Reformed Churchmen

We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879

Showing posts with label Sola Gratia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sola Gratia. Show all posts

Thursday, July 18, 2013

Roman, Greek, Tractarian & Arminian Edits of Rom.3.21-31


Here's what the Messieurs, men of adiaphora, in the ACNA, refuse to address. They self-identify as Anglican, but have--to be polite--a "low" theology.
 
In fact, their silence on these matters is complicity with Rome, Constantinople and Arminian soteriological centres.
 
Ergo, we bring you the following: "Roman, Greek, Semi-Pelagian and Arminian Edits to St. Paul."

These sober and deliberative editors thought St. Paul needed their editorial and theological insights.  This is reflected in the Council of Trent, subsequent theologians, and documents.
 
We bring these much-needed corrections to the canonical text to you, that is, Romans 3.21-31... corrected, amended and taught world-wide. This will aid St. Paul "above" (if he had enough good works) and those of us "below."

(God’s Righteousness Through Faith and Works)


 21 But now the righteousness of God including the law is revealed, being witnessed by the Law and the Prophets, 22 even the righteousness of God, through faith in Jesus Christ as well as all your meritorious good works, pieties and deeds, to all and on all who believe in Jesus and work hard as well. For there is no difference; 23 for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, 24 being justified at a contributory cost (among other contributory causes) by His grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus including the treasury of the saints (whom you should invoke for help, especially Mary), 25 whom God set forth as a propitiation by His blood, through faith but also your good works as meritorious instruments, to demonstrate His and your righteousness (it’s cooperative), because in His forbearance God had passed over the sins that were previously committed, 26 to demonstrate at the present time His and your righteousness, that He might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus and who has meritorious works too. Never forget this; those Lutheran, Reformed and old school Anglican Protestants are screwballs.

 (Boasting Included)

27 Where is boasting then? It’s right here. It is included. By what law? Of works? Why of course! Yes, boasting is by the law of faith and the law of good works, including “tweets-for-reductions in purgo-time.” So, go ahead, boast and exalt yourself and other saints too.  "You deserve some of the credit, after all." Ask Joel Osteen, he's got it about right. 28 Therefore we conclude, again, we conclude definitively that a man is justified by faith and the deeds of the law. 29 Or is He the God of the Jews only? No, but He is also the God of the Gentiles? Yes, of the Gentiles also, 30 since there is one God who will justify the circumcised by faith and the uncircumcised through faith. 31 Do we then make void the law through faith? Certainly not! On the contrary, we establish the law. One is justified by "faith in Christ and his or her works." So, get’a’ crackin.’

Wednesday, April 10, 2013

Rev. Roger Salter (Ch. of England): Summing Up the Solas

http://www.virtueonline.org/portal/modules/news/article.php?storyid=17415

Posted by David Virtue on 2013/4/10 10:30:00 (122 reads)
SUMMING UP THE SOLAS

By Roger Salter
Special to Virtueonline
www.virtueonline.org
April 10, 2013

The current fascination for evangelicals with Rome may be a token of respectful, and hopeful ecumenism, and it may be an education in those truths we hold mutually in the creeds and the writings of certain saints under the aegis of Rome. But it is too much to concede that for all of us Rome should be home. Some Protestants have been denied what they suppose to be available in Rome - reverence, certainty, sacramental observance, rich piety and devotion, historical continuity and authority.

Rome makes claims as to providing these missing elements in popular Protestantism but with many attendant Scriptural and historical flaws of its own in the admixture. Protestantism, too, has its flaws and has slipped away from its original moorings and spiritual maturity. Its historical perspective is largely lacking, its doctrine is diluted, and its piety is casual. What is more, in many of its expressions, its ecclesiology is almost non-existent, merely narrowly local and heavily individualistic. Rome is not our home and we shall see that if once again we reclaim our original Scriptural heritage. Speaking for Anglicanism, and with high regard for other Biblical traditions, we have a tradition that is Reformed and Catholic, and in the face of confident claims made by emigrants to Rome on behalf of their choice, one dares to say, for the sake of honesty and clarity, that John Jewel was correct in saying that Anglicanism's Catholicism is purer than Rome's.

The Reformational "solas" do not exist alone, or function in total isolation, they are instrumentalities ordained and employed by God that are sufficient in themselves for their purpose - the actualization of his method of grace. The "solas" are the sole means of our deliverance from sin and our restoration to God, but they are connected to the effects of divine goodness and power in action i.e. Scripture to exposition, faith to love, grace to good works. The redemptive measures taken by God are accompanied by their results. You cannot separate origin from outcome, root from fruit, fountain from flow in God's work of salvation.

It is an obvious matter of the unity of cause and effect. God is the cause and believers are compliant with his goodness at work in them. The Bible speaks and we are graciously enabled to hear. Salvation is wrought and we are enabled to trust. Grace is given and we are enabled to obey. Understanding, faith, and works accompany all the phases of divine action in our lives. As recipients of mercy believers are moved to respond appropriately to heavenly impulses as they occur. God initiates and Christians follow. Believers rely on the solas but they react concurrently. Grace enlivens thus authenticating itself.

The love of Scripture, the love of God, the love of neighbour, the love of righteousness are the evidences of grace communicated through the "solas". To maintain the distinction between cause and effect Protestants avoid the mixture of inspired Scripture and human tradition, justification and sanctification, grace and works. Whatever links may exist in respect of these must be in the nature of cause and effect. The saving efficacy is in the cause. The effects validate the cause. God blesses and man manifests the blessing. The solas work alone but they are not alone. They are twinned with what they create, namely belief, new status, holiness in the lives they touch.

Scripture Alone

Scripture is the written record of God's speech, his Word for us. Scripture alone speaks with divine authority and it is meant to be studied and expounded. The term Scripture alone means that the truth we hold, confess and disseminate must be derived from the sacred writings. Scripture generates preaching, commentary, and explanatory writings, but Scripture alone is to be the infallible source of all truth concerning salvation through Christ. God's Word alone is perfect and through the assistance and influences of the Holy Spirit the faithful approximations of men to Scripture in their teachings from the Bible are effective in bringing souls to Christ.

The Bible is our sufficient guide along the path to life in Christ to be enjoyed here and in eternity. There is sufficient clarity to lead us to salvation and infinite profundity to keep us humble and ever learning. Someone has opined that the Word of God is like a pool, safe enough for a little child to paddle in and deep enough to drown an elephant. The basic message is simple and the attendant insights supplied by the Bible's guided authors challenge the mind and confound the intellect. We are all mere students and never masters. The tradition we embrace is the content of Scripture and the human comment consonant with it, and we employ our Spirit-controlled reason to discern the connection. It is naïve to assert that Protestants are prisoners of a book. We are magnetized by the message. For us now the Book is the source and preserver.

Faith Alone

What are we to make of two seemingly contradictory apostolic positions in Scripture? Paul: "If, in fact, Abraham was justified by works he had something to boast about - but not before God. What does the Scripture say? 'Abraham believed God, and it was credited to him as righteousness.' " Romans 4:2. "Consider Abraham: 'He believed God, and it was credited to him as righteousness.' " Galatians 3:6. James writes: "You see that a person is justified by what he does and not by faith alone" James 2: 24.

Are we to choose which apostle we shall honor by our theological bias, or preference for either of them as persons? Paul's position is skillfully expounded by highly competent Evangelicals and Rome is staunchly in favor of James. Each solves the difficulty of avoiding contradiction in Scripture by a different rationale.

Catholics contend that Paul is referring to the Mosaic law (but in which sense) and that James is commending works of charity that accrue to our merit and complete our justification. Evangelicals believe that Mosaic law is not legalistic obligation that clashes with the principle of charity but the moral law established by and expressive of love to God and which enjoins love for neighbor. The law, therefore, is fatherly wisdom for the good life, the congenial standard for that which is right according to the will of God, and that man, since the fall, has no capacity to conform to the law. As both apostles use Abraham as their example of the justified man it may be significant that neither of them has the Mosaic dispensation specifically in mind - certainly not ritual or ceremonial law specific to Israel after the exodus. Abraham represents universal sinful man who has breached the law of love and cannot justify himself in any way. Righteousness before God is the state of being just. Paul is adamant that Abraham, unjust through sin, is justified - made just, put right with God - by faith. He has been granted the righteousness of God conveyed to his possession through faith and that is the righteousness which justifies him freely and perfectly. If Abraham was required to add something of his own to that righteousness then grace would cease to be grace, and justification is by grace, "And if by grace, then it is no longer by works; if it were grace would no longer be grace" (Romans 11:6). It would be unpardonably audacious to even suggest that Christ's righteousness were not sufficient to justify the sinner that places his confidence in it. "He entered the Most Holy Place once for all by his own blood, having obtained eternal redemption. . . How much more, then, will the blood of Christ, who through the eternal Spirit offered himself unblemished to God, cleanse our consciences from acts that lead to death, so that we may serve the living God." (Hebrews 9:11,14). Is it not his sacrifice that procures our justification? And is it not more than sufficient? It is in this passage and like passages cited from Paul that we find the alone that Romanism cannot seem to detect. It doesn't have to be a word; it is a necessary concept. And what is more, James does not conflict with it. He is examining the genuineness of professed faith.

Both apostles speak in highly ethical terms, but James is characteristically practical, dealing with concrete issues that he has observed closely. Both men preach principle but James notes more overtly the problems that arise in community life and is corrective of abuses on a wide scale. He sees the rich honored and the poor despised. He wrestles with his brethren in temptation. He notes the suffering ones and sympathizes with the sick. He walks with those who have a dead faith. What good is it, my brothers if a man (perhaps one of us) claims to have faith but has no deeds? Can such a faith save him? James is opening up a discussion on faith and a comparison between true and false faith. The faith that justifies is accompanied by love. The works engendered by love are proof of the sincerity of faith.

For Abraham the declaration of justness occurred when he believed God's promise (Genesis 15:6). His subsequent life of obedience came conspicuously to the fore, "when he offered his son Isaac on the altar" (Genesis 22). Justifying faith is faith that instantly loves and works. It is proof of regeneration and it is faith that is alive in yielding fruit. Martin Luther addresses the question, " 'Doesn't faith justify and save us without works?' Yes, that's true. But where's your faith? How does it show itself? Faith must never be useless, deaf, dead, or in a state of decay. But it must be a living tree that bursts forth with fruit. That's the difference between genuine faith and false faith. Where there is true faith, it will show itself in a person's life" (Faith Alone: A Daily Devotional, Zondervan, Grand Rapids, 2005). The Reformation did care about holiness and discipleship. Sanctification and service were its goals.

We must be cognizant of the association of faith and works without confusing the two. Faith is more than assent to certain truths. It is a relationship with God that produces God-like action. Faith, under the spell of divine affection, issues in obedience. If it did not it is mere pretence, something feigned. God's love activates faith which is the conscious appreciation of his love in Christ that saves us. James is not addressing real faith but "non-faith", a profession devoid of the power of love, a notion about grace without the experience, theological orthodoxy without orthopraxy. Paul believed in fruits as much as James, but the fruit is consequent upon salvation and not contributory to it. We must look in depth at the meaning of the gospel - that it is life and not mere opinion. Faith is active and not mere academic abstraction and intellectual toying with the truth of God. That only ties us in with the faith of demons and is not saving. When we encounter James and Paul and ask them to stand together we do not find contradiction but congruity as G.C. Berkouwer observes: "On one side we are warned against religious self-confidence, on the other against a faith which is not really directed to God's grace in Jesus Christ, and is and remains dead" (Faith and Justification, Eerdmans, Grand rapids, Michigan, 1954).

George Whitfield's convert and colleague R. Elliot sums everything up so beautifully in his description of the great evangelist's understanding of justification. "The doctrine of justification by faith in Christ, he diligently and constantly taught: but he held faith not as our justifying righteousness, but only as the instrument of our justification, which some that profess to teach the same doctrine absolutely deny: we are justified, said Mr. Whitefield, three ways, viz.: (1) Meritoriously by the blood of Christ; (2) Instrumentally by the faith of Christ; and (3) declaratively by our good works. And when speaking of being justified by faith, he would always direct the sinner to Christ's blood and righteousness as the only proper procuring cause of his justification". Refer to Hebrews 9: 11 &14 quoted above.

Grace Alone

In terms of prominence "grace alone" is the thunderous proclamation of Scripture. In terms of divine comfort and love it is Scripture's sweetest refrain that soothes and delights the awakened offender. The logic of justification leads us inevitably to the conclusion that salvation is entirely through electing love which is the sovereign expression of grace. We are chosen to salvation not self-appointed. The choice is unconditional not on the basis of anything present or foreseen in the believer. From whence would come our suitability for God's approval? What in our nature would desire him before the receiving of enabling grace? If that capacity were given to all as an equalizer why do some tilt to faith and others do not? Is grace distinguishing or do some have a talent within themselves to make a good choice and that quality distinguishes them. Better it is to settle for Paul's reply, "I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy" (Romans 9:15).

Can we not settle for the word of God without disputing it?

Whitefield's friend, Elliot, guides us here in referring to possibly the world's greatest evangelist, "Mr. Whitefield taught concerning the new birth, that man by nature has no power or will at all to come to God and save himself. It is indeed manifestly absurd, and it implies a contradiction, to suppose that a man can be the cause of his own existence; or that he has power to change his present fallen condition, when it implies a change of his heart and will, and comprehends in it a new creation. Therefore man has no power or will at all to effect his own conversion, it being the entire work of God's Spirit".

Well might we heed the testimony of John the apostle: "Flesh gives birth to flesh, but the Spirit gives birth to spirit" (John 3: 6). We as individuals make no contribution to either event as regards ourselves. But we might as sinners say that we resist the latter until the Spirit exerts his power in sovereign mercy (John 1:12-13). Scripture is prized with all our heart because it tells us as habitual and helpless lawbreakers that Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believes (Romans 10:4). Faith is the precious gift that is granted to us in order to claim Christ as our righteousness without worth or works (Ephesians 2:8). Grace is the power and favor of God that places us in Christ. It is because of him that you are in Christ Jesus (1 Corinthians 1:30).

It is wonderful as to how grace demolishes our pride, self-reliance, and sense of prestige and trains our eye upon Christ alone so that we ascribe our rescue and restoration by grace alone to the glory of God alone. And that is how the renewed soul prefers to see it and that is why Protestantism must say it in the solas of the Sixteenth Century Reformation.


The Rev. Roger Salter is an ordained Church of England minister where he had parishes in the dioceses of Bristol and Portsmouth before coming to Birmingham, Alabama to serve as Rector of St. Matthew's Anglican Church.

Friday, March 16, 2012

Trueman: Warfield on the Essence of Christianity and the Book of Common Prayer

What Dr. Carl Trueman cites here from B.B. Warfield is precisely what is taught, believed, and delivered in the old 1662 Book of Common Prayer. While Warfield has spoken ably, as per the quote below and as offered by Carl Trueman, there is nothing distinctive here that hasn't been believed, taught and prayed for centuries in that old Book of Common Prayer. A faithful Confessional Anglican will recognize, immediately, the sense and orientation offered by B.B. Warfield...it's Biblical Churchmanship, a point Dr. Trueman commends.  Dr. Trueman's points are offered below at:
http://www.reformation21.org/blog/2012/03/warfield-on-the-essence-of-chr.php

Warfield on the Essence of Christianity

Posted by

I gave a lecture yesterday on the life and theology of B B Warfield, focusing on his engagement with German liberalism as expressed in a number of his book reviews. His book reviews are, I suspect, the most neglected part of his published works but actually contain some of his most astute theological observations.

In the Q and A afterwards, somebody asked if the first paragraph of his first article on 'Miserable Sinner Christianity' was the most brilliant thing which he ever wrote. As usual in such situations, I could not remember the piece, something made only slightly less embarrassing by the fact that Darryl Hart, student of all things old Princeton, was unable to help me. Darryl had followed my lecture with a briliant and provocative analysis of how Princeton Seminary had been crushed by the denomination's drive to be a cultural mover-and-shaker and thus to downplay confessional distinctives for, as we would say today, a place at the table or a voice in the conversation. If it is to be published, it will be a must-read for those enamoured of a confessional evangelicalism which, despite the name, actually does not reflect the priorities, distinctives and ecclesiologies that originally drove the production of confessions in the first place.

After the lecture, I ferreted out the paragraph and here it is. Whether it is the most brilliant thing Warfield ever wrote is not for me to judge; but it is undeniably a brilliant and sobering statement of what Christianity is:

It belongs to the very essence of the type of Christianity propagated by the Reformation that the believer should feel himself continuously unworthy of the grace by which he lives. At the center of this type of Christianity lies the contrast of sin and grace; and about this center everything else revolves. This is in large part the meaning of the emphasis put in this type of Christianity on justification by faith. It is its conviction that there is nothing in us or done by us, at any stage of our earthly development, because of which we are acceptable to God. We must always be accepted for Christ's sake, or we cannot ever be accepted at all. This is not true of us only "when we believe." It is just as true after we have believed. It will continue to be true as long as we live. Our need of Christ does not cease with our believing; nor does the nature of our relation to Him or to God through Him ever alter, no matter what our attainments in Christian graces or our achievements in Christian behavior may be. It is always on His "blood and righteousness" alone that we can rest. There is never anything that we are or have or do that can take His place, or that can take a place along with Him. We are always unworthy, and all that we have or do of good is always of pure grace. Though blessed with every spiritual blessing in the heavenlies in Christ, we are still in ourselves just "miserable sinners": "miserable sinners" saved by grace to be sure, but "miserable sinners" still, deserving in ourselves nothing but everlasting wrath. That is the attitude which the Reformers took, and that is the attitude which the Protestant world has learned from the Reformers to take, toward the relation of believers to Christ.

Sunday, October 31, 2010

Reformation Essentials - Five Pillars of the Reformation

Reformation Essentials - Five Pillars of the Reformation

Reformation Essentials - Five Pillars of the Reformation

by Michael Horton
In May, 1989, a conference jointly sponsored by the National Association of Evangelicals and Trinity Evangelical Divinity School was held at the Trinity campus in Illinois. Dubbed a consultation on Evangelical Affirmations, the meeting revealed more than it settled. In the published addresses (Zondervan, 1990), Carl F. H. Henry, the dean of American evangelicalism, sets the tone for book with his opening line: "The term 'evangelical' has taken on conflicting nuances in the twentieth century. Wittingly or unwittingly, evangelical constituencies no less than their critics have contributed to this confusion and misunderstanding." He warned that "evangelical" was being understood, not according to Scriptural teaching and "the theological 'ought,'" but according to the sociological and empirical "is." In other words, Henry was disturbed that evangelicalism is increasingly being defined by its most recent trends rather than by its normative theological identity. Author after author (presumably, speaker after speaker) echoed the same fears that before long "evangelical" will be useless as any meaningful identification.

The term itself derives from the Greek word euangelion, translated "Gospel," and it became a noun when the Protestant reformers began their work of bringing the "one holy, catholic and apostolic church" back to that message by which and for which it was created. People still used other labels, too, like "Lutheran," "Reformed," and later, "Puritans," "Pietists," and "Wesleyans." Nevertheless, the belief was that the same Gospel that had united the "evangelicals" against Rome's errors could also unite them against the creeping naturalism and secularism of the Enlightenment in the eighteenth century. The so-called "Evangelical Awakening" in Britain coincided with America's own "Great Awakening," as Wesley, Whitefield, Edwards, Tennant, and so many others centered their preaching on the atonement. Later, of course, Wesley's zeal for Arminian emphases divided the work in Britain, but the Reformation emphases were clearly and unambiguously articulated in the Great Awakening.

Out of this heritage, those today who call themselves "evangelicals" (or who are in these churches, but might not know that they are in this tradition) are heirs also to the Second Great Awakening. Radically altering the "evangel" from a concern with the object of faith, the Second Great Awakening and the revivalism that emerged from it focused on the act and experience of faith, in dependence on the proper "excitements", as Finney and others expressed it, to trigger the right response. In our estimation, this Second Great Awakening was the most important seismic shift in American religious history. Although the Reformation emphases of sin and grace continued to exercise some influence, they were being constantly revised to make the "Gospel" more acceptable to those who thought they could pull themselves up by their own bootstraps.

Only in the last decade of this century have many of the movement's mainstream leaders considered the loss of an evangelical substance. No longer is the evangel the focus of the movement's identity, but it is now known more by a sub-culture, a collection of political, moral and social causes, and an acute interest in rather exotic notions about the end-times. At a loss for words, one friend answered a man's question, "Who are the evangelicals?" with the reply, "They're people who like Billy Graham."

It is at this point that those of us who are heirs to the Reformation--which bequeathed to evangelicalism a distinct theological identity that has been since lost--call attention once more to the solas (only or alone) that framed the entire sixteenth-century debate: "Only Scripture," "Only Christ," "Only Grace," "Only Faith," and "To God Alone Be Glory."

Sola Scriptura: Our Only Foundation
Many critics of the Reformation have attempted to portray it as the invitation to individualism, as people discover for themselves from the Bible what they will and will not believe. "Never mind the church. Away with creeds and the church's teaching office! We have the Bible and that's enough." But this was not the reformers' doctrine of sola Scriptura--only Scripture. Luther said of individualistic approaches to the Bible, "That would mean that each man would go to hell in his own way."

On one side, the reformers faced the Roman Church, which believed its teaching authority to be final and absolute. The Roman Catholics said that tradition can be a form of infallible revelation even in the contemporary church; one needs an infallible Bible and an infallible interpreter of that sacred book. On the other side were the Anabaptist radicals, who believed that they not only did not need the teaching office of the church; they really didn't seem to need the Bible either, since the Holy Spirit spoke to them--or at least to their leaders--directly. Instead of one Pope, Anabaptism produced numerous "infallible" messengers who heard the voice of God. Against both positions, the Reformation insisted that the Bible was the sole final authority in determining doctrine and life. In interpreting it, the whole church must be included, including the laity, and they must be guided by the teachers in the church. Those teachers, though not infallible, should have considerable interpretive authority. The creeds were binding and the newly reformed Protestant communions quickly drafted confessions of faith that received the assent of the whole church, not merely the teachers.

Today, we are faced with similar challenges even within evangelicalism. On one hand, there is the tendency to say, as Luther characterized the problem, "I go to church, hear what my priest says, and him I believe." Calvin complained to Cardinal Sadoleto that the sermons before the Reformation were part trivial pursuit, part story-telling. Today, this same process of "dumbing down" has meant that we are, in George Gallup's words, "a nation of biblical illiterates." Perhaps we have a high view of the Bible's inspiration: 80% of adult Americans believe that the Bible is the literal or inspired Word of God. But 30% of the teenagers who attend church regularly do not even know why Easter is celebrated. "The decline in Bible reading," says Gallup, "is due in part to the widely held conviction that the Bible is inaccessible, and to less emphasis on religious training in the churches." Just as Rome's infallibility rested on the belief that the Bible itself was difficult, obscure, and confusing, so today people want the "net breakdown" from the professionals: what does it mean for me and how will it help me and make me happy? But those who read the Bible for more than devotional meditations know how clear it is--at least on the main points it addresses--and how it ends up making religion less confusing and obscure. Again today, the Bible--especially in mainline Protestant churches--is a mysterious book that can only be understood by a small cadre of biblical scholars who are "in the know."

But we have the other side, too. There is a popular trend in many "evangelical" churches to emphasize direct communication with the Holy Spirit apart from the Word. In these circles, tradition and the teaching ministry of the church through the ages are not only treated as fallible (as the reformers believed), but as objects of mockery. The sentiments of Thomas Muntzer, who complained that Luther was "one of our scribes who wants to send the Holy Ghost off to college," would find a prime-time spot on the nation's leading evangelical radio and television broadcasts. Calvin said of these folks, "When the fanatics boast extravagantly of the Spirit, the tendency is always to bury the Word of God so they may make room for their own falsehoods."

Christianity is not a spirituality, but a religion. Wade Clark Roof and other sociologists have pointed out that evangelicals today are indistinguishable from the general cultural trends, especially when it comes to preferring to think of their relationship to God more in terms of an experience than in terms of a relationship that is mediated through words. Ours is a visual or image-based society, much like the Middle Ages, and yet Christianity can only flourish through words, ideas, beliefs, announcements, arguments. There can be no communication with God apart from the written and living Word. Everything in the Christian faith depends on the spoken and written Word delivered by God to us through the prophets and apostles.

Further, sola Scriptura meant that the Word of God was sufficient. Although Rome believed it was infallible, the official theology was shaped more by the insights of Plato and Aristotle than by Scripture. Similarly today, psychology threatens to reshape the understanding of the self, as even in the evangelical pulpit sin becomes "addiction"; the Fall as an event is replaced with one's "victim" status; salvation is increasingly communicated as mental health, peace of mind, and self-esteem, and my personal happiness and self-fulfillment are center-stage rather than God's holiness and mercy, justice and love, glory and compassion. Does the Bible define the human problem and its solution? Or when we really want facts, do we turn somewhere else, to a modern secular authority who will really carry weight in my sermon? Of course, the Bible will be cited to bolster the argument. Political ideology, sociology, marketing, and other secular "authorities" must never be allowed priority in answering questions the Bible addresses. That is, in part, what this affirmation means, and evangelicals today seem as confused on this point as was the medieval church.

Solus Christus: Our Only Mediator
In the Middle Ages, the minister was seen as having a special relationship with God, as he mediated God's grace and forgiveness through the sacraments. But there were other challenges. We often think of our own age as unique, with its pluralism and the advent of so many religions. But not too long before the Reformation, the Renaissance thinker Petrarch was calling for an Age of the Spirit in which all religions would be united. Many Renaissance minds were convinced that there was a saving revelation of God in nature and that, therefore, Christ was not the only way. The fascination with pagan philosophy encouraged the idea that natural religion offered a great deal--indeed, even salvation--to those who did not know Christ.

The Reformation was, more than anything else, an assault on faith in humanity, and a defense of the idea that God alone reveals Himself and saves us. We do not find Him; He finds us. That emphasis was the cause of the cry, "Christ alone!" Jesus was the only way of knowing what God is really like, the only way of entering into a relationship with Him as father instead of judge, and the only way of being saved from His wrath.

Today, once more, this affirmation is in trouble. According to University of Virginia sociologist James Hunter, 35% of evangelical seminarians deny that faith in Christ is absolutely necessary. According to George Barna, that is the same figure for conservative, evangelical Protestants in America: "God will save all good people when they die, regardless of whether they've trusted in Christ," they agreed.

Eighty-five percent of American adults believe that they will stand before God to be judged. They believe in hell, but only 11% think they might go there. R.C. Sproul observed that to the degree that people think they are good enough to pass divine inspection, and are oblivious to the holiness of God, to that extent they will not see Christ as necessary. That is why over one-fourth of the "born again" evangelicals surveyed agreed with a statement that one would think might raise red flags even for those who might agree with the same thing more subtly put: "If a person is good, or does enough good things for others during life, they will earn a place in Heaven." Furthermore, when asked whether they agreed with the following statement: "Christians, Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, and others all pray to the same God, even though they use different names for that God," two-thirds of the evangelicals didn't find that objectionable. Barna observes "how little difference there is between the responses of those who regularly attend church services and those who are unchurched." One respondent, an Independent Fundamentalist, said, "What is important in their case is that they have conformed to the law of God as they know it in their hearts."

But this cultural influence toward relativism is not only apparent in the masses; it is self-consciously asserted by some of evangelicalism's own teachers. Clark Pinnock states, "The Bible does not teach that one must confess the name of Jesus Christ to be saved. The issue God cares about is the direction of the heart, not the content of their theology." For those of us who have some inkling of the direction of their heart (see Jer 17:9), that might not be as comforting as Pinnock assumes.

To say solus Christus does not mean that we do not believe in the Father or the Spirit, but it does insist that Christ is the only incarnate self-revelation of God and redeemer of humanity. The Holy Spirit does not draw attention to himself, but leads us to Christ, in whom we find our peace with God.

Sola Gratia: Our Only Method
The reason we must stay with the Scriptures is because it is the only place where we are told that we are saved by the unprovoked and undeserved acceptance of God. In "The Sound of Music," Maria (Julie Andrews), bewildered by the captain's sudden attraction to her, rhapsodizes, "Nothing comes from nothing, nothing ever could. So somewhere in my youth or childhood, I must have done something good." Deep down, human nature is convinced that there is a way for us to save ourselves. We may indeed require divine assistance. Perhaps God will have to show us the way, or even send a messenger to lead us back, but we can actually follow the plan and pull it off.

The Law is in us by nature. We were born with a conscience that tells us that we are condemned by that Law, but our reason concludes immediately that the answer to that self-condemnation is to do better next time. But the Gospel is not in nature. It is not lodged somewhere in our heart, our mind, our will, or our emotions. It is an announcement that comes to us as foolishness and our first response, like that of Sarah, is to laugh. The story is told of a man who fell off a cliff, but on his way down managed to grab a branch. He broke his fall and saved his life, but before long he realized that he could not pull himself back up onto the ledge. Finally, he called out, "Is there anyone up there who can help me?" To his surprise, a voice boomed back, "I am here and I can help you, but first you're going to have to let go of that branch." Thinking for a moment about his options, the man looked back up and shot back, "Is there anyone else up there who can help me?" We are looking for someone to save us by helping us save ourselves. But the Law tells us that even our best works are like filthy rags; the Gospel tells us that it is something in God and his character (kindness, goodness, mercy, compassion) and not something in us (a good will, a decision, an act, an open heart, etc.) that saves us.

Many in the medieval church believed that God saved by grace, but they also believed that their own free will and cooperation with grace was "their part" in salvation. The popular medieval phrase was, "God will not deny his grace to those who do what they can." Today's version, of course, is, "God helps those who help themselves." Over half the evangelicals surveyed thought this was a direct biblical quotation and 84% thought that it was a biblical idea, that percentage rising with church attendance at evangelical churches.

On the eve of the Reformation a number of church leaders, including bishops and archbishops, had been complaining of creeping Pelagianism (a heresy that denies original sin and the absolute need for grace). Nevertheless, that heresy was never tolerated in its full expression. However, today it is tolerated and even promoted in liberal Protestantism generally, and even in many evangelical circles.

In Pelagianism, Adam's sin is not imputed to us, nor is Christ's righteousness. Adam is a bad example, not the representative in whom we stand guilty. Similarly, Christ is a good example, not the representative in whom we stand righteous. How much of our preaching centers on following Christ--as important as that is--rather than on his person and work? How often do we hear about his work in us compared to his work for us?

Charles Finney, the revivalist of the last century, is a patron saint for most evangelicals. And yet, he denied original sin, the substitutionary atonement, justification, and the need for regeneration by the Holy Spirit. In short, Finney was a Pelagian. This belief in human nature, so prominent in the Enlightenment, wrecked the evangelical doctrine of grace among the older evangelical Protestant denominations (now called "mainline"), and we see where that has taken them. And yet, conservative evangelicals are heading down the same path and have had this human-centered, works-centered emphasis for some time.

The statistics bear us out here, unfortunately, and again the leaders help substantiate the error. Norman Geisler writes, "God would save all men if he could. He will save the greatest number actually achievable without violating their free will."

Sola Fide: Our Only Means
The reformers said that it is not enough to say that we are saved by grace alone, for even many medieval scholars held that view, including Luther's own mentor. Rome viewed grace more as a substance than as an attitude of favor on God's part. In other words, grace was like water poured into the soul. It assisted the believer in his growth toward salvation. The purpose of grace was to transform a sinner into a saint, a bad person into a good person, a rebel into an obedient son or daughter.

The reformers searched the Scriptures and found a missing ingredient in the medieval notion of grace. To be sure, there were many passages that spoke of grace transforming us and conforming us to the image of Christ. But there were other passages, too, that used a Greek word that meant "to declare righteous," not "to make righteous." The problem was, the Latin Bible everyone was using mistranslated the former and combined the two Greek words into one. Erasmus and other Renaissance humanists "laid the egg that Luther hatched" by cleaning up the translation mistakes.

According to Scripture, God declares a person righteous before that person actually begins to become righteous. Therefore, the declaration is not in response to any spiritual or moral advances within the individual, but is an imputation of the perfect righteousness that God immediately requires of everyone who is united to Christ by faith alone. When a person trusts Christ, that very moment he or she is clothed in his perfect holiness, so that even though the believer is still sinful, he or she is judged by God as blameless.

This apostolic doctrine, proclaimed to Abraham and his offspring, has fallen on hard times again in church history. Not only do most Christians today not hear about the doctrine of justification by grace alone through faith alone, many cannot even define it. Although justification is the doctrine by which, according to the evangelical reformers "the church stands or falls," it has been challenged. Finney openly declared, "The doctrine of an imputed righteousness is another gospel. For sinners to be forensically pronounced just is impossible and absurd. The doctrine of an imputed righteousness is founded on a most false and nonsensical assumption, representing the atonement, rather than the sinner's own obedience, as the ground of his justification, which has been a sad occasion of stumbling to many."

In our own time, Clark Pinnock wonders why we cannot even embrace the notion of purgatory:

I cannot deny that most believers end their earthly lives imperfectly sanctified and far from complete. [Most? How about all!] I cannot deny the wisdom in possibly giving them an opportunity to close the gap and grow to maturity after death. Obviously, evangelicals have not thought this question out. [We have: It was called The Reformation.] It seems to me that we already have the possibility of a doctrine of purgatory. Our Wesleyan and Arminian thinking may need to be extended in this direction. Is a doctrine of purgatory not required by our doctrine of holiness?

Russell Spittler, a Pentecostal theologian at Fuller Seminary, reflects on Luther's phrase concerning justification: simul iustus et peccator, (simultaneously just and sinner): "But can it really be true--saint and sinner simultaneously? I wish it were so. Is this correct: 'I don't need to work at becoming. I'm already declared to be holy.' No sweat needed? It looks wrong to me. I hear moral demands in Scripture. Simul iustus et peccator? I hope it's true! I simply fear it's not."

The Wesleyan emphasis has always been a challenge to the evangelical faith on this point, although in his best moments Wesley insisted on this heart of the Gospel. To the extent that the consensus-builders and institutional abbots of the evangelical monasteries have attempted to incorporate Arminianism under the label "evangelical," to that extent, it seems to me, it ceases to be evangelical indeed.

Soli Deo Gloria: Our Only Ambition
The world is full of ambitious people. But Paul said, "It has always been my ambition to preach the Gospel where Christ was not known." (Rom 15:20). Since God has spoken so clearly and saved so finally, the believer is free to worship, serve, and glorify God and to enjoy him forever, beginning now. What is the ambition of the evangelical movement? Is it to please God or to please men?

Is our happiness and joy found in God or in someone or something else? Is our worship entertainment or worship? Is God's glory or our self-fulfillment the goal of our lives? Do we see God's grace as the only basis for our salvation, or are we still seeking some of the credit for ourselves? These questions reveal a glaring human-centeredness in the evangelical churches and the general witness of our day.

Robert Schuller actually says that the Reformation "erred because it was God-centered rather than man-centered," and Yale's George Lindbeck observes how quickly evangelical theology accepted this new gospel: "In the fifties, it took liberals to accept Norman Vincent Peale, but as the case of Robert Schuller indicates, today professed conservatives eat it up."

Many historians look back to the Reformation and wonder at its far-reaching influences in transforming culture. The work ethic, public education, civic and economic betterment, a revival of music, the arts, and a sense of all life being related somehow to God and his glory: These effects cause historians to observe with a sense of irony how a theology of sin and grace, the sovereignty of God over the helplessness of human beings, and an emphasis on salvation by grace apart from works, could be the catalyst for such energetic moral transformation. The reformers did not set out to launch a political or moral campaign, but they proved that when we put the Gospel first and give voice to the Word, the effects inevitably follow.

How can we expect the world to take God and his glory seriously if the church does not? The Reformation slogan Soli Deo Gloria was carved into the organ at Bach's church in Leipzig and the composer signed his works with its initials. It's inscribed over taverns and music halls in old sections of Heidelberg and Amsterdam, a lasting tribute to a time when the fragrance of God's goodness seemed to fill the air. It was not a golden age, but it was an amazing recovery of God-centered faith and practice. Columbia University professor Eugene Rice offers a fitting conclusion:

All the more, the Reformation's views of God and humanity measure the gulf between the secular imagination of the twentieth century and the sixteenth century's intoxication with the majesty of God. We can exercise only historical sympathy to try to understand how it was that the most brilliant intelligences of an entire epoch found a total, a supreme liberty in abandoning human weakness to the omnipotence of God.

Soli Deo Gloria!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dr. Michael Horton is professor of apologetics and theology at Westminster Seminary California (Escondido, California).

© Modern Reformation

Permissions: You are permitted and encouraged to reproduce and distribute this material in any format provided that you do not alter the wording in any way, you do not charge a fee beyond the cost of reproduction, and you do not make more than 500 physical copies. For web posting, a link to this document on our website is preferred. Any exceptions to the above must be explicitly approved by Modern Reformation.

Please include the following statement on any distributed copy: This article originally appeared in the Mar / Apr 1994 edition of Modern Reformation and is reprinted with permission. For more information about Modern Reformation, visit www.modernreformation.org or call (800) 890-7556. All rights reserved.

Friday, October 29, 2010

Martin Luther: You Tube Resources

Reformation Day is here, 31 Oct 2010. We will hear nothing from the Anglican world. We affirm most of Lutheranism. We, like the English Reformers, are Reformed and Anglican. With Cranmer, we affirm, as he did 21 Mar 1556: "...And as for the Pope, I refuse him as Christ's enemy and Antichrist, with all his false doctrine." Given widespread amnesia in Anglicanism enabled by its muddling leaders, we must do our own work. All confidence is gone as we live in the Babylonian Captivity fostered by the ecclesiastical politicians doing theology by polling indicia, cultural exegesis, and historic blindness. We offer these reminders of Bruder Martin--who gave the Gospel back to England. Classical Anglicanism is deeply indebted to Bruder Martin. Our tribute to him follows.

Martin Luther at the Diet of Worms
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5P7QkHCfaI

Martin Luther
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0F1utKV46w&feature=related

Martin Luther - Here I Stand, I Can Do No Other
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2xQsCtpcj_E&feature=related

Here I Stand, I Can Do No Other
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0tk_EvWXQQ&feature=related

The next is a three-part set.

1/3 Martin Luther's Here I Stand: The Speech that Launched the Protestant Reformation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDYZpBMbmck&feature=related

2/3 Martin Luther's Here I Stand: The Speech that Launched the Protestant
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gY0LpfA2L38&feature=related

3/3 Martin Luther's Here I Stand: The Speech that Launched the Protestant
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G0S-7bw-pW4&feature=related

Reformation Series #1- Martin Luther
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=48j4pguwuFw&feature=related

The Protestant Reformation - Part 1
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h025a8GFlyI&feature=related

The Protestant Reformation - Part 2
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePwNQ9o03ig&feature=related

The Reformation-Martin Luther
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EFqWnEpZvjs&feature=related

For a Romeward-view of Luther.
Martin Luther - Protestant Reformer
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H1yZi6-Pf9c&feature=related

The next is a two-part set. Two Papist attacks on Martin Luther. Tired of these Papists' inability to exegete Romans 3.28--they just don't get it. Sola fide, while not in the text verbally, is there in concept. Justified apart from/without the works. Nuff said. Poor.
Part One: What you don't know about Martin Luther!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kd66KXIbAjc&NR=1

Part Two. Martin Luther, the Devil and Denominations
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xL2Hyve-kwg&feature=related

A more balanced view than the tripish sets above.
Martin Luther The Reformation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QO9TmGbueyQ&feature=related

In the next video: "The main issue that drove Martin Luther to post his famous 95 theses on Oct. 31 1517 was the practice of selling indulgences (essentially "pay the church, your sin is forgiven"). However, the theological avalanche that followed would flow far and wide through established Church theology and tradition. Man's condition, justification, the priesthood, confession, authority of Scripture -- these areas were all brilliantly reconsidered by the Reformers." Contains excellent quotes.

Fathers of the Reformation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mn2sQRqS_p8&feature=related

An video-technology class by some students. For what it's worth. If anything, it shows students attempting to digest this magisterial Reformer.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8L8Kjiti4Nk&feature=related

An Irish Presbyterian gives his take. Cork Free Presbyterian Church. A nice review of all leading Reformers, including Luther.
Our Glorious Protestant Reformation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x_QTFih-jsU&feature=related

Martin Luther history project.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZZbJyVMZBY&feature=related

Another school history project. If anything, it shows how young people research, digest and process Luther and our glorious Reformation of the Catholic (not Papist) Church.
Martin Luther Reformation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DwdSGLrizGA&feature=related

An excellent documentary follows. Numerous competent scholars appear in the next several sets. Of note--as an Anglican here, Alistair McGrath, Oxford, makes an appearance. Some excellent photos. Excellent commentary. Good musical background. This 2002 documentary chronicles the life of Martin Luther, from his childhood, to his days as an ascetic Catholic monk, to his stance as the voice of reform from within (and, finally, from without) the Catholic Church. This may be the best set in this post. It has twelve parts and is about 2 hours in length.

Part One: Martin Luther E01P01
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GsMpIx6fxoA&feature=related

Part Two: Martin Luther E01P02
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOq93pUZyD8&feature=related

Part Three: Martin Luther E01P03
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NnjGIv-tFEE&NR=1

Part Four: Martin Luther EO1PO4
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WjvPlztYuGc&feature=related

Part Five: Martin Luther E01P05
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29FiYa0A5tU&feature=related

Part Six: Martin Luther EO1PO6
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4i8u_KQvZkk&feature=related

Part Seven: Martin Luther E02P01
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3p01dS27bCQ&NR=1

Part Eight: Martin Luther EO2PO2
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXLr_Rtv-es&feature=related

Part Nine: Martin Luther EO2PO3
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rY6hMVMtjPg&NR=1

Part Ten: Martin Luther EO2PO4
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XzUPp1BgWg8&feature=related

Part Eleven: Martin Luther EO2PO5
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5YiEXA2Mv-s&feature=related

Part Twelve: Martin Luther EO2PO6
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5rK8HL7ziN4&NR=1

The Reluctant Revolutionary
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ni1gupkGAW0&feature=related

A critical look at Luther.
Did Martin Luther Believe In Faith Alone?
http://video.yahoo.com/watch/6849097/17813323

Coral Ridge Presbyterian presentation. A quote from their site: "October 31, 1517 a young monk named Martin Luther nailed 95 theses to a church door in Wittenberg, Germany.He touched off what became the Protestant Reformation and changed the world forever. Gary Cass, chairman of the Christian Anti-Defamation Commission, challenges modern Christians to begin standing boldly for biblical truth—as Luther did."
Learn2Discern - Reformers Needed
http://video.yahoo.com/watch/6243114/16203360

Martin Luther's Morning Prayer
http://vimeo.com/9651771

Martin Luther's Evening Prayer
http://vimeo.com/9704170

Martin Luther Speech
http://vimeo.com/9073784

Martin Luther
http://vimeo.com/3455964

Luther The Reformer
http://vimeo.com/7250181

A grand rendition of our Battle Hymn.
Battle Hymn of the Reformation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wiRpUtVByxU&feature=related

Some rap and some more humour.
'95 Theses' - rap music video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dt5AJr0wls0

Another rap tune.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHey8fExPxo&feature=related

A little humour.
The Reformation Polka
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b4TeJJmQJqU&feature=related

The lyrics are for the Reformation Polka, a justifiable assault on that false gospeller and Antichrist of Rome (not rhetoric, but Gal.1.6-10):

When I was just ein junger Mann I studied canon law;
While Erfurt was a challenge, it was just to please my Pa.
Then came the storm, the lightning struck, I called upon Saint Anne,
I shaved my head, I took my vows, an Augustinian! Oh…

Chorus:
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation -
Speak your mind against them and face excommunication
Nail your theses to the door, let’s start a Reformation!
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation!

When Tetzel came near Wittenberg, St. Peter’s profits soared,
I wrote a little notice for the All Saints’ Bull’tin board:
“You cannot purchase merits, for we’re justified by grace!
Here’s 95 more reasons, Brother Tetzel, in your face!” Oh…

Chorus:
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation -
Speak your mind against them and face excommunication
Nail your theses to the door, let’s start a Reformation!
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation!

They loved my tracts, adored my wit, all were exempleror;
The Pope, however, hauled me up before the Emperor.
“Are these your books? Do you recant?” King Charles did demand,
“I will not change my Diet, Sir, God help me here I stand!” Oh…

Chorus:
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation -
Speak your mind against them and face excommunication
Nail your theses to the door, let’s start a Reformation!
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation!

Duke Frederick took the Wise approach, responding to my words,
By knighting “George” as hostage in the Kingdom of the Birds.
Use Brother Martin’s model if the languages you seek,
Stay locked inside a castle with your Hebrew and your Greek! Oh…

Chorus:
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation -
Speak your mind against them and face excommunication
Nail your theses to the door, let’s start a Reformation!
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation!

Let’s raise our steins and Concord Books while gathered in this place,
And spread the word that ‘catholic’ is spelled with lower case;
The Word remains unfettered when the Spirit gets his chance,
So come on, Katy, drop your lute, and join us in our dance! Oh…

Chorus:
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation -
Speak your mind against them and face excommunication
Nail your theses to the door, let’s start a Reformation!
Papal bulls, indulgences, and transubstantiation!