)
Reformed Churchmen
We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879
Tuesday, March 11, 2014
Ligonier Ministries: War on the Word
)
Friday, October 4, 2013
Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) Michael Kruger: "Top 10 Books on the Bible"
2013
Top 10 Books on the Bible's Authority
Due to the popularity of that question, I have compiled an annotated list of the 10 best books on this topic. It goes without saying that such a list is highly selective (and debatable). So many good books deserve to be included. But my list is guided by these main criteria: (a) books that focus on the theological side of biblical authority and not as much on the historical evidences for the Bible's history (though some overlap is inevitable); (b) books that are "modern," meaning they have been written sometime between the Reformation and the present (otherwise, many patristic works would make the list); and (c) books that are rigorously orthodox (Karl Barth's Dogmatics is not on the list despite the fact that it has been influential on the modern church's view of Scripture).
With these criteria in mind, let's take a look at the top 10:

10. D. A. Carson and John Woodbridge, eds., Scripture and Truth (Baker, 1983); idem, Hermeneutics, Authority, and Canon (Zondervan, 1986).
Even though this first entry technically includes two books, I am regarding them together since the same authors edited both of them. I appreciate that these books gather together some of the best evangelical scholars who cover a wide variety of contemporary issues related to biblical authority.
There are essays from theological, philosophical, historical, hermeneutical, and exegetical perspectives. Although some of the essays need to be updated (some are 30 years old), they constitute an indispensable treasure trove of material on the authority of the Bible.
9. Herman Bavinck, Reformed Dogmatics: Prolegomena (vol. 1): Part IV: Revelation (Baker Academic, 2003).
I don't prefer to use systematic theologies in this list, but Bavinck's work is too important to pass up. Bavinck originally published his Gereformeerde Dogmatiek from 1895 to 1901, and we are blessed to have it translated into English. It provides the quintessential introduction to a Reformed view of Revelation and Scripture, and one can hear echoes of Bavinck for generations to come in major scholars such as Geerhardus Vos, Cornelius Van Til, Herman Ridderbos, and Louis Berkhof. If you find these Dutch theologians difficult to understand then go back and read the one on whose shoulders they are standing: Bavinck.
8. E. J. Young, Thy Word Is Truth (Banner of Truth, 1963).
Young was a vigorous defender of the authority of Scripture, and this book embodies the ethos of his scholarship. It focuses primarily on the extent of inspiration (against those who try to limit it), and the doctrine of inerrancy (against those who suggest the Bible makes mistakes). This book lays out the foundational truths about the authority of the Bible in a clear and compelling manner. Young even covers a number of alleged contradictions and offers helpful solutions. All pastors should read this book.
7. Ned Stonehouse and Paul Woolley, eds., The Infallible Word: A Symposium by the Members of the Faculty of Westminster Theological Seminary (P&R, 1946).
This fine collection of essays by the faculty of Westminster is too frequently overlooked. With articles from Murray, Young, Stonehouse, and Van Til, and a foreword from D. Martyn Lloyd-Jones, it is difficult to know how it has been forgotten. The most important article is the first, by John Murray, where he lays out the self-attesting nature of Scripture and the internal testimony of the Holy Spirit that helps God's people identify Scripture. In a world where most defend the authority of Scripture purely on the basis of historical evidence, Murray brings a refreshing and welcome perspective. Our doctrine of Scripture needs to include serious reflection on the issue of Scripture's self-authentication, and this volume is the place to start.

6. J.I. Packer, 'Fundamentalism' and the Word of God (Eerdmans, 1958).
This little book is one of my all-time favorites. It is small, but it packs a punch. The book is written in the context of the early 20th-century controversies over "fundamentalism" and whether we can (or should) still embrace traditional beliefs about the authority of the Bible. Carefully, patiently, and methodically, Packer walks through all the key issues related to these debates and impressively defends the traditional view. This is a great book to give to a fellow Christian struggling with these issues.
5. William Whitaker, Disputations on Holy Scripture (Soli Deo Gloria, 2000).
Don't let the date of this book fool you. Whitaker lived from 1547 to 1595, during the height of the Protestant Reformation, and dedicated the book to William Cecil, chancellor of Cambridge University. This book is a masterful defense of the Protestant view of the Bible. Whitaker spends considerable time defending the self-authenticating nature of Scripture and contrasts it effectively with the Roman Catholic approach. This book is also overlooked in many discussions and deserves a much wider reading. Thanks to Soli Deo Gloria publishers, we don't have to try to read it in Latin.
4. John Owen, The Divine Original: Authority, Self-Evidencing Light, and Power of the Scriptures, vol. 16 of Owen's Collected Works (Banner of Truth, 1988).
Moving forward one century from Whitaker, Owen provides one of the finest articulations of the Reformed doctrine of Scripture from the Puritan era. He too focuses on the self-authenticating nature of Scripture and the role of the Holy Spirit, contrasting it with alternative models, particular Roman Catholic. This is vintage Owen: thorough, meticulous, verbose, and utterly profound. Be warned: this is no light beach reading. It is a heavy slog to get through anything Owen writes. But the reward is worth it.
3. Meredith Kline, The Structure of Biblical Authority (1971).
Kline is one of the most original Christian thinkers in the last century, and this book is no exception. He approaches the issue of biblical authority from a distinctive angle, namely the covenantal structure of the Old Testament. Kline argues that the idea of an authoritative text derives directly from God's covenant-making activities. You can't understand the authority of the Bible if you don't understand the nature of the covenant. This is a no-frills book (I still have my original copy from when I had Kline as a professor; pea-green cover and all), but it is truly ground-breaking.

2. John Frame, The Doctrine of the Word of God (P and R, 2010).
If you are looking for a comprehensive, profound, and utterly biblical treatment of the authority of Scripture from a Reformed perspective, then this is the book. This is the fourth installment in Frame's series, A Theology of Lordship, but is really the most foundational volume (although The Doctrine of the Knowledge of God is right up there). There is hardly an issue Frame doesn't cover, or a question he doesn't answer. And his answers are so clear and balanced that it makes you wonder why you ever had that question in the first place. No one is better than Frame at making complex ideas simple (some scholars seem to have the opposite gift). This book is a treasure trove of wisdom that every pastor needs to have on the shelf ready at hand.
1. B. B. Warfield, The Inspiration and Authority of the Bible, with intro by Van Til (P&R, 1948).
Classics are classics for a reason. Warfield's work still stands out today as one of the most cogent, insightful, and helpful works on the authority of Scripture. It aptly represents the ethos of Old Princeton and is the gold standard for a distinctively Reformed view of the Bible's inspiration. Warfield's insights are so applicable to modern-day issues that it is easy to forget the content is more than 100 years old. In addition, Van Til's introduction (68 pages long) is immensely helpful. It provides a presuppositional context for Warfield's work, and reminds the reader that Van Til and Warfield had more in common than some people assume (though there are still differences).
Monday, September 23, 2013
Mr. (Dr.) Dockery: Bible, Necessity, Revelation, Inspiration, Authority, & Infallibility
It is available at: http://www.amazon.com/
Mr. (Dr.) Dockery offers "basics on the basics," but even at that...they are worth revisiting, reviewing, and holding consistently before the eye of faith and the life of the Church. We've added a few points here and there.
Why is the Bible needed?
• Man is in God’s image, God is unlimited, and man is limited. “Man is unable, unaided, to investigate him” Mr. Dockery informs us (1). It was God’s initiative to make Himself known. A “Self-disclosure,” “unveiling,” “revelation.”
• Human sin has noetic, affectional, and volitional. There is a “blinding” (2 Cor. 4.4) and inability “to understand correctly” (2).
• We must offer the Westminsterians’ inimitable insight, The Westminster Confession of Faith, chapter 1, paragraph 1: “I. Although the light of nature, and the works of creation and providence, do so far manifest the goodness, wisdom, and power of God, as to leave men inexcusable; yet are they not sufficient to give that knowledge of God, and of his will, which is necessary unto salvation; therefore it pleased the Lord, at sundry times, and in divers manners, to reveal himself, and to declare that his will unto his Church; and afterwards for the better preserving and propagating of the truth, and for the more sure establishment and comfort of the Church against the corruption of the flesh, and the malice of Satan and of the world, to commit the same wholly unto writing; which maketh the holy Scripture to be most necessary; those former ways of God's revealing his will unto his people being now ceased.”
Natural and Special Revelation
• Natural—Psalm 19, Rom. 1.18ff., inter alia.
• Special—forms such: visions (e.g., Isaiah 6), dreams (e.g., Daniel), specific ideas as God’s Word, deeds (e.g. creation, exodus, Red Sea, Jericho falling, etc.), incarnation
• Some claim the Bible is fallible reports by fallible men about God (perhaps the majority report in the mainline??). For example, Barth and Brunner spoke of “encounters” with God as a form of revelation as the form and manner of revelation.
• “An accurate and reliable source of truth requires preservation in a written form” (8).
Inspiration
• Jeremiah: “These are the words the LORD spoke concerning Israel and Judah” (Jer. 30.4)
• Isaiah: “The LORD spoke to me…” (Is. 8.11). This is repeated often in the major and minor Prophets.
• 2 Tim. 3.15-17: “15 and that from childhood you have known the Holy Scriptures, which are able to make you wise for salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus. All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, thoroughly equipped for every good work.” Or, kαὶ ὅτι ἀπὸ βρέφους [τὰ] ἱερὰ γράμματα οἶδας, τὰ δυνάμενά σε σοφίσαι εἰς σωτηρίαν διὰ πίστεως τῆς ἐν Χριστῷ Ἰησοῦ. πᾶσα γραφὴ θεόπνευστος καὶ ὠφέλιμος πρὸς διδασκαλίαν, πρὸς ἐλεγμόν, πρὸς ἐπανόρθωσιν, πρὸς παιδείαν τὴν ἐν δικαιοσύνῃ, ἵνα ἄρτιος ᾖ ὁ τοῦ θεοῦ ἄνθρωπος, πρὸς πᾶν ἔργον ἀγαθὸν ἐξηρτισμένος.
• 2 Peter 1.20-21. “ And so we have the prophetic word confirmed, which you do well to heed as a light that shines in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts; knowing this first, that no prophecy of Scripture is of any private interpretation, for prophecy never came by the will of man, but holy men of God[c] spoke as they were moved by the Holy Spirit. Or, kαὶ ἔχομεν βεβαιότερον τὸν προφητικὸν λόγον, ᾧ καλῶς ποιεῖτε προσέχοντες ὡς λύχνῳ φαίνοντι ἐν αὐχμηρῷ τόπῳ, ἕως οὗ ἡμέρα διαυγάσῃ καὶ φωσφόρος ἀνατείλῃ ἐν ταῖς καρδίαις ὑμῶν: τοῦτο πρῶτον γινώσκοντες, ὅτι πᾶσα προφητεία γραφῆς ἰδίας ἐπιλύσεως οὐ γίνεται: οὐ γὰρ θελήματι ἀνθρώπου ἠνέχθη προφητεία ποτέ, ἀλλὰ ὑπὸ πνεύματος ἁγίου φερόμενοι ἐλάλησαν ἀπὸ θεοῦ ἄνθρωποι.
• Acts 1.16, the Holy Spirit spoke by the mouth of David in reference to Psalm 69.25 and 109.8. Other references here might be cited.
• Jesus and the Temptation addressed the Anti-Christ with the authoritative “Word of God.”
• Jesus: “Scripture cannot be broken…” (Jn. 10.35).
• Mt. 5.18: “Not a jot or tittle would pass away from the law…”. Sometimes this is referred to as “jot-and-tittle inspiration.”
• We would add that Jesus stated His own words would not pass away, a direct claim to co-equal authority with the Old Testament writers.
Theories/Approaches to Inspiration:
• Intuition = insight = gift of those who are more religiously gifted, thoughtful and insightful.
• Illumination theory = a variant of the above, that is, a “heightened state given by the Holy Spirit”
• “Dynamic theory” = Holy Spirit guides ideas, not words
• “Plenary, Verbal view” = God governs and superintends the ideas and very words. This is the classic Protestant and Reformed view.
• “Dictation view” = the writers were stenographers. This approaches the Roman Tridentine view.
Inerrancy and Infallibility
• Some claim these are new terms
• Mr. Dockery, regrettably, does not reference the “International Council on Biblical Inerrancy,” 1978, or Mr. (Rev. Dr. Prof.) R.C. Sproul’s work on it. Explaining Inerrancy. http://www.amazon.com/
• Various periods have addressed different issues: Trinity (e.g. ecumenical councils), deity and humanity of Christ (4th-5th centuries), atonement (11th-12th centuries), soteriology (16th century) and the 19th-20th centuries: inspiration, authority, and infallibility.
• Some protest that the term “inerrancy” or “infalliblity” is not in the Bible. Nor is the word “Trinity” or “sacrament.” The objection is empty.
Illumination
• John 16.8-11: the Holy Spirit brings conviction of sin, righteousness and judgment
• John 14.26: Holy Spirit sent by the Son to illumine. (Let the American Anglican accommodators to the Greek Filioquesters eat this and related texts. The Americans have other agendas in their sell-out.). The Holy Spirit gives internal testimony, conviction, and assurance of the divine authority and infallibility.
• Of course, the Westminster Confession (I.5) gives the following: “V. We may be moved and induced by the testimony of the Church to an high and reverent esteem of the holy Scripture; and the heavenliness of the matter, the efficacy of the doctrine, the majesty of the style, the consent of all the parts, the scope of the whole (which is to give all glory to God), the full discovery it makes of the only way of man's salvation, the many other incomparable excellencies, and the entire perfection thereof, are arguments whereby it doth abundantly evidence itself to be the Word of God; yet, notwithstanding, our full persuasion and assurance of the infallible truth and divine authority thereof, is from the inward work of the Holy Spirit, bearing witness by and with the Word in our hearts.”
• Or, as from our good South African friend, Mr. Griesel, at: http://
• To wit, Franciscus Junius (1545-1602) was a Reformed scholar and theologian who studied under John Calvin and Theodore Beza at Geneva and later became professor at the universities of Heidelberg and Leiden. Below are excerpts from his posthumously published Opera Theologica, in which he states that the testimony of the Holy Spirit is the ultimate assurance of the divinity, inspiration and authority of Scripture.
Junius distinguishes between a testimonium internum and a testimonium externum for the authority of Scripture:
“The testimonies are either internal or external. The internal testimony that exceeds all other authority and without which all the other testimonies and arguments will be of no weight or importance for us, is the Holy Spirit speaking to our hearts and testifying to our spirits that these books of Holy Scripture are θεοπνευστος (God-breathed), that is, dictated by Him.”
- Franciscus Junius (1545-1602), Opera Theologica 1, Opuscula Theologica Selecta, 117-118
Junius then states that the external testimony is threefold: The first external testimony is Scripture itself or rather God who speaks to us in Scripture and asserts its divine authority. The second is the testimony of the prophets and apostles who have handed over to the church what they received from the Lord. The third is the witness of the church that gives a constant and perpetual consent to Scripture. This third externum testimonium is restricted. Just as Scripture is canonical and authentic in itself (in se), it also appears to be so to us (nobis), and the testimonium of the church is mute and invalid without the testimony of the Spirit. The internal testimonium not only persuades believers that everything in the Scriptures is dictated by God, but also enables them to discern these books from the counterfeit books by a spiritual judgment. After the testimonies Junius mentions eleven arguments from which the authority of the Scriptures also can be concluded. Among these are some of Calvin’s arguments, such as the heavenliness of its doctrine, the unity of its parts, and its antiquity. But he says:
“Although all these arguments bind and force our judgment and strongly prove that Scripture is truly divine, still they absolutely cannot persuade us firmly of this, unless the testimonium of the Holy Spirit comes with them. That alone gives these arguments power and not only forces and presses us, like them, but also awakens our whole mind to assent and fills our hearts with wonderful assurance (πληροφορια) and causes us to embrace Holy Scripture as truly θεοπνευστος (God-breathed).”
- Franciscus Junius (1545-1602), Opera Theologica 1, Opuscula Theologica Selecta, 118
What is said of the arguments can be applied to the external testimonies as well: only the Holy Spirit can give us the full assurance of the divine origin and authority of Scripture.
Saturday, August 17, 2013
Episcopal Priest on "Why You Can Trust Your Bible"
Justin Holcomb|12:01 AM CT
Why You Can Trust Your Bible
It's common to see the argument that the Scriptures we have today aren't the same as what was written by the apostles in the first century. Such arguments attempt to portray the Bible as unreliable and therefore irrelevant. As we will see, however, these challenges do not stand up to scrutiny.
What About Textual Variants?
The Gospels—Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John—were probably written during the second half of the first century. We don't actually have any of the original documents (called autographs) in our possession today. Instead, we have copies, often handwritten by scribes to preserve and circulate the words of the apostles so they could be passed around and used in worship services. The fact the original manuscripts were copied shows how important these writings were to local congregations. However, in the process of copying the manuscripts, scribes often made small changes, some of them unintentional and others intentional.
For example, early copies of the Greek New Testament were composed in an ancient style in which words were written in all capital letters with no spaces, punctuation, or paragraph divisions. A classic illustration of this style is the phrase "GODISNOWHERE." A copyist would have to decide whether the phrase meant "God is now here" or "God is nowhere." Context would determine the meaning of the phrase, so it's not surprising a scribe could occasionally get things wrong. Furthermore, scribes sometimes misspelled words, wrote the same word twice when it should have been written once, or skipped over sections of text because the same words occurred later down the page. These are all examples of unintentional changes.
Other times, however, scribes changed the texts they were copying on purpose. This happened for a variety of reasons. They might make grammatical improvements or liturgical changes (such as adding a doxology), or they might eliminate apparent discrepancies, harmonize passages, or make doctrinal changes. However, even Bart Ehrman, a New Testament scholar who argues against the reliability of the Bible, recognizes, "Most of the changes found in our early Christian manuscripts have nothing to do with theology or ideology. Far and away the most changes are the result of mistakes, pure and simple—slips of the pen, accidental omissions, inadvertent additions, misspelled words, blunders of one sort or another."
Because of the large number of variations in New Testament manuscripts, some argue the words of the New Testament are unreliable. But in fact, the vast number of New Testament manuscripts actually enables us to figure out what the originals said with a great deal of certainty. As Mark Roberts puts it, "Having many manuscripts actually increases the likelihood of our getting back to the original text." Scholars can compare the various manuscripts containing the same passages of Scripture and determine, on the basis of internal and external evidence, which of the manuscripts most likely get the original wording right.
How Does the New Testament Compare to Other Ancient Documents?
The earliest manuscripts of the works of first-century historians such as Josephus, Tacitus, and Suetonius are dated from the 9th to 11th centuries—more than 800 years after the originals were written. In terms of the number of surviving manuscripts, there are 200 for Suetonius, 133 for Josephus, and 75 for Herodotus.
When we compare these ancient texts to the New Testament, the difference astonishes. For instance, the earliest New Testament manuscript is from around AD 125, while significant portions of the Gospels are represented in manuscripts from the late 2nd to early 3rd century. Whereas the best ancient historical works have 500 to 800 years between the actual date the work was written and the date of the earliest surviving manuscript, there is less than a 100-year gap between the writing of the Gospels and the manuscripts we possess. This difference cannot be overstated.
In addition, the sheer number of Gospel manuscripts we've found is staggering in comparison to other ancient works. As Mark Roberts notes, "The number of Gospel manuscripts in existence is about 20 times larger than the average number of extant manuscripts of comparable writings." This figure doesn't even represent the hundreds of thousands of quotes from the Gospels in the writings of the early church fathers. With nearly 2,000 manuscripts of the Gospels in hand, it becomes clear that to doubt the reliability of the Gospels is to doubt the reliability of nearly every ancient text ever found.
Scripture Is Trustworthy and Reliable
Because of who God is, and because of what God has done to preserve his Word, we have confidence the events described in Scripture are accurate and historical. This is important because Christianity, unique among world religions, depends on historical events: particularly Jesus' life, death, and resurrection. As J. Gresham Machen writes, "Christianity is based upon an account of something that happened, and the Christian worker is primarily a witness." Scripture tell us this account, revealing Christianity's climax—its central, historical, and verifiable event: God's gracious act of bringing salvation through the cross of Jesus Christ.
Monday, March 26, 2012
Al Moher Interviews Jimmy Carter on the Bible
http://www.albertmohler.com/2012/03/26/the-bible-meets-the-modern-age-a-conversation-with-former-president-jimmy-carter-2/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+AlbertMohlersBlog+%28Albert+Mohler%27s+Blog%29
The Bible Meets the Modern Age: A Conversation with Former President Jimmy Carter
Today's Thinking in Public program features my interview with former President Jimmy Carter. The conversation was remarkable, and I was honored to have this interview with the 39th President of the United States. The focus of the interview was on the Bible, a book that has framed President Carter’s life from his earliest memories. Even now, he remains the world’s most famous Sunday School teacher.
What makes this conversation so important, however, is the candor of our discussion. President Carter speaks warmly of his love for the Bible, but he also reveals a view of the Bible’s inspiration and authority that rejects inerrancy and opens the door for what he describes as a “selective” application of the Scriptures when it comes to many issues.
President Carter speaks of his boyhood in Georgia, his experience as President of the United States, and his energetic post-presidency.
Related Posts
- The Bible Meets the Modern Age: A Conversation with Former President Jimmy Carter (Audio)
- The Bible Meets the Modern Age: A Conversation with Former President Jimmy Carter
- The Gospel According To Jimmy Carter (Audio)
- Jimmy Carter Revises the Gospel . . . Again
- President Carter Responds to My Commentary
You can listen to The Bible Meets the Modern World: A Conversation with Former President Jimmy Carter, here. Remember to subscribe to Thinking in Public through this website, or through iTunes.
Friday, March 23, 2012
Judicial Hardening & Blindness Imposed: Episcopal Leadership
http://www.virtueonline.org/portal/modules/news/article.php?storyid=15736
By Ladson F. Mills
Special to Virtueonlinewww.virtueonline.org
March 23, 2012
The Episcopal Church has become the personification for what my friends in AA call the definition of insanity; repeating the same behavior over and over again and expecting a different result. In a denomination which has become accustomed to bad news the news grows progressively worse. The Washington Cathedral is a potential casualty following a year that has marked the closings of at least three diocesan cathedrals. Trinity Church Wall Street, arguably the wealthiest single parish in the world, finds itself on the receiving end of unflattering articles concerning finances and its relationship with the rector. Its enormous wealth and prestige has failed to protect it from the collective angst now permeating the Episcopal Church.
In 2000 Jan Nunley, then communications officer for the Diocese of Rhode Island wrote an article admitting the 1990's Decade of Evangelism was more like a Decade of Factionalism. What began with a whimper had ended with a sigh. A further effort by the church to establish a goal of significant growth by 2020 can only be viewed as having been received with a collective yawn. One cannot thrive when the challenge is how does one survive.
Following the 2003 General Convention the Diocese of East Tennessee where I was then serving experienced the institutional insanity which has become our denomination's trademark. Following the vote to confirm Gene Robinson my bishop wrote back to the diocese that although he voted against this confirmation he would stand, applaud and welcome Robinson into the House of Bishops.
The position of our deputies to the convention seemed even more confusing. After being quoted in the local newspaper expressing concern as to the adverse effect their vote to confirm Robinson might have on the diocese, I was immediately challenged by diocesan newspaper editor Sharon Rassmussen. She argued since not all our deputies were in agreement the vote was not unanimous as I had stated. While I could not confirm the accuracy of her statement I could in fact note the deputies from East Tennessee voted to give their consent to approve Gene Robinson as Bishop of New Hampshire. Technical hairsplitting aside this was a source of concern for many members of my parish as well as others throughout the diocese
I found myself experiencing a curious situation. The bishop was creating an impression that although he had voted against Robinson he might actually be supporting him. The diocesan deputation was now trying to create a plausible deniability that while voting to confirm Robinson's election as a bishop they may not truly be in support of him. This may be the poster child for disingenuousness, but it is masterful example of smokescreen and political astuteness. It created enough illusion to keep the conservatives quiet and hopeful they were not being completely disenfranchised.
This philosophy appears to be driving the current debate on the new same sex liturgies in dioceses such as Georgia. The debate is frame worked around theological subtleties such as differences between blessing a relationship and the blessing of a marriage. This is a smokescreen. Conservatives will embrace hope their concerns are being honored while revisionists know it's simply a matter of time. It is hard to fathom anyone doubting that when same sex blessings are approved same sex marriage will soon follow. This type of obfuscation may make for good politics. The question is does it make for good Gospel? "
The Executive Council of the Episcopal Church during its recent meeting received sobering statistics in regard to our continuing decline. Among the most alarming were a 33% national decrease in church school attendance and a 2.5 to 1 ratio of parish closings to openings. We are closing churches and losing our future. Our bishops during their recent meeting at Camp Allen, Texas seem reassured things are better since they found their time together less contentious than usual. One can hardly contain ones relief at such joyous news. Like the AA definition of insanity we are determined to continue the same behavior expecting a different result.
If as the old saying goes there is no lesson in the second kick of a mule our collective heads must be ringing as we approach the 2012 General Convention. We are once again deluding ourselves with the belief that same sex unions and inclusiveness (whatever that is supposed to mean) will somehow turn this disaster around sobering statistics notwithstanding. While House of Deputies President Bonnie Anderson and our Presiding Bishop continue their power struggle one must wonder will there be anyone left to inherit this legacy of our collective insanity.
An increasingly number of bishops, priest and laity across the theological spectrum see this tragic situation for what it is and will admit so privately. I am impressed by their astuteness. Although Bonnie Anderson does easily attract clergy support many have come to view her as the only senior Episcopal Church Leader in a position that affords her the independence necessary to thwart the power grab by the Presiding Bishop and her chancellor. Their use and some would suggest misuse of the canons is designed to force submission through regulation, isolation and control. This has resulted in Anderson receiving an ever increasing number of reluctant and silent supporters among the clergy.
Others, however, note that as bad as the House of Bishops may be they are as a body more conservative and predictable than the House of Deputies. Theology may not be the bishop's strong suit but they do understand the power of the check book. One priest observed that in this climate even his well known revisionist bishop has begun speaking to the need for Christian witness and mission.
So where do we go from here? Do we embrace the legal fictions that make good politics but poor Gospel? Do we wait to see how the turf war between Katherine and Bonnie turns out? Or do we continue on our current path and pray for the continued gift of insanity. It won't produce any different results but at least we can find solace in the fact that it is one thing we continually do well.
Ladson F. Mills III is a retired priest living in South Carolina with over thirty years parish experience. He currently serves as Scholar in Residence at Church of Our Saviour Johns Island.
Friday, March 9, 2012
Justin Taylor: Do Historical Matters Matter to the Faith
Justin Taylor offers this book recommendation. It
looks good. The subject of inerrancy, Biblical authority, sola scriptura,
inspiration and the "International Council on Biblical Inerrancy"
have been subjects of recent musings. Little appears in the popular media
outlets on the subject. In addition to the book below, we strongly recommend
reading the English Reformer, William Whittaker, and his volume, entitled,
"Disputations on Holy Scriptures." The latter volume is available
electronically by a books.google.com search. Here's Justin's post on "Do
Historical Matters Matter to the Faith."
Do Historical Matters Matter to Faith?

Crossway has just published a major new collection of essays from an international team of top-flight scholars on the historicity of Scripture and why it matters to faith: Do Historical Matters Matter to Faith? A Critical Appraisal of Modern and Postmodern Approaches to Scripture, edited by James K. Hoffmeier and Dennis R. Magary.
You can read the table of contents and the commendations below:
Foreword by John Woodbridge
Preface
Part 1: Biblical, Systematic, and Historical Theology:
1. Thomas H. McCall, “Religious Epistemology, Theological Interpretation of Scripture, and Critical Biblical Scholarship: A Theologian’s Reflections”
2. Graham A. Cole, “The Peril of a ‘Historyless’ Systematic Theology”
3. Mark D. Thompson, “The Divine Investment in Truth: Toward a Theological Account of Biblical Inerrancy”
4. James K. Hoffmeier, “‘These Things Happened’: Why a Historical Exodus Is Essential for Theology”
5. Michael A. G. Haykin ,”Fundamentum et Columnam Fidei Nostrae“: Irenaeus on the Perfect and Saving Nature of the Scriptures”
Part 2: Old Testament and Issues of History, Authenticity, and Authority
6. Richard E. Averbeck, “Pentateuchal Criticism and the Priestly Torah”
7. Robert B. Chisholm Jr., “Old Testament Source Criticism: Some Methodological Miscues”
8. Robert D. Bergen, “Word Distribution as an Indicator Authorial Intention: A Study of Gen. 1:1-2:3″
9. John W. Hilber, “The Culture of Prophecy and Writing in the Ancient Near East”
10. Richard L. Schultz , “Isaiah, Isaiahs, and Current Scholarship”
11. Alan Millard, “Daniel in Babylon: An Accurate Record?”
12. Willem A. VanGemeren & Jason Stanghalle, “A Critical-Realistic Reading of Psalms Titles: Authenticity, Inspiration and Evangelicals”
13. Jens Bruun Kofoed, “The Old Testament as Cultural Memory”
Part 3: New Testament and Issues of History, Authenticity, and Authority
14. Robert W. Yarborugh, “God’s Word in Human Words: Form-Critical Reflections”
15. Craig L. Blomberg, “A Constructive Traditional Response to New Testament Criticism”
16. Darrell L. Bock, “Precision and Accuracy: Making Distinctions in the Cultural Context that Give Us Pause in Pitting Gospels Against Other”
17. Eckhard J. Schnabel, “Paul, Timothy, and Titus: The Assumption of a Pseudonymous Author and of Pseudonymous Recipients in the Light of Literary, Theological, and Historical Evidence”
18. Thomas W. Davis, “Saint Paul on Cyprus: The Transformation of an Apostle”
Part 4: The Old Testament and Archaeology
19. John M. Monson, “Enter Joshua: The Mother of Current Biblical Debates”
20. Richard S. Hess, “Yahweh’s ‘Wife’ and Belief in One God in the Old Testament”
21. Michael G. Hasel, “New Excavations at Khirbet Qeiyafa and the Early History of Judah”
22. Steven M. Ortiz, “The Archaeology of David and Solomon: Method or Madness?”
Here are a few of the endorsements:
—D. A. Carson, Research Professor of New Testament, Trinity Evangelical Divinity School
—Philip Graham Ryken, President, Wheaton College
—Ravi Zacharias, Founder and President, Ravi Zacharias International Ministries; author, Jesus Among Other Gods
—Raymond C. Ortlund Jr., Lead Pastor, Immanuel Church, Nashville, Tennessee
—John Oswalt , Distinguished Professor of Old Testament, Asbury Theological Seminary
—David S. Dockery, President, Union University
—Timothy George, Founding Dean, Beeson Divinity School; General Editor, Reformation Commentary on Scripture
—Daniel I. Block, Gunther H. Knoedler Professor of Old Testament, Wheaton College; author, The Gospel according to Moses: Theological and Ethical Reflections on the Book of Deuteronomy
—C. Hassell Bullock, Pastor, Warren Park Presbyterian Church, Cicero, Illinois; Franklin S. Dyrness Professor of Biblical Studies Emeritus, Wheaton College
—Duane A. Garrett, Professor of Old Testament, The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary; author, A Modern Grammar for Biblical Hebrew and Amos: A Handbook on the Hebrew Text
—David M. Howard Jr., Professor of Old Testament, Bethel University, St. Paul, Minnesota
Thursday, March 8, 2012
Francis Turretin: "Scriptural and Patristic Testimony to the Holy Spirit's Illumination and Scripture's Self-Authenticating Power
---------------------------------------
In the comment box of a previous post, Pastor David King provided the following Scriptural and patristic testimony to the Holy Spirit's inward illumination of believers and Scripture's self-authenticating character, to which I've made some minor edits:
The canon of Scripture is an artifact of revelation rather than an object of revelation. By "artifact" I mean something that is a feature not normally present but visible as a result of an external agent or action.
While the Romanist treats the canon as an object of revelation, it is the result (hence an "artifact") of revelation. In other words, the canonical list of the books of Holy Scripture are the result of God's revelatory work, and not the object of what God has revealed.
A Christian's recognition of these books is result of God's working in him to will and to believe.
I believe 1) Scripture's own witness of its inspiration, and 2) that God confirms that by the illuminating power of the Holy Spirit. I drawn a distinction (as the Reformers did before me) between the Spirit's revelatory work and his illuminating work.
In his work, Against the Epistle of Manichaeus Called Fundamental, Chapter 14, Augustine made this point.
Augustine (354-430) in response to Manichaeus:
You can find nothing better than to praise your own faith and ridicule mine. So, after having in my turn praised my belief and ridiculed yours, what result do you think we shall arrive at as regards our judgment and our conduct, but to part company with those who promise the knowledge of indubitable things, and then demand from us faith in doubtful things? while we shall follow those who invite us to begin with believing what we cannot yet fully perceive, that, strengthened by this very faith, we may come into a position to know what we believe by the inward illumination and confirmation of our minds, due no longer to men, but to God Himself.Latin text:Nihil aliud elegisti, nisi laudare quod credis, et irridere quod credo. Cum igitur etiam ego vicissim laudavero quod credo, et quod credis irrisero; quid putas nobis esse judicandum, quidve faciendum, nisi ut eos relinquamus, qui nos invitant certa cognoscere, et postea imperant ut incerta credamus; et eos sequamur, qui nos invitant prius credere, quod nondum valemus intueri, ut ipsa fide valentiores facti, quod credimus intelligere mereamur, non jam hominibus, sed ipso Deo intrinsecus mentem nostram illuminante atque firmante?
Citation: Augustine, Contra Epistolam Manichaei Quam vocant Fundamenti, Liber Unus, Caput XIV, PL 42:183; translation in NPNF1: Vol. IV, Against the Epistle of Manichaeus Called Fundamental, Chapter 14.
We acknowledge with Augustine that the Church is most often the initial and outward means by which men are called to faith in Christ, but God brings us to the place (as Augustine put it) "to know what we believe by the inward illumination and confirmation of our minds, due no longer to men, but to God Himself."
Scripture itself furnishes us with clear illustration of this in the fourth chapter of John’s gospel. After having dealings with Christ, the woman of Samaria returns to her city, and there bears witness to Christ.
John 4:39-42
And many of the Samaritans of that city believed in Him because of the word of the woman who testified, “He told me all that I ever did.”
So when the Samaritans had come to Him, they urged Him to stay with them; and He stayed there two days. And many more believed because of His own word.
Then they said to the woman, “Now we believe, not because of what you said, for we ourselves have heard Him and we know that this is indeed the Christ, the Savior of the world.”
The point this passage illustrates is this - that though it was the woman’s witness which initially induced belief in Christ, nonetheless, the confirmation of their faith came to rest in the testimony of Christ’s own word. While the woman’s witness was true and sufficiently credible to move the inhabitants of the city, it does not follow that she became the infallible bulwark of their subsequent faith. The inhabitants of the city came to rest not in her word, but Christ’s own word.
Likewise, though the Church (or the witness of an individual Christian) is often the initial and outward means by which men are called to faith in Christ, it does not follow that this renders the church or the individual Christian with the attribute of infallibility.
God's own word is a spiritual reality which is sufficient to create faith in itself. No church or human being is able to accomplish that supernatural work.
The Apostle John wrote, “If we receive the witness of men, the witness of God is greater; for this is the witness of God which He has testified of His Son” (1 Jn. 5:9).
Needing no support, the witness of God stands by itself. God’s own testimony is decisive and inexpugnable. If Holy Scripture is in reality the God-breathed word, then it must be self-authenticating, and in need of no human sanction. It is nothing less than a compromise of the integrity of God’s own witness to presuppose Scripture to be anything other than the living oracles of the Creator and Redeemer of mankind. To hold in suspension, as it were, the question of God’s speaking in Scripture until some external, authoritative criterion outside of God himself is applied as the deliberative, decisive court of appeal is a de facto assault on the truth that “the witness of God is greater.”
Chrysostom (349-407): Besides, what benefit would there be in a homily when prayer has not been joined to it? Prayer stands in the first place; then comes the word of instruction. And that is what the apostles said: "Let us devote ourselves to prayer and the ministry of the word." Paul does this when he prays at the beginning of his epistles so that, like the light of a lamp, the light of prayer may prepare the way for the word. If you accustom yourselves to pray fervently, you will not need instruction from your fellow servants because God himself, with no intermediary, enlightens you mind.
Citation: John Chrysostom, FC, Vol. 72, On the Incomprehensible Nature of God, Homily 3.35, (Washington, D.C.: The Catholic University of America Press, 1984), pp. 111.
We have strong precedent in the some works of the Early Church Fathers (ECFs) that indicate there was also in their time a recognition of the fact that God's word is self-authenticating. Some examples of this precedent are shown below.
Nemesius of Emesa (around the end of the 4th century):
But for us the sufficient demonstration of the soul’s immortality is the teaching of Holy Scripture, which is self-authenticating because inspired of God.Greek text:
ἡμῖν δὲ ἀρκεῖ, πρὸς ἀπόδειξιν τῆς ἀθανασίας αὐτῆς, ἡ τῶν θεῖων λογῖων διδασκαλία, τὸ πιστὸν ἀθ’ ἐαυτῆς ἔχουσα, διὰ τὸ θεόπνευστος εἶναι•Citation: Nemesius of Emesa, De Natura Hominis, Caput II.18, Migne PG 40:589; translation in William Telfer, ed., The Library of Christian Classics, Vol. IV, Cyril of Jerusalem and Nemesius of Emesa: On the Nature of Man, Chapter 2 Of the Soul (Philadelphia: The Westminster Press, 1955), p. 292. (It is believed that Nemesius of Emesa wrote this work sometime between A.D. 392-400.)
Salvian the Presbyter (5th century):
I need not prove by arguments what God Himself proves by His own words. When we read that God says He perpetually sees the entire earth, we prove thereby that He does see it because He Himself says He sees it. When we read that He rules all things He has created, we prove thereby that He rules, since He testifies that He rules. When we read that He ordains all things by His immediate judgment, it becomes evident by this very fact, since He confirms that He passes judgment. All other statements, said by men, require proofs and witnesses. God’s word is His own witness, because whatever uncorrupted Truth says must be the undefiled testimony to truth.Latin text:
Neque enim necesse est ut argumentis a me probetur quod hoc ipso quia a Deo dicitur comprobatur. Itaque cum legimus dictum a Deo quia aspiciat jugiter omnem terram, hoc ipso probamus quod aspicit quia aspicere se dicit; cum legimus quod regat cuncta quae fecit, hoc ipso approbamus quod regit, quia se regere testatur; cum legimus quod praesenti judicio universa dispenset, hoc ipso est evidens quod judicat quia se judicare confirmat. Alia enim omnia, id est, humana dicta, argumentis ac testibus egent. Dei autem sermo ipse sibi testis est, quia necesse est quidquid incorrupta veritas loquitur, incorruptum sit testimonium veritatis.Citation: Salvian the Presbyter, Sancti Salviani Massiliensis Presbyteri De Gubernatione Dei, Liber Tertius, I, PL 53:1567; translation in FC, Vol. 3, The Writings of Salvian, The Presbyter, The Governance of God, Book 3.1 (New York: CIMA Publishing Co., Inc., 1947), pp. 68-69.
Epiphanius of Salamis (310/320-403):
But the truth is always steadfast and needs no assistance. It is self-authenticating, and always established in the sight of the true God.Greek text:
τῆς ἀληθείας ἀεὶ ἑδραίας οὔσης καὶ μὴ χρείαν ἐχούσης βοηθείας, ἀλλὰ αὐτοσυστάτου οὔσης καὶ παρὰ θεῷ τῷ ὄντως ὄντι ἀεὶ συνιστωμένης.Citation: Epiphanius of Salamis, Adversus Haereses, Liber I, Tom. III, XLIV, §1, PG 41:821; translation by Frank Williams, trans., The Panarion of Epiphanius of Salamis: Book I (Sects 1-46) 44. Against Apelleans, 1,3 (Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1994), p. 340.
Epiphanius (310/320-403):
The truth is self-authenticating and cannot be overthrown even if wickedness shamelessly opposes the precept of truth.Greek text:
αὐτοσυστάτης οὔσης τῆς ἀληθείας, καὶ μὴ δυναμένης καθαιρεῖσθαι, κἄν τε ἀντιπράττοι ἡ ἀνομία ἀναισχυντίᾳ φερομένη τῷ τῆς ἀληθείας θεσμῷ,Citation: Epiphanius of Salamis, Adversus Haereses, Liber II, Tom. II, LXVI, §10, PG 42:44; translated by Frank Williams, trans., The Panarion of Epiphanius of Salamis, Books II and III (Sects 47-80, De Fide), 66. Against Manichaeans, 10,4 (Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1994), p. 230.
Clement of Alexandria (150 - c. 215):
It will naturally fall after these, after a cursory view of theology, to discuss the opinions handed down respecting prophecy; so that, having demonstrated that the Scriptures which we believe are valid from their omnipotent authority, we shall be able to go over them consecutively, and to show thence to all the heresies one God and Omnipotent Lord to be truly preached by the law and the prophets, and besides by the blessed Gospel.Greek text:
Οἷς ἑπόμενον ἂν εἴη μετὰ τὴν ἐπιδρομὴν τῆς θεολογίας τὰ περὶ προφητείας παραδεδομένα διαλαβεῖν, ὡς καὶ τὰς γραφὰς αἷς πεπιστεύκαμεν κυρίας οὔσας ἐξ αὐθεντείας παντοκρατορικῆς ἐπιδείξαντας προϊέναι διʼ αὐτῶν εἱρμῷ δύνασθαι, καὶ ἁπάσαις ἐντεῦθεν ταῖς αἱρέσεσιν ἕνα δεικνύναι Θεὸν, καὶ Κύριον παντοκράτορα τὸν διὰ νόμου καὶ προφητῶν, πρὸς δὲ καὶ τοῦ μακαρίου εὐαγγελίου γνησίως κεκηρυγμένον.Citation: Clement of Alexandria, Stromata, Liber IV, Caput 1, PG 8:1216; translation in ANF: Vol. II, The Stromata, Book IV, Chapter 1.
Lactantius (260-330):
For it was not befitting that, when God was speaking to man, He should confirm His words by arguments, as though He would not otherwise be regarded with confidence: but, as it was right, He spoke as the mighty Judge of all things, to whom it belongs not to argue, but to pronounce sentence.Latin text:
Nес enim decebat ut cum deus ad hominem loqueretur, argumentis adsereret suas voces, tamquam aliter fides ei non haberetur, sed ut oportuit locutus est tamquam rerum omnium maximus iudex, cuius est non argumentari, sed pronuntiare.Citation: Lactantius, L. Caeli Firmiani Lactanti Opera omnia, Volume 19 (in Corpus Scriptorum Ecclesiasticorum Latinorum, Samuel Brandt Editor)(F. Tempsky, 1890), p. 197, lines 4-8; translation in ANF: Vol. VII, The Divine Institutes, Book III, Chapter I. See also FC, Vol. 49, The Divine Institutes, Book III, Chapter 1 (Washington D.C.: The Catholic University Press, 1963), pp. 165-166. Alternative translation:
... when God was addressing man, addition of arguments to his words, as if he would not otherwise be believed, was not appropriate; he spoke as the supreme judge of all creation ought to speak, his business being not discussion but declaration.Citation: Lactantius: Divine institutes, Volume 40 of Translated Texts for Historians, Bowen et al. ed. (Liverpool University Press, 2003), p. 169 at 11
These ECFs, to name a few, are examples in the ancient church who (like us) believed Scripture to be self-authenticating.


