Reformed Churchmen

We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879

Showing posts with label Billy Graham. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Billy Graham. Show all posts

Friday, March 7, 2014

7 Mar 1789: Charlotte Elliott, Author of "Just As I Am," Born to Church of England Manse


7 March 1789.  Charlotte Elliott, the author of “Just as I Am,” was born.

Dr. Rusten tells the story.  Rusten, E. Michael and Rusten, Sharon. The One Year Christian History. Carol Stream, IL: Tyndale House Publishers, 2003. 


Ms. Elliott was born to a Church of England manse.  Her grandfather was the Evangelical Anglican cleric, Henry Venn.  Her father and brother were Church of England clerics.

She suffered ill health her entire life, including bodily pain but also bouts of depression.

Dr. Caesar Malan, a Swiss minister and family friend, asked her one day about her faith.  She was upset and defensive.  She inquired how she might be saved and come to Jesus.  Dr. Malan said, “Just as you are.”

She penned the hymn and published it anonymously. The hymn gained popularity in England.  Billy Graham, a century later, would popularize it in his crusades.

It remains in the 1982 Episcopal Hymnal, number 693. Let’s raise a toast to Ms. (PB) Schori.  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w2VrRk4pZHY

1.          Just as I am, without one plea,

            but that thy blood was shed for me,

            and that thou bidst me come to thee,

            O Lamb of God, I come, I come.

 

2.          Just as I am, and waiting not

            to rid my soul of one dark blot,

            to thee whose blood can cleanse each spot,

            O Lamb of God, I come, I come.

 

3.          Just as I am, though tossed about

            with many a conflict, many a doubt,

            fightings and fears within, without,

            O Lamb of God, I come, I come.

 

4.          Just as I am, poor, wretched, blind;

            sight, riches, healing of the mind,

            yea, all I need in thee to find,

            O Lamb of God, I come, I come.

 

5.          Just as I am, thou wilt receive,

            wilt welcome, pardon, cleanse, relieve;

            because thy promise I believe,

            O Lamb of God, I come, I come.

 

6.          Just as I am, thy love unknown

            hath broken every barrier down;

            now, to be thine, yea thine alone,

            O Lamb of God, I come, I come.

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Billy Graham's "Judgment Letter" Stirs Discussion

http://www.charismanews.com/us/33880-billy-grahams-judgment-letter-sparks-charismatic-commotion

Billy Graham's 'Judgment' Letter Sparks Charismatic Commotion     

Troy Anderson        

Billy Graham
(BGEA)
Famed evangelist Billy Graham’s letter calling America and its “deceived people” to repentance is one in a series of escalating warnings that the nation is in growing danger of God’s judgment, prominent faith leaders told Charisma News.

“This may be our last chance to call the nation to pray,” says Anne Gimenez, national chairperson of America for Jesus—America for Jesus—The Awakening, which expects hundreds of thousands of people to gather at Independence Mall in Philadelphia Sept. 28-29 to pray and intercede for the United States.

“We believe it possibly could be the last time we have this opportunity. Nineveh is a great example. All the wickedness of that city, and yet when they did what God said they should do and repented, God healed their land. That’s right where America is today. We’re on the brink of America being destroyed as we know it, but I believe God is giving America a chance at this hour.”

In his letter, “My Heart Aches for America,” the 93-year-old Graham wrote that he recalled how his late wife, Ruth, once expressed concerns about the nation’s “terrible downward spiral”—exclaiming, “If God doesn’t punish America, He’ll have to apologize to Sodom and Gomorrah.”

Graham, who has preached to more people than any other Protestant in history—2.2 billion—wrote that he wondered what Ruth would think of the country today where “self-centered indulgence, pride and a lack of shame over sin are now emblems of the American lifestyle.”

“My hearts aches for America,” wrote Graham, who has provided spiritual counsel to every president from Harry S. Truman to George W. Bush and received Barack Obama in his home in 2010. He has been on Gallup’s “Ten Most Admired Men in the World” list 55 times since 1955.

“The wonderful news is that our Lord is a God of mercy, and He responds to repentance. In Jonah’s Day, Nineveh was the lone world superpower—wealthy, unconcerned and self-centered. When the Prophet Jonah finally traveled to Nineveh and proclaimed God’s warning, people heard and repented. I believe the same thing can happen once again, this time in our nation.”

Graham’s letter calling America to repentance comes as a growing number of highly respected Christian leaders have issued similar warnings in recent months, noting that the nation is in a downward spiral of economic decline, immorality, corruption, growing secular humanism and attacks on religious liberty.

