Reformed Churchmen

We are Confessional Calvinists and a Prayer Book Church-people. In 2012, we remembered the 350th anniversary of the 1662 Book of Common Prayer; also, we remembered the 450th anniversary of John Jewel's sober, scholarly, and Reformed "An Apology of the Church of England." In 2013, we remembered the publication of the "Heidelberg Catechism" and the influence of Reformed theologians in England, including Heinrich Bullinger's Decades. For 2014: Tyndale's NT translation. For 2015, John Roger, Rowland Taylor and Bishop John Hooper's martyrdom, burned at the stakes. Books of the month. December 2014: Alan Jacob's "Book of Common Prayer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Book-Common-Prayer-Biography-Religious/dp/0691154813/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1417814005&sr=8-1&keywords=jacobs+book+of+common+prayer. January 2015: A.F. Pollard's "Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation: 1489-1556" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-English-Reformation-1489-1556/dp/1592448658/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1420055574&sr=8-1&keywords=A.F.+Pollard+Cranmer. February 2015: Jaspar Ridley's "Thomas Cranmer" at: http://www.amazon.com/Thomas-Cranmer-Jasper-Ridley/dp/0198212879/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1422892154&sr=8-1&keywords=jasper+ridley+cranmer&pebp=1422892151110&peasin=198212879

Showing posts with label Archbishop Rowan Williams. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Archbishop Rowan Williams. Show all posts

Friday, February 28, 2014

Abstract: Mr. (Canterbury) Rowan Williams' D.Phil Dissertation, Oxford University

http://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:15b86a5d-21f4-44a3-95bb-b8543d326658


Reference: Rowan Douglas Williams, (1975). The theology of Vladimir Nikolaievich Lossky: an exposition and critique. DPhil. University of Oxford.


Citable link to this page: http://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:15b86a5d-21f4-44a3-95bb-b8543d326658
 
Title: The theology of Vladimir Nikolaievich Lossky: an exposition and critique


Abstract:  Part 1. Chapter 1. Introduction: the Man and his work. The intellectual life of Russia at the turn of the century was marked by a lively interest in religious questions, and, in some circles, a cautious rapprochement between the intelligentsia and the Orthodox Church. Vladimir Lossky was born into an academic environment which looked more sympathetically upon traditional Christianity than had previously been usual: and the fact of his being brought up in a household both academic and (articulately and critically) Christian tends to set him apart from the religious thinkers of his father's generation (Bulgakov, Berdyaev, and others) who had discovered, or rediscovered, Orthodox faith in adult life after experiencing disillusion with radicalism or Idealism, or both. Lossky's first major theological essay was, in fact, directed against the ethos of Russian 'religious philosophy', especially its preoccupation with the Wisdom of God (Sophia) as a cosmic principle. In this, as in later works, he pleads for a theology rooted in the historical experience of the Church and free from philosophical systems. His commitment to the 'historical experience' of the Church is reflected in his lifelong allegiance to the Patriarchate of Moscow as the only canonically authoritative Russian ecclesial body. His thinking on the relation between Church and culture was clarified in his experiences in the Second War, which also brought him into close association with several Catholic theologians. It was in this context that he first attempted a synthetic presentation of Orthodox dogma in his best-known work, the 'Essai sur la théologie mystique de l'Eglise d'Orient'. In the post-war period he continued his professional work as a mediaevalist at the Sorbonne, but continued to write on theological questions, developing, in particular, a distinctive approach to the concept of the human person and to the catholicity of the Church. He was much involved in ecumenical gatherings in France and England, and, in Paris, up to the time of his death, assisted in the training of clergy for the Patriarchal jurisdiction (though his hopes for the development of a western-rite group were frustrated).


Chapter 2: The debate with Bulgakov. Superficially, Lossky's theology has much in common with that of Sergei Bulgakov, especially in their attitudes to tradition and catholicity, and Lossky's hostility to Bulgakov is surprising. However, a brief examination of Bulgakov's thought reveals its extensive dependence upon the notion of 'Sophia', the Divine Wisdom, as an all-embracing cosmic reality, both divine and human - a notion which Lossky rejects absolutely as deterministic, destructive of a proper sense of both divine and human freedom. He also condemns Bulgakov's Christology: the idea of 'Godmanhood', fundamental to Bulgakov's theology, jeopardises the reality of Christ's humanity, and tends to reduce the Incarnation to a manifestation of cosmic process. The basic theme of Lossky's critique is that Bulgakov's system, in Christology, ecclesiology, and Trinitarian theology, is dominated by metaphysical presuppositions incompatible with orthodox belief: it is insufficiently apophatic, too preoccupied with concepts. Lossky's own theology shows a marked and conscious reaction away from this kind of conceptualism.


