him.

Just as in the past it was the influence of the church that enabled hospitals to be built, charities created, the hungry fed, the sick nursed and the poor given shelter…


…so today faith based groups are at the heart of modern social action.

Organisations like the Church Urban Fund which has supported over 5,000 faith based projects in England’s poorest communities…

…including the Near Neighbours Programme which Eric Pickles helped to launch last month.

And St Ethelburga’s Centre for Reconciliation and Peace in London’s Bishopsgate…

…a building once destroyed by an IRA bomb…

…but now a centre where people divided by conflict, culture or religion can meet and listen to each other’s perspective.


In total, there are almost 30 thousand faith based charities in this country…

…not to mention the thousands of people who step forward as individuals, as families, as communities, as organisations and yes, as churches….


…and do extraordinary things to help build a bigger, richer, stronger, more prosperous and more generous society.

And when it comes to the great humanitarian crises – like the famine in Horn of Africa – again you can count on faith-based organisations…

…like Christian Aid, Tearfund, CAFOD, Jewish Care, Islamic Relief, and Muslim Aid…
…to be at the forefront of the action to save lives.

So it’s right to recognise the huge contribution our faith communities make to our politics.

…and to recognise the role of the Bible in inspiring many of their works.

People often say that politicians shouldn’t “do God.”

If by that they mean we shouldn’t try to claim a direct line to God for one particular political party…

…they could not be more right.

But we shouldn’t let our caution about that stand in the way of recognising both what our faith communities bring to our country…


…and also just how incredibly important faith is to so many people in Britain.

The Economist may have published the obituary of God in their Millennium issue.

But in the past century, the proportion of people in the world who adhere to the four biggest religions has actually increased from around two-thirds to nearly three quarters…

…and is forecast to continue rising.

For example, it is now thought there are at least 65 million protestants in China and 12 million Catholics – more Christians than there are members of the communist party.


Official numbers indicate China has about 20 million Muslims – almost as many as in Saudi Arabia – and nearly twice as many as in the whole of the EU.


And by 2050, some people think China could well be both the world’s biggest Christian nation and its biggest Muslim one too.


Here in Britain we only have to look at the reaction to the Pope’s visit last year…

…this year’s Royal Wedding…
…or of course the festival of Christmas next week, to see that Christianity is alive and well in our country.

The key point is this.

Societies do not necessarily become more secular with modernity but rather more plural, with a wider range of beliefs and commitments.


And that brings me to my third point.

The Bible has helped to shape the values which define our country.

Indeed, as Margaret Thatcher once said, “we are a nation whose ideals are founded on the Bible.”

Responsibility, hard work, charity, compassion, humility, self-sacrifice, love…

…pride in working for the common good and honouring the social obligations we have to one another, to our families and our communities…


…these are the values we treasure.

Yes, they are Christian values.

And we should not be afraid to acknowledge that.

But they are also values that speak to us all – to people of every faith and none.

And I believe we should all stand up and defend them.

Those who oppose this usually make the case for secular neutrality.

They argue that by saying we are a Christian country and standing up for Christian values we are somehow doing down other faiths.


And that the only way not to offend people is not to pass judgement on their behaviour.

I think these arguments are profoundly wrong.

And being clear on this is absolutely fundamental to who we are as a people…

…what we stand for…

…and the kind of society we want to build.
First, those who say being a Christian country is doing down other faiths…

…simply don’t understand that it is easier for people to believe and practise other faiths when Britain has confidence in its Christian identity.


Many people tell me it is much easier to be Jewish or Muslim here in Britain than it is in a secular country like France.


Why?

Because the tolerance that Christianity demands of our society provides greater space for other religious faiths too.

And because many of the values of a Christian country are shared by people of all faiths and indeed by people of no faith at all.


Second, those who advocate secular neutrality in order to avoid passing judgement on the behaviour of others…

…fail to grasp the consequences of that neutrality…

…or the role that faith can play in helping people to have a moral code.
Let’s be clear.
Faith is neither a necessary nor sufficient condition for morality.
There are Christians who don’t live by a moral code.
And there are atheists and agnostics who do.
But for people who do have a faith, their faith can be a helpful prod in the right direction.
And whether inspired by faith or not – that direction, that moral code, matters.
Whether you look at the riots last summer…

…the financial crash and the expenses scandal…

…or the on-going terrorist threat from Islamist extremists around the world…

…one thing is clear: moral neutrality or passive tolerance just isn’t going to cut it anymore.

Shying away from speaking the truth about behaviour, about morality…

…has actually helped to cause some of the social problems that lie at the heart of the lawlessness we saw with the riots.


The absence of any real accountability, or moral code…

…allowed some bankers and politicians to behave with scant regard for the rest of society.

And when it comes to fighting violent extremism, the almost fearful passive tolerance of religious extremism that has allowed segregated communities to behave in ways that run completely counter to our values…


… has not contained that extremism but allowed it to grow and prosper…

…in the process blackening the good name of the great religions that these extremists abuse for their own purposes.

Put simply, for too long we have been unwilling to distinguish right from wrong.

“Live and let live” has too often become “do what you please”.
Bad choices have too often been defended as just different lifestyles.

To be confident in saying something is wrong…

…is not a sign of weakness, it’s a strength.

But we can’t fight something with nothing.
As I’ve said if we don’t stand for something, we can’t stand against anything.

One of the biggest lessons of the riots last Summer is that we’ve got stand up for our values if we are to confront the slow-motion moral collapse that has taken place in parts of our country these past few generations.

The same is true of religious extremism.

As President Obama wrote in the Audacity of Hope:

“…in reaction to religious overreach we equate tolerance with secularism, and forfeit the moral language that would help infuse our politics with larger meaning.”


Frankly, we need a lot less of the passive tolerance of recent years and a much more active, muscular liberalism.

A passively tolerant society says to its citizens, as long as you obey the law we will just leave you alone.

It stands neutral between different values.

But I believe a genuinely liberal country does much more; it believes in certain values and actively promotes them.

We need to stand up for these values.

To have the confidence to say to people – this is what defines us as a society…

…and that to belong here is to believe in these things.

I believe the church – and indeed all our religious leaders and their communities in Britain – have a vital role to play in helping to achieve this.

I have never really understood the argument some people make about the church not getting involved in politics.

To me, Christianity, faith, religion, the Church and the Bible are all inherently involved in politics because so many political questions are moral questions.


So I don’t think we should be shy or frightened of this.

I certainly don’t object to the Archbishop of Canterbury expressing his views on politics.
Religion has a moral basis and if he doesn’t agree with something he’s right to say so.

But just as it is legitimate for religious leaders to make political comments, he shouldn’t be surprised when I respond.


Also it’s legitimate for political leaders to say something about religious institutions as they see them affecting our society, not least in the vital areas of equality and tolerance.


I believe the Church of England has a unique opportunity to help shape the future of our communities.

But to do so it must keep on the agenda that speaks to the whole country.

The future of our country is at a pivotal moment.

The values we draw from the Bible go to the heart of what it means to belong in this country…

…and you, as the Church of England, can help ensure that it stays that way.

Friday, December 2, 2011

American Anglican Evangelicals?

Comments in blue below by DPV.

http://www.ecusa.anglican.org/109399_14327_ENG_HTM.htm

Evangelical

The evangelical movement in the Episcopal Church (DPV:  But evangelical and Episcopal, or Anglican, is redundant...hint, hint, the BCP is evangelical)  was influenced strongly (DPV:  Far over-stated and strongly overstated) by the Great Awakening in America during the mid-eighteenth century (DPV: Eegads, overstated). Episcopal evangelicals reflected American evangelicalism in many ways (DPV:  In fact, Lutherans and Anglicans were pretty resistant to enthusiasts), including a characteristic emphasis on personal religion and religious emotion (Huh?  Evangelicals were Prayer-book reading people)
, personal conversion, the authority of the Bible (DPV:  Like the BCP) as centered in the revelation of God in Christ (DPV: Sorta like the Creeds?) , the importance of justification by faith (DPV: Like Articles 9-11, sorta like the Reformation? ), the preaching of the Word and the study of the gospel (DPV: Like Article 6, sorta like the preaching commened by the first 6 centuries of Churchmen, e.g sorta like sola scriptura), the centrality of the cross (DPV:  Eegads, the Gospels?) for salvation (DPV:  Like the 39 Articles and BCP), the importance of the believer's direct relationship with God (DPV: Is there any other kind?), and a desire for pure and undefiled religion (DPV: And the BCP suggests otherwise?  What does the singing of the Psalms in the Anglican suggest? ) which included a strong aversion to worldliness and threats to public morals (DPV:  And what else might the 10 commandments suggest from Holy Communion in the 1789, 1892 or 1928 Prayer Books?). Episcopal evangelicals (DPV: An oxymoron) attended prayer meetings which included informal prayers (DPV: Horrors!  Holy moly!) and enthusiastic singing of hymns (DPV: Proof?  When have we--Anglicans--ever abandoned our beloved BCP?  Our beloved hymns?  Our heritage of honour, dignity, decorum or depth?  Stop!  This is rank revisionism). Evangelicals wrote many of the hymns (DPV:  Huh?  Evidence please?) that were used in the first years of the Episcopal Church. Evangelicals in the Episcopal Church used the Prayer Book and participated in the sacraments (??  DPV:  We need evidence here)  not emphasize the importance of sacramental form or the importance of apostolic succession (DPV: Quite overstated and simplified). They saw much value in the less liturgical (DPV: rank revisionism, Evangelical Anglicans were Prayer Book folks) style of other Protestant churches (DPV:  Hogwash. Anglicans never tossed their beloved BCP) and were impatient with canonical restrictions (DPV:  More overstatements, evangelicals loved their BCPs)  that prevented their participation in the services of other Protestant denominations (DPV: This deserves a howl) or the participation of other Protestant ministers in Episcopal services (DPV: Well, yes, admittedly, rightly, they saw "true churches" outside of Anglicanism, as Anglicanism historically saw, e.g. Confessional and Reformational Lutheran, Reformed and Presbyterian.) They were opposed to ritual excess (DPV:  Like Tractarians and other Ritualists in the late 19th and early 20th centuries), which they associated with the Roman Catholic Church (DPV: Puleeeze.  Get some sophistication here, please; some of us do read ya know?). Bishop Charles P. McIlvaine of Ohio challenged the theology of the Oxford Movement in his Oxford Divinity (1841) (DPV: That received very wide support in England that most Americans do not realize;  but don't tell the ACNA or AMiA about these insights from Bp. McIvaine), which identified Oxford divinity with the Roman Catholic Church and urged that both served to undermine the Protestant doctrine of justification by faith (DPV:  Yawn, puleeze.  Historic scholarship has identified Newman with Romanistic Trent.  Ahem.). The the Episcopal Church. Evangelicals have been at the center of the overseas missionary work of the Episcopal Church since the 1830s (DPV :  Evangelical and Anglican are not antonyms despite revisionist reviews). Noted evangelicals in the Episcopal Church included Bishops Richard Channing Moore and William Meade of Virginia; Philander Chase, Gregory T. Bedell, McIlvaine of Ohio (DPV: Supporters of the early REC although they later bagged Bp. Cummins, KY); Alexander Viets Griswold of the Eastern Diocese, who later served as Presiding Bishop; and Alonzo Potter of Pennsylvania. Other notable evangelicals were Elizabeth Channing Moore, and the Rev. William H. Wilmer, who served as president of William and Mary College (DPV: An Evangelical at William and Mary College?  That's news.)  ; and Francis Scott Key, author of "The Star-Spangled Banner." (DPV:  Key, an Evangelical?) Evangelical principles guided the founding of the Virginia Theological Seminary in Alexandria, Virginia, by Meade, Wilmer, and others; and the founding by Chase of Kenyon College and Gambier Theological Seminary (later Bexley Hall) in Ohio. (DPV:  Regrettably, VTS was 4-point Calvinist in 1819, a substantive step-down from classical Dortrechtian Calvinism of 1618-1619, unlike the Elizabethan Bishops who were 5-pointers until the disastrous Arminian Laud, but...this much...FAR, FAR BETTER THAN ANYTHING ON OFFER WITH TEC OR CofE in our times...these modern loons wouldn't know a TULIP if it hit them on the head.  We continue to live in the Anglican exile.  How long, O LORD, must we endure the revisionists and self-serving revisionists?)

Monday, November 28, 2011

Anti-Calvinists: Rise of English Arminianism c. 1590-1640

http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/view/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198201847.001.0001/acprof-9780198201847

Anti-Calvinists: The Rise of English Arminianism c.1590-1640

Nicholas Tyacke

Abstract

This is a study of the rise of English Arminianism and the growing religious division in the Church of England during the decades before the Civil War of the 1640s. The widely accepted view has been that the rise of Puritanism was a major cause of the war; this book argues that it was Arminianism — suspect not only because it sought the overthrow of Calvinism but also because it was embraced by, and imposed by, an increasingly absolutist Charles I — which heightened the religious and political tensions of the period. Almost all English Protestants were members of the established Church. Consequently, what was a theological dispute about rival views of the Christian faith assumed wider significance as a struggle for control of that Church. When Arminianism triumphed, Puritan opposition to the established Church was rekindled. Politically, Charles and his advisers also feared the consequences of Calvinist predestinarian teaching as being incompatible with ‘civil government in the commonwealth’.

Dr. Carl Truman on John Stott, American Propensity to Celeb Culture, and Failure of Critical Analysis

http://www.reformation21.org/articles/where-has-critical-appreciation-gone.php.  An excellent article by Dr. Carl Truman, Westminster east. Sage, wise, thoughtful, recalibrative and necessary.

Where has critical appreciation gone?

Article by November 2011
The death of John Stott has led to a veritable flood of accolades and uncritical adulation over the last few months. A recent example was the memorial service for him at Wheaton College which raised a number of questions in my mind. One was the issue of what Stott himself would have thought of it. I never met him but he seems to have been a modest and unassuming man by all accounts; it was thus probably a relief to him not to have to be there and listen to the hyperbolic claims being made for him and his ministry by others. We can presumably assume that one who did not live for the praise of men during his lifetime is probably not too bothered about it afterwards either.
The second question, or perhaps better, observation, was why the art of critical appreciation seems to have disappeared from the culture of the modern world, especially the modern evangelical (for want of a better term) world.

Even as I write, I have just been passed an article from USA Today in which Stott is described as one of the Christian church's `most universally beloved figures.' Only an American could have written that. Back home in Britain, Stott was a more ambiguous figure, great man though he undoubtedly was. Like all great men, his faults were as dramatic as his virtues, from his conscientious objection to war service in World War II to aspects of his theology to his ecclesiastical strategy.

Death is, of course, the great atonement. I have commented before on how you only have to die these days in order to have all of your sins, both great and small, cast as far from you as the east is from the West. The late Ted Kennedy is a good example. So is Michael Jackson. Jackson, in fact, is an even more dramatic example of how death - particularly death in absurd circumstances at a comparatively early age - not only washes away one's sins in the public eye but also lifts one's modest talent to the level of that of the Olympian gods.

Watching Gene Kelly in the wonderful film An American in Paris recently, I commented to my wife that Kelly could dance, he could really dance. In comparison, Michael Jackson was able to do what? Walk backwards with a certain amount of style? There is no comparison; yet Jackson is a god; Kelly is all but forgotten.

To return to Stott, the problems with him were threefold: his protology; his eschatology; and his ecclesiology. I do not want to dwell on any of these things here; and I would also agree with any who might say that it would be somewhat distasteful to mention these at a memorial service; but to present him as a normative ideal for Christians would seem to involve quite a selective reading of his life and theology, as indeed it would for the life of anyone else being presented as such. As one friend once said to me: if you see that someone is wrong about the beginning and the end, you might want to think twice about what they say about the middle as well. Yet I have looked in vain in the various laudatory obituaries and appreciations for any hint that there may have been any significant theological drawbacks with John Stott.

The problem with that fact is twofold: first, it fosters a nostalgic view of the past which can itself hinder action in the present, on the grounds that `we will not see his/her like again'; and second it precludes any truly critical appreciation of a man's legacy. As to the first point, the title of the article on my desk says it all; `Will evangelicals ever fill John Stott's shoes?' Again, only an American - or at least, somebody totally unfamiliar with the British scene - could have written such a headline. More unfortunate still, however, is the signal it sends: a unique giant has gone who can never be replaced and the church is changed, changed utterly, and that for the worse.

Actually, of course, God has a remarkably strong track record of replacing giants: the deaths of Stephen, Athanasius, Augustine, Aquinas, Luther, Calvin, Owen, Simeon, Spurgeon, and Lloyd-Jones do not seem to have stalled the spread of the gospel in any significant way. So why pretend otherwise, and in a manner designed only to cause despondency of the `we can never measure up' variety rather than that of `let us seize the initiative and move forward'?

As to the second, critical appreciation seems to be a lost art these days. My suspicion is that this derives from the rather effeminate nature of modern culture where we regard any criticism as deeply personal and a fundamental attack on character. Add to this the American cultural proclivity of investing unreasonably huge amounts of hope and expectation in single individuals and you have a powerful sedative which will dull the senses to matters of real concern.

Stott was assuredly a force for good in personal evangelism, in his thinking about preaching and in the way he inspired a generation of men to go in to the ministry. Few if any of us can boast his record in these areas. But there was another side to the story. On ecclesiology, he was arguably an utter disaster and he must take his fair share of the blame for weakening the overall strength of the English church. He put his Anglicanism before his evangelicalism and thereby led his followers up a dead end from which they have only recently returned.  

Protology and eschatology were not strong points either.

These were mistakes from which future generations might profitably learn.