Jack Hayford, the founding pastor of The Church on the Way in Van Nuys, Calif., and the former president of the International Church of the Foursquare Gospel, says Graham’s letter comes as the nation is in a “very grim hour as we approach the election this year.”

“What we need is something on the order of shock troops at this hour, and I can imagine that can be raised,” Hayford says. “I don’t feel despairing. I do feel the urgency. We are at a point that desperate action is needed and Billy’s voice, certainly as no other, can give rise to that.”

Rabbi Jonathan Cahn, the author of the New York Times best-selling book The Harbinger, says Graham’s letter is a “prophetic word” that parallels the message in The Harbinger—that America is rapidly departing from God and is in danger of judgment unless it turns back to God in humble and genuine repentance.

The fact that Graham released the letter “should get our attention” and is “very striking” and “very stunning,” says Cahn, the senior rabbi at the nation’s largest messianic congregation, the Beth Israel Worship Center in Wayne, N.J.

“I believe this is a very, very critical time for America and for God’s people in America, and I believe it has ramifications for world history,” says Cahn, a descendant of Aaron, the high priest of the ancient Israelites and the brother of the Biblical prophet Moses. “The way that America goes is going to affect the world, and the way God’s people in America go will affect America.

“So, the message of The Harbinger is that we are in danger and that the same progression of judgment that occurred in the last days of ancient Israel is now occurring in America. The call is ultimately for salvation for those who don’t know the Lord and for repentance and revival for those who do. I see this (Graham’s letter) as another very stark sign that we are a critical point.”
Joel Rosenberg, the New York Times best-selling author of Implosion: Can America Recover from its Economic & Spiritual Challenges in Time?, echoed Cahn’s remarks in a blog entry last week, noting Graham’s letter highlights “the need for spiritual revival.”

“America is in grave danger,” Rosenberg wrote. “The massacre in Aurora. The child sex-abuse scandal at Penn State. The scourge of abortion and pornography and runaway spending and debt in Washington. The list tragically goes on and on. In Implosion, I try to document how serious the situation is, and how a Third Great Awakening is the only answer.”

Graham’s letter comes as several organizations are planning prayer gatherings, evangelistic festivals and other events.

In his letter, Graham wrote his son Franklin Graham is planning to launch an outreach entitled My Hope with Billy Graham “that wouldbring the gospel into neighborhoods and homes in every corner of America next year.”

“America is desperately in need of another great awakening,” says Cindy Jacobs, co-founder of Generals International. “As many other nations in history have belatedly discovered, one cannot eliminate the name of Jesus and think that God does not see. We all need to listen and respond to what the Lord has put on the heart of Dr. Billy Graham, and respond to his message of hope as well as courageously find our own voice in calling the church and nation to repent.”

Meanwhile, starting Sept. 28 and continuing through Nov. 6, 40 Days to Save America is calling for prayer, fasting and repentance in the 40 days prior to the presidential election.

“During the American Revolution, in the darkest days of the Civil War, at the outset of our involvement in World War II, leaders as different as George Washington, Abraham Lincoln and Franklin Delano Roosevelt declared national seasons of prayer, fasting and repentance,” wrote Rick Scarborough, chairman of 40 Days to Save America on the website.

“Today, our nation faces multiple crises—pending economic collapse, moral disintegration and international terrorism—but all have spiritual underpinnings. Together, they are even more daunting than those Americans confronted in 1776, 1863 and 1941. Now as then our national survival is at stake. Now as then, our destiny rests in God’s hands. The crises confronting us are beyond the power of human beings to resolve without divine guidance. Nothing short of a Third Great Awakening can save us.”

The calls for prayer and repentance come a year after Texas Gov. Rick Perry declared Aug. 6, 2011, a day of national prayer, fasting and repentance and invited fellow governors to attend The Response at Reliant Stadium in Houston. Given the trials besetting the nation from the “global economic downturn to natural disasters, the lingering danger of terrorism and continued debasement of our culture,” Perry said he believed it was time to “convene the leaders from each of our United States in a day of prayer and fasting, like that described in the book of Joel.”

Doug Stringer, the founder of Somebody Cares America and the national mobilization coordinator for The Response, says a battle for the soul of the nation is underway, the wake-up call has come and yet “we keep pushing the snooze button.”

“Coming from one who has been such a great giant—an ambassador for Christ around the world—I think [Graham’s] words at age 93 should deeply, deeply impact each and every one of us,” Stringer says. “I really believe we’re in a Joel 2 moment where the church must take seriously personal and individual repentance. America is in trouble. We need God himself to intervene.”

For another Great Awakening to occur, Hayford says the church and believers must engage in “gut-level, spiritually-impassioned intercessory prayer”—something lacking in most churches today, few of which even hold prayer meetings anymore.

“The undermining of the ensconced dark powers that are eating out the underpinnings of our national life are only going to be neutralized and cast down in one way,” says Hayford, author of Penetrating the Darkness: Discovering the Power of the Cross Against Unseen Evil. “You can preach about it, and that’s valid, and it’s not worthless. But it’s what is awakened in the church through prayer that becomes the truly penetrating and ultimately victorious dynamic.”

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Evangelical Loons: Billy Graham, Schuller, & Riccy Warren

Silva, an American Anabaptist, calls out Graham, Schuller, Rick Warren and other ignorant inclusivists of small intellectual, confessional, historical or biblical attainments.  Silva has an argument, although he, himself, is an Anabaptist with problems. Here's Silva.

http://apprising.org/2012/05/08/john-macarthur-on-roman-catholicism-billy-graham-and-evangelical-inclusivism/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+apprising%2F2+%28Apprising+Ministries%29

JOHN MACARTHUR ON ROMAN CATHOLICISM, BILLY GRAHAM, AND “EVANGELICAL” INCLUSIVISM


 
Apprising Ministries brings you the audio clip below where Dr. John MacArthur gives some background on the current apostasy in which evangelicals are now accepting apostate Roman Catholicism as genuine Christianity. He also quotes from the transcript of an appearance by Billy Graham on Hour of Power with Robert Schuller.
This is program #1426 entitled Say “Yes” To Possibility Thinking, which was originally broadcast May 31, 1997:
Schuller: Tell me, what do you think is the future of Christianity?
Graham: Well, Christianity and being a true believer–you know, I think there’s the Body of Christ. This comes from all the Christian groups around the world, outside the Christian groups. I think everybody that loves Christ, or knows Christ, whether they’re conscious of it or not, they’re members of the Body of Christ. And I don’t think that we’re going to see a great sweeping revival, that will turn the whole world to Christ at any time. I think James answered that, the Apostle James in the first council in Jerusalem, when he said that God’s purpose for this age is to call out a people for His name.

And that’s what God is doing today, He’s calling people out of the world for His name, whether they come from the Muslim world, or the Buddhist world, or the Christian world or the non-believing world, they are members of the Body of Christ because they’ve been called by God. They may not even know the name of Jesus but they know in their hearts that they need something that they don’t have, and they turn to the only light that they have, and I think that they are saved, and that they’re going to be with us in heaven.

Schuller: What, what I hear you saying that it’s possible for Jesus Christ to come into human hearts and soul and life, even if they’ve been born in darkness and have never had exposure to the Bible. Is that a correct interpretation of what you’re saying?

Graham: Yes, it is, because I believe that. I’ve met people in various parts of the world in tribal situations, that they have never seen a Bible or heard about a Bible, and never heard of Jesus, but they’ve believed in their hearts that there was a God, and they’ve tried to live a life that was quite apart from the surrounding community in which they lived.

Schuller: I’m so thrilled to hear you say this. There’s a wideness in God’s mercy.

Graham: There is. There definitely is.
Below is the segment with Billy Graham and his friend Robert Schuller referenced above. See it for yourself:

00:00
00:56
 

Well, the sad fact is this “Evangelical” Inclusivism is Older Than You Think. And it’s also the root rot of the Church Growth Movement as evidenced e.g. by sinful Southern Baptist ecumenicist Rick Warren and his Emergent counterpart Living Spiritual Teacher and EC guru Brian McLaren who’re following Graham’s footsteps.

For example, Warren has said, “It really doesn’t matter your denomination, folks. We’re all on the same team if you love Jesus.”[1] And McLaren has opined that if people are “happy being Muslim, or Buddhist or Jewish or atheist,” he doesn’t think it’s right to try to “shoe-horn them out of their religion” into Christianity.[2]


That’s why John MacArthur is dead-on-target in what he says about this evangelical inclusivism below:

___________________________________________________________________________
End notes:
[1] http://bit.ly/L3VkR7, accessed 5/8/12.
[2] http://bit.ly/IWeMmq, accessed 5/8/12.

Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Dangers of an Uneducated Ministry: Franklin Graham Steps in It

Billy Graham (l) and son, Franklin Graham (r)
RNS is reporting the following at:  http://www.religionnews.com/politics/election/black-churches-defend-obamas-faith.  It's another story of a cleric without much of an education venturing into areas in which he's not trained--not to mention theology.  I saw the original MSNBC clip.  Pretty poor answers by Franklin. The NAACP ate his lunch, but turned to their standard race-baiting line to good effect.  Fact is, Obama supports partial-birth abortion--homocide in the first degree--and Franklin coulda' and shoulda' taken an higher and more educated approach.  Unfortunately, he's ill-equipped.  Further, NAACP's claim of "bearing false witness" is a bit much.  Even further, NAACP's claim about "political wedges" created by religious views is laughable.  Poor Franklin, again, ham-handed and hapless.   The danger of ill-educated and uneducated ministers. Here's RNS's story.

WASHINGTON (RNS) Evangelist Franklin Graham apologized Tuesday (Feb. 28) to President Obama for questioning his Christian faith and said religion has "nothing to do" with Graham's decision not to support Obama's re-election.

Graham's apology came after a group of prominent black religious leaders criticized the evangelist for saying he did not know whether Obama is a Christian and suggesting that Islamic law considers him to be a Muslim.

Graham, president of the relief organization Samaritan's Purse and the son of famed evangelist Billy Graham, said he now accepts Obama's declarations that he is a Christian.

"I regret any comments I have ever made which may have cast any doubt on the personal faith of our president, Mr. Obama," he said in a statement.

"I apologize to him and to any I have offended for not better articulating my reason for not supporting him in this election -- for his faith has nothing to do with my consideration of him as a candidate."

Graham said he objects to Obama's policy stances on abortion and same-sex marriage, which Graham considers to be in "direct conflict" with Scripture.

More than a dozen members of a religious subgroup of the NAACP had accused Graham of "bearing false witness" and fomenting racial discord.

"We can disagree about what it means to be a Christian engaged in politics, but Christians should not bear false witness," the NAACP statement said. "We are also concerned that Rev. Graham's comments can be used to encourage racism."

When asked in a recent MSNBC interview if Obama was a Christian, Graham responded, "I cannot answer that question for anybody." He went on to say that because Obama's father was a Muslim, "under Islamic law, the Muslim world sees Barack Obama as a Muslim."

By contrast, Graham said there is "no question" that GOP presidential candidate Rick Santorum is a "man of faith" because "his values are so clear on moral issues." Santorum has also faced criticism for saying the president has a "phony theology" that is unbiblical.

"By his statements, Rev. Graham seems to be aligning himself with those who use faith as a weapon of political division," the NAACP said. "These kinds of comments could have enormous negative effects for America and are especially harmful to the Christian witness."

Signatories of the open letter included presidents of the National Baptist Convention, USA; the National Baptist Convention of America; the Progressive National Baptist Convention; as well as bishops of the African Methodist Episcopal Church, African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church and the Christian Methodist Episcopal Church.

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

Danger of Uneducated Ministers: (Rev.) Franklin Graham

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/45755883/vp/46475340#46475694

Laurence O'Donnell, a royalist and pedigreed liberal on MSNBC, one of MSNBC's sharper wits, engages the ham-fisted and hapless (Rev.) Franklin Graham.  O'Donnell's criticism can be rebutted handily enough, but Graham reveals the dangers of an uneducated, inarticulate, unformed, un-theological, non-confessional, and non-liturgical ministry.  O'Donnell pummels Graham as a "rich" and "famous" celebrity-seeker making an annual income of $750,000 and one who speaks on a level "lower than any under average Southern Baptist minister."  While O'Donnell trades on "a" stereotype of SBC backwoodsman clerics, there is "some" truth in the stereotype. Graham hardly speaks with caution, nuance or even a "fundamental respectability," that is, "substantial credibility" that all listeners must engage.  Ergo, O'Donnell rightly dismisses the son of Billy Graham as a serious interlocutor. 

Saturday, July 23, 2011

Romanists May Buy Bob Schuler's Crystal Cathedral

"GARDEN GROVE, Calif. (AP) — A Roman Catholic diocese made a $50 million cash offer to buy Southern California's financially struggling Crystal Cathedral, officials said Friday."

http://www.usatoday.com/news/religion/2011-07-23-Crystal-Cathedral-Catholic_n.htm?csp=34&utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+Religion-TopStories+%28News+-+Religion+-+Top+Stories%29

Bob Schuler, Sr., reared in a Confessional Reformed context, became a national figure in America with his "Hour of Power" broadcast from the famed "Crystal Cathedral."  Bob was ordained in the Reformed Church in America (RCA). He is 84 years old. Bob Sr. has through the years preached a disfigured, non-Reformed and Pelagianized non-Gospel. 

Billy Graham, whom President Bush called the nation's Pastor, and Schuler Sr. crowed a few years back in public that everyone trying to live according to the light of nature would be saved, whether they believed in Christ or not.  Schuler Sr."enthused" and "crowed" over Billy's statement.  Schuler, Sr., was shocked and asked Graham again if he heard him right.  Graham reitered his point and Schuler Sr. said: "I'm so glad to hear you say that, `There really is a wideness in God's mercy,'" to which Graham said, "Yes, there is."  In this respect, Schuler, Sr., Billy Graham, and Vatican II agree.

Schuler, Sr., also had a catty and snarky exchange with Dr. Mike Horton in a radio interview in which Dr. Horton pressed Schuler about "itching ears" and "false doctrine."  Schuler, Sr., was rather intolerant and bumptious re: Dr. Horton's inquiry. 

This scribe recalls one "Hour of Power" broadcast years ago.  Rev. Schuler, Sr., had his uncle on to speak.  The uncle was an old school Churchman and Minister trained in the old school of Princeton Calvinism.  This scribe remembers the reference to that.  The uncle spoke eloquently and kindly about God's mercies, our sins, Christ's atonement, Christ's justifying mercies alone, and then gave his personal testimony  as to how Christ had saved him and that, "day by day," he loved his Saviour and Lord.  The pulpit tension between Rev. Schuler and his uncle was palpable.  Rev. Schuler was trying to butt into the conversation and end it. 

Also, and this goes back to the early 90s in Norfolk, VA, at Christ Reformed Episcopal Church.  A longtime member and supporter of Crystal Cathedral had moved to Norfolk.  She was considering joining Christ REC.  She attended the home Bible study, but could not accept original sin, justification and related doctrines.  This scribe remembers her saying, "We never learned this at Crystal Cathedral."  She did what unbelievers do by nature, choose freely according to their natures.  We never heard from her again.

Also, Schuler Sr. brought his son Robert Schuler, Jr., into the ministry at the Crystal Cathedral.  Bob Jr. became the leading speaker on the national program. Bob Jr., a graduate of Fuller Seminary, preached evangelical messages on repentance, justifiying faith, and justification. That was a substantial contrast  and conflict with his father. Baptisms went up. The national program featured people expressing their faith, again, shown on national and international television.  He also telecasted the Lord's Supper, something never seen through the years on "The Hour of Power." The father pulled junior from the church over "philosophic differences."  Bob Jr. pulled out of the Cathedral Church, moved up the street, and founded a RCA church.  There must be some interesting discussions in that regional classis (the Dutch term for presbytery).

Then, with Junior gone, Bob Sr. put his 50-somethingish daughter in charge of the pulpit and church.  She wasn't much theologically or even in terms of pulpit presence.  From this scribe's view, the daughter was quite poor theologically. The numbers were sinking. Then, she, the daughter, decided to switch from traditional music--at which the Cathedral was rather good--to Christian Contemporary-Praise Band-Gospel, but the father was appalled.  In response, the daughter, being a board member, had her father ousted from the board. 

According to news reports, Mrs. Schuler Sr, the mother, remained on the Board of Directors, but refused and still refuses to attend the Board meetings. 

Half the congregation left over the worship changes.  Numbers and donations went down.  Cyrstal Cathedral entered bankruptcy proceedings.  Several offers have been made to purchase the land and property.  The leading offer is from the Romanist diocese of Southern Califoria. 

Bob Sr.'s positive thinking and upbeat confidence must be in the tank these days.  Perhaps he should write a book, "From Positive Thinking to Despairing Thinking."  His entire effort of decades has failed.  The Reformed Church in America must share blame for the failure to discipline (over the decades) the theological errors, misrepresentations, and defamations of God and the Gospel by the
Rev. Mr. Schuler, Sr.. 


Rev. Schuler, a reasonable person would infer, might be sunken in disappointment.  Again, a reasonable person would infer that there are family issues for Rev. Schuler that are outstanding:  a son removed from the ministry, a daughter removing Rev. Schuler Sr. from the board and ministry, the mother refusing to attend Board meetings, bankrupty proceedings and the selling of the Cathedral.  Family holidays might have tense moments.

One take-away, the glitz, glamour, notoriety,  fame, and visibility can disappear with speed--the Final Assize will publish or republish the judgment already apparent on this ministry.   Bob Sr. had left the Sovereign God of his fathers and forefathers decades ago.  He turned his back on the covenanted mercies and grace conveyed and promised to him in his baptism, confirmed to him in his confirmation, and reiterated repeatedly in his subsequent readings and studies in Reformed Theology, notably, through John Calvin.  (Rev. Schuler, Sr., did a Master's thesis on John Calvin.) "The decrees of God are his eternal purposes, whereby, for His own glory, he foreordains whatsover comes to pass" (Westminster Shorter Catechism). 


Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Revivalists, Pentecostalists, Baptists and Others: "The Anxious Bench" by John Williamson Nevin (1803-1866)

Professor John Williamson Nevin (1803-1866)

"The Anxious Bench" by John Williamson Nevin (1803-1866).  A few notes about Nevin, prior to posting excerpts from his book.  Nevin was reared as a Presbyterian. He graduated from Union College (1821), studied theology at Princeton Theological Seminary (1823-1828).  He studied under the infamous and magnificent Charles Hodge (1826-1828).  Nevin was professor of Biblical literature at Western Theological Seminary (now Pittsburgh Theological Seminary) from 1830-1840.  In 1840, he resigned his chair and taught in the (German Reformed) Theological Seminary at Mercersburg, PA. "The Anxious Bench—A Tract for the Times" was written in 1843.  In it, he attack the excesses of revivalistic methods then gaining cross-denominational influence.  Dr. Nevin was also a co-labourer alongside one of America's premier historian, Dr. Philip Schaff (e.g. the three-volume Creeds of Christendom and the eight-volume History of the Christian Church, both "must reads"). 

Some excerpts from Dr. Nevin's "The Anxious Bench" in quotation marks, with emphasis added in italics, with sundry comments outside the quotation marks.

Truly, the Finneyite system and Anabaptification of American churches has curved in on itself, as source of their own embarrassment. 

"With the reproaches that have been showered upo/ me personally, in different quarters, I have not a I lowed myself to be much disturbed. I had looked foi it all beforehand ; knowing well the spirit of the system, with which I was called to deal. I knew o) course, that I should be calumniated as an enemy to revivals, and an opposer of vital godliness. But I felt satisfied at the same time, that the calumny would in due season correct itself, and recoil with disgrace on the heads of those from whom it might proceed. It has begun to do so already, and will continue to do so, no doubt, more and more."

Reformation Churches would oppose the anxious bench, altar calls like Billy Graham's, and the mechanistic gimmickry of Anabaptistic and Pentecostalist evangelicals, said to include, but not limited to:  Rick Warren, TBN, etc.

"It is with a very bad grace, that reference is made occasionally by some, to the idea of a foreign spirit in the tract, as related to the German Churches. It is in full sympathy with the true life of these Churches, as it stood in the beginning. The charge of seeking to force a foreign spirit on them, lies with clear right against the other side. The system of New Measures has no affinity whatever, with the life of the Reformation, as embodied in the Augsburgh Confession and the Heidelbergh Catechism. It could not have found any favor in the eyes of Zuingli or Calvin. Luther would have denounced it, in the most unmerciful terms. His soul was too large, too deep, too free, to hold communion with a style of religion so mechanical and shallow."

Almost prophetic, namely, that the Revivalist "Anxious Bench" proceeds where ignorance rules and is a fertile ground for the Anabaptification and Pentecostalification of the gullible. Our sense is that this prevailed more largely in the U.S. than in England.

"The general mind unhappily has not been furnished thus far with proper protection and guidance, in the way of full religious teaching ; and the result is that in these interesting circumstances it has become exposed more or less, at almost every point, to those wild fanatical influences, which in this country are sure to come in like a desolating flood wherever they can find room. Upstart sects have set themselves to take possession if possible of the entire field in this way, on the principle that the old organizations are corrupt and deserve to be destroyed. Their reliance of course in this work of reformation, is placed largely on New Measures! Thus a whole Babel of extravagance has been let loose upon the community, far and wide, in the name of religion, one sect vieing with another in the measure of its irregularities."

The enthusiasts, Methodo-Anabaptifiers and Pentecostaholics, on Nevin's view, predictably produce doctrinal falseness, shallowness and non-accountability.

"No account is made comparatively, of the danger of bringing both the truth and power of God into discredit, by countenancing pretensions to the name of a revival where the thing itself is not present. The danger itself is by no means imaginary. Spurious excitements are natural and common. Gross irregularity and extravagance, carried often to the point of downright profanity, are actually at work, in connection with such excitements, on all sides. The whole interest of revivals is endangered, by the assumption impudently put forward, that these revolting excesses belong to the system. False and ruinous views of religion, are widely disseminated."

Pentecostalism, one direct fruit of the gimmick-meisters of extravagance, rant, noise and disorder. "Justified by feeling" is a choice phrase below.

"If Finneyism and Winebrennerism, the anxious bench, revival machinery, solemn tricks for effect, decision displays at the bidding of the preacher, genuflections and prostrations in the aisle or around the altar, noise and disorder, extravagance and rant, mechanical conversions...justification by feeling rather than faith, and encouragement ministered to all fanatical impressions ; if these things, and things in the same line indefinitely, have no connection in fact with true serious religion and the cause of revivals, but tend only to bring them into discredit, let the fact be openly proclaimed."

I recently attended a Pentecostalist hothouse.  See:  http://reformationanglicanism.blogspot.com/2011/05/my-recent-experience-in-pentecostalist.html  Quite in keeping with that experience, Nevin rightly claims:

"It is a popish maxim, by which ignorance is made to be the mother of devotion."

Luther strongly resisted the Enthusiasts and wild Phrygian Montanists in Germany; Calvin did also. Cranmer also resisted them...so should we today.

Old snake-eyes himself, Charles Finney (1792-1875)
We say rather, Let there be light. The cause of the Reformation was more endangered by its own carricature, in the wild fanaticism of the Anabaptists, than by all the opposition of Rome. Luther saved it, not by truckling compromise, but by boldly facing and unmasking the false spirit, so that all the world might see, that Lutheran Christianity was one thing, and wild Phrygian Montanism, with its pretended inspiration, quite another. So in the present crisis, the salvation of the old German Churches in this country is to be accomplished, not by encouraging them to `believe every spirit,' but by engaging them, if possible, to `try the spirits, whether they be of God.' Let things that are wrong be called by their right names, and separated from things that are right."

Success is claimed for the "New Measures" (e.g. Gimmicks like the anxious bench, provocative speech and more).  Ultimately, the Word itself and Sacraments themselves are belittled and His Majesty's work through these "ordinary means of grace."  It sounds like Church-growth philosophies, e.g. Rick Warren.

"The patrons of the system, it is plain, make much account of its popularity, of the success with , which it seems to be attended, and of the power it is supposed to manifest on the part ot those who can use it with effect. But all who are at all acquainted with the world, know, that the worst things may thus run for a season and be glorified, in the popular mind. And especially is this the case, where they hold their existence in the element of excitement, and connect themselves with religion, the deepest and most universal of all human interests. No weight of fashion enlisted in favor of the Anxious Bench can deserve to be much respected, in such a trial of its merits as We are here called to make."

Word, Sacrament, and due diligence in discipline is in order.  When these factors prevail, the modern experiments in enthusiasm and excitement, including bongo-drumming enthusiasts, as efforts to reach the unchurched...these new measures fall and fail.  These gimmicks belittle the Word and Sacraments. 

"It is marvellous credulity, to take every excitement in the name of religion, for the work of God's Spirit. It is an enormous demand on our charity, when we are asked to accept in mass, as true and solid, the wholesale conversions that are made in this way. It will soon be made to appear, that there is the greatest reason for caution and distrust, with regard to this point."

An example from the fifth century.  God uses oddballs, quacks, as His Majesty pleases, but this is not the ordinary, prescribed, and biblical method of nurturance.   God uses oddballs, quacks, loons, windbags, gasbags, and others as His Majesty pleases, but this is not the ordinary, prescribed, and biblical method of nurturance. Nevin observes:

"Simeon, the Stylite, distinguished himself, in the fifth century, by taking his station on the top of a pillar, for the glory of God and the benefit of his own soul. This whimsical discipline he continued to observe for thirty seven years. Meanwhile he became an object of wide-spread veneration. Vast crowds came from a distance to gaze upon him, and hear him preach. The measure took with the people wonderfully. Thousands of heathen were converted, and baptized by his hand. Among these, it may be charitably trusted were some, whose conversion was inward and solid. God made use of Simeon's Pillar, to bring them to himself. The seal of his approbation might seem to have rested upon it, to an extraordinary extent. No wonder the device became popular. The quackery of the Pillar took possession of the Eastern world, and stood for centuries a monument of the folly that gave it birth. We laugh at it now ; and yet it seemed a good thing in its time, and carried with it a weight of popularity such as no New Measure can boast of in the present day."

Rome and Anglican ritualism claim the same, success in piety.  Let's introduce monkery and conventicles again.

"The Romish Church has always delighted in arrangements and services, animated with the same false spirit. In her penitential system, all pains have been taken to produce effect by means of outward postures and dress, till in the end, amid the solemn mummery, no room has been left for genuine penitence at all. Yet not a ceremony was ever introduced into the system, that did not seem to be recommended by some sound religious reason at the time."

Sounds quite modern, although Nevin is describing the "hothouse" American revivalists.  It sounds like Church-growth Anabaptists and Pentecostalists.

"Commonly indeed, those who deal in the anxious seat, rely far less upon the presentation of truth to the understanding, than they do upon other influences, to bring persons forward. Pains are taken rather to raise the imagination, and confound the judgment. Exciting appeals are made to the principle of fear. Advantage is taken in every way of the senses and nerves. Especially the mysterious force of sympathy is enlisted in support of the measure, and made to tell in many cases with immense effect."

How utterly modern are these comments by Nevin on the hot-bench enthusiast of his time, Charles Finney. 

"It shows no inward power whatever, to be able to move a congregation in this way. It can be done without eloquence, and calls for no particular earnestness or depth of thought. It is truly wonderful indeed, with how little qualification of intellect and soul a man may be fitted to carry all before him at certain times, and to show himself off to the eyes of a bewitched multitude as `the great power of God,' by having recourse to new measures. He may be vulgar, coarse and dull, and so pointless and sapless in his ordinary pulpit services, that it will be a weariness to hear him ; and yet you shall find him, from time to time, throwing a whole community into excitement, gathering around him crowded houses night after night, and exercising as it might seem, far the space of three or four weeks, an irresistible sway, in favor of religion. Such cases are by no means Uncommon. Some of the most successful practitioners in the art of the Anxious Bench show themselves lamentably defective in the power of serious godliness, as well as in mental cultivation generally. The general habit of their liyes is worldly and vain and their religion, apart from the occasional whirlwinds of excitement in which they are allowed to figure in their favorite way, may be said to be characteristically superficial and cold. Nay, the evidence. may be palpable, that religion has nothing at all to do with the system, in cases where it is employed with the greatest apparent effect. Nothing is more common, than for those even who glory in the power of the Anxious Bench, as employed within their own communion, to look with entire distrust on its results as exhibited in the practice of other sects."

Bill Hybels of Willow (Dried-up) Creek, a church-growth outfit, learned this the hard way. Billy learned that his spiritually hungry were most put off by the (Dried-up) Willow Creek services. In short, the services were unedifying, unhelpful and unsustaining.  They would have to become "self-feeders" outside of divine worship.  From Nevin:

"In the sphere of religion, as indeed in the world of life generally, the outward can have no value, except as it stands continually in the power of the inward. To estimate the force of appearances, we must try their moral constitution."

How very modern, that is, the church-growth, CCM, and Pentecostalist hype-jobs throughout the USA.  Quack-shops and quack-jobs.  At root, it is about foundational UNBELIEF IN THE WORD AND SACRAMENTS.

"It has been shown, that the successful Use of the Anxious Bench calls for no spiritual power. It is within the reach of fanaticism and error, to be employed in their service, with as much facility as it may be enlisted in the service of truth. It is no argument of strength, as is often imagined, that a preacher is able to use such an agency with effect. I now go a step farther and pronounce it an argument of spiritual weakness that he should find it either necessary or desirable to call in such help. There is a measure of quackery in the expedient, which always implies the want of strength, so far as it may be relied on at all, as being of material account, in carrying on the work ot God."

What is a "theological quack?"   Nevin wrote when medical quacks in the USA were unregulated. I think it was 1909 when standards were introduced to the USA to reduce medical quacks and quackdom. What about modern pulpits and quacks? Quack, quack, sounds like a dumb duck.

"The self-styled physician, who without any knowledge of the human frame, undertakes to cure diseases by a sovereign panacea, in the shape of fluid, powder, or pill, is a quack; and there is no doubt abundance of quackery in the medical profession, under more professional forms, where practice is conducted without any true professional insight and power. Such practice may at times seem eminently successful, and yet it is quackery notwithstanding."

Religious quackjobs. Nevin must have been thinking about the Western frontiermen in America where revivalist ignoramuses gained a foothold. Finney wasn't too well accepted in the educated and reading classes. Quack-jobs, USA.  From Nevin,

"Quack lawyers, quack statesmen, quack scholars, quack teachers, quack gentlemen, quacks in a word of every name and shape, meet us plentifully in every direction. We need not be surprised then to find the evil fully at home also in the sphere of religion."







Friday, September 3, 2010

MacArthur on the Modern Church « Churchmouse Campanologist

MacArthur on the Modern Church « Churchmouse Campanologist

The Church Campanologist gives us insights from the Rev. Mr. John MacArthur. Mr. MacArthur offers an experienced perspective about the impoverished deity that has shaped American evangelicalism and the Protestant mainline. RA believes the term the "weightless god" needs expatiation and application. Thankfully, the classical Book of Common Prayer, 1662, and its daily use for Morning and Evening Prayer along with chanted Psalms (using those from St. Paul's Cathedral, London) and all associated Bible readings, have shielded the practitioners from this "weightless and worthless god of therapeutic irrelevance."

RA recommends this as a doctrinal, praiseworthy and pious approach that it safe. Furthermore, we recommend reading and studying the Bible to see the mistakes that religious teachers are making.

As the Rev. Dr. Cornelius Van Til always reminded us, summarily, that all heresies and apostasies began and ended with the doctrine of God.