Reformed Churchmen

We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879

Showing posts with label American Anglicanism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label American Anglicanism. Show all posts

Saturday, September 8, 2012

Hubris, Power Struggles, & Theological Chaos Mark AMiA-ACNA Wars

http://www.virtueonline.org/portal/modules/news/article.php?storyid=16497

AN UNHOLY MESS: Clash of Wills, Power Struggles, & Theological Direction Mark AMIA-ACNA Struggle

AMIA loses her last ecclesiastical lifeboat. Society for Mission and Apostolic Works formed

By David W. Virtue
www.virtueonline.org
Sept. 8, 2012

By any criteria, it has become one of the most disastrous and devastating ecclesiastical battles since the formation of the Anglican Mission in the Americas (AMIA) and the later birth of the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA). It may well be the greatest single spiritual blot on the emerging landscape of North American Anglicanism.

The genesis of this battle between Bishop Charles "Chuck" Murphy, leader of the AMIA, and the Most Rev. Robert Duncan, archbishop of the ACNA, goes back two years. It has escalated to the point that it now involves three African Anglican provinces (Rwanda, Kenya, Congo) and indirectly affects two Primates from the Church of the Province of South East Asia. As a result of the continuing war, positions have so hardened that reconciliation now seems virtually impossible.

The larger war has resulted in archbishops, bishops, priests, deacons and laity fighting in localized ecclesiastical battles over who belongs to whom. The walking wounded are too numerous to name and number, and the war is still not over. The fallout continues. The most recent battle over flagship AMIA parish, All Saints Church, Pawleys Island, finds the rector in a pitched battle for his job desiring to take his parish to the ACNA with the bishop and chairman of the AMIA resisting. The Anglican Mission itself hangs in the balance facing an uncertain future. This story can be found here:
http://tinyurl.com/99jcxbt

The story has generated over 7,000 hits at the website with even more through VOLs weekly digest and pass-alongs in the blogosphere and around the Anglican Communion. It bespeaks the intensity with which this battle continues to rage and occupy the hearts and minds of orthodox Anglicans everywhere, many of whom paid an enormous price having left The Episcopal Church over its abandonment of biblical faith and morals. Many orthodox Anglicans now feel abandoned, hurt and betrayed by the current confusion and war being waged. The All Saints battle is a microcosm of the larger war. The large number of VOL readers reveals just how important this story has become. Many see the divisions and splits among the newly forming orthodox Anglican jurisdictions as Satan's poisonous hand in the lives of godly men and women caught in the vortex of this ecclesiastical and spiritual storm.

At the forefront of the battle are the personalities, leadership and vision of two men: AMIA chairman and Bishop Chuck Murphy and ACNA Archbishop Robert Duncan.

For 12 years, Bishop Murphy has led The Anglican Mission. He is thought highly of by such spiritual luminaries as Archbishops Moses Tay, and Yong Ping Chung of South East Asia, Emmanuel Kolini of Rwanda and is supported by theologians like TEC bishop C. FitzSimmons Allison (SC ret.) and author/theologian/Bishop Dr. John Rodgers.

Depending on who you talk to, Murphy is either a strong visionary leader who early saw where the Episcopal Church was going and formed the AMIA as a counter to TEC's heretical path, proudly proclaiming his desire to reach America's 130 million unchurched by planting new churches across North America, Many of those same people now believe he has become, over time, a proud, arrogant, stubborn, tyrannical, inflexible man who is mentally unstable and should step down. There is no middle ground. He is either loved or loathed.

On the other side of the ecclesiastical table, sits Archbishop Robert Duncan who suffered greatly at the hands of TEC Presiding Bishop Jefferts Schori and her House of Bishops when he was the Episcopal Bishop of Pittsburgh. He emerged battle scarred to form the Anglican Church in North America now five years old, drawing together a body of disparate Anglican jurisdictions something that had never before been achieved. (The 1977 St. Louis Convention saw four breakaway Anglo-Catholic bishops and jurisdictions that now number more than 50.) Today the ACNA can boast nearly 1,000 church plants with over 100,000 Anglican parishioners. Many Anglican jurisdictions affiliated with ACNA hold dual ecclesiastical citizenships with Anglican provinces like Nigeria, Kenya, Ghana and Uganda. For his theological stance and conciliar skills, he has been recognized by the leading orthodox Primates of the Anglican Communion and sits on the Primates Council of GAFCON. By any reckoning, it is a huge achievement.

Both men have reached the zenith of their respective careers; both will step down in the next two years with no visible successors at this time.

A CLASH OF WILLS

Those who know both men say that there was bound to be a clash of wills, sooner or later. Perhaps because Duncan comes from a strong military background, the two men were bound to butt heads. Others say that the differing DNAs of the AMIA and ACNA could not be reconciled as the AMIA is a "mission" while the is being a fully-fledged province even though it is not officially recognized by the Anglican Communion and its leader the Archbishop of Canterbury, or the Anglican Consultative Council. It is, however, recognized by leading Global South African Anglican provinces.

Both groups are driven by evangelistic purpose, church planting and the desire to see God's Kingdom spread throughout North America. It's hard to see how the DNA could be that different; clearly more is going on.

One insider clergyman gave VOL this insight. "A couple of years ago Murphy had a national clergy conference of AM where the theme was 'Pirates'. There was a large blow up of pirates all over the meeting room. Murphy had decided to embrace the term that had been so used against them in the beginning days of First Promise and AM. Most of the clergy voiced serious concern about the image."

