Reformed Churchmen

We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879

Showing posts with label Charismatics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Charismatics. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Schooling Anglicostals, TBN, Charismatics, Montanists and their Kin: Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) F.N. Lee

Lee, Francis Nigel. Miracles and Pseudo-Miracles—What and When and Why?
http://www.dr-fnlee.org/docs8/mapm/mapm.pdf. Accessed 30 Sept 2013.

Schooling Anglicostals, TBN, Charismatics, Montanists and their Kin : Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) F.N. Lee. Costals aggressively pushed themselves forward; the pushback is long overdue and is undertaken.

Proverbs 12.1: “Whoever loves instruction loves knowledge, but he who hates correction is stupid.”

A theological study about the nature of miracles and their cessation at inscripturation but the continuation of pseudo-miracles according to revealed religion from the fall of the first Adam till the second coming of the Second Adam.)

And now, for instructions and corrections from F. Nigel Lee:

20. Thornwell: miracles were supranatural; provable; revelational; ethical

Rev. Professor Dr. J.H. Thornwell wrote a whole treatise on miracles. There, he insisted43 that "miracle presupposes God -- and so does the world. But the miracle, as a phenomenon, may be apprehended even by the atheist.... The Scriptural term which gives us the nearest insight into the real nature of the miracle, is...the word 'wonder'...."It is true that every wonder is not a miracle; but every miracle [certainly] is a wonder. The cause of 'wonder' -- is the unexpectedness of an event.... The 'miracle'...contradicts that course of nature which we expected to find uniform. It is an event either above, or opposed to, secondary causes. Leave out the notion of these secondary causes -- and there can be no miracle...."The essence of the miracle, consists in the contranatural or the super-natural.... Is the 'miracle' to command, absolutely and without further question, the obedience of those in whose sight it is done?" No!

"The Scriptures themselves warn us against the lying-wonders of the man of sin.... The miracle...is not only a specimen of the supernatural in general, but a specimen of the precise kind of the supernatural which it is adduced to confirm. It is a specimen of inspiration...."The true doctrine is that, as the miracle proves by an evidence inherent in itself – no 'miracles' should be admitted as the credentials of a messenger or doctrine but those which carry their authority upon their face. Doubtful 'miracles' are in the same category with doubtful arguments; and if a religion relies upon this class alone to substantiate its claims, it relies upon a broken reed.

"There are unquestionably phenomena which, surveyed from a higher point of knowledge, we should perceive at once to be perfectly 'natural'.... The effect is, where the line cannot be drawn -- that the[se] 'wonders' are not to be accepted. We do not [then] know them to be miracles -- and consequently have no right to give them the weight of miracles....But, as Cudworth has suggested, there are some miracles which carry their credentials upon their face -- so clearly above nature and all secondary causes, that no one can hesitate an instant as to their real character...."When we turn to the miracles of the Bible, we feel intuitively that they are of a character in themselves and on a scale of magnitude which render the supposition of secondary causes ridiculously absurd.... The scenes at the Red Sea; the cleaving of the waters; the passing over of the Israelites on dry land between the fluid walls; the pillar of cloud by day and of fire by night; the daily supply of manna from the skies -- effects like these carry the evidence of their original on their face. There is no room for doubt...."And so [too] in the New Testament.... They reveal, at a glance, the very finger of God.... "Their principal office is to guaranty an external, objective revelation by which we can try [or test] the spirits, whether they be of God. They are the criterion by which a real is distinguished from a pretended revelation -- the mark by which we know that God has spoken, and discriminate His Word from the words of men.

"An external, objective, palpable test is the only one which can meet the exigencies of the case.... The necessity of such a test has been universally acknowledged.

"The Catholic feels it, and appeals to a visible, infallible society [the Romish Church] which is to judge between the genuine and spurious. The Protestant feels it, and appeals to his Bible.... 'To the Law and to the testimony! If they speak not according to this word – it is because there is no light in them' [Isaiah 8:20]...."The miracle...brings God distinctly before us -- and has a direct tendency to promote  the great moral ends for which the sun shines, the rains descend, the grass grows, and all nature moves in her...majestic course. Miracles and nature join in the grand chorus to the supremacy and glory of God....

"The true point of view, consequently, in which the miracle is to be considered -- is in its ethical relations. It is not to be tried [or tested] by physical but by moral probabilities.... We degrade ourselves, and we degrade our Creator, when we make the physical supreme; when we make the dead uniformity of matter more important than the life and health and vigour of the soul."

Monday, November 4, 2013

(49-50) Corrections for Anglicostals, TBN, Alpha, Charismatics, Mr. (Canterbury) Welby, Montanists and their Kinfolk : Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) F.N. Lee

Lee, Francis Nigel. Miracles and Pseudo-Miracles—What and When and Why? http://www.dr-fnlee.org/docs8/mapm/mapm.pdf. Accessed 30 Sept 2013.

Corrections for Anglicostals, TBN, Alpha, Charismatics, Mr. (Canterbury) Welby, Montanists and their Kinfolk : Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) F.N. Lee. Costals aggressively pushed themselves forward; the pushback is long overdue and is undertaken.

Proverbs 12.1: “Whoever loves instruction loves knowledge, but he who hates correction is stupid.”

A theological study about the nature of miracles and their cessation at inscripturation but the continuation of pseudo-miracles according to revealed religion from the fall of the first Adam till the second coming of the Second Adam.)

And now, for rebukes from F. Nigel Lee:

19. Dabney: miracles were rare; supernatural; and attested God's messages

The view of the great Southern Presbyterian Church in its heyday, was essentially the same. Rev. Professor Dr. R.L. Dabney's Lectures in Systematic Theology boldly declared:41

"The prime end for which God has introduced miracles, [is] to be attestations to man of God's messages....It is the glory of the true miracle, that the more fully it is comprehended the more certainly it would be a smeion" alias a sign -- and indeed such a one as to attest "God's messages alias His words.

"A miracle," explained Dabney by way of definition, "is a phenomenal effect above all the powers of nature, properly the result of supernatural power -- i.e., of God's immediate power which He has not regularly put into any second causes lower or higher.... Miracles are not anarchical infractions of nature's order....Every miracle was wrought in strict conformity with God's decree. But this is in God: the natural law is impressed on the nature of second causes."

Miracles, Dabney further clarified (in his work Discussions: Evangelical and Theological), are all past tense. "We are all in substance agreed," he insisted, 42 "that a miracle was such a manifest suspension of the laws of nature -- as only God can work. Miracles were usually rare in their times. For, had they become customary, their end would have been disappointed...."While the Christian miracles are thus proved to be entirely credible, we have no need to claim that God now answers prayer by miracle. The doctrine of the Bible is that He answers prayers for spiritual good by grace in the hearts of men, and for natural good by that perpetual and special providence through which He regulates the working of every second cause in accordance with its natural law."

Wednesday, October 23, 2013

"Strange Fire:" Attitude Adjustments for Anglicostals, Pentecostals, Charismatics, Montanists and other frenzied wildcats from Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) F.N. Lee


Lee, Francis Nigel. Miracles and Pseudo-Miracles—What and When and Why? http://www.dr-fnlee.org/docs8/mapm/mapm.pdf. Accessed 30 Sept 2013.

Attitude Adjustments for Anglicostals, Pentecostals, Charismatics, Montanists and other frenzied wildcats from Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) F.N. Lee. Costals aggressively pushed themselves forward; the pushback is long overdue and is undertaken.

A theological study about the nature of miracles and their cessation at inscripturation but the continuation of pseudo-miracles according to revealed religion from the fall of the first Adam till the second coming of the Second Adam.)

And now, for reproofs from F. Nigel Lee:

16. A.A. Hodge (continued): miracles are objective and redemptive

"The gospel is not a disclosure of abstract moral or spiritual truths, but rather of a series of objective FACTS constituting the stupendous history of redemption....

Among the most convincing elements of this history, is the witness it bears to the events we call 'MIRACLES.'

The incarnation, the crucifixion, the resurrection, are the very substance of Christianity and its saving power.... These are the central suns of the constellations of miracles recorded in the Bible...."Sporadic, inconsequent 'miracles' could prove nothing -- and would themselves be difficult to prove. But, given a supernatural crisis; a supernatural teacher; and a supernatural doctrine -- MIRACLES are found to be in place like JEWELS on the state-robes of a king.

ALL the great MIRACLES recorded in Scripture, gather around two great foci in the history of REDEMPTION -- the giving of the Law through Moses" (right after the Lord saved His people from oppression in Egypt), "and the life and death of the incarnate God" in and miraculously conjoined to His human nature.

"If God did not carefully CONFINE His powers to the lines of established and known LAWS; if we lived in a world in which MIRACLES instead of being the INFINITE EXCEPTION were the RULE and God were constantly breaking forth with the exercise of supernatural power in unexpected places, and like the wild lightning eluding the most rapid thought as it dashes zig-zag across the sky -- we should find all thought and intelligent action impossible.... The universe would be a chaos, and the community of men a bedlam...."

If Adam had not apostasized, the entire course of human history would have been a NORMAL development in fellowship with God. The central principle of loyalty to God having been preserved intact; the whole moral nature of man would have GROWN healthily; and all his faculties in all their exercises, and all his relations with his fellows, would have been correspondingly normal.

"But since sin introduced rebellion against the supreme authority of God, the human character had been radically corrupted and human society disorganized.... In consequence of this state of facts, the God of Heaven has set up a Kingdom in antagonism to the kingdom of Satan and to all temporal kingdoms organized in Satan's interest; which Kingdom shall never be destroyed but, breaking in pieces all its antagonists, shall stand for ever. This Kingdom of the God of Heaven was introduced immediately after the Fall...."The process by which this Kingdom grows through its successive STAGES toward its ultimate completion can, of course, be very inadequately understood by us. It implies the CEASELESS operation of the mighty power of God working though all the forces and LAWS of nature, and CULMINATING in the supernatural manifestations of grace and of MIRACLE.... The omnipotent Holy Ghost works to the same end, directly and indirectly, in every sphere of nature and of human life....

"This Kingdom from the beginning and in the whole circle of human history -- has been always coming. Its coming has been marked by great EPOCHS -- when NEW revelations and new communications of divine power have been imported, from WITHOUT [alias from the OUTSIDE], into the current of human history. The CHIEFEST of these have been the giving of the Law; the incarnation, crucifixion, resurrection, ascension, and session of the King on the right hand of the Father; and the mission of the Holy Ghost." Thus Rev. Professor Dr. A.A. Hodge.

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Steve Lawson: "Strange Fire" and the Charismatics

The charismatic movement is hard to define. It represents a vast, diverse array of teaching and practice. On the charismatic spectrum, you'll find extravagant prosperity teachers, ecstatic speaking in tongues, strange "spiritual" manifestations, as well as legitimate ministries where the gospel is faithfully preached. However, regardless of where charismatic groups might land on that spectrum, they are all tainted with the same dangerous defect. In the following video, Steve Lawson elaborates on that defect—the fundamental flaw of the charismatic movement....

http://www.gty.org/Blog/B131001

Monday, September 30, 2013

Mr. Andy Underhile: Heresy as Necessity, Mysticism, and Charismatics


Mr. Andy Underhile at:  http://andycontramundum.blogspot.com/2010/03/holy-heresy-part-1.html

Holy Heresy - Part 1
Why heresy is needed in the true Church

At first blush, it seems like a strange statement to say that heresy is “necessary” to the condition of the true Church. But history demonstrates the truth of this assertion. The great ante-Nicene African theologian, Tertullian, wrote, “We ought not to be astonished at the heresies (which abound) neither ought their existence to surprise us, for it was foretold that they should come to pass; nor the fact that they subvert the faith of some, for their final cause is, by affording a trial to faith, to give it also the opportunity of being ‘approved’.” 1 Even St. Paul warned that heresies must occur. He said, “For there must be also heresies among you, that they which are approved may be made manifest among you.” 2

Perhaps at this point we should define heresy. In the earliest uses it meant primarily the work of schismatic or divisive teachers within in the Church. But by the writing of Peter’s second epistle, heresy had come to mean the false teachings of these schismatic or divisive teachers. This is the meaning which has persisted to the present day. Peter calls their teaching,”damnable heresies.” 3

But even in the Old Testament, God warned Israel that false teachers would arise and that the whole point was to test Israel’s faithfulness to God’s Law. Moses wrote, “If there arise among you a prophet, or a dreamer of dreams, and giveth thee a sign or a wonder, and the sign or the wonder come to pass, whereof he spake unto thee, saying, Let us go after other gods, which thou hast not known, and let us serve them; thou shalt not hearken unto the words of that prophet, or that dreamer of dreams: for the Lord your God proveth you, to know whether ye love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul.” 4 This means that just because a leader is attractive this is no guarantee that he is led by God. New ideas from inspiring people may sound good, but we must judge them by whether or not they are consistent with God’s Word.

Throughout the history of the Church, heresies have forced us to formulate more clearly what we mean to say by the terminology we employ. In the first four centuries of the Church, the heresies of Marcion, Arius, Paul of Samosata, Nestorius, Eutyches, Sabellius and Pelagius drew forth from the early Fathers the great Creeds of Nicaea, Constantinople and the definition of Chalcedon. During the Reformation era, the Remostrants prompted the synod of Dort. This is perhaps one of the greatest services of heresy for the true Church: it forces us to think clearly. We are required by the exigencies of the situations to declare the whole counsel of God not in an “uncertain sound.” 5 One thinks of the great Councils of Nicaea, Orange and Dordt as examples of this process. When error encroaches upon the Church, the Lord raises up an Athanasius, a Prosper, a Luther, a Calvin or a Voetius to help the Church more clearly define what she means by the terms she uses.
 
For more, see:
 

Saturday, September 28, 2013

Mr. Andy Underhile (Field Report): "Lies" Pentecostals/Charismatics Tell about Tongues


http://andycontramundum.blogspot.com/2010/09/missionary-tongues-story.html

The Missionary "Tongues" Story

Ever since I was a child, I have often encountered a particular story. It is something of an urban legend in certain church circles.
It goes like this: There was a missionary who met up with a person, usually a tribeman of some sort in a remote jungle area, with whom he wished to share the Gospel. Unfortunately, though, they could not understand each other's languages. Somehow the missionary felt compelled to open his mouth and just speak. To his surprise, he found himself speaking the other person's language fluently, though not aware of what he was saying. The tribesman was miraculously converted.

 I have heard a dozen or more incarnations of this story, but those are the central story factors that are always present. As I said earlier, in some church circles, especially Pentecostal ones, this is something of an urban legend. It is always recounted third or fourth hand. I have never spoken with someone who actually claims to have personally had this experience.

The unspoken assumption, and often very clearly spoken assumption, of this story is that egghead cessationists are wrong and the supernatural sign gift of tongues still functions in the church today. Usually, this idea is further 'established' by claiming that while much of the tongues speaking that goes on in many Pentecostal churches is fraudulent, this kind must be real because it occurs in situations that seem to replicate the condition of the 1st Century Church.

This is a problematic assumption. I am not satisfied that this situation replicates the situation of the Apostolic age. I don't think it even comes within a hundred miles of the situation that existed on the Day of Pentecost.

1. On Pentecost, there was, as yet, no New Testament.

2. Tongues did not miraculously preach the Gospel to people in need of an interpreter.
 
3. The 3,000 converts were converted by Peter's plain preaching of the Gospel in Aramaic, a language they all understood anyway. Peter did not preach in tongues. The witnesses, though fluent in other languages, were all Jews who understood Peter's Aramaic sermon. The elect were converted, the non-elect mocked them, in direct fulfillment of Isaiah 28:11-12.
 
4. Pentecost was the event wherein the New Testament Church emerged from the cocoon of the Old Testament Church. This can never be repeated.
 
5. Virtually the entire visible church was present - something that has not been repeated since.
 
6. Tongues, on the Day of Pentecost, was not a conversation between a believer and an unbeliever. It was not an evangelism tool.
 
For more, see:
 

Thursday, September 26, 2013

Mr. (Rev. Dr.) John MacArthur, Conference (16-18 Oct 13), and Pentecostals/Charismatics

Mr. (Rev. Dr.) John MacArthur is hosting a conference on Pentecostals and Charismatics entitled "Strange Fire" of date 16-18 Oct. 2013.  He will publish a book a few weeks thereafter. Long, long overdue, but most, most welcome.

http://www.tmstrangefire.org/speakers#.UkSpb4zD9jo

Speakers

John MacArthur

John is the pastor-teacher of Grace Community Church in Sun Valley, California, and the Bible teacher for Grace to You. John has written dozens of bestselling books, including The MacArthur Study Bible, The Gospel According to Jesus, and The MacArthur New Testament Commentary series. He is also the president of The Master’s College and Seminary. John and his wife, Patricia, have four married children and fifteen grandchildren.
John MacArthur

R.C. Sproul

Dr. R.C. Sproul is founder and chairman of Ligonier Ministries in Orlando, Florida, and can be heard daily on the radio broadcast "Renewing Your Mind." He is co-pastor at Saint Andrews Chapel, as well as president of Reformation Bible College and Ligonier Academy. Dr. Sproul has written more than 50 books, including The Holiness of God, Loved by God, Chosen by God, and Grace Unknown, and he has authored scores of magazine articles for evangelical publications. In addition, he has taught at numerous colleges and seminaries. He and his wife, Vesta, have two children.
R.C. Sproul

Conrad Mbewe

Conrad Mbewe has been the pastor of Kabwata Baptist Church in Lusaka, Zambia, Africa, since 1987. He is a frequent conference speaker throughout Africa and around the world. He has written Maintaining Sexual Purity and Foundations for the Flock, and contributed to a number of other books, including Dear Timothy: Letters on Pastoral Ministry. He is also the editor of Reformation Zambia magazine, and he writes a column for a Zambian national weekly newspaper as well as his own blog, called A Letter from Kabwata. Conrad and his wife, Felistas, have six children.
Conrad Mbewe

Steve Lawson

Dr. Steven J. Lawson is the senior pastor of Christ Fellowship Baptist Church in Mobile, Alabama. He is the author of numerous books, including Pillars of Grace, Foundations of Grace, The Unwavering Resolve of Jonathan Edwards, and The Expository Genius of John Calvin. He is a teaching fellow with Ligonier Ministries and a visiting professor at the Ligonier Academy, The Master’s Seminary, and Samara Theological Seminary in Russia. Steve and his wife, Anne, have three sons and a daughter.
Steve Lawson

Tom Pennington

Tom is the senior pastor of Countryside Bible Church in the Dallas area. Before his ministry in Texas, Tom served sixteen years in various roles connected to Grace Community Church, including administrative pastor and personal assistant to John MacArthur. For many years he was also managing director of Grace to You, overseeing the day-to-day operations of the international radio, audio, publications, and Internet ministry.
Tom Pennington

Phil Johnson

Phil is the executive director of Grace to You. He has been closely associated with John MacArthur since 1981 and edits most of John’s major books. Phil also maintains several popular websites, including The Spurgeon Archive, The Hall of Church History, and the Pyromaniacs blog. He is an ordained elder and pastor at Grace Community Church. Phil and his wife, Darlene, have three adult children and four grandchildren.
Phil Johnson

Nathan Busenitz

Nathan serves on the pastoral staff at Grace Community Church and teaches historical theology at The Master’s Seminary. He has written or edited a number of books, including Living a Life of Hope, Reasons We Believe, and Men of the Word. He is also a regular contributor to Pulpit Magazine and the Cripplegate blog. Nathan and his wife, Beth, have four young children.
Nathan Buesenitz

Justin Peters

Raised in a Southern Baptist church but genuinely saved as a preacher, Justin has studied in great depth the word-faith movement which, along with Roman Catholicism, is unfortunately the face of Christianity in much of the world today. He has developed a seminar confronting that movement entitled A Call for Discernment. In it he incorporates video clips of false teachers such as Benny Hinn, Kenneth Copeland, Jesse Duplantis, Joel Osteen, and Joseph Prince as he refutes that biblically bankrupt system. Justin has taught on the word-faith movement across the U.S. and in ten countries and has attended numerous word-faith churches and conferences to support his research. Justin and his wife, Kathy, live in Edmond, Oklahoma.
Justin Peters

Todd Friel

Todd studied to be a pastor only to discover he was not actually saved. Presently he is the host of the syndicated daily radio program, Wretched Radio. Todd is also the host of Wretched TV, available in 80 million American households. Todd has produced the following DVDs or audio lessons: Drive-By Theology, Drive-By Church History, Drive-By Marriage and Parenting, What Hath Darwin Wrought?, On the Shoulders of Giants, Herman Who?, It’s Not Greek to Me, Drive-By Pneumatology, Drive-By Discernment, Terrified, and Decisions Decisions. Todd has one wife, three kids, and a dog.
Todd Friel

Joni Eareckson Tada

Joni Eareckson Tada has lived in a wheelchair as a quadriplegic for over forty-five years, enabling her to share a biblical view of suffering which is authoritative, yet personal. Her worldview and advocacy on disability issues has been honed over thirty-five years of leadership at Joni and Friends (JAF), including visits to forty-five countries and serving on the Disability Advisory Committee to the U.S. State Department. Mrs. Tada has led the JAF team in declaring and demonstrating the gospel through: thirty years of radio outreach, Wheels for the World Family Retreats, over fifty books, a global network of disability ministry through Joni and Friends offices and international charter ministries—including NGOs on every continent.
Joni Eareckson Tada

Thursday, March 8, 2012

Carl Trueman's new book: "Fools Rush In Where Monkeys Fear to Tread"

Todd Pruitt at 1517 gives an important notice of a book that may warrant a purchase.  Todd offers an excerpt from Carl Trueman's new book, "Fools Rush In where Monkeys Fear to Tread."  We are again reminded of non-liturgical worship with its unfortunate emphases.  Todd posts at http://toddpruitt.blogspot.com/2012/03/why-you-should-read-carl-trueman.html.  H/T to Todd on this provocation to purchase a modern book--a rare event at RA. 
-------------------- 

Why You Should Read Carl Trueman...
On losing the sense of God's holiness in the church:
When prayers become the equivalent of "Yo, how you doin'?!" then something has gone awry. Public prayers should lead people into the presence of God, and that should be a humbling, if not crushing experience. When was the last time a pulpit prayer left you in awe of the God who humbles himself so that you might worship him? What about sermons? How many of us sit in judgment on the sermon, grading it for quality, length, clarity, interest, as the minister brings to us the Word of God? If we have any grasp of God's holiness, and any inkling of the importance of the prophetic task of preaching, we won't be giving the minister a grade; rather, we will be sitting and listening to what he has to say, acutely conscious of our own unworthiness to hear God as he speaks to us. Then, when the songs we sing can be summarized by the phrase, "Jesus is my best boyfriend," we can be sure that something is seriously out of joint. The words we sing to God should reflect the gravity of the words of God first speaks to us. Then, when the church itself becomes a take-it-or-leave-it venture that we can turn up for a time that suits us, perhaps even sipping lattes from Starbucks as we take our seats, something is seriously missing. What is it? Well, the answer isn't rocket science: a sense of the deep holiness of God. The casual nature of the postmodern world, where all hierarchies are oppressive and the consumer is king, cannot even begin to understand the void that lies at the heart of such slapdash Christianity. Your doctrine can be as correct and confessional as possible; but if it is all just so much of a game, then it is no theology at all.

That passage is from Dr. Trueman's newest collection of essays entitled Fools Rush In Where Monkeys Fear To Tread (pp. 65-66). If you are familiar with Trueman's writing then the subtitle will make perfect sense: "Taking Aim At Everyone." One of the reasons I like reading Carl's essays is because he refuses to bow to the ever-changing standards of sentimental niceness. If you wear your feelings on your fingertips tread cautiously. But read none-the-less.


Trueman is a professor of church history and historical theology. But he is also a keen observer of the culture. So whether he is recalling a chance meeting with Joe Frazier, extolling the virtues of Mott The Hoople (don't ask), or skewering the latest banalities of contemporary evangelicalism you can count on plenty of theological reflection. He makes it look easy, but it ain't. So don't try this at home kids. Just pick up Fools Rush In Where Monkeys Fear To Tread and enjoy.

Incidentally, I rather like the cover illustration on this new book. But, and I will take this up with Carl personally, the illustrator gave him entirely too much hair.


You can check out some of Dr. Trueman's other titles HERE.

Dr. Trueman blogs regularly at Ref21.

Wednesday, February 29, 2012

So this Church-Growther and this Liturgomaniac Walk into a Bar…; Micro Koinonia Project Coming to BJS, by Pr. Rossow

Steadfast Lutherans is offering this debate.  It sounds interesting.  http://steadfastlutherans.org/?p=17431&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+BJS+%28The+Brothers+of+John+the+Steadfast%29

Pastor Rossow says:

"So this Church –Growther and this Liturgomaniac walk into a bar… Well, it isn’t quite like that but it is close. It’s not a joke, it’s not a bar and it’s not really a church-growther and a liturgomaniac but it is about a pastor who espouses many church growth principles and a pastor who espouses the liturgy sitting down to talk to see how far apart they are and how close they can get, and doing it all for the world to see here on BJS.

"One of my friends and colleagues is Pastor Mark Schulz from Trinity Lutheran Church in Lisle, Illinois, the next suburb over from me and my church, Bethany Lutheran in Naperville, Illinois. He and I have been in the same circuit for over ten years, had coffee together through the years, given each other grief about how we “do” church and also shared some life experience together. I had the pleasure of teaching religion/confirmation to his son Christian for two years at our day school here at Bethany.

"We had lunch together today and agreed to have an online discussion about our similarities and differences and invite the BJS crowd to chime in via the comment section.

"We will start out with each of us giving a summary view of what goes on in our churches and the principles that we use to guide those activities. Then in consequent postings we will critique each other’s practice and principles. We are not sure where it is headed or how long it will go on but we are both really enthused about having it out on line here and seeing where out little Micro-Koinonia Project ends up. We hope and pray it will be a blessing for our beloved Lutheran Church Missouri Synod."

Dangers of an Uneducated Ministry: "You May Have Been Raised Charismatic If…"


Tim Schraeder on 02/29/2012 posts the following.  He does so with joy and fondness, but we draw the opposite conclusions.  He proud of this stuff?  Takes joy in it?  There is flippancy, self-referential comedy, and irreverence in content and tone--who's surprised?  Tom states, "I wouldn’t trade it for the world."  We'd recommend trading all this stuff of manifold loondom.  More evidence for the dangers of an illiterate and uneducated ministry. 
http://www.timschraeder.com/2012/02/29/you-may-have-been-raised-charismatic-if/

My Christian journey was profoundly shaped by the fact that I was raised in what some would call a charismatic church. I was raised in an Assemblies of God church and the first five years of my life in ministry were working on staff at an A/G church. I am grateful for how I was raised and after no longer attending an A/G church, I have come to value the impact growing up in a charismatic church made on my life. I will, however, note that there are some unique and quirky things that come along with it.
This list is by no means intended to belittle the charismatic upbringing I had, but more to celebrate some of the oddities that can be associated with the heritage we charismatic kids can share.

