Reformed Churchmen

We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879

Showing posts with label Reformed Episcopal Church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reformed Episcopal Church. Show all posts

Saturday, October 5, 2013

"Trojan Horse" Warning to Confessional Churchmen: Stay Away from Reformed Episcopal Seminary

Here's how the (Un-) Reformed Episcopal Seminary now sells itself. Advisorial for all Confessional Reformation Churchmen, Lutheran or Reformed, this is a "Trojan Horse." Try teaching Tractarianism, charismania, and other syncretisms at Concordia Seminary (LCMS) or at Westminster Seminaries, or the varied Reformed seminaries. 

The putative claim to "over-all respect" obtains until you object to their Misters and one understands this as a "marketing tool" for an ever-shrunken school. They'll pull the "charity card" if you object, presuming themselves to be charitable, while, in fact, being quite uncharitable.

Try "invoking Mary" or saints during Chapel exercises at any one of the Reformation-based schools in the nation!  

Try "Babbeling" in a Neo-Montanist state during any of the classes or Chapel services in Confessional Lutheran or Presbyterian schools.

This is the new-three-streams: Tractarianism, Bablyonics, and syncretizing-indifferentism now advocated by "this thing" they call the Anglican Church in North America.

Go ahead, leaders of the (Un-) Reformed Episcopal Seminary. By the way, how's the alumni association these days? 

Here's a word from a FB post.

"Yet another testimony for Reformed Episcopal Seminary -- given by one of our second year students. Robert Garrett on the Reformed Episcopal Seminary group page:

"Coming from a Charismatic background, I continue to be blessed and strengthened by the balance and care that is shown by the RES, REC and the ACNA towards convergent (three-streams) worship expressions and the over-all respect given to other branches of Christ's church. Amidst the challenges and changes within Anglicanism in the Americas and globally over the past decades, as a new-comer, I can see a bright future for those of us who have come to love Anglicanism, but come from a blended worship background. Taking a quote from Bishop Duncan... Jesus said, "I am come that they might have life more abundantly.""

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Roman-Seeds in Anglican Soil

D’Aubigne, Merle. The History of the Reformation in England, 2 Vols. Edinburgh: Banner of Truth, 1963.

Volume 1 is available at:
http://www.amazon.com/The-Reformation-England-Volume-1/dp/0851514863/ref=sr_1_13?ie=UTF8&qid=1375919662&sr=8-13&keywords=Merle+d%27Aubigne

Volume 2 is available at:
http://www.amazon.com/The-Reformation-England-Volume-2/dp/0851514871/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1375919662&sr=8-1&keywords=Merle+d%27Aubigne .  


 It appears to not be available online.


From Vol. 1, Pg.475:

“The second, which was essential to the renewal of the church, was represented by Cranmer, and consisted particularly in re-establishing the authority of holy Scripture. Wolsey did not fall alone, nor did Cranmer rise alone: each of these two men carried with him the system he represented. The fabric of the Roman traditions fell with the first; the foundations of the holy Scriptures were laid by the second; and yet, while we render all justice to the sincerity of the Cambridge doctor, we must not be blind to his weaknesses, his subservience, and even a certain degree of negligence, which, by allowing parasitical plant to shoot up here and there, permitted them to spread over the living rock of God’s Word. Not in this movement, then, was found the Reformation with all its energy and all it purity” [emphasis added].

Laud would seethe with fury at Mr. D'Aubigne, although he was substantially inferior to Mr. D'Aubigne as a scholar, exegete and historian. 19th century Tractarians did their level best to keep D'Aubigne from a lecture in England.

The Reformed Episcopal Church (REC) believed, albeit so modestly if not ineffectively, that "Romanist germs" or "seeds" lay within the Anglican soil.  Corrections were needed; the REC corrections appeared ham-fisted; they failed to embrace the Reformed Confessions.  But this conviction was their's: Roman-seeds in Anglican soil.  Misters Riches and Sutton drove it downwards inside of upwards. They became what the REC once feared.


The Tractarians, the 2.0ers, are testimonies to that. The REC itself--these days--has yielded to the 2.0ers and they know it, but will not admit it. I suspect D'Aubigne would be bad-mouthed by the REC neo-Tractarians although, insofar as one can see from any publications, "they have not a single one" on a level of D'Aubigne's scholarship or publications. "Not a single one."

Pg. 476:

“The father of this church in England was not Henry VIII. When the king cast into prison or gave to the flames men like Hitton, Bennet, Patmore, Petit, Bayfield, Bilney, and many others, he was not the `the father of the Reformation of England,’ as some have so falsely asserted; he was its executioner.”

“The church of England was foredoomed to be in its renovation a church of martyrs; and the truth father of this church is our Father which is in heaven.”

Friday, July 26, 2013

FIFNA & Misters Ray Sutton, Keith Ackerman, Jack Iker and Bob Duncan of the Anglican Church of North America

Cardinal John Henry Newman
Convert to Rome
Former Anglican and Oxford Professor
Hero, Patron Saint, and Forerunner of Tractarians

 

http://anglicansablaze.blogspot.com/2013/07/apprising-new-fifna-declaration.html

By Robin G. Jordan
 
Mr. (bp.) Keith Ackerman
FIFNA Leader
Confraternity of Blessed Sacrament
SSC (Society of Sacred Cross)
Tractarian
 
I am posting a link to “A Hasty But Comprehensive Response to the Critics of the New FIFNA Declaration,"  Nathaniel Kidd’s defense of the recent changes in the FIFNA Declaration of Common Faith and Purpose. The Rev. Kidd would lead us to believe that those draw attention to the changes in the FIFNA Declaration and their implications are engaging in sensationalism. Their criticism of this theological statement is unwarranted.

 








Mr. Bob Duncan (left),
Mr. Jack Iker (right).
Mr. Iker is
another Tractarian
Kidd’s defense of the new FIFNA Declaration assumes that Henry Newman’s interpretation of the Thirty-Nine Articles in a Roman Catholic direction is an acceptable interpretation of the Articles. The GAFCON Theological Resource Group in The Way, the Truth, and the Life, however, rejects Newman’s interpretation of the Articles. They identify his interpretation of the Articles as part of the Anglo-Catholic movement’s challenge to the authority of the Bible and the classic Anglican formularies in the Anglican Church. Newman disregarded authorial intent and historical context in interpreting the Articles as have subsequent Anglo-Catholics in imitation of Newman. Newman would eventually reject the Articles and become a Roman Catholic, believing that his earlier attempts to reconcile the Articles and Roman Catholic theology were untenable.
 
 
Nineteenth century Evangelical and Protestant High Church scholars in the Church of England effectively refuted the claims of the Tractarian and Ritualist movements that they alone represented authentic historic Anglicanism and their churchmanship was the only true churchmanship. Twentieth century scholars have also shown the falseness and inaccuracy of these claims. The Anglo-Catholic movement in the twenty-first century continues to make such claims. They underlies its claim to be a genuine expression of Anglicanism.
 
 
Mr. Ray Sutton
Reformed Episcopal Church
 
Both nineteenth and twentieth century scholars have shown that the Anglo-Catholic movement is essentially an anti-Bible, anti-Reformation movement that seeks to change the identity of the Anglican Church and to make the Anglican Church more Roman Catholic in belief, order, and practice. At one time the hope of Anglo-Catholics was that if they made the Anglican Church sufficiently like the Roman Catholic Church, the pope would accept the Anglican Church back into the Roman Catholic fold.

 
The acceptance of Anglo-Catholicism in the Anglican Church is confined to one segment of the Church. This acceptance may be attributed largely to the erosion of Biblical authority and the liberalization of the Church. 
 
 
The late Peter Toon’s observation that the initial Common Cause theological statement went well beyond historic Anglicanism in its affirmation of the teaching of the first seven Councils of the undivided Church is applicable to the new FIFNA Declaration of Common Faith and Purpose. Interestingly a number of the church leaders involved in the Common Cause Roundtable also serve on the FIFNA Council. The final Common Cause theological statement forms the basis of the Anglican Church in North America’s Fundamental Declarations.

 
The new FIFNA Declaration of Common Faith and Purpose’s assertion that Christ is substantively present under the species of bread and wine is clearly at odds with Article 28. While a segment of the Anglican Church may have embraced the doctrine of transubstantiation under the influence of the Anglo-Catholic movement, this is not sufficient grounds to disregard the doctrine of the Articles as it applies to the sacrament of the Lord’s Supper. A segment of the Anglican Church also no longer regards homosexual behavior as immoral and sinful. Are we then on the same basis to reject the teaching of the Bible and the doctrine of the Articles as they apply to God’s moral law?

 
Forward in Faith in North America may now be representing itself as a teaching organization, rather than a lobbying group. However FIFNA represents itself, the organization promotes Anglo-Catholicism. It unites in its membership Anglo-Catholics who desire to export their beliefs and practices to the global South and change the shape of global Anglicanism. Anglo-Catholicism and liberalism are the two major challenges to the authority of the Bible and the classic Anglican formularies that the GAFCON Theological Resource Group identifies in The Way, the Truth, and the Life.

 
The observation that the new FIFNA Declaration of Common Faith and Purpose puts Forward in Faith North America at odds with historic Anglicanism, the Thirty-Nine Articles and the Jerusalem Declaration is a valid one. Kidd may wish to gloze over this fact—explain it away. But it is undeniable.
The making public of the changes in the ACNA Ordinal, of the ACNA Catechism, and of the ACNA Holy Communion rites may shed light on this development. They will reveal the theological direction of the Anglican Church in North America, which Forward in Faith North America may be seeking to anticipate and influence with its new Declaration of Common Faith and Purpose. We shall see when the Anglican Church in North America finally releases those documents.

Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Mr. Sutton on the Resurgence of the Reformed Episcopal Church

Mr. Sutton on the Resurgence of the Reformed Episcopal Church

 
Vis a vis: 

http://juicyecumenism.com/2013/07/08/ird-exclusive-bishop-ray-sutton-on-the-reformed-episcopal-resurgence/#comments

and

http://www.virtueonline.org/portal/modules/news/article.php?storyid=17771#.Udtt-p3D9jo


1. Those who have been impressed by Mr. Sutton’s spirited justification of the “new” REC might be interested in getting to know the gentleman further, through asking a few pertinent questions:

2. From what institution does Mr. Sutton claim to have an earned PhD? (Inquiring minds should be prepared to ask, at the same time, the P.O. Box in the UK this institution uses as its classroom, administrative and library facility).

3. What might have been the topic of the day last November when Mr. Sutton had a personal audience with Pope Benedict XVI?

4. In 1964, the membership of the Reformed Episcopal Church was listed as 7007 with 66 churches; in 2008, it listed 125 congregations but only 6040 members. Is this what Mr. Sutton means by resurgence?
 
5. Which of the following interesting statements was written by Mr. Sutton?
 
a) For the non-Christian, mysticism is that which is comprehensible in the universe. If this is true, then mystery is something that can be manipulated in the form of knowledge, liturgy, experience and so forth.
 
b) But, today, our Churches are filled with "pampered" individuals who are the product of too much direct attention. They float from Church to Church trying to find someone who will give his/her life for him.
 
c) Does this mean that man cannot have personal transcendence? No, the Psalmist says, “1 said, you are gods, and all of you are sons of the Most High” (Psalm 82:6; John 10:34). In the words of Athanasius, the early Church Father and great defender of Trinitarianism, “God became man that man might become god.”
 
d) "Protestantism has failed to give the world a better Church."
 
e) Man is the son of God in a covenantal sense. He can be called a “god,” little g, without taking on Deity. This is not double talk, rather, it is covenantal talk.
 
f) All of the above
 
6. Who does Mr. Sutton think was responsible for the REC’s new “historical consciousness?”
 
7. What resurgence did the Theological Seminary of the Reformed Episcopal Church experience during the years it was under Mr. Sutton’s leadership?  Give a year by year record of full time students during your tenure.   Also, provide the same for the years 2000-2013, year by year.
 
8. Did Mr. (bp.) Roy Grote tell Mr. Sutton to scrub any and/or all internet references to Mr. Sutton's online articles about Reconstructionism and related subjects? If so, what articles, references, and connections? When and why? Explain the history.
 
9. What is Mr. Sutton's view of Federal Vision? Explain your relationship to the Shepherd controversy including views held amongst the Theonomists at Westminster Presbyterian Church, Tyler, TX.
 
10. Please explain your church affiliation while at Dallas Theological Seminary including your views of premillenial dispensationalism.  Explain the theo-exegetico-historical circumstances of switching to postmillenialism.
 
11. Explain your call and time at Westminster Presbyterian Church, Tyler, TX and relationships with Rousas Rushdoony, Gary North, James Jordan and the elders?  Why did you leave?  Are you still a theonomist? Was this authoritarianism a personal and tempermental tendency or did you have long-term and genuine theological convictions about reconstructionism? 
 
12. Explain in full the history, circumstances and relationships to Dr. Daniel Dunlap?  Was Dr. Daniel Dunlap also an ex-Theonomist like yourself? Dr. Milton Fisher? Dr. Allen Guelzo?  Dr. Geoffrey Hubler? Rev. Niel Bech? And other faculty members or administrative staff at The Theological Seminary of the Reformed Episcopal Church.  What were the circumstances and reasons for leaving this seminary?
 
13. What happened to the study centre in Arkansas?  Does it still exist?  If not, why not?
 
14. Fully explain your relationship with Mr. (bp.) Walter Grunsdorf of the Anglican Province of America as well as other Anglo-Catholic individuals, churches and/or institutions. Include circumstances, times and places, including their views and your views on seven sacraments, purgatory, invocation of saints, prayers for the dead, Mariology, missals and breviaries, rosary beads, incense, icons, Massing vestments, Masses, Masses for the dead, seven councils, episcopacy as a divine institution or human institution, the anti-Reformation perspective, Tract XC, Tractarianism, John Newman, the Lady of Walsingham, legitimacy of Protestant (Lutheran, Presbyterian) ordinations, the Society of the Holy Cross, Confraternity of the Blessed Sacrament, justification by faith alone, sola scriptura, sola fide, solus Christus, Capernaitic-corporal-fleshly presence of the Ascended Redeemer in the Communion, free will, predestination, covenant theology, Arminianism and semi-Pelagianism, and the Thirty-nine Articles of the Church of England, Irish Articles of 1615, and the Westminster Confession of Faith.
 
15.  Did Baptists or Bible Church Pastors ordain you?  Provide the names of Baptist Pastors who ordained you as well as the time and circumstances. Following that, what Presbytery examined you?  If a Presbytery, provide the name of the denomination and presbytery (we understand it was not the ARP, PCA, RPCGA, URC, URCNA, CRC or the OPC).
 
16.  Explain the circumstances when you, Mr. Sutton, changed your views from the Baptist version of "believers' immersionistic baptism" to "infant baptism."  Provide names, dates and influences in your thinking.

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

There's Another Reformed Anglican...Unbelievable!

Unbelievable, there really is—actually, there really is—another Reformed Anglican in America!  Reading this joyful post is like watching children grow up!  A few are beginning to mature and grow-up, no thanks to their Bishops it must be added.  No thanks to their seminaries.  Time for Bob Duncan, an ACNA cleric and Archbishop, to grow up and get a profound Reformed theological vision without the charismatic revivalists and without the anti-Reformed Tractarians.  But, Bob doesn’t have the depth or cajones to see beyond his significant limitations—and they are, indeed, serious.  Also, time for David Virtue, the alleged voice for "Orthodox Anglicanism" (www.virtueonline.org) to get off the dime and "get with the program."  He, like RA, rails against the braying asses in liberalism.  Fair enough.  We do too.  We've been in that war for 100 years, Virtue, thanks to Professor J. Gresham Machen. Old school Westminsterians have been in the long battle for decades. But, liberalism is an old story and it is time for American Anglicans to--sorta like--grow up. Additionally, it's time to push the Tractarians to where they belong...in the Continuum, not in Reformed and Reformational Anglicanism.  But, we have men with marshmellow stones.  It's time for Virtue to take the measure of his pitifully small gonads, get a theology, move on, get some Confessional depth and take some public and journalistic stands.  Perhaps, Jim Packer's anticipated Systematic Theology will lay down some territorial boundaries, like male dogs with lifted legs, justifiably, marking their territories.  Jim would be more polite.  Most others would prefer more dignified language. We apologize to the Brits and Canadians.  As an ex-Canadian, I understand the culture of compassion, politeness and dignity.  As for American mutants, phoohey onit.  More largely, screw it.  We're Marines and we're tired of the fudging weakness with the controlling and governing "wimp factor." Speaking of Tractarians, Jim's track record with Tractarians has been woefully weak.  The same for the ACNA and AMiA.  Own it, fellas, if ya' can.   Or, the charismatic Arminians with hothouse music. You're weak and disabled.  Admit it.  Get a pair and fix it. Get in a 12-step program and work the program with the first step, admitting you've been in deep denial and are helpless.  But this much, with the post below, we are thankful for even "this" small offering at Treading Grain. There really is a Calvinistic and Reformed Anglican.  There are few, but they exist.  Rev. Dr. Lee Gatiss at Peterhouse, Cambridge is another Reformed Prayer Book man.  There are few. We live in exile, but with faith, hope, learning and trust in His Dreaded Majesty. (The Reformed Episcopalians once were Reformed, but they've sold out and sponsor "babbling charismatics," saints-invokers, bloviating Tractarians like the APA-hustlers, along with repudiations of their heritage and the English Reformation, notwithstanding contrary protestations...they tolerate Tractarians.  Informed observers see it too. Give the salute to the honour-seeking Presiding REC Bishop, Leonard Riches, and the ever-changing chamelon (Fundamentalist, Dispensationalist, Presbyterian, Theonomist, Reconstructionist, Federal Visionist, Reformed Episcopalian, and now...drum roll...Pro-Tractarian all within one lifetime), Ray Sutton, both ever seeking a place at the bigger table, the lust for respectability rather than doctrinal fidelity.  Own it Riches.  Own it Sutton.  You're flip-floppers, especially you, Riches.  Dr. Rudolph's view of you, Riches? Dr. Herter's thoughts on you, Riches?  Dr. Fisher's thoughts on you Riches?  Dr. Guelzo's thoughts on you, Riches?  Doctored men with world class doctorates with dim views of you, your meager MDiv.  Or, Dr. Geoff Hubler's (D.Phil, Oxford) view on you, Riches?  Dr. Hubler has very, very dim views of you, Riches. Or, my Marine-view of you Riches? Weak men in pursuit of respectability and as a function of deep-seated inferiority complexes and lack of confidence in the Reformed faith.  You get no respect because you've dissipated your capital and you tossed the heritage.)  Although Treading Grain is "one" Calvinistic Anglican, it is probably too much to hope that the Muddling American Anglicans might recover their genuine roots, the English Reformers. Well, alas, at least there is one Reformed Anglican, a small and great comfort.  The "exile" is lonely.


5 Myths About Reformed Theology

Michael Horton has a nice article over at The Resurgence addressing common myths about Reformed theology. It was a nice summary of his book, For Calvinism, which I am just finishing and recommend wholeheartedly. The readers of this blog will know that I believe the truest and best expression of Anglicanism, which comes to us from our Reformers, is a Reformed Anglicanism.

Horton opens his article noting the irony that can attend Reformed theology.  He writes:

Calvinists can be pains in the neck. I should know—I’ve been one myself on occasion. Yet, it is a terrific irony that a theology that so exalts God and lays human beings low before his majesty and grace should be championed sometimes with a spirit that contradicts it.
He continues by laying out five common misperceptions about Reformed theology:

·         Reformed theology is arrogant and prideful.
·         Reformed theology makes us robots in God’s plan.
·         Reformed theology has no grace and love.
·         Reformed theology kills genuine, heart-felt piety.
·         Reformed theology kills community and mission.

Ouch.

So, how does Horton answer these critiques? Read the article. Or, better yet, buy the book.

Tuesday, November 22, 2011

REC? Church Soc? Calvinistic Anglicans? USA?

D. Philip Veitch (reformationtoday@yahoo.com)
CC:  reformationtoday@yahoo.com; protestantallianceofconfessingevangelicals@yahoogroups.com; aocanglican@yahoogroups.com; director@churchsociety.org; englishchurchman@aol.com; aguelzo@gettysburg.edu; dpmprompt@aol.com; cranmer1959@gmail.com; 
<><> <><> <><> <><> <><>
Subj:   RES/REC/Church Soc
Gillis: 

As an historian, I appreciate your historical effort vis a vis the Church Society. But REC? Am an 87' grad of RES with an 81' degree from WTS and additional grad credits in classics (languages) and Roman theology (Villanova). Very leary of anything connected to the current REC leadership...across the top. Why not AOC?
Thanks, but massive trust issues with the REC. In fact, the current Bishops are a great and weighty argument against episcopacy and in favour of Presbyterianism. Leo the Capitulator? Ray the accomodator of APA? Dan, permitting Marian invocations? Roy in Houston?
An old Calvinist with an old BCP, but in exile. Re: REC big time Caveat Emptor.
Regards,
Don