So, one is forced to ask, is it really a clash between two men or a clash between two world views of the kind of leadership that is needed to win a war (or in this case the effort of Anglicans in America). Is it a navy or a group of pirates? The clergyman offered up this illustration. "There is a great scene in the movie Patton when Omar Bradley is trying to explain why Eisenhower will be leading the D-Day invasion and not George. Omar says to George 'You are great at winning battles but no good at what it takes to win the war'. Murphy has been great at winning battles, but clearly did not have what it was going to take to win the big picture of bringing such a wide variety of entities together to form the ACNA. There is no indication that George ever accepted Omar's reasoning. Murphy has yet to accept that he wasn't to lead ACNA so rather than be honest with himself and accept that, he needs to blame someone else in order for it to make any sense to him why he is not able to fulfill what he believed was his destiny."

In the early stages, Murphy and his bishops were members of the ACNA College of Bishops, but later he withdrew himself and his mission over differences between himself and Duncan. Murphy made it clear, in withdrawing, that he did not want Duncan talking to his bishops. Was it simply a clash of ideology or was it more one of strong wills between two men as to who should lead the ACNA?

So why did he withdraw AMIA from ACNA? An AMIA priest said that the only reason the leadership in the AM was given was that because they were "embedded" into the Canons of Rwanda, they were not able to be in ACNA. "SHAME on us (the leadership of AM) for having taken him at his word. But we not only didn't do that, we didn't even ask for the specifics of the Canons that would make us in violation if we were part of ACNA. We didn't even read the canons, and Chuck's Council of Bishops later admitted that they had never even read either the Constitution of PEAR (Rwandan House of Bishops) or the Canons or the original Charter of the previous organization known as AM."

Part of the rationale Murphy used last fall to his council of bishops, his network leaders and to his college of presbyters for why they needed to secede from the Province of Rwanda was that overseas oversight was just not working anymore. It came to be known amongst the clergy as the "Out of Africa" doctrine.

"Last Fall Murphy told us that we never had been part of the Constitution of Rwanda, which at the time he was saying was a good thing as far as he was concerned because we could now be a missionary society. He blamed it on 'misunderstanding' in the writing of the Constitution. But that just isn't true," the source told VOL.

LEADERSHIP

Even though it was apparent to most people that Duncan was the natural leader that did not sit well with Murphy who believed, as he was the first out of TEC and the first to begin an Anglican ministry, that he should have been the first Anglican leader.

Time, it was thought, would heal the wounds and their differences. Duncan told friends and co-laborers that he worked hard to heal the breach. However, both men argued and fought whenever their paths crossed in the US and UK. The gulf, in time, only widened between them.

Then came leadership change in the Anglican Province of Rwanda.

When word came down that Rwandan Archbishop Kolini's successor, Onesphorus Rwaje, wanted more accountability from the AMIA's leadership over such issues as money and control over Murphy's insistence on turning the AMIA into a missionary society, it all blew up.

An ecclesiastical eruption between the two men became public with finger pointing and the first of many parishes departed the AMIA for new ecclesiastical pastures. Two AMIA bishops promptly resigned and came under PEAR/USA preferring to remain with the Anglican Province of Rwanda. Later other bishops would ally themselves directly with the Anglican Church in North America.

Murphy wrote a letter accusing the Rwandans of being Egyptians and that he, Moses, would lead the AMiA out of the Egypt of Rwanda into the Promised Land. God he said is "doing a new thing". Bishop Murphy's further remarks about "reverse colonialism" were painfully received in the Rwandan House of Bishops. Murphy later apologized for this remark.

Still others believe that Bishop Murphy's "style" was on a collision course with that of the newly anointed Archbishop Rwaje and that personality differences between the two men made confrontation inevitable. True or not, Murphy burned a bridge that would never be rebuilt. The relationship between the Province of Rwanda and the AMIA collapsed. Murphy told his people that the mission had spent $46 million dollars over its 12 years, but he would not say, nor could an accounting be obtained, about how much of that went to his friend Archbishop Kolini and the Province of Rwanda. Rwaje later told VOL that he would not be blackmailed by money and he would not change his mind - that the AMIA had to come fully under his authority. He gave Murphy six months to make up his mind if he would stay or go.

Rwandan Bishop John Rucyahana put his finger in the pulse of the situation when he wrote VOL saying, "I wrote an open letter to +Chuck calling for him and the House of Bishops in Rwanda to put right the differences that developed in the June 2011 meeting. Indeed, what I predicted has come true. The formation of a missionary society came at a wrong time when Rwanda was transitioning in leadership from ++ Kolini to ++ Rwaje." Reconciliation, however, was not to be. Positions hardened.

REJECTION SLIPS

Following his departure from the Province of Rwanda, Murphy looked to other African provinces for ecclesiastical cover but to no avail.

Murphy sought cover from The Rt. Rev. Nathan Kyamanywa, Bishop of Bunyoro-Kitara Diocese, in the Province of Uganda. Ugandan Archbishop Henry Luke Orombi quickly scotched that forcing Bishop Nathan to withdraw his offer.

AMIA continued to flounder in an ocean of ecclesiastical uncertainty. The mission also changed its name several times without telling its clergy. What began as the Anglican Mission in America became the Anglican Mission in the Americas, and then TheAM leaving people wondering and confused.

In another effort to provide canonical residency to clergy in the AMiA and the Society of Mission and Apostolic Works, Murphy approached Archbishop Henri Isingoma of the Province de I'Eglise Anglicane du Congo. Murphy obtained temporary ecclesiastical refuge from the Congolese Archbishop that technically runs out at the end of October. VOL has been told that a letter is on its way from Isingoma saying that they respectfully decline offering the oversight he sought, citing its relationship with Uganda, and Rwanda. Isingoma and Duncan also sit on the GAFCON Primates Council.

Many have asked why the AMIA leadership chose to announce the formation of the Missionary Society move right after Archbishop Emmanuel Kolini retired and Archbishop Rwaje was on his way in and his feet were still wet. The timing seemed poor.

It should be noted that Bishop Murphy's decision to withdraw from ACNA was based on consultation among the AM Council of Bishops and SE Asian Archbishops Moses Tay, Yong Ping Chung, and African Archbishop Emmanuel Kolini. Interference by these retired archbishops incensed Duncan who believes that once an archbishop or bishop retires, he should stay out of the politics of the church.

UNHOLY MESS

It all became an unholy mess. Murphy withdrew from the ACNA leadership.

When letters and communiques from both sides floated onto the Internet, the blogosphere exploded. Painful internal memos and emails sent to VOL give a picture of a man out of touch with the reality of what he had done, clinging to power even as his ecclesiastical world was, in the words of Archbishop Duncan, "disintegrating."

As the Anglican Mission narrative has played out, one cannot help but think that a certain amount of paranoia now prevails at the Pawleys Island headquarters. Wrote one observer, "The AM narrative to its front line was first that the problem was Archbishop Rwaje and the HOB of Rwanda, now the narrative has shifted to the problem being Archbishop Bob Duncan and to some extent still Bishop Terrell Glenn (the first bishop to leave the AM for PEARUSA). Add to what is happening now at All Saints, Pawleys Island to Robert L. Grafe one is forced to ask, who is the common denominator in all these clashes"?

"I have heard with my own ears public, hateful, painful, even embarrassing demonization of Archbishop Bob from Bishop Murphy," wrote a priest to VOL. "I have yet to hear it in reverse."

In a personal reflection on Anglican TV on the unholy mess, Archbishop Duncan reiterated what he said in Ridgecrest at a recent ACNA Mission's Assembly Conference: the AMIA is "disintegrating" and that the AMIA poses a challenge to unity in North America and a challenge to unity throughout the Confessing Anglican movement, as well as the emerging communion "which is taking the place of the structures we have known."

Duncan praised the AMIA's early vision for being in the forefront of mission with church planting, "They had hit exactly on the right thing. When I called for the building of 1000 churches we built on the trajectory of the Anglican Mission. We worked very hard with the AMIA to structure a province in North America. What we sought was a diocesan cluster or network that looked at a structure that allowed for the freedoms that had been developed there. In time they became more geographical."

Murphy would have none of it, said Duncan. "In 2010 the AMIA ceased to be a jurisdiction. Murphy didn't want to spend his and AMIA's energies building a church; he only wanted to do the mission. But if you are going to be a church then one must follow the Lord's Prayer in John Ch. 17 where Jesus says we must be one. You can't just focus on the mission and build relationships. The thing we tried to do with the AM is for them to be accountable. We wanted them to be a part of the ACNA and their bishops should be chosen and seated in ACNA's College of Bishops. Then the day came when he didn't want me to communicate with his bishops they could only go through him. He then said he didn't want them to communicate directly with the archbishop, only through him." The AMIA's autonomous and independence emerged.

Duncan was particularly disturbed at the continuing interference from former (retired) archbishops from SE Asia and Rwanda Archbishop Emmanuel Kolini who offered continual cover to Murphy. "Our polity is that when an archbishop ceases to be an archbishop he ceases to be a part of a province actively as an archbishop and must go." That was not the case with Murphy and the AM.

"This is contrary to the good order of the church. We hoped to find a way to work with the AM, but there is no precedence in the Western Church for a dispersed authority found for such a Society for Apostolic Works. When you look at the documents they are not at all Anglican. You can be a member of any church or not. There is nothing particularly Anglican about them. A Primatial vicar is not an Anglican idea."

Duncan recalled how amidst the turbulence Murphy announced that the AMIA was going into the Congo; "He had a sudden arrangement with the Congo, imagine that."

Duncan said the structure of the AM held all power in the hands of one man (Murphy). "As an Apostolic vicar no one really knows what happens or who is accountable to whom. When the Congo had the opportunity to think about it the HOB rejected the idea and only one bishop gave cover. Isingoma offered his province as only temporary cover.

Earlier in April Rwaje, who clearly had jurisdiction, asked AMIA's bishops to declare themselves. "He agreed to give them a window of six months. We in the ACNA agreed to receive those bishops who asked. Bishops Todd Hunter, TJ Johnson and John E. Miller have asked to come into ACNA. Others will follow."

Duncan described the situation as "confusing." When the documents for the Society and Apostolic Works came forward, it became clear that there was a technical accountability of bishops and clergy to ACNA bishops or to bishops in other parts of the world, but there was no real jurisdictional authority. All had been ceded to this apostolic vicar (Murphy).

"We tried to find a pathway forward to partner with the AMIA but confusion reigns. It was impossible. There was no reconciliation. There are more broken relationships than ever," said Duncan.

The archbishop asked for clarity, simplicity and flexibility. "There was no notion of subsidiarity in our dealings. We have tried to be flexible but our being flexible is bringing about more confusion." Duncan said he sent in two of his bishops, one from Canada (Charlie Masters) and the other from Blue Bell, PA (REC Presiding Bishop Leonard Riches) to help work things out but to no avail. "This confusion we are participating in is not helping. Relationships are broken and they are only getting worse. They have been spiraling down since 2010. AMiA doesn't fit the vision laid out to both Kolini and Chuck it all fell on deaf ears."

Duncan delivered his coup de grace.

Duncan told Murphy that if he wanted to be a part of a Mission Society (it is not a jurisdiction), then ACNA could not be a part of the confusion spilling out all over the communion and he could not be participate in the [ACNA] province. "For the good order the church, the ACNA cannot participate in the diminishing confusion. We cannot let them participate in the chaos. As the AMIA reshapes and new generation of leaders emerges perhaps unity will be possible."

Duncan concluded by saying that he hoped the AMIA gets reshaped and that it will want to come back to the ACNA. "We have not changed our vision - we are biblical, missionary and united."

An Anglican leader who has watched the situation unravel said he believes the manner in which Duncan has modeled conciliarity with the [new] Primate of Rwanda will be one of the highlights of his legacy.

To end the confusion, Duncan said that a new diocese was in formation - Western Gulf Coast - that will be under the Rev. Clark Lowenfield, a refugee from the AMIA, who would absorb more of AMIA's congregations.

In their new constitution, AMIA leaders make no mention of any overseas oversight, describing itself simply as a society of mission and apostolic works. You can see it here:
http://www.theamia.org/am_cms_media/amia-constitution--adopted.pdf

The sad truth is that the Anglican Mission is fracturing and disintegrating. With less than 100 parishes and six bishops, its long-term survival would seem unsustainable. The Anglican Church in North America is growing and remains the only game in town recognized by leading Global South Anglican Primates. The future clearly belongs to Archbishop Robert Duncan and his successors. All ties with African provinces must at some point cease. One can only hope and pray that whoever succeeds Bishop Murphy will be humble enough to accept that reality and link hands across a divide that should never have broken in the first place.

The Anglican TV interview can be found here:
http://www.anglican.tv/content/archbishop-duncan-discusses-amia-crisis

PERSONAL FOOTNOTE: This has been one of the hardest stories this journalist has ever had to write. I have been involved with the AMIA from its inception - over 12 years - attending every winter conference. I have worshipped, heard lectures and sermons, and caught the vision of a movement that was clearly touched by God. Tragically, the pride, hubris and inability of one man to see beyond his own vision for a greater vision, is bringing down the Mission. This is not the first time this has happened and it certainly won't be the last. There is still time to redeem the situation, if wiser heads prevail and full repentance is made.

To read a response to this story from Bishop Murphy click here:
http://tinyurl.com/d5lkblu

Thursday, August 30, 2012

Anglican TV: ABP Duncan Discusses AMiA Crisis

Archbishop Duncan discusses the AMiA Crisis
 
Kevin Kallsen and Archbishop Duncan sit down to an intense interview about how the year-old AMiA crisis is affecting the Anglican Church in North American and international relations with the Global South and GAFCON.

Submitted by kkallsen on Thu, 08/30/2012 - 00:43
02:59
 

Friday, July 27, 2012

A Well-Grounded Anglicanism


Finally, finally, finally.  A man of history, theology, the confessions, creeds, old Prayer Book, learning and intelligence!  Uncommon to hear these things these days.  Certainly not from the "minority faiths," e.g. Western Anglicanism.

A WELL GROUNDED ANGLICANISM

By Roger Salter
Special to Virtueonline
www.virtueonline.org
July 21, 2012

 We witness today a severely enfeebled Anglicanism. Our leadership is vague. Our parishes are nondescript. Our identity is unclear. Our effectiveness is minimal. There are exceptions, some notable, to these characterizations, but on the whole the condition of Anglicanism is not healthy.

Much of it is perverse. In its manifestation it is too diverse, unwieldy in its divergence from biblical truth, and confusing in its deviations from the historic Anglican Way. The multiplicity of "versions" of Anglicanism, all with the claim to be authentic, and all professing the aim of Anglicanism's resurgence as a strong and vibrant Christian movement have proved to be disappointing, have lacked certain vital elements, or added alien features to its simple Scriptural, Reformational, Protestant, character.

For Anglicanism to get itself right it must first rediscover its roots as a Reformed Catholic expression and presentation of divinely revealed truth. We need to know ourselves, first of all, from a historical perspective. Without a sense of history we are orphaned, unsure, and directionless.

We need an inherited sense of origin, conviction, and aspiration as a body. Our heritage is strong, rich, and wise and it is summed up in the Liturgy, Ordinal, and Articles compiled in the 1662 Book of Common Prayer. The intentional meaning and use of the BCP is outlined for us in the lives, ministries, and witness of our Reformers and the faithful heirs of their tradition. Their teachings and biographies assist us in maintaining constitutional and confessional Anglicanism. It is inexcusable to go astray. It is easy to consult the guidance of our founders and their followers, ascertain their mind, and adhere to their counsel.

Our Biblical Catholicism derives from subscription to the great Ecumenical Creeds, namely the Apostles', Nicene, and Athanasian Creeds, our regard for the fathers when their instruction is Scriptural, and we stand with the great champions of effective grace from the earliest post-apostolic era to the time of the Reformation e.g. Prosper, Fulgentius, Gregory the Great, Isidore of Seville, Gottschalk, Ratramnus, Anselm, Bernard of Clairvaux, Peter Lombard, Aquinas, Bradwardine, Wycliffe, Gregory of Rimini, Huss, and Luther's mentor Staupitz. All of these figures were firm Augustinians and highly regarded by the men who guided the English nation into Gospel light in the fifteen hundreds.

From Cranmer to Abbott, a span of 70 years, our Archbishops of Canterbury and the bulk of English Bishops were staunch Reformation men (with the obvious exception of Archbishop Reginald Pole in Mary's brief reign, himself a near evangelical reformer within the Church of Rome). The rise of William Laud signaled the end of the dominance of Reformational thought.

But Anglican history from the 16th century to the present is studded with the names of great men who have adhered to the doctrinal and devotional Augustinianism of the BCP. The company of these luminaries is large, including: Ridley, Latimer, Bradford, Jewel, Whitgift, Grindal, Hooker, Davenant, Hall, Donne, Boys, Herbert, Ussher, Perkins, Trapp, Gurnall, Beveridge, Whitefield, Toplady, Newton, Romaine, Grimshaw, Law (Henry), Simeon, McIlvaine, Tyng, McNeile, Ryle, Moule, Griffith Thomas, and so on into the 20th and 21st centuries. Here is a galaxy of worthies who can be our guides in maintaining the testimony of classic and authentic Anglicanism.

How can genuine Anglicanism jettison its Calvinism and embrace sacramentalism, as some have advised, when we stand in such a lineage of faithful, brave, and holy advocates of Christ's Gospel? It is unthinkable and not negotiable. The doctrines of grace are far too precious to us. Nor should fear of contradiction, criticism, and accusation keep us silent. We are not to be discourteous, but we are not to be dissuaded from proclaiming plain Scriptural truth that keeps us indebted to grace and eternally grateful to the mercy of God. We are not to brawl over doctrine and be gratuitously offensive but nor must we muzzle ourselves in the enunciation of truth that humbles man and exalts the Lord Jesus as entirely our Saviour in every necessary way in the accomplishment of our salvation.

Our loyal confessionalism does not confine our affection for other believers and our fellowship with them. All of God's people are admired and accepted right along the spectrum from Rome to anywhere else the Word of God is revered and the Redeemer wholly relied upon. Love must be the bond between us all, but allegiance to our standards in belief and ministry may not be compromised. It is dangerous to our calling and conscience. Sovereign grace is to be extolled. It glorifies the great Three in One who has stooped and sacrificed to save us to the uttermost when we were, and without him are, utterly helpless. Arminianism is alien to Anglicanism and should not prevail among us (our leadership and clergy). Arminianism has diluted our dealing with sin and our estimate of the magnitude of grace (pure and free). "We make no contribution from ourselves to our salvation. From beginning to end it is of grace . . . . The seventeenth Article not only accompanies Calvin beyond the point where Augustine stopped short, but it effectively excludes an Arminian interpretation of predestination" (D.B. Knox). Electing love exhilarates, encourages, and emboldens us and Anglicanism today needs all three - the capacity to exhilarate believers with the wonder of grace, present it encouragingly to the lost, and be bold in doing both.

The day for dithering is over. The day for decisiveness is here. May God grant us the restoration of Anglicanism as it clearly should be.

The Rev. Roger Salter is an ordained Church of England minister where he had parishes in the dioceses of Bristol and Portsmouth before coming to Birmingham, Alabama to serve as Rector of St. Matthew's Anglican Church

Thursday, May 10, 2012

Wash Post: Christ Anglican Church, Vienna, VA



Shamus Ian Fatzinger/Fairfax County Times) - Johnny Kurcina Jr. prays with Caroline Berry, Sarah Roper and Holly Berry during Sunday service at Christ Church Vienna, which he began late last year
Vienna pastor’s spiritual journey leads him home
By Gregg MacDonald,  Published: May 9/The Washington Post
For Johnny Kurcina Jr., Mark 6:4, “A prophet is without honor only in his hometown, among his relatives, and in his own home,” has special meaning.
“I’m determined to prove that wrong,” said Kurcina, 36.
Amid controversy and court battles between the local Episcopal and Anglican dioceses, Kurcina, a 1993 graduate of James Madison High School, recently started an Anglican church in his native Vienna. He is ministering to a congregation of about 250, and that number continues to grow.
The church is an offshoot of the Anglican half of the Falls Church, which has been embroiled in a legal land battle over church property for several years with its Episcopal cousins.
Eleven local churches broke from the Episcopal Church in early 2007 to join a more conservative Anglican Church under the auspices of the Convocation of Anglicans in North America. The Anglican churches, however, kept the Episcopal church properties.
In January, Fairfax County Circuit Judge Randy Bellows reversed his original 2008 ruling that the breakaway congregations were entitled to the properties.

Kurcina began Christ Church Vienna late last year and continues to be amazed with its success. Services are in the Louise Archer Elementary School cafeteria, where parishioners sit in plastic chairs and the walls are adorned with lunch menus.
“Holding services in a school cafeteria does hold some challenges,” Kurcina said. “We are not allowed to use wine for communion so we use grape juice, and our candles look real but the flame is really a small flickering light bulb because we are not allowed to use real flame candles on school grounds.”
Despite the obstacles, the church continues to draw new parishioners.
“My idea was just to bring Jesus to anyone who would accept him,” Kurcina said. “I thought we would perhaps garner interest from about 50 people, mostly friends, family, neighbors and acquaintances. It has been through the grace of God that we have been able to minister to so many more.”
Growing up in Vienna, Kurcina said, he was a typical teenager. He was active in sports and dreamed about being accepted into a military academy. But then he got involved with a Christian youth group and became aware of a talent he never knew he had.
“I began to see that my faith and love for God began affecting others,” he said. “When I was 16, I would hold Bible study sessions for kids a few years younger than myself, and I took notice that I was actually getting through to them.”
After graduating from the University of Virginia, Kurcina attended a seminary in Massachusetts and eventually moved to Bristol, England, to pursue a doctorate in New Testament studies. While there, he said, he felt a strong urge to return to Vienna.
“My family is strongly rooted here,” he said. “My mother also graduated from Madison in the 1960s, and my father moved here from Pennsylvania around that same time. He opened, and still owns, a business — John Edwards Hair Design — in town.
On any given Sunday, Kurcina’s father, mother and wife can be seen helping out with the services.
“My father works as a greeter as people come in,” Kurcina said. “Sometimes people who don’t know he is my dad come up to me and say, ‘That guy looks just like an older version of you.’ ”
Vienna native Brian Berry, who went to U-Va. with Kurcina and sits on the Christ Church board of directors, attributes the church’s success to the fact that Kurcina and his extended family are so charismatic and entrenched in the community.
“Johnny is the real deal,” he said. “He is not an egghead and doesn’t come across as holier than thou or anything like that. In his spare time, he coaches football, baseball and his love for Vienna shows. People know him and his family, and see him as a regular guy from the neighborhood.”
For now, the school cafeteria works fine for the church but it soon might no longer meet its needs, Kurcina said.
“We won’t stay there long term,” he said. “We are not a static church. We are dynamic ,and we want to grow, bringing Jesus to as many as we can.”
That sentiment has not gone unnoticed within the Anglican Diocese of the Mid-Atlantic.
“This new church is thriving,” Bishop John Guernsey said. “Christ Church Vienna is an excellent example of our diocese’s commitment to spreading the Gospel. The congregation is living proof that you don’t need a steeple to grow in mission, ministry and numbers.”

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Wannabe Anglican: AMiA's Anglicostal Bishop Turns ACNA Bishop

Some excellent questions were raised by “Wannabe Anglican” that continue to justify, confirm and strengthen our unremitted doubts and suspicions about ACNA and AMiA Bishops and churches.  The update on this story was AMiA Murphy’s desertion of Rwandan Anglicanism and oversight.  Hunter, an AMiA Anglicostal and bishop, now repairs to ACNA Duncan’s oversight and embrace.  Here’s Wannabe’s comments.


Wednesday, May 09, 2012
About Bishop Todd Hunter (and 1 Timothy 5:22)
There has been concern expressed online and elsewhere about the appropriateness of Todd Hunter speaking at the upcoming ACNA Provincial Assembly in the aftermath of AMiA’s fall out with Rwanda. (+Hunter is (or was) an AMiA bishop.)
Bishop Todd Hunter of the Anglican Mission in America (AMiA) has been received by the Anglican Church in North America and will serve as an assistant bishop in the office of the primate, the Most Rev. Robert Duncan.
And I agree with Matt Kennedy that it is good to see him, at his initiative, reconciled with Rwanda.
Bishop Hunter also stated that he had asked for and had received forgiveness from the Primate of Rwanda, Archbishop Onesphore Rwaje for “my part in actions, attitudes or communications that were hurtful to him or to my brother bishops in Rwanda.”
So he, Bishop Duncan, and others involved are to be commended for getting this matter resolved and that well before the Provincial Assembly.
However (“Uh, oh,” my readers are saying.), I think we should not let pass without comment a significant reason Todd Hunter got into this mess in the first place. The following gives a clue about that:
When I walked across the dance floor and was introduced to Anglicanism three years ago I was told repeatedly that we were all working toward one, unified, missional, kingdom-oriented, Spirit-enabled Anglican church in North America. I took that vision into my heart and have pondered it since,” [Bishop Hunter] said.
So he was an Anglican for only three years before being made an Anglican bishop? Not exactly. He was made bishop back in 2009. Look at his own statement back in 2009 between his election and consecration as bishop in the AMiA:
It is big shocker because in the past I would have never thought of myself as an Anglican. While I admired and respected Robert Webber from a distance, I was not one of those people on the Canterbury Trail. I’ve often said over the last six months that this has all come out of the blue for me.
It is not clear exactly what “six months” refers to. But “three years ago” is 2009. So, by his own admission, he was Anglican for less than a year before being elected an Anglican bishop. (By the way, I remember overhearing talk of this at the Bedford Provincial Assembly.) That is indeed “out of the blue.” Read more of his 2009 statement and the comments there to get a flavor of that.
Paul commanded Timothy to “lay hands hastily on no man.” (1Tim. 5:22) It is safe to say that making a new Anglican an Anglican bishop is hasty.
And it put Hunter in a difficult position. Certainly, to be a bishop of a church and tradition of which one is just getting to know is not an easy position to be in. That goes double for Anglicanism, in which jurisdictions can be slightly labyrinthine. This all compounded the difficulty of dealing with the mess when Chuck Murphy went rogue.
Bishop Todd Hunter, made a Bishop
after a mere 3 years into Anglicanism
and without Prayer Book pieties (or education)
seen in the mature and experienced. 
Good stuff
for Anglicostalism.
Again, +Hunter is to be commended for setting matters aright. And he may turn out to be an outstanding bishop. It is clear Archbishop Duncan is among those who have high hopes for him. God is gracious and often causes undertakings that did not start well to become great blessings and end well. Even some of the church fathers were made bishops very quickly. And if anyone is to be criticized, it is those who laid hands on Todd Hunter more than Mr. Hunter himself.
But Paul did not give the above commandment to Timothy for nothing. And the awkwardness in which +Hunter found himself in recent months illustrates part of St. Paul’s wisdom.

Tuesday, February 28, 2012

VA Attorney General Files Brief in Behalf of Falls Church, Anglican, Fairfax County, VA

Virginia Attorney General Intervenes for Breakaway Anglicans in Property Battle
The Falls Church has been in existence since the 18th century
http://www.christianpost.com/
February 29, 2012


 

Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli's brief, filed on Wednesday with the Fairfax County Circuit Court, argued that the departing congregations should be allowed to keep their personal property and donations they made to the churches they inhabited.

Faith McDonnell, a member of Church of the Apostles, which is one of the seven churches involved in the property controversy, told The Christian Post that she agreed with the attorney general.

"Cuccinelli is very right when he says that this is a religious freedom issue," said McDonnell.

"There is a violation of religious freedom in taking the funds and/or other property given to the churches by members and other friends that intended them to go to that particular body of believers."

Last month, Fairfax County Circuit Court Judge Randy Bellows ruled in favor of the Diocese of Virginia regarding who owned the property of seven Episcopal churches that had decided to break away from TEC over theological differences.

In his motion, Cuccinelli noted that since 2003 nearly all the donations given by members of the seven churches were specifically given to their respective church and not the Diocese of Virginia or The Episcopal Church.

Cuccinelli cited "donor intent" when arguing that Bellows' decision ignored the intentions of the donors, violating their religious conscience.

"[E]ven before the time of the official split from The Episcopal Church, church members have been indicating in the memo section of their checks that they are designated for use by the local congregation only," said McDonnell.

McDonnell said there were other donations that were of a non-monetary nature, such as a cross that was given to the Church of the Apostles, handmade pulpits, and a mural.

The properties The Episcopal Church gained control of included The Falls Church and Truro Church, which were both established during the 18th century, with George Washington serving as a vestryman.

When the seven congregations decided to break away, they remained with the overall Anglican Communion, joining conservative denominations like the Convocation of Anglicans in North America.

Henry D.W. Burt, Secretary & Chief of Staff for the Episcopal Diocese of Virginia, told CP that Cuccinelli's brief was part of an ongoing involvement the attorney general had had with the case.

"The attorney general ... notes that he does not take sides in the matter, noting only that the CANA congregations have raised a prima facie case that the court has not considered donor intent in its ruling," said Burt.

"We will respond in a filing next week. We remain confident that this case was correctly decided."

Jeff Walton, staff member for the Institute on Religion and Democracy's "Anglican Action" program, told CP that he believed there was a religious liberty aspect to this case.

"This is an acknowledgement that the departing Anglican congregations have a substantial argument that deserves consideration," said Walton.

"The court should not compel persons to give money to a religious institution. Clearly, the overwhelming number of donations to these parishes since 2003 were specifically restricted by donors not to go to either The Episcopal Church or the Diocese of Virginia."

END

Monday, February 27, 2012

Truro Anglican Church, DC

BlueBaby reports the following at:  http://babybluecafe.blogspot.com/2012/02/now-is-time-to-pray.html
 
It is true, a church building is not the church, but oh, it is a home that tells the story of the people who lived there.

1662 Prayer Book Contest to Take Place

Prayer book contest to take place
Young people will recite their favourite passage from a prayer book as part of a speaking competition in London.

The Cranmer Awards is seen as a way to introduce younger generations to Cranmer's Book of Common Prayer, the Anglican church's founding liturgy. The awards are in their 23rd year.

Young people aged between 11 and 18 who have won regional heats in Church of England dioceses and at various literary and public speaking awards, will take part in the final on March 1, at Sutton's Hospital Chapel, The Charterhouse, London.

The entrants receive marks for clarity and projection; pace, use of pause and emphasis; fluency and rhythm; natural, intelligent communication of meaning; and secure, accurate memorisation and timing.


This year's competition coincides with the the Prayer Book Society's celebration of the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Prayer Book.

For more, see:
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ukpress/article/ALeqM5hesYhowDWmgraWVZm-qzCAs_0oBg?docId=A112203511330333870A00

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

An American Prayer Book (2009): A Penitential Service by Robin Jordan

Robin Jordan offers this gentle revision of the 1662 BCP's Commination Service. 

http://exploringananglicanprayerbook.blogspot.com/2012/02/american-prayer-book-2009-penitential.html

An American Prayer Book (2009): A Penitential Service




A PENITENTIAL SERVICE
TO BE USED ON THE FIRST DAY OF LENT, AND AT
OTHER TIMES AS THE ORDINARY SHALL APPOINT

This service may be used after Morning or Evening Prayer, or after the Litany if the Litany follows Morning or Evening Prayer. It may be used as a part of the Second Alternative Form of Morning and Evening Worship, in which case it may replace the General Confession, the Absolution (or declaration of forgiveness), and the Prayers. It may also be used as a separate service.

When A Penitential Service is used as a separate service, it may be preceded by a Psalm, canticle, or hymn and one of the readings of the day.

The minister says


Brothers and sisters, there has been, from ancient times, a godly custom in the Church, that, at the beginning of Lent, Christian people should be warned and reminded in a special manner, of the wrath of God revealed by heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness, in order that they may take to heart their own sinfulness and continuing need to turn to God, and not become hardened by the deceitfulness of sin. It is therefore fitting, that at this time (in the presence of you all) should be read the general sentences of God’s cursing against impenitent sinners, gathered out of the twenty-seventh chapter of Deuteronomy, and other places of Scripture; and that you should answer to every sentence, Amen: to the intent that, being admonished of the great indignation of God against sinners, you may be moved to sincere and true repentance, and may walk more warily in these dangerous days, fleeing from such vices, for the which you affirm with your own mouths, the curse of God to be due.

Then the minister says

Cursed be the man who makes a carved or cast metal image, an abomination to the Lord, a thing made by the hands of craftsman, and sets it up in secret. AMEN
Cursed be anyone who dishonors his father and his mother. AMEN
Cursed be anyone who moves his neighbor’s landmark. AMEN.
Cursed be anyone who misleads a blind man on the road. AMEN.
Cursed be anyone who perverts the justice due to the sojourner, the fatherless, and the widow. AMEN.
Cursed be anyone who strikes down his neighbor in secret. AMEN.
Cursed be anyone who lies with his neighbor’s wife. AMEN.
Cursed be anyone who takes a bribe to shed innocent blood. AMEN.
Cursed be anyone who puts his trust in man, and takes man for his defense, and in his heart departs from the Lord. AMEN.
Cursed be the unmerciful, the sexually immoral, and the greedy, the idolaters, slanderers, drunkards, and swindlers. AMEN.

Then the minister says

Now seeing that all are accursed (as the Prophet David bears witness) who err, and wander from the commandments of God, let us (remembering the dreadful judgment hanging over our heads, and being always at hand) return to our Lord God, with all contrition and meekness of heart mourning and lamenting our sinful life, acknowledging and confessing our offences, and seeking to bear fruit worthy of repentance. Even now is the axe laid to the root of the trees. Every tree therefore that does not bear good fruit, is cut down and thrown into the fire. It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God: he shall rain coals on the wicked; fire and sulfur and a scorching wind shall be the portion of their cup. For behold, the Lord is coming out from his place to punish the inhabitants of the earth for their iniquity. But who can endure the day of his coming, and who can stand when he appears? His winnowing fork is in his hand, and he will clear his threshing floor and gather his wheat into the barn, but the chaff he will burn with unquenchable fire. The day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night. While people are saying, “There is peace and security,” then sudden destruction will come upon them as labor pains come upon a pregnant woman, and they will not escape. Then, on the day of wrath when God’s righteous judgment shall be revealed, shall appear the wrath that those with a hard and impenitent heart are storing up for themselves, who presumed upon the riches of God’s kindness and forbearance and patience, by which he meant to lead them to repentance. Then they will call upon me, says the Lord, but I will not answer. They will seek me diligently but will not find me. And because they hated knowledge and did not choose the fear of the Lord, would have none of my counsel and despised all my reproof, it shall be too late to knock, when the door shall be shut, and too late to cry for mercy, when it is the time of justice. O terrible voice of most just judgment, which shall be pronounced upon them, when it shall be said to them: “Depart from me, you cursed, into eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels.” Let us, brothers and sisters, take heed in good time, for now is the day of salvation. Night is coming when no one can work; but let us while we have the light, believe in the light, that we may become sons of light; that we may not be caste into the outer darkness. In that place there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. Let us not abuse the goodness of God, who calls us mercifully to amendment, and of his endless pity promises us forgiveness of that which is past, if (with a whole mind and true heart) we return to him. Though our sins are like scarlet, they shall be as white as snow; though they are red like crimson, they shall become like wool. Repent and turn from all your transgressions, lest iniquity be your ruin. Cast away from you all transgressions that you have committed, and make yourselves a new heart and a new spirit! Why will you die, O house of Israel? For I have no pleasure in the death of anyone (declares the Lord God) so turn and live. But if anyone does sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous. He is the propitiation for our sins. He was wounded for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities. Let us therefore return to him, who is the merciful receiver of all true penitent sinners, assuring our selves that he is ready to receive us, and most willing to pardon us, if we come to him, with faithful repentance, if we will submit our selves to him, and from that moment on walk in his ways; if we will take his easy yoke, and light burden upon us, to follow him in lowliness, patience, and charity, and be ordered by the governance of his Holy Spirit, seeking always his glory, and serving him duly in our vocation with thanksgiving. If we do this, Christ will deliver us from the curse of the law, and from the extreme malediction, that shall alight upon those who shall be set on the left hand. And he will set us on his right hand, and give us the blessed benediction of his Father, commanding us to take possession of his glorious kingdom; to which he condescends to bring us all, out of his infinite mercy. Amen
 
For more, see:
http://exploringananglicanprayerbook.blogspot.com/2012/02/american-prayer-book-2009-penitential.html

Sunday, February 19, 2012

AMiA Bishops on Their Future After Break with Rwandan Anglican Church

For those not following the story, here are some pertinent issues. First, Anglican Mission in America (AMiA) is about 11 years old. Second, AMiA has about 150 churches or so.  Third, AMiA split from the parent American body, The Episcopal Church (TEC).  Fourth, although AMiA claims the 1662 BCP and Thirty-nine Articles as formularies, they use the 1979 BCP.  Fifth, AMiA supports women's ordination.  Sixth, they are charismatically-inclined. Seventh, AMiA's majority of Bishop "resigned" from the Rwandan Anglican Bishops and Churches.  This has caused consternation and difficulty for some of the American Churches. Eighth, it remains very unclear why this resignation occurred. Ninth, at present, AMiA looks like MiA without the Anglican part, without a Provincial connection and appears as a more of a liturgized version of a charismatic church. Here's an odd, undistinctive, and unhelpful letter from MiA bishops that offers little. 

http://www.virtueonline.org/portal/modules/news/article.php?storyid=15587

AMiA's Council of Bishops Issues Letter on Their FutureFebruary 16, 2012

Dear Friends,

Grace and peace to you from our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.

In the weeks since Winter Conference, we have continued conversations about the Anglican Mission's future and are grateful for many of you who have responded positively, offering your valuable insight and perceptions.

Your questions and recommendations have contributed significantly to our ability to better serve you and work toward greater clarity as we move forward together.

Last week, we gathered in a special meeting of the Council with a deep desire to seek Jesus' heart for the Anglican Mission.

As we concluded our meeting, we were convinced that the Lord had truly met with us and had given us clear direction, enabling us to consider things in a new way with fresh insight.

We concluded our meeting united and confident that the Lord was showing us an exciting and challenging way forward.

In order to more fully embrace our call of service to Christ's Church, we have determined to form a Mission Society that is authentically Anglican and focused on North America.

We remain committed to boldly and creatively reaching out to those who are disconnected from Christ and His Church through church planting (Luke 15).

Like other mission societies that have historically supported the broader Church by planting churches on its behalf, we also feel called to express our ministry through such a model. (See attached documents.)

This decision marks the first step in a process to develop the mission society as we continue to seek the Lord's guidance with your input.

With this end in mind, we will be reviewing all of our structures and roles in order to discern the specific shape of the mission society as we engage our process.

We are committed to the following:

* evangelism and discipleship through planting churches that plant churches;
* the expression of three streams: the Sacred (sacramental and liturgical) the Scripture (evangelical), and the Spirit (charismatic);
* orthodox theology (adherence to the 39 Articles of Religion and historic formularies of the Church);
* Anglican polity;
* fostering an entrepreneurial culture;
* pursuing both temporary (short-term solutions) and enduring relationships with an Anglican jurisdiction.

This vision is consistent with our clear call to be "a mission, nothing more and nothing less." Our focus on planting churches as an outreach for an existing judicatory within the one holy catholic and apostolic church continues our established pattern.

As we continue our conversations and discernment with the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA), we will keep you fully informed.

We want you to know that our goal is to provide our parishes with strategies and support which will allow us all to move forward together.

During this process, we are committed to open dialogue and are proceeding diligently, but carefully and prayerfully.

We ask for your prayers for wisdom and discernment as we intercede daily for your mission and ministry.

In Christ,

Anglican Mission Council of Bishops

Anglican Mission in the Americas
http://theamia.org
Heart of North America Network, AMiA
http://honanetwork.com
Ph. 330.990.9475