Reformed Churchmen

We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879

Showing posts with label W.H.Griffith Thomas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label W.H.Griffith Thomas. Show all posts

Thursday, January 2, 2014

2 Jan 1861: Birth of Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) W. H. Griffith Thomas

Lest we forget this titan from Wycliffe College, Oxford and the Wycliffe College, University of Toronto.

2 January 1861. Birthday for the Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) W.H. Griffith Thomas (2 January 1861 – 2 June 1924).

He was one of those few dependable Anglican clerics and scholars (on the essentials and the Reformed faith) from England in the 20th century. We know of none in the US [think TEC, USA]. We might be inclined to add Jim Packer, but he has solid out a few times.

Life and work

Griffith Thomas was born in Oswestry, Shropshire, England, to a Welsh family. According to the General Register Office marriage record for his parents, his mother (Anne Nightingale Griffith) was the daughter of William Griffith, a surgeon of Oswestry. She married William Thomas on August 30, 1860. William Thomas was a draper and the son of Thomas Thomas, a farmer. By the 1861 census, Mrs. Thomas was widowed and living in Oswestry with her parents and infant son. She married secondly, in 1864, Joseph Charles. In the 1871 census, the family was living in Shrewsbury, Shropshire. By the 1881 census, Griffith Thomas was living in London. Then 20 years old, he worked for his stepfather's younger brother, William Charles, who was a watch dial maker. From 1882-85 he was a student at King's College London where he took an Associateship of King's College, before proceeding to Christ Church, Oxford.

In addition to several pastorates, he taught for several years as Principal of Wycliffe Hall, Oxford (1905–1910)[1] and then at Wycliffe College in Toronto, Canada (1910–1919).[2] He was a co-founder with Lewis Sperry Chafer of Dallas Theological Seminary. He authored several books including The Principles of Theology, a systematic theology text based on the 39 Articles of the Anglican Communion. Theologically conservative, Griffith Thomas was an Anglican and an early dispensationalist.

Gaining the reputation of a popular author and speaker in dispensationalism and victorious Christian life, he spent the last five years of his life writing and speaking at conservative gatherings. Partially funded by the Milton Stewart Evangelistic Fund, Thomas traveled with Charles G. Trumbull to Japan and China in the summer of 1920. In 1920 after returning to the United States from China, he made a sweeping accusation of the modernist tendency among China missionaries in the famous speech, "Modernism in China." The speech was delivered to the Presbyterian Social Union in Philadelphia in January 1921 and caused a great deal of debate among the churches and mission boards in North America. Thomas was accused of being directly responsible for the founding of the Bible Union of China. His reply was that "I had nothing to do with the formation of the Bible Union, except in so far as my address seems to have been the immediate occasion for it." There is certainly no evidence that Thomas personally initiated the Bible Union in China, but his speeches in China during summer missionaries retreat had the effect of significantly intensifying the conservatives' negative sentiment toward modernism in the field and prompting them to take public action.

Legacy

More recently, Griffith Thomas has been drawn into the current science-versus-religion debate by theologian Alister McGrath in his argument with scientist Richard Dawkins over the issue of whether or not religious faith is based on evidence. The quotation from Griffith-Thomas cited by McGrath ("[Faith] affects the whole of man's nature. It commences with the conviction of the mind based on adequate evidence...")[3] is taken from The Principles of Theology. Griffith-Thomas' view of "evidence" and "proof" in relation to the Bible, can be found in How We Got Our Bible and Why We Believe It Is God's Word.[4]

Notes

1. ^
http://web.mac.com/brian.douglas/iWeb/Anglican%20Eucharistic%20Theology/Blog/7A199A4D-FCBA-11DA-9B93-001124732AA0.html
2. ^ http://dts.edu/utility/file.aspx?FileID=252
3. ^ http://www.st-edmunds.cam.ac.uk/cis/mcgrath/lecture.html#_ednref22 Alister McGrath - Cambridge CiS-St Edmunds Public Lecture
4. ^ How We Got Our Bible - by W.H. Griffith From the Church Society at:
http://churchsociety.org/issues_new/history/griffiththomas/iss_history_griffiththomas_intro.asp

William Henry Griffith Thomas (1861-1924)
Minister, Scholar, Teacher
Summary

• 2nd Jan 1861 Born at Oswestry, Shropshire, England, of Welsh family. Endured family hardship as his Father died before he was born, left school at 14 because of financial problems.
• 1878 Converted after the witness of two friends.
• At the age of 18 went to London to work in his uncle's office, studied hard in his spare time and obtained a good understanding of Greek .
• 1882 Offered lay-curacy, studied at King's College, London in the mornings and spent the rest of his time in parish work.
• 1885, Influenced by Henry Wace's lectures at King's, and friendship continued until death.
• Ordained in 1885, by the Bishop of London.
• 1888 Senior Curate at St Aldate's, Oxford for 7 years, at the same time studied for a degree at Oxford University.
• 1896 Vicar of St Paul's, Portman Chapel, London.
• 1898 Married Alice Monk
• 1902 Winifred, their only child was born.
• 1905-1910 Principal of Wycliffe Hall, Oxford, committed to conservative evangelical theology.
• 1910-1919 Wycliffe College, Toronto, Canada, appointed to teach Old Testament Literature and Exegesis, later taught Systematic Theology. H K Mowll and Dyson Hague also on the staff.
• Often spoke at the Keswick Convention.
• Authored several books including The Principles of Theology (a systematic theology text based on the 39 Articles), The Catholic Faith and The Work of the Ministry. Also a variety of Bible commentaries and books on apologetics and pastoralia.
• 1919 Left Toronto to exercise a wider ministry (based in Philadelphia), including conference work, Bible lectures, theological courses, writing for newspapers and magazines etc. Memorable visit to China and Japan, leading to the formation of the Bible Union of China following his lectures at Kuling.
• Co-founder of Dallas Theological Seminary
• 1924 Died, Philadelphia hospital due to heart trouble.


W. H. Griffith Thomas Biography by M. Guthrie Clark
Published by Church Book Room Press


• Chapter 1 - Introduction and Early Days
• Chapter 2 - Ordination
• Chapter 3 - Portman Square and Wycliffe Hall
• Chapter 4 - Books and Teaching
• Chapter 5 - Wycliffe College, Toronto
• Chapter 6 - The Man and his Message


The Principles of Theology by W H Griffith-Thoams
Published by Church Book Room Press
• Buy from the online store
• View the text online

"A Sacrament of our Redemption" by W H Griffith-Thomas
An Enquiry into the Meaning of the Lord's Supper in the New Testament and the Church of England.

Published by The Church Book Room.

• Preface & Contents
• Chapter 1 - The True Starting point of Enquiry
• Chapter 2 - The Approach to the Institution
• Chapter 3 - The Institution of the Lord's Supper
• Chapter 4 - The Lord's Supper in the Epistles
• Chapter 5 - Summary of New Testament Teaching
• Chapter 6 - The Lord's Supper in the Prayer Book
• Chapter 7 - The Lord's Supper in the Prayer Books of 1549 and 1552
• Chapter 8 - The Lord's Supper in the Prayer Books of 1559 and the Articles of 1571
• Chapter 9 - The Lord's Supper in the Prayer Books of 1604 and 1662
• Chapter 10 - The Lord's Supper in Ritualist Teaching - Part I - "The Real Presence."
• Chapter 11 - The Lord's Supper in Ritualist Teaching - Part II - "Eucharistic Sacrifice."
• Chapter 12 - The Lord's Supper in Ritualist Teaching - Part III - "Eucharistic Adoration."
Articles
• New Lease of Life - A Preface by James I Packer to The Principles of Theology by W. H. Griffith Thomas. Churchman article from 1978.

Friday, August 23, 2013

Mr. (Rev.Dr. Prof.) Packer's Notes on Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) Thomas' "Prinicipals of Theology"


A few notes on Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) James I. Packer’s "Prefatory" notes (1977) on Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) W. H. Griffith Thomas’ Principles of Religion: An Introduction to the Thirty-nine Articles.

Mr. Thomas’ manuscript was developed but unpublished at Mr. Thomas’ death in 1924. It was published posthumously by Mr. (Rev. Canon) Dyson Hague of Wycliffe College, University of Toronto.

Thomas, W. H. Griffith Thomas. The Principles of Theology: An Introduction to the Thirty-nine Articles (7th Ed.) Philadelphia, PA: PTS Series of The Reformed Episcopal Church, 1996. We’re quite delighted to point you to “another publisher” other than PTS-REC group so that the profits might go to them, to wit, to Wifp and Stock. That, rather than them, is available at:
http://www.amazon.com/The-Principles-Theology-Introduction-Thirty-Nine/dp/159752073X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1377128631&sr=8-1&keywords=principles+of+theology+w.h.+griffith+thomas

Mr. Packer notes that Mr. Thomas served parishes at St. Aldgate’s, Oxford and St. Paul’s, Portman Square, London. He served as a Professor of Systematic Theology and as a Principal at Wycliffe Hall, Oxford. He served as a Principal of Wycliffe College, University of Toronto.

Mr. Dyson Hague says of Mr. Thomas:

“The late Dr. Griffith Thomas was remarkable as a teacher and leader. His outstanding characteristic was clearness and forcefulness…singular conciseness of order and method. From his early days at King’s College, London and Christ Church, Oxford, he lived a life of the most strenuous industry and was ever the prodigious toiler….” His volume was “almost an Anglican encyclopedia.”

We now cull a “few gems” directly from Mr. Packer’s "Prefatory" comments in 1977 along with our musings:

• Mr. Thomas’ volume was a “regular textbook on the Articles in evangelical Anglican theological colleges; and it holds its place as the most thorough historical exposition of the Anglican confessional basis that has ever been produced. As such, it stands by merit alongside Hardwick’s History of the Articles, itself more than a century old.”

Based on the above, we ask Mr. Packer, who still uses Mr. Thomas? And, while watching all the Anglican “hand-wringing" over the words “confessional” and denials of the word "confessional," do Anglicans really “confess” these Articles? Or, Mr. Hardwick, where’s he been? Or, what American seminary uses this volume? Sewanee? General? Nashotah House? This much: Mr. Packer is high and approving of Mr. Thomas’ volume. Ever seen any articles or references to Mr. Thomas over at Virtue's hothouse?

• Mr. Packer notes this comparison: “Hardwick, goaded by Newman’s sleight-of-hand with the Articles, offers specialist research; Thomas’s 250,000 terse words…exact thought at maximum comprehension…displays `the essential Anglican doctrine’…he excludes any request for originality.”

We ask Mr. Packer, who, pray tell, believes that the Articles express “essential Anglican doctrine?” Did Misters Duncan, Iker, Ackerman and Sutton get this memo?

If Packer believes this, he must be out of sorts with the American leaders? And what ACNAer will talk “openly” of “Newman’s sleight-of-hand?” This much, the historians do.

We would add that Mr. Hardwick is available at: Hardwick, Charles. A History of the Articles of Religion: To which is Added a Series of Documents from A.D. 1536 to A.D. 1615. No location: BiblioBizarre, 2009. Available at:
http://www.amazon.com/History-Articles-Religion-Documents-D/dp/1103949896/ref=sr_1_7?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1377145782&sr=1-7

• Mr. Packer then goes on glowingly: “The Principles of Theology may be said to have rounded off a four-hundred year era of Protestant Anglicanism…it addressed Rome’s Trojan horse in the Church of England…to vindicate historic Protestantism as authentically Anglicanism.”

We engage Mr. Packer again. Sir, did you say “Protestant Anglicanism?”   Mr. Packer, is that not an oxymoron according to 20th-21st century Western Anglicans? What will the Nashotah House denizens, graduates, and men like Mister Iker and Ackerman say to this issue of “Protestant Anglicanism?” And your use of the term “Roman Trojan horse?”   Will Mr. (ABP) Duncan say this to Misters (Bps.) Iker and Ackerman?  Agents of the "Roman virus?"  "Roman Trojan horses?"  Did you really write this? Or, did some crypto-Protestant assistant furtively slip this into your manuscript? Do you still stand by this?

• Mr. Packer then speaks of a cadre of men in Mr. Thomas’ league and of similar sentiments and skills: William Goode (worth reading). George Cornelius Gorham (whom Bp. Philpott of Exeter tried to “gore”), T.P. Boultbee, T.S.L. Vogan, Nathaniel Dimock, E.A. Litton, Henry Wace, Handy C.G. Moule, J.T. Tomlinson, W. Prescott Upton, and Charles Sydney Carter. Litton’s Introduction to Dogmatics (1882, 1892, 1912) and Boultbee’s Commentary on the Thirty-nine Articles: Forming an Introduction to the Theology of the Church of England (1871, 5th edition of 1880) was replaced by Mr. Thomas’ volume.

We would add: Boultbee is available at: Boultbee, T.P. A Commentary on the Thirty-Nine Articles: Forming an Introduction to the Theology of the Church of England. Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock Publication, 2005. Available at:
http://www.amazon.com/Commentary-Thirty-Nine-Articles-Introduction-Theology/dp/1597523569/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1377143821&sr=8-1&keywords=Boultbee+Commentary+on+the+Thirty-nine+Articles


For Litton, see below.

• And now for this “gem:” “The whole corpus of anti-Tractarian writing stands behind the Principles of Theology…”

And, Mr. Packer, have you buried the hatchet with the Tractarians? What say you, Sir?  Word on the street says you've buried that hatchet?

• Or, “…the Protestant Evangelical tradition…”

Mr. Packer, and what the heck is this? There you go again with those swear words.

• “Thomas wrote his Protestant exposition of basic Christianity, Prayer Book style, and he called it The Catholic Faith.”

Mr. Packer, there you go again, using that swear word “Protestant.” Tell the Continuers this, would you. Or, Mr. Duncan.

Mr. Packer, are you saying that Protestant Anglicans are Catholics? No, it cannot be!


Thomas, W. H. Griffith Thomas. The Catholic Faith: A Manual of Instruction for Members of the Church of England. No location: Forgotten Books, 2012. http://www.amazon.com/The-Catholic-Faith-Instruction-Members/dp/B008FH3JNU/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1377136851&sr=8-1&keywords=W.H.+Griffith+Thomas+Catholic+Faith

• Mr. Thomas’ Principals is the “theological Rock of Gibraltar.”

• Mr. Thomas displaced Litton’s and H.C.G. Moule’s Outlines of Christian Doctrine (1889, 1919). We would add availability at:
http://www.amazon.com/Outlines-Christian-Doctrine-Classic-Reprint/dp/B008NC30PY/ref=sr_1_fkmr0_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1377284145&sr=8-1-fkmr0&keywords=litton+moule+outlines+of+Christian+doctrine

• Mr. Packer says, “The Articles retain their place as the Anglican Confession…”

Mr. Packer, in what Western Anglican body is this claimed? Perhaps, in Kenya or Nigeria, but the UK, US, or Canada? Perhaps in Sydney, in pockets, but where else? Or, is this a “wish” only? Nonetheless, Sir, you have made your point and it is noted.

To provide a round-up and summary, we would say that Mr. Packer’s recent volume on the Thirty-nine Articles expresses his general lamentation that no one really takes them seriously or confessionally anymore.


Mr. Packer's jeremiad and lamentation is available.

Packer, James I. and Beckwith, R.T. The Thirty-nine Articles: Their Place and Use Today. Vancouver, BC, Canada:  Regent College Publishing, 2007.  Available at: http://www.amazon.com/The-Thirty-nine-Articles-Their-Place/dp/1573834130/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1377144118&sr=8-1&keywords=Thirty-nine+Articles
 

Thursday, December 23, 2010

The Principles of Theology - Article 5 by W.H.Griffith Thomas


The Principles of Theology - Article 5
by W.H.Griffith Thomas

ARTICLE 5

Part 2. The Scripture Doctrine Of The Holy Spirit

1. This is clearly a Bible doctrine and cannot be derived from any other source. It is essentially a truth of revelation. Naturally the subject is not so prominent in the Old Testament as in the New, but it is referred to in about half of the thirty-nine books, and the idea of the Spirit in Genesis is regarded as quite familiar, just as it is in St. Matt. 1.

2. The doctrine of the Holy Spirit in the Old Testament calls for attention, first of all, and it is noteworthy that the New Testament identifies the Holy Spirit with the Spirit of God in the Old Testament, thereby showing that there is no difference between them. Indeed, the New Testament conception of the Spirit is very largely only intelligible when read in the light of the teaching of the Old Testament. There are three main lines of teaching in the Old Testament in regard to the Holy Spirit: (a) the cosmical, or world-relation of the Spirit of God. The Spirit associated with creation and human life as a whole; (b) the redemptive relation of the Spirit. The connection of the Spirit with Israel; (c) The personal relation of the Spirit. This is concerned with the spiritual life of individuals. It is often asked whether there are indications of development in the Old Testament of the doctrine of the Spirit of God. In the earlier books the Spirit is certainly depicted as a Divine energy, but in the later there seems to be something like an approximation to the doctrine of the Spirit as a Personal Being (Isa. 48:16; 63:9, 10; Zech. 4:6). Perhaps, in general, the Spirit in the Old Testament is a Divine Agent rather than a distinct Personality. God is regarded as at work by His Spirit. One strong confirmation of the truth that the doctrine of the Spirit is a Bible doctrine is the fact that for all practical purposes the period of the Apocrypha from Malachi to Matthew contributed nothing to it. It is only when we come to New Testament times that we are enabled to see the real implications of the Old Testament in the fuller light and richer experience of the days of Christ.

3. The New Testament is very full of the subject of the Holy Spirit, and it is found in every book, except three short and personal ones. It emerges naturally and clearly from the revelation of Jesus Christ. When we look at it in the light of the New Testament we notice three main divisions:

(a) The character and teaching of Christ. In the Synoptic Gospels we have the Holy Spirit in relation to Christ Himself at each stage of His earthly manifestation. Then there is the teaching of Christ, the general idea being that of the Holy Spirit as a Divine power, promised to the disciples for the fulfilment of the Divine purpose of redemption. The Fourth Gospel is much fuller and more thoroughly developed, though it is particularly noteworthy that here, as in the Synoptic Gospels, there is a clear assumption of familiarity with the Holy Spirit (John 1:32 ff.). But there is a distinct development of teaching in the Fourth Gospel, where the Spirit is personal, and closely associated at all points with the redemption of Christ. Perhaps the most important feature in this Gospel is the use of the new term “Paraclete,” which is found in connection with the detailed teaching of chapters 14-16. The general idea of the Johannine teaching is that the departure of Christ was to issue in the gift of the Holy Spirit, as the special bestowal of the new covenant for the purpose of perpetuating Christ’s spiritual presence and effecting His redemptive work. Thus, the Holy Spirit would at once be a revelation of truth, a bestowal of life, and an equipment for service.

(b) From the Gospels it is natural to pass to the Acts of the Apostles as expressing the first thirty years of the Church’s life and work, and the prominence given there to the Holy Spirit is very remarkable. There are at least seventy references, and on this account the book has been well called “The Acts of the Holy Spirit.” This emphasis is really a testimony to the prominence of the Divine over the human element, and starting from the Day of Pentecost we see that the Spirit of God is at work, and, indeed, in supreme authority in every part of the early Church. His Person, His gifts, and His work are everywhere, and the book is dominated throughout by the Spirit, because the life of the Church was controlled by His Divine presence and power.

(c) The teaching of the Epistles will naturally follow, and in this St. Paul’s work is of the very first importance. A remarkable fullness is seen in his writings and the teaching touches every part of his message. The usual fourfold grouping of his Epistles reveals references to the Spirit in a variety of ways, and both in regard to the work and the nature of the Spirit St. Paul has very much to say. The Holy Spirit is closely related to God (Rom. 8:9); is regarded as possessing personal activities (Eph. 4:30); and is intimately bound up with Christ (Rom. 8:9). The activity of Christ as the Redeemer and Head of the Church is regarded as continued by the Holy Spirit, and yet with all this intimacy of association they are never absolutely identified. A careful study of St Paul’s teaching will support the view of a well-known writer that “the Apostle’s entire thinking stands under the influence of his estimate of the Spirit.”[3] Other parts of the New Testament are slight and insignificant in comparison with the writings of St. Paul and St. John.

4. The summary of the teaching of the Bible on the subject of the Holy Spirit suggests the following lines: (a) A close and essential relation of the Spirit to Christ; (b) The Holy Spirit as “the Executive of the Godhead” in and for the Christian Church; (c) the Deity of the Spirit (Matt. 28:19; 2 Cor. 13:14); (d) the Personality of the Spirit.

It will be seen from a study of the New Testament that the distinctions in the Godhead are always closely connected with Divine operations rather than with the Divine nature. While there is nothing approaching the metaphysical Trinity of later days, the association of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit with Divine operations is a clear implication of essential Deity. The fundamental conceptions are the same throughout the whole of the New Testament, and there is no development of the doctrine of the Spirit through Ebionism to Orthodoxy.

>> Part 3. The History Of The Doctrine

Tuesday, December 14, 2010

The Principles of Theology - Article 5 by W.H. Griffith Thomas

We are always pleased by what we read at the Church Society site. We most highly commend the Church Society for its quality-articles and stedfast adherence to the Protestant, Reformed and Calvinistic heritage of classical Anglicanism.

http://www.churchsociety.org/publications/principles/principles-art05-s1.asp

The Principles of Theology - Article 5
by W.H.Griffith Thomas

ARTICLE 5

Introduction

Part 1. The Teaching Of The Article

The Article elaborates the statement of Article 1 in regard to the Holy Spirit, and thereby follows naturally from the statements of Articles 2, 3, and 4 respecting our Lord. Before looking in detail at the theological topics embraced in the Article it will be useful to analyse it as a whole.

1. The Fact of the Holy Spirit; “The Holy Ghost.”

2. The Procession of the Holy Spirit; “Proceeding from the Father and the Son.”

3. The Equality of the Holy Spirit with the Father and the Son; “Of one substance, majesty, and glory, with the Father and the Son.”

4. The Godhead of the Holy Spirit; “Very and eternal God.”

It will be seen that the Article follows closely the statements of the Nicene Creed in harmony with the Church doctrine of Chalcedon.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

J I Packer’s preface to Griffith Thomas’ Principles of Theology : Anglican Church League, Sydney, Australia

The unread book in Anglicanism at large.


J I Packer’s preface to Griffith Thomas’ Principles of Theology : Anglican Church League, Sydney, Australia

In 1977, Dr J I Packer wrote the Preface to an edition of W.H. Griffith Thomas’ The Principles of Theology.

“As in general terms Calvin’s 1559 Institutes rounded off the forty-year Reformation era in European theology, so in general terms The Principles of Theology may be said to have rounded off a four-hundred year era of Protestant Anglicanism, and in particular to have summed up a century of vigilant scholarship which, in face of what looked like Rome’s Trojan horse in the Church of England, had sought to vindicate historic Protestantism as authentically Anglican and as the only position with more than squatter’s rights within the Establishment.

This was the scholarship of such men as William Goode, George Cornelius Gorham, T. P. Boultbee, T. S. L. Vogan, Nathaniel Dimock, E. A. Litton, Henry Wace, Handley C. G. Moule, J. T. Tomlinson, W. Prescott Upton and Charles Sydney Carter – giants in the land in their own day, however little remembered now.”