Reformed Churchmen
We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879
Tuesday, June 17, 2014
17 June 1837 A.D. Old School Presbyterians Prepare to Act
Saturday, October 6, 2012
"Creedal Imperative" by Dr. Carl Trueman
http://reformedforum.org/podcasts/ctc248/?utm_source=Reformed+Forum+General&utm_campaign=ac044246f7-2012_10_Newsletter&utm_medium=email
Creeds and Confessions in the Contemporary Church
Participants: Camden Bucey, Carl Trueman, Jared Oliphint
Monday, July 30, 2012
Dr. Darryl Hart: "Almost All Old Princeton All the Time"
![]() |
| Princeton Seminary |
Wednesday, July 11, 2012
Dr. R. Scott Clark: "Drawing the Line: Why Doctrine Matters"
http://www.ligonier.org/learn/articles/drawing-the-line-why-doctrine-matters/
Thursday, June 28, 2012
There He Goes Again: Dr. Carl Trueman's "What in a Name?"
“There He Goes Again,”
a title that summarizes our thoughts on Carl’s post at the Bapyterian blog, www.reformation21.org, an affair under
Ligon Duncan and an outfit that largely hosts Anabaptists on its board. (And yes, Carl, given your petulance on the point, I'm an old Canadian aware of courtesy protocols, am older than you, and have enough educational, military, command and executive experience to call you "Carl," if reading this.) Carl is essentially a broad-based British
evangelical who matured into a later commitment to the Westminster standards. Carl was not reared in the old standards of
catechesis, let alone Prayer Book Churchmanship. While he’s reportedly solid
in 16th-17th century Reformation history, his
oft-expressed opinions on current issues are frequently “chips on his shoulder”
that lack weight or merit. Hence, “There
He Goes Again.” But, we won't being losing sleep over this incompetent opinion ceding the ground to non-Confessional Baptyerians (WTS-P, ACE, Ref21) and American Anabaptists (T4G, YRR, inter alia).'Reformed' as a term has expanded its meaning over the years to the point where it is no longer a given. In the context of the Gospel Coalition (perhaps a bellwether for the contemporary evangelical scene), it seems to mean something akin to 'broadly Calvinistic in soteriology'. Thus, adherence to all or a subset of the Five Points of Calvinism qualifies one as Reformed. Used in this way, it includes Baptists and Charismatics.Some object strongly to this. I cannot summon any emotional energy to combat it: it seems to me that as long as one knows the term is being used somewhat equivocally, no real harm is done.
More narrowly, it is sometimes used to refer to those who hold to more traditional forms of worship and polity. Thus, one can have Reformed Baptists as well as Reformed Presbyterians. (I am guessing that groups such as Acts 29 would not typically call themselves 'Reformed Baptists' even though broadly Calvinistic in theology and baptistic in practice.)
More narrowly still, it is used to refer to those who hold either to the Westminster Standards or the Three Forms of Unity as their confessional documents. Finally, for the real ecclesiology geeks out there, it is sometimes used to distinguish even within this group to refer to those who hold to the Three Forms and to continental polity, as opposed to Presbyterianism.
Bottom line: the term as used in Gospel Coalition/T4G circles is really used in a somewhat equivocal way, a manner disconnected from covenant baptism and Reformed polity. This is of no real significance except when those using the term do not realise that it can be used in varying ways. If one were to assume that the word can only be used univocally then one might be tempted to relativise, say, the differences between Mars Hill in Seattle and your typical OPC or PCA congregation, seeing them as of minimal significance or simply matters of taste.
'Reformed' in current popular parlance is somewhat like 'confessional.' I keep meeting 'confessional evangelicals' who do not actually adhere, other than at a notional level, to any of the great historic ecclesiastical confessions. They seem to be using the adjective as a substitute for 'conservative' or 'orthodox', which is fine -- as long as (once again) it does not then lead to blurring the significant difference between being orthodox in belief and being confessional in practice. Being confessional in the traditional, ecclesiastical sense, has profound practical significance for how one operates at the level of the church; it does not simply express a set of ideas to which one is intellectually committed, with no direct implications for church governance etc. Further, as I have said before, a true return to the confessions of the Protestant church will inevitably involve a return to the divisions which those confessions enshrined and which were in fact often the very reason for their production: fundamental disagreements among Protestants over sacraments and ecclesiology. The current confessional evangelical movement seems to default, in practice, to baptist independency -- which brings us back to the point being made by Dr. Bradley.
So the eclipse of Presbyterians in the evangelical world's adoption of the term 'Reformed' is probably in large part a function of the transformation of the term's meaning by the contemporary evangelical scene. This is not something I myself will lose any sleep over.
Tuesday, May 15, 2012
Update: Anglican Church of Ireland Reaffirms Traditional Marriage
Rev.Dr. Alan McCann: Calls for Repentance by Irish Dean and Bishops in Church of Ireland” at:
By Alan McCann in Dublin
Special to virtueonline
www.virtueonline.org
May 14, 2012
Just to let you know that the motion was passed today. All of the amendments, four in total, were defeated by a 2:1 ratio in the house of laity and house of clergy.e motion itself was passed 3:1 in the house of laity and 80 in favour, 60 against in the house of clergy.
When the Bishops voted it was 10:2 in favour of the motion, with the Bishop of Cork and Bishop of Cashel and Ossory voting against the motion.
On the whole the debate was respectful, courteous and not without some humour on occasions.
Personally, the most powerful speech of the day came from one of our ecumenical guests, Father Ireanaeus du Plessiis.
He spoke from a deep personal faith and conviction, with great courage warned the General Synod against acting unilateral and changing the doctrine of marriage which the church catholic has held to for nearly 2000 years.
He gently but firmly spoke about his own Antiochian Church and how for them the matter of human sexuality was settled nearly 2000 years ago by the Church catholic - that marriage is between one man and one woman and outside of this all were to remain celibate.
He lovingly spoke of 'holy space' and not just the 'safe place' that the motion mentioned. He also reminded those present, and especially the clergy, that we were to be holy because God is Holy.
In my heart I wished we had such leadership speaking with such conviction, clarity and courage before a general synod. God used this man in a powerful way today.
The passing of the motion was received in respectful silence, as requested by the Archbishop if Armagh. He had chaired this part of synod with fairness and allowed a long time for people to put their viewpoints.
It was disappointing and to be honest hurtful to then read what can only be described as a vitriolic diatribe on certain liberal and pro-gay blogs immediately the vote was announced.
However, that came as no surprise as members of Changing Attitude Ireland, who attended as visitors, stood at the back of the synod hall during the vote.
Personally it did not intimidate or annoy me to have to walk past these individuals to go into the voting lobby but I know some synod members did feel it was intimidating to have to do so.
Thankfully, the Church of Ireland synod has restated this is what the Church teaches concerning marriage and the 'only normative place for sexual intercourse.'
Thankfully it has also condemned language and actions that bring hurt, shame and fear into the lives of others (irrespective of sexuality).
It has committed the Standing Committee of the General Synod to bring before Synod next year proposals for a Select Committee and its terms of reference.
I for one am not gloating over the passing of this motion. It pains me to belong to a Church which at one point appeared to be unclear as to what it actually has taught and does teach about marriage.
It pains me that some people would want to move away from God's revealed will for mankind in the area of human sexuality but I am encouraged by the actions of General Synod today.
The result of the vote has been a tirade of negative comments from the pro-gay lobby both inside the Church of Ireland and further afield.
On BBC Radio Ulster's Sunday Sequence the chairwoman of Changing Attitudes Ireland, Canon Ginnie Kennerly, even complained that members of synod stayed on the third day of synod to vote.
Imagine, complaining that people actually turned up, as they were elected to do, for the last day of synod and exercised their democratic right to vote. It would appear you are only allowed to turn up on the last day if you vote in a certain way.
This motion doesn't actually change anything in the Church of Ireland as it simply restates the teaching of the Church. However, it does restate the standard against which teaching and practice is to be measured. The liberal revisionist pro-gay lobby are already seeking to demonise those who voted for this motion and who adhere to the teaching of canon 31, and the prayer book on marriage, as those determined to go on a 'witch hunt' for gays within the Church of Ireland.
Such propagating of untruth has come as no surprise to many who have had to live with this for years from the pro-gay lobby. It falls into line with the pre-synod lied that no gay people were invited to the Cavan Conference.
Changing Attitude Ireland were invited to put forward a speaker for the conference and they (the seemingly inclusive group) put forward their chairperson, Cannon Kennerly, and then complained that no gay people were speaking - despite the fact that two of the keynote speakers identified themselves as homosexuals.
It would be good if in the listening process that the truth was actually spoken and half-truths and outright lies were not pedalled. It would appear that certain members of the pro-gay lobby believe spin = truth.
END
Mindless Churches & Youths: "Generational Blackmail?"
Well, young people don’t like doing
research, writing papers or doing careful thinking either, but the College
Profs insist otherwise—hat tip and salute to the Professors. I took an English literature course last
semester. Without missing a beat, the
Teacher “imposed” Shakespeare on us with all the old language. She didn't ask if we liked the old English. We had no choice. No one complained either, but all were
edified.
many clerics are supportive. Reformation Anglicanism believes a war on the quest for
continued ignorance and illiteracy must be waged. We recommend this audit to our
"good old Book of Common Prayer," to wit: "Pastor/Rector: `Luni et stulti omnes
sunt.' Congregation: `Et semper illiterati.'" Thank God for good Pastors and Teachers
who did not and are not accomodating the quest for ignorance, generally, Confessional
Churchmen.
This is a good question from For Clavigera. See: http://forsclavigera.blogspot.com/2012/05/generational-blackmail.html
Generational Blackmail?
And what exactly are we supposed to do with these claims? I think the upshot is pretty clear. Indeed, am I the only one who feels like they're a sort of bargaining chip--a kind of emotional blackmail meant to get the church to relax its commitments in order to make the church more acceptable?
Could we entertain the possibility that millennials might be wrong?
Sociology and Theology of Family: Family Upheaval & Theological Decline
By Peter Smith
THE COURIER-JOURNAL
http://www.blogs.courier-journal.com/
May 14, 2012
My story here looks at how churches are coping with a half-century of revolutionary change in Americans' family structures and sex lives. Nearly half of adults are now single, and the never-married and divorced as groups are less likely to attend church than married people. Many are divorced, cohabiting and/or unwed parents, their very presence posing a challenge to traditional church morals. Every church leader I spoke with said they'd rather bring out the welcome mats than the scarlet letters.
This conciliatory approach contrasts with the judgmentalism that churches showed more when they represented the establishment - and that doubtless many show today.
But here's another angle to consider: the family and sexual revolutions didn't happen in a vacuum. They were aided in part by religion's declining influence, and in turn hastened that decline.
According to author and journalist James Haught, the crumbling of sexual and other taboos is one of the surest signs that the United States is belatedly following Europe and other industrialized nations into a post-religious era.
In his book, "Fading Faith: The Rise of the Secular Age," Haught cites the growing lack of religious identity among young adults, the steep decline in liberal Protestant denominations and an exodus from the Catholic Church.
And this, from an essay based on the book in the Charleston, W.Va., Gazette, where he is editor:
"A half-century ago, church-backed laws had power in America. In the 1950s, it was a crime to look at the equivalent of a Playboy magazine or R-rated movie - or for stores to open on the Sabbath - or to buy a cocktail or lottery ticket - or to sell birth-control devices in some states - or to be homosexual - or to terminate a pregnancy - or to read a sexy novel - or for an unwed couple to share a bedroom. Now all those morality laws have fallen, one after another. Currently, state after state is legalizing gay marriage, despite church outrage."
A different world indeed. But did these social lurches cause the religious decline, result from it, or some combination of both?
Survey after survey is confirming the "creeping secularism" in the nation, in the words of "American Grace" authors Robert Putnam and David Campbell. This trend is driven by the youngest adults who are increasingly rejecting the religions of their elders (often retaining some type of spirituality, but without signing on to particular dogma or religious tribal identity). Just between 2006 and 2011, they wrote, growing minorities of adults and particularly young adults are more likely to disbelieve in God, avoid religious services, consider sex outside of marriage to be OK, support gay marriage and believe in evolution without divine involvement.
So is America becoming more like secular Europe? Not so fast, the authors said. "Given the entrepreneurial dynamism of American religion, it seems likely that America's religious leaders will respond to the secular shift and seek to bring the disaffected back to religion." One way they're doing so already is by easing up on the politics that have alienated many from religion.
It's also worth noting that Putnam's, Campbell's and other studies show that religion is fading fastest among the less-educated and the struggling classes. For whatever reason, religion is holding on the strongest among the better-off. People used to say that America had the religious diversity of South Asia in the grassroots but almost no faith among the elites in college towns, Hollywood, New York and Washington. So the old joke was that we were a nation of Indians ruled by Swedes. Are we now becoming a nation of Swedes ruled by Indians?
END