Chapter 3. The Via Negativa. The 'negative way' is not, for Lossky, merely a dialectical step in theology, a 'corrective' to affirmative theology: it is the essential ground of all theology. Theology beings in personal encounter with a personal God, an encounter which cannot be expressed in concepts; negative theology, which declines to speak of God in concepts, most closely reflects this basic reality. It is the μετάνοια, the conversion and self-sacrifice, of the intellect. The Greek patristic language about meeting God in 'darkness' is simply a 'dogmatic metaphor' for this experience, complementing, not contradicting the imagery of 'light': darkness and light together here represent the experience of transcending the sphere of the intellect. The history of early Christian spirituality shows a gradual movement towards a via media between intellectualism and agnosticism, a position which allows for both the absolute incomprehensibility of God in seipso, and His accessibility to man. This via media is expressed most fully by Gregory Palamas, but is anticipated by the Cappadocians, pseudo-Dionysius, and Maximus. It envisages God 'transcending His transcendence, expressing His unknowable 'essence' in His 'energies', His manifestation in the world. God's self-transcendence calls forth man's 'ecstacy'. The personal encounter of man with God is a mutual movement of self-giving: man is nearest to God and so most fully God-like in this movement. And since God is always fully personal, man is therefore most personal in the act of self-renunciation: negative theology alone is adequately 'personalist'.


Chapter 4. Imago Trinitatis. Man is in the image of God because he is personal: he cannot be reduced to his 'nature', to what is common, repeatable and conceptualisable. He is more than an individual of a species; and this constitutes him in the image of God's trinitarian life, in which individuality is perfectly transcended in full communion. The Church, in which man realises his capacity for communion can also be called imago Trinitatis: it is a plurality of persons, each called and sanctified in a unique manner by the Spirit, sharing one nature, the humanity which Christ has restored and 'deified'. This 'trinitarian' life is what is designated by the term 'catholicity', the existence of the whole in the part. Lossky's method in discussing the theology of personality is resolutely Christocentric: the impossibility of interpreting ὑπόστᾰσις as 'individual' is established by an appeal to the inadmissibility of so interpreting it in Christology. Lossky's appeal to the Fathers in support of this thesis is, however, problematic: his concern to include the body in the imago Dei, and his understanding of ὑπόστᾰσις both lack a clear and consistent patristic foundation. Although he does genuinely build upon certain Greek patristic ideas, he is, as a 'personalist', essentially and inevitably - a -post-Augustinian'. The ambiguity of the patristic evidence raises the serious question of how far Lossky is justified in criticising Western theology (as he does) according to alledgedly patristic criteria.


Chapter 5: The debate with the West (i). Lossky presupposes the unity of Christian theology; if one doctrinal topic is infected with error, the whole theological system is poisoned. In the West, it is the doctrine of the double procession of the Spirit, the filioque, which is the basic error: it suggests that the Spirit is somehow less personal than the Son, rejects the patristic idea that the Father is the sole source of 'cause' of the other persons, and so makes the unity of the Trinity reside not in the person of the Father but in a super-personal 'essence', that which is common to Father and Son. Western theology opts for a divine essence, in place of the living God of revelation: it is as much in thrall to philosophy as Bulgakov's system. Consequently, it is consistently impersonalist, not only in Trinitarian theology, but in its ecclesiology, its doctrine of grace, and its ascetical theology. Protestantism is as much conditioned as Catholicism by the basic assumption implicit in the filioque that real communion, sharing (in some sense) of substance, is impossible between God and man, because both are encapsulated in their 'essences'. Historically, Lossky's critique is often inaccurate and unjust; but he makes a good case, nonetheless, for the dominance, in much of Western theology, of conceptualism and impersonalism. There is little to correspond to Lossky's profound apophoticism and 'kenotic' idea of personality


Chapter 6: The debate with the West (ii). For Lossky, the Palamite distinction of 'essence' from 'energy' is one of the most important safeguards in Eastern theology against a philosophical essentialism. The scholastic's rejection of Palamism is of a piece with his defence of the filioque. Palamism asserts that God communicates Himself fully to creation in His 'energies', although His 'essence' remains incomprehensible and imparticipable: but the energies are not merely relative to creation, since God eternally acts, is eternally έν ένεργειας. Closer examination reveals a good deal of logical strain in Lossky's language on this subject, traceable to some serious philosophical confusions in Palamas himself and his precursors. There is, in particular, a certain vacillation between a (broadly) Platonic and a (broadly) Aristotelean understanding of oὐσία. Lossky seems, at least in later years, to have been aware of some of these confusions, and attempts a cautious restatement, connecting the energies far more closely with God's personal act of self-transcendence and self-renunciation. And this lends him to modify and clarify his ideas on the filioque, allowing a sense in which it may be affirmed with references to the complete mutual dependence of all three persons in their activity towards each other, and towards creation.