But the Stott who was `the Pope-like figure of the [evangelical] movement [who] was a unifying voice who put Christianity's best foot forward' (to quote USA Today) is a Stott from whose mistakes we cannot learn for the simple reason that we are not even being informed of the existence of such. It is striking in the accounts of the Wheaton service that nobody seems to have expressed how much they learned from his errors of judgment and theology. Perhaps that would not have been not appropriate for such an occasion, but we must surely hope that the ethos of the memorial service does not become the default mode for his reception in the wider Christian world. He was a great man with a great mind; and he made some great mistakes, from which the rest of us can learn - but only if we first acknowledge that they are in fact mistakes.

It is surely ironic that Christianity, a religion committed to the notions of universal sinfulness and of undeserved salvation only in Christ, apparently has such difficulty with the idea that our heroes are flawed. Yes, we all pay lip-service to the idea; but it seems to make no practical difference.

The problem with such failure to engage in critical appreciation is evident all around: we seem incapable of learning from those whom we cannot shoe-horn into our own parties. Think of Bonhoeffer and C S Lewis: their makeover as evangelicals, a label which both men would presumably have repudiated, actually does them little service. And who could forget Richard John Neuhaus being named as one of the most influential evangelical leaders in America by Time magazine? If we can only learn from those we first remake in our own image, then we can never really learn from that which is different. Indeed, learning becomes little more than the reinforcement or clarification of what we know or believe already.

That Stott was important and influential is beyond dispute; but we should not sentimentalise him because of that or ignore his faults or, worst of all, so praise him that those very faults might ultimately be baptized as virtues and continue to do damage long after his departure to glory. Our brains must be kept switched on; we must give credit where credit is due; but we must also remember that sometimes we learn most from great men when we look at the great mistakes they made.

Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Church Society in the USA? REC?

HT to Charlie Ray at:  http://reasonablechristian.blogspot.com/2011/11/gillis-harp-proposal-north-american.html.

We quote:

Dear friends:

I have been active in evangelical Anglican circles in North America since the 1980s. Recently, I have thought about establishing an organization that would bring together conservative evangelical Anglicans (both clergy and laymen) regardless of their current denominational affiliation. While in Britain this past July, I was approached by a couple board members of the English Church Society and asked if I'd be interested in starting a North American affiliate of their body. I am writing to ask if you would be interested in discussing the creation of such a fellowship.
If you are unfamiliar with Church Society, please click on the link below.
http://www.churchsociety.org/

Please respond to this email if you would be interested in meeting sometime in 2012 to discuss this proposal.

Warm regards in Christ,

Gillis Harp
Grove City College
Grove City, PA
RefEpisc AT hotmail DOT com

Sunday, November 20, 2011

UK Theolgian Dr. Turnbull Says God Still Has Plan for CofE

http://www.virtueonline.org/portal/modules/news/article.php?storyid=15207

UK Seminary Theologian Says God still has a Plan for CofE despite Theological Liberalism, Cultural Obstacles

An Interview with the Rev. Dr. Richard Turnbull principal (president) and Dean of Wycliffe Hall, Oxford

By David W. Virtue
www.virtueonline.org
November 16, 2011

He was the youngest at 44 in 2005 to lead a prominent British theological institution. Now at 51, the Rev. Dr. Richard Turnbull who holds a First Class honors degree in theology and a doctorate in Church History from Durham University has weathered the early storms that go with a new principal (president) and Dean of Wycliffe Hall, Oxford. He is naturally proud that his institution is a recognized college of the University of Oxford although his institution came under close scrutiny a few years ago. In fact Richard comments that the University has been strongly supportive of Wycliffe, its role within the University and its scholarly contribution to the Faculty of Theology. As principal, Turnbull gives leadership to the college as well as teaching and representing the college externally. He teaches courses on Anglicanism, Anglican and Evangelical Identity and the Reformation. He is currently undertaking research projects in Evangelical spirituality and the future of Evangelicalism.

He is the author of Anglican and Evangelical? and Shaftesbury, the great reformer - a great biography of Wilberforce's effective successor who served in Parliament for 60 years. Books on the history of the Evangelical Revival and Evangelical Spirituality will be published in 2012.He was a member of the committee that drafted the document A Covenant for the Church of England. Richard has also served on the Archbishops' Council and chaired review committees for the Church of England.

He was in Philadelphia recently lecturing at the John Jay Institute, an Anglican-based Fellows Program for post-graduate persons aspiring to public office in society and the church.

VOL met with Dr. Turnbull at the Bala Cynwyd based organization and sat down to talk with him about the state of the Church of England, women bishops, as well as theological education in the UK and if the Church of England will be a viable institution 25 years from now.

VOL: What is the state of your theological college and theological education in general in England?

TURNBULL: We have about 100 students. We are among the largest theological colleges in England. About two-thirds are training for the Anglican ministry, another quarter studying apologetics and the rest are doing post-graduate work. Candidates for ministry are evangelicals going into the ministry and they are coming from mainly conservative churches.

While the overall numbers for ordination are down slightly, a fair number are in their 20s which says to me that God still has a plan for England and the Church of England.

Another college like us is Oak Hill in London, though we would probably have a wider range of students. Ridley ,Trinity, Bristol, St John's Nottingham, Durham are much less conservative (some would use the description liberal evangelical - meaning less clarity on the doctrine of scripture and the substitutionary atonement), though all these have some good people. Ripon College Cuddesdon and Westcott House, Cambridge, Queens, Birmingham are more liberal and not evangelical. The Anglo-Catholic colleges are small and very weak. St. Stephens House has less than 20 and The College of the Resurrection Mirfield, is also very liberal and struggling.

ANGLO-CATHOLICISM

VOL: Does Anglo-Catholicism have a future in the Church of England?

TURNBULL: Anglo Catholicism is in long term serious decline in the Church of England. Anglo-Catholics are more conservative in some areas and more liberal in other areas. So for example, most Anglo-Catholics would affirm the same principles of revelation as evangelicals but on issues such as homosexuality there would be much divided opinion in the Catholic constituency.Affirming Catholicism is liberal in theology and doctrine. A majority, are catholic minded Anglicans but there is a great deal of antipathy between Anglo Catholics and Affirming Catholics. Dr. Rowan Williams is an Affirming Catholic, but to be honest he is also a thoughtful and engaging scholar. We at Wycliffe try to co-operate with the Anglo-Catholic constituency as much as possible but friends in the US need to understand that whilst evangelicals in the Church of England are relatively strong, the Catholic constituency is really very weak, with few ordinands.

VOL: What are some of the pressures you face?

TURNBULL: There are lots of pressures on seminaries particularly those that are clear cut in their theology with intrusion from secular authorities. I was advised that I could not hire a Christian as my personal executive assistant. I was told that anybody could type or answer the phone. I thanked the advisors and refused to accept their authority in this matter. I utterly and totally repudiate the notion that you have to accept pressure from the state and pressure from the church over teaching good old fashioned evangelical doctrine. I want to teach people to love Jesus and proclaim the message of the cross and resist the pressure to conform. Jesus was not a conformist.

I am committed to teaching traditional doctrine of the OT & NT and history with lots of training for the practical (pastoral) ministry. A lot of institutions have titles for their professors that do not reflect either sound doctrine or pastoral concerns, a lot of approaches have to do with self esteem and self realization. I don't understand what all that navel gazing has to do with one's ability and need to teach the historic faith. Of course, that is not to say we do not need character formation, that is essential, but it is a matter of being clearly focused on the essentials.

ROWAN WILLIAMS

VOL: It has been widely reported that Dr. Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury is going to resign though Lambeth Palace has said nothing either way. What is your take?

TURNBULL: I am not sure about the veracity that he will resign. The idea that Rowan Williams will return to an academic post at some point is not news. All that is at some point in the future. To my knowledge there has been no decision. He may do that and that would not be a surprise. Speculation about his successor is wide of the mark. Most candidates are 2-3 years older than Rowan therefore unlikely to succeed him including John Sentamu Archbishop of York and Richard Charters Bishop of London.

VOL: In your opinion does the former Bishop of Rochester, Dr. Michael Nazir Ali have a chance?

TURNBULL: It would be great if Michael could succeed Rowan. He is very controversial in the minds of some. In point of view of orthodox biblical faith Anglicans would find no better representative than Nazir Ali. He has the confidence of the Global South but within the UK he is probably not a realistic prospect. I should add that Michael serves as a senior fellow at Wycliffe Hall and brings great insights into our teaching.

WOMEN BISHOPS

VOL: Are women bishops inevitable in the Church of England? Can the momentum really be stopped?

TURNBULL: The issue of women bishops is causing much anxiety in the evangelical community in England and although there are various views the majority of evangelicals believe that there should be some legally provided protection for those who, in conscience, find the appointment of women bishops not to be in accordance with the scriptures. What is happening is that all 44 dioceses are voting individually on proposed legislation and it looks likely that it will be passed in most dioceses. In fact we now know that all but two dioceses have passed the legislation but around 12 dioceses also passed resolutions seeking more formal protection for those who have reservations.

VOL: What happens next?

TURNBULL: It will then come back to Synod in July 2012 where it will require two-thirds majority of bishops, clergy and laity voting separately. The vote will be close in the House of Laity, maybe then the archbishop will seek a compromise to offer protection in order to ensure its passage. You need 33% to block it, but they will wobble when they see the other houses go for it. There is a real prospect, but no certainty, that the Measure will in fact fail to gain the necessary votes in the House of Laity.

For the remaining Anglo-Catholics in the Church of England it is a real disaster and will lead to more defections to Rome after the vote.

VOL: What will be the impact on Evangelicals?

TURNBULL: The problem for the evangelical wing is that we are not that keen on bishops anyway and will carry on doing our own thing.

The Church of England will have women bishops and some of the existing bench of bishops can't wait to be the first to make such an appointment. That will create problems if women are appointed for the sake of it and for those parishes and clergy who cannot in conscience accept it. My genuine hope is that there will be some legally provided provision to enable both sides of the debate to coexist.

VOL: Will church attendance suddenly rocket if there are Women Bishops?

TURNBULL: None whatsoever. Most people are not interested and they do very little evangelism in the name of Jesus and it is therefore a distraction from the real mission of the church.

HOMOSEXUALS AND THE CHURCH OF ENGLAND

VOL: Where is the "gay" agenda going in the Church of England?

TURNBULL: It is only a matter of time before we have an attempted effort to appoint a bishop who is a practicing homosexual. Regrettably some people are already campaigning on the issue and can't wait till the opportunity arises. The problem for most orthodox Christian believers is that such an appointment would be contrary to Scripture.

VOL: Would that split the Church of England?

TURNBULL: It's very complicated in England because local churches have significant independence from their bishop and can safely ignore the bishop so there will not be a clean linear split. That explains why there won't be a split.

VOL: What is the difference between a TEC bishops' authority versus a CofE bishops' authority?

TURNBULL: It is amazing to us that TEC bishops have that power and authority and can determine the employment and future of a local priest. In England a bishop does not necessarily have that same authority at all.

VOL: In TEC a bishop has rights of visitation to a parish and has significant control over the priest and acts really as a key central ecclesiastical authority. A priest is obliged to receive a bishop once every three years.

TURNBULL: The history of the Church of England is that authority is diffused and dispersed and bishops have no power to impose their will on local churches. The local church is not ecclesiastically required to invite a bishop to his/her parish. All financial assessments are voluntary and could/should be drastically reduced. A bishop does not have the power to visit at will or to fire a priest without a disciplinary process, for example involving adultery.

VOL: There are some very real fundamental differences then?

TURNBULL: Yes. The situation in England is different from that in TEC and it is possible for parishes to exist within the Church of England without the same degree of oppression and most evangelicals have no intention of leaving the Church of England - mainly because the foundation documents are clearly Protestant and Reformed. In England most evangelical priests have a low opinion of the theology of bishops and also most of the occupants on the current bench in the House of Lords.

The Lords Spiritual as they are called number 26 in the House of Lords, and they love it for the preferment it offers and they enjoy the status it gives them and they can lead prayers. I welcome the Christian voice in the public square. However, they are rarely united and most wouldn't know how to lead anyone to Christ.

VOL: Former Archbishop George Carey and former Rochester Bishop Dr. Michael Nazir Ali have been quite vocal on the Culture Wars. What is your take on this?

TURNBULL: I admire and welcome both men's contribution to the debate on the clash of culture and the challenge to Christianity that comes from culture. Christianity has always been counter cultural not just submerged underneath the culture, especially in terms of secularization and Islam.

Both men have been very brave speaking out about most things. It is seen as very politically incorrect in the UK to do so. It is very brave of Nazir Ali. He is powerfully speaking up about the challenge of Islam because he has direct experience as well as being the [former] Bishop or Rochester. He was not listened to but he represents a strong standard of English public opinion. Both Christianity and Islam are missionary faiths and it is not surprising there are clashes of culture. We should not be afraid of Christianity being a missionary faith.

THE FUTURE OF THE CHURCH OF ENGLAND

VOL: What do you see as the future of the Church of England?

TURNBULL: The Church of England will be smaller in 10-15 years and my hope is it will be slimmer and fitter. It suffers from an enormous bureaucracy and a financial system that looks like a command economy and that needs to change. I hope we reduce the number of dioceses and reduce bureaucracy and appoint bishops, that is leaders who are spiritual, evangelical and church planters rather than estate agents and managers.

VOL: Should the CofE be disestablished?

TURNBULL: On balance to go down that road of disestablishment would be a distraction from evangelism and mission and church planting. The CofE is not a state church, it is the church in Europe that is least connected to the state and it is a common misunderstanding that the state controls the church or funds the church. It does neither. The establishment can give enormous opportunity for witness and evangelism. My responsibility is to train clergy so that they can make effective use of those opportunities to proclaim Jesus.

VOL: With the growing liberalization and feminization of the Church of England can you easily place graduates?

TURNBULL: Generally that is not a problem. There are occasional issues of mismatch of graduates from evangelical colleges but mostly graduates can find jobs and it is the best interest of the Church of England that they do so.

VOL: How important is C. S. Lewis to the British public?

TURNBULL: He is only a big name in regard his being the author of children's books. Some people would recognize the Christian analogy that is drawn from those books. Very few know him as a Christian apologist. I think he is better known as a Christian apologist in the US

CULTURE WARS

VOL: There have been several reported instances in the British press of English Christians losing their jobs and facing legal action for praying with people, wearing Christian symbols, B& B owners being fined for not allowing homosexual couples to stay in their place and generally standing up for their Christian convictions.

TURNBULL: The use of legal action against Christians has caused enormous anxiety and we have even had situation of people losing their jobs for having a Christian symbol in their vehicle while working for a city council. Legal action on behalf of Christians oppressed in this way has generally failed, which frankly, is quite depressing. I see no end in sight, but there could be a backlash if this continues.

EVANGELISM AND CHURCH PLANTING IN THE UK

VOL: How is evangelism and church planting doing in England?

TURNBULL: England is spiritually desperate and more in need of the message of the gospel than ever before. This is the land of Wesley and Whitfield and we need people raised up with a passionate love of Christ to proclaim his life changing message. God has acted before in England I believe he will do so again. We need to plant churches, declare it in our teaching and allow God to act.

England has a great missionary heritage and is now in need of missionaries returning to England with that same gospel we once took elsewhere, so I welcome all of those who come from the Global South because they have the spiritual experience, suffering and persecution and the clarity of biblical teaching which England so desperately needs.

VOL: The Occupy Wall Street movement has come to England and St. Paul's Cathedral became the focus of their protest resulting in three resignations including the Dean. It has also put the Bishop of London Richard Charters in a very awkward position. If you side with the protestors who believe the moneyed few control the assets of England then the cathedral suffers from lost income (about $23,000) a day. If you side with the cathedral who look like the money changers in the Temple you might incur the wrath of Jesus or at the very least the protestors if you call the Police in to take them away. What is your take?

TURNBULL: I do have sympathy, great sympathy, with St Paul's Cathedral who found themselves in an impossible position. I very much regret the Dean's resignation. The truth is that once the police were sent away and the protesters welcomed, any decision made by the Cathedral authorities was likely to be problematic. I personally do not have much sympathy with the protesters and the church has been made to look foolish. Most of the protesters are 'fair weather' agitators; they put up their (rather expensive) tents and go to sleep in their comfortable suburban homes at night.

Actually we do not wish to adopt the views of the protest groups, I do not think they represent any significant opinion in the UK they are a rather motley collection of Marxists and anarchists. We need the banks, we need wealth creators we need innovation. However, I also believe that it is a legitimate Christian concern to raise questions about the level and structure of remuneration in the banking industry, but the questions need to be asked in context and not linked to some bizarre protest. Equally I would say that the Cathedral is right not to pursue legal action to evict if possible. We should not use unnecessary legal means or force that is not a great witness. My point also though is we should also not 'baptize' protest movements as representing the views of Christ. God created man to work, to create wealth and we should encourage that, as well as asking appropriate questions about philanthropy, boundaries, distribution etc - but you cannot properly discuss the latter without the former.

VOL: I understand there might be a silver lining with an orthodox bishop called to take over the helm of the cathedral. Can you elaborate on that?

TURNBULL: English Cathedrals are another idiosyncrasy. They are independent of Bishops (again, rather vigorously so in some respects) and the Bishop cannot control the cathedral. The senior cleric is the Dean, appointed in consultation with the Bishop, but no exclusively so. Occasionally a Bishop may move to be a Dean, but it is not usual, slightly more often, a Dean moves to become a Bishop. To be Dean of St Paul's is an important and highly responsible job, I pray the right person is appointed.

VOL: Thank you Dr. Turnbull.

END