You may have been raised charismatic if…

  • you’ve recommitted your life to Christ more than 10 times per year.
  • you would say a quick prayer asking for the forgiveness of as many sins as you can remember when the traveling prophet would start walking around in the congregation.
  • a family road trip included stops in Toronto or Pensacola, Florida, in the mid-late 90s.
  • you know what the initial evidence of the infilling of the Holy Spirit is.
  • you were a cast member in “Heaven’s Gates and Hell’s Flames.”
  • your church logo had a dove on fire.
  • you feel uncomfortable in churches where people don’t raise their hands.
  • you liked Hillsong before they were cool.
  • your church was worried about Y2K.
  • you’ve experienced and/or participated in a Jericho March.
  • you’ve question the salvation of your Catholic friends.
  • you’ve complained about worship services being too short.
  • someone in your service ‘caught’ the Holy Ghost, and subsequently gave it to others.
  • you know what JBQ stands for.
  • you’ve ‘laid’ things at the altar, but never physically left anything there.
  • your church showed the “Thief in the Night” movies followed by an emotional appeal for people to be sure of their salvation.
  • you’ve been grazed by a banner during a worship service.
  • you’ve worried you’ve missed the rapture on more than one occasion when you can’t get a hold of your Christian family members.
  • the only kind of dancing that’s allowed at your church is dancing in the Spirit.
  • it’s common for people to take their shoes off during worship.
  • your church’s altar ministry team included “catchers.”
  • your pastor would shout and sweat when he preached.
  • you friends’ parents were skeptical of letting them come with you to youth group.
  • your college options were Northwestern, Southwestern, Central, Southeastern, or North Central.
  • there was lots of talk about the End Times in sermons.
  • your church had real altars at the front.
  • your youth group did a “Hell House” during Halloween.
  • you were in Royal Rangers or Missionettes.
  • it was OK for women to be pastors, prophets, teachers, or evangelists.
  • one of your family vacations was to Heritage USA.
  • you get the shivers listening to the song “The Mercy Seat.”
  • you know what a “human video” is.
  • there were banners and tambourines with ribbons used in your worship services.
  • your worship leader would sing the same refrain or chorus from a song for more than 5 minutes.
  • your grandparents watch and give money to TBN.
  • the ushers in your church wore maroon or purple sport coats with gold name badges.
  • you’ve had to explain to your friends what being slain in the Spirit means.
  • your church had a ‘blanket’ ministry.
  • you know the names Oral Roberts, Kenneth Copeland, Creflo Dollar, and Jesse Duplantis.
  • your parents were members of the Maranatha/Integrity praise tape club.
  • your Easter services included live animals.
  • the movie Jesus Camp was eerily similar to your summer Bible camps.
  • your Christmas services were like a Broadway show.
  • you took a water bottle with you to church.
  • you would find your seat after the worship portion of your church service.
  • you have had a “word” spoken over your life.
  • Kleenex boxes lined the front altar of your church.
  • you know the significance of Azusa Street.
  • you’ve made Faith Promise or made of Vow of Faith.
  • your church was known as the “rock and roll” church.
  • your pastor went from being very conservative in the 90s to very trendy in more recent days.
  • there was no such thing as an “order of service” at your church.
  • your youth pastor used lots of hair gel.
  • your church took over Denny’s, Perkins or any 24-hour restaurant around 10 PM on Sunday nights.
  • you’re comfortable with spontaneous singing.
  • you know there are two IHOPs.
  • the shofar was used in your church’s worship services.
  • Pentecost Sunday was a big deal at your church.
  • some of your church services were all worship and no teaching [mainly on Sunday evenings or Wednesday nights].
  • your pastor was skeptical of the seeker-sensitive movement.
  • summer camp involved pressure for you to receive your prayer language.
  • it was common for people to start speaking loudly in the middle of your worship service and use phrases like “my children…” or “thus saith the Lord…”
  • your church celebrated the Year of Jubilee.
  • you faked being “blessed by the Spirit” to get out of taking tests at your Christian school. [I did that once.]
  • you know what Buddy Barrel is.
  • photos of your pastor and his wife were predominant in publications.
  • the phrase, “I’m feeling led by the Spirit right now to…” was used frequently in your church services.
  • you would have to ask people around you if they wanted you to walk down to the altar with them.
  • the phrase “IshouldaboughtaHondabutIboughtaNissan” makes you laugh and makes you feel guilty at the same time.
  • you would address people as “Brother” or “Sister.”
  • the altar call lasted as long as the actual church service.
  • when someone shouted “FIRE!” in your church it didn’t cause alarm.
  • you’ve been drunk…in the Spirit.
  • you would keep your eyes open during a response time to see if people were really raising their hands all across the room.
  • if this resembles one of your church services:


See Charlie Brown Praise Break : http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=yDWeyVEyKEI

Ok, ok I know. I need to stop. But really, the longer this list of charismania got the more I realized how crazy and special it was to share the joys of being raised charismatic. I wouldn’t trade it for the world.

Monday, February 27, 2012

Pentecostals and Intimidation Tactics (Which Works on the Ignorant, Gullible, Vulnerable and/or Stupid)

Paul Crouch, known to
abuse any and all critics
Andy Underhill takes a look at the Pentecostalists, their errors, and their abusive intimidation tactics.

Holy Heresy (Pt 1)
http://andycontramundum.blogspot.com/2012/02/holy-heresy-part-1.html

Holy Heresy (Pt 2)
http://andycontramundum.blogspot.com/2012/02/holy-heresy-part-2.html

Holy Heresy (Pt. 3)
http://andycontramundum.blogspot.com/2012/02/holy-heresy-part-3.html

A taste from Part 3:

Intimidation of those with opposing views

Benny Hinn stated publicly that he'd
like to take a Holy Ghost machine gun
and kill all his critics
This is perhaps the greatest weapon of the Charismatic heresy. They revel in mocking any and every opposing view. And they do it with such panache - such vehemence and acerbity. Benny Hinn has repeatedly claimed that God has shown him, by divine revelation that He is going to kill those who oppose Hinn’s ministry. What are we supposed to say to such asininities? Hinn is not the only one to resort to such ludicrous tactics. Countless of these self-proclaimed “prophets” torture 1 Chronicles 16:22 (Touch not my anointed…) into an umbrella to shield themselves from all scrutiny. Despite the fact that 1 Chronicles 16:22 has no possible application to their cause, they do not extend the same leeway to their opponents. They speak in the most brutal terms against any who do not subscribe to their “manifestations.” Perhaps not many have gone as far as Hinn in claiming that God is going to kill his critics, but every single one of his ilk is guilty by association.


Anti-intellectual and anti-rational Hillbillies
Another tactic is to discount the right of those outside their circles to judge their orthodoxy. One of the arch-heretics of the Third Wave, Roberts Liardon says, “Spectators do not have the qualifications to comment on participators.” (4) This line of reasoning is patently false. It is begging the question to say that I cannot judge the orthodoxy of their doctrine or practice because I haven’t experienced these things. Do I have to commit murder or adultery in order to know that they are wrong? Should I have to experience Buddha worship to analyze its falsity? If I asked Benny Hinn if he believed that homosexuality is sin, I would like to believe that he would answer in the affirmative. What would he think if I asserted that he had no right to judge the validity of the gay lifestyle because he had never tried it? This is pure question begging, but he would use the same line of reasoning against me if I called into question his bizarre practices.
We lampoon these anti-intellectualists.  See this as it describes and summarizes our larger view of these Hillbillies.  The so-called Pastor delivered a 20-minute tirade against those who know doctrine.  He told us we were"dead" and that doctrine would kill people.   http://reformationanglicanism.blogspot.com/2011/05/my-recent-experience-in-pentecostalist.html

Friday, July 29, 2011

Charismatic Chaos: Resources from John MacArthur

To his credit, John MacArthur is one of the voices speaking out against the neo-Montanism or Pentecostalism of our time.   The weak press and weak academics often refuse engagement.  We're not sure why that happpens, but it does.

http://solasisters.blogspot.com/2011/07/charismatic-chaos.html

Charismatic Chaos


Posted by Christine Pack
For anyone with loved ones who have gotten sucked into the Charismatic movement, the following sermon series is a must-listen. This is the sermon series given by John MacArthur that compelled him to write his bestselling book on the dangers of the Charismatic movement, Charismatic Chaos. From the Grace To You website:
"The charismatic movement, once considered a splinter group on the fringe of Christianity, has gained steam and entered the ‘90s at full speed. Dramatic new accounts of bizarre, supernatural events are attracting men and women hungry for religious experiences while causing others simply to ask, What is really happening here?, or more important, What should I believe?
This 13-message album thoughtfully and carefully shines the light of Scripture on teaching that is gaining a massive and loyal television following, leading to disunity on a world-wide scale, and promising to fuel controversy for years to come. Recorded by John MacArthur, these messages will help you gain an understanding of his bestseller Charismatic Chaos in a short amount of time."

Below are links to each message of the 13-part sermon series. Each message can be either read in article form, or downloaded as an audio file:
Does Experience Determine Truth?
Does God Still Give Revelation?
Does God Still Give Prophecies?
Proper Biblical Interpretation
Does God Do Miracles Today?
The Third Wave
How Do Spiritual Gifts Operate?
What Was Happening in the Early Church?
Does God Still Heal?
Speaking in Tongues
What Is True Spirituality?
Does God Promise Health and Wealth? Part 1
Does God Promise Health and Wealth? Part 2

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Wilhelmus À Brakal’s Response To Continuists:


An excellent statement about the Charisholics. Andy Underhill gives us a good post.

Wilhelmus À Brakal’s Response To Continuists:


Wilhelmus À Brakal’s Response To Continuists:
In volume 2 of à Brakal’s “Reasonable Service” he discusses the marks of true and false churches. The sixth mark he refutes as a mark of a false church is the continuing presence of miracles. To this à Brakal replies:

“Sixthly, miracles are proposed as one of the distinguishing marks of the church. To this we reply:

(1) Miracles do not belong to the distinguishing marks of the true church. This is nowhere to be found in the Word of God.
(2) Miracles are not intended for believers, but for unbelievers; thus the church has no need of them. If one were desirous of bringing an unbeliever into the true church, one would have to perform a wonder time and again, which, however, the proponents of this mark do not do.
(3) The performance of and boasting in miracles in the post-apostolic era, as a means of the confirmation of doctrine, is a distinguishing mark of the anti-Christian church. “Even him, whose coming is after the working of Satan with all power and signs and lying wonders” (2 Thess 2:9). This certainly confirms that the performance of miracles does not belong to the distinguishing marks of the church.” (Wilhelmus à Brakal, The Christian’s Reasonable Service, vol. 2, pg. 29.)

Isn’t ironic that the continuists claim to follow Scripture, hence their practice of charismata, yet Scripture nowhere states that miracles are a distinguishing characteristic of the Church. In fact, Scripture takes it for granted that false teacher may perform “miracles.” (Deut. 13:1-5; 2 Thess. 2:9). In fact, Jesus never rebuked the Pharisees for not believing in His miracles; He rebuked their unbelief of His teaching and the Scriptures. The warning of Deut. 13:1-5 is surely behind this fact.

I once knew a missionary who claimed that miracles were, in his words, “the dinner bell to salvation.” I watched him preach and pray for those who came forward to his altar calls. I can’t recall a single miracle. No doubt there were many in his imagination, but there were certainly no verifiable miracles. I don’t buy the claims of healing from headaches or back pain.

Moreover, à Brakal’s point is dead on: where are the people performing verifiable miracles over and over to bring unbelievers into the Church. Indeed the Charismatic doctrine of faith precludes this. On the Charismatic scheme, miracles occur for those who have the faith to believe for their miracle, hence an unbeliever could never receive a miracle. If miracles are to convince unbelievers, we have a catch-22 on our hands. Those who need miracles and for whom they exist can never have one!