Conclusion to Part I. The central theme in Lossky's theology is a particular model of personality, divine and human, as 'kenotic', fulfilled in absolute self-giving. While this idea has some roots in patristic thought, it is quite clearly indebted to other and later sources. It is therefore desirable to turn to a brief examination of Lossky's immediate background in Russian philosophy, identifying some of its basic concerns in order to assess how far Lossky may be said to stand within the same tradition.


Part II. Chapter 7: The definition of an ethos: Kireevsky to Soloviev. Philosophy in Russia began to develop only in the 19th century. The problems of historical and national identity created by the Petrine reforms perhaps predisposed the Russians to Hegelianism, a philosophy very much rooted in a sense of historical conflict: the basic question of much 19th century Russian thought is the issue between voluntarism and historical determinism - that is, the problem of the relation of individual identity to corporate identity, of individual volition to corporate process. Russian religious philosophy attempts to discover a point of equilibrium between individualism and collectivism, a kind of personalism, in fact, which resolves the tension between the particular and the general by seeing the general in the particular. Different philosophers incline to different sorts of solution, depending largely upon whether they are (like Kireevsky) more concerned with the history and self-awareness of the Church (in which case they will tend to a very radical voluntarism), or (like Soloviev, and, to a lesser extent, Khomyakov) more interested in global or cosmic patterns (in which case they will tend to some sort of determinism). Soloviev's use of the myth of 'Sophia' was to have an immense influence on those thinkers inclined to the latter school. By the turn of the century, the tension between the impulse to voluntarism and the metaphysical attraction of 'sophiology' has become acute.


Chapter 8: essays in synthesis. Various attempts to reconcile these two concerns were made. The brothers Trubetskoi, despite a large debt to Soloviev, move towards a voluntarist and 'historicist' position; Pavel Florensky, while extending the 'sophiological' world-view, insists equally upon the unique value of the individual. He is particularly violently opposed to any kind of theological rationalism and stresses the importance of paradox and antinomy. This is stated still more strongly by Berdyaev, who, however, rejects the whole apparatus of sophiology in an extreme form of personalism. The 'hierarchical personalism' of Nikolai Lossky (Vladimir's father) moves back towards determinism; S. L. Frank adopts an unconventional, but in some ways deeply traditional, approach to the absolute value of the person, but is still hampered by the legacy of sophiology. Losev attempts to develop a form of Neo-Kantianism based on the apophatic recognition of the incomprehensibility of particular, concrete and living, substances. Karsavin (Lossky's teacher at Petersburg) despite his highly personalist and voluntarist understanding of the Fathers, generally presents a very impersonalist metaphysical approach. No satisfactory resolution of the tensions identified seems to have been possible within the terms of the tradition dependent on Hegelianism and sophiology.


Chapter 9: the ecclesiastical tradition. Not all Russian religious thinkers, however, were identified with this tradition. An 'alternative theology', more dependent on Scripture and the Fathers, and closely associated with monastic groups, existed, represented by men like Philaret of Moscow and Antony of Kiev (or earlier philosophers, Kireevsky is closest to this school). Philaret's emphasis on kenosis, not only in the Incarnation, but in the eternal life of the Trinity, is of great importance for Lossky (and others); and in Antony's works, we find a clear statement of the doctrine of man-in-the-Church as imago Trinitatis, and of a mature personalism and apophaticism strikingly close to Lossky's thought. The major spokesman of this school in the 20th century is Georges Florovsky, who argues for a 're-Hellenisation' of theology and a 'neopatristic synthesis'. Although close to Lossky in many respects (his early writings influenced Lossky a good deal), he lays less emphasis on the person as such, and more on the radical freedom which characterises the person. There are also important differences between their views on the relation between Christ, the Spirit, and the Church. Generally, Florovsky is far closer than Lossky to the ipsissima verba patrum, less willing to revise or extend patristic concepts: Lossky appears as the more original mind of the two.


Conclusion. The scope of Lossky's theological synthesis is considerably wider than he himself would have admitted. His work presupposes the continuing debate within Russian religious thought sketched in the preceding chapters, and incorporates the more positive intuitions of this tradition of theistic metaphysics. Lossky's hostility to the conceptual mechanisms of Russian religious philosophy should not blind the student to the extent of his debt to the tradition. To deny this debt is to deny a great part of the creativity and comprehensive vision of Lossky's system, his ability to transcend patrological fundamentalism in a theology which is, in every sense, personal.

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

(Virtueonline): Bp. Justin Welby Chosen for Abp of Canterbury

http://www.virtueonline.org/portal/modules/news/article.php?storyid=16777

 
Bishop of Durham Justin Welby to be Archbishop of Canterbury


By John Bingham, and Jonathan Wynne-Jones
The Telegraph

http://www.telegraph.co.uk
http://bit.ly/Ulnijz


It marks a meteoric rise for the former oil executive who has been a bishop for only a year, but insiders described Welby as "the outstanding candidate".

Last night a spokesman refused to confirm his appointment. But it came a few hours after he pulled out at short notice from a planned appearance on the BBC Radio 4 discussion programme Any Questions due to take place in County Durham on Friday. He also cut short a retreat with diocesan staff and returned to the capital where it is understood his wife is travelling down to join him tomorrow.

Earlier this week bookmakers stopped taking money on Bishop Welby after a flurry of bets on him being chosen.

Sources in Canterbury earlier attempted to play down the expectation, with one even suggesting that they had been “surprised” that it was not him.

Although one of the front-runners since the beginning of the process there had been doubts over whether Bishop Welby had been a bishop for long enough. He took over at Durham just a year ago having previously been Dean of Liverpool.

There were also questions over whether an Eton-educated Archbishop would be well received in some quarters.

It is thought that the questions played a part in delaying the final decision although it is also thought his family were reluctant to be drawn into the limelight.

Dr John Sentamu The Archbishop of York, was the early favourite for the post and and the Bishops of Coventry, Norwich and Liverpool were also widely tipped.

But the choice of the 56-year-old to lead the world's 77 million Anglicans marks a decisive break with the past for the Church.

While his predecessors have drawn on long and distinguished careers as academics or clerics, his experience is of the world of mammon as much as God.

A former oil executive he gave up a highly paid career after feeling a “call” to the priesthood in the late 1980s.

“Something in me just said ‘this is what you should be doing’,” he recently explained.

He was able to draw on years of experience in oil exploration in troubled areas of west Africa, when his ministry led him to work in conflict resolution in the violent Niger Delta, where he narrowly avoided being shot dead.

At a time when the Church is grappling with the aftermath of the banking crisis, he combines - almost uniquely – an understanding of the working of the City with that of life in the inner city, gleaned as a parish priest and Dean of Liverpool.

He has used his seat in the Lords as a platform to challenge the “sins” of the multi-billion pound banks as much as the small-scale pay-day “loan sharks" he has seen at work on the North East - condemning the practice in the language of the Old Testament as “usury”.

Although Educated at Eton and Cambridge and even a member of a Pall Mall club, he is seen as far from an establishment figure.

Theologically, he is unashamedly part of the evangelical tradition, upholding a more traditional and conservative interpretation of the Bible than some in the Church of England.

But he is also a strong advocate of more modern styles of worship.

Dr Williams is also due back in London tomorrow after almost two weeks abroad, visiting Papua New Guinea before attending a meeting of world Anglican leaders in New Zealand.

Speaking in Auckland yesterday, at what aides said would be his final press conference, he was asked for advice for his successor.

Quoting the theologian Karl Barth, he said that the new Archbishop should preach “with a Bible in one hand and a newspaper in the other”.

He said that it was vital that whoever is named must be able to make his message relevant to modern life and “like” reading newspapers.

"You have to be cross-referencing all the time and saying, 'How does the vision of humanity and community in the Bible map onto these issues of poverty, privation, violence and conflict?'

“And you have to use what you read in the newspaper to prompt and direct the questions that you put to the Bible: 'Where is this going to help me?'

“So I think somebody who likes reading the Bible and likes reading newspapers would be a good start."

END

Monday, October 8, 2012

UK: Archbishop panel split over Church's future

http://www.virtueonline.org/portal/modules/news/article.php?storyid=16625

Posted by David Virtue on 2012/10/8 16:50:00 (104 reads)
 
UK: Archbishop panel split over Church's future
The panel meeting to appoint the successor to Dr Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury, is split over the future of the Church

Niine days after the successor to Dr Rowan Williams should have been named, the 16 men and women of the Crown Nominations Commission have remained silent Photo: CLARA MOLDEN

By Cole Moreton, and Edward Malnick
THE TELEGRAPH
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/
Oct 6, 2012
It is the decision that 77 million Anglicans around the world are waiting for: who will become the next Archbishop of Canterbury.

But nine days after the successor to Dr Rowan Williams was expected to have been named, the Crown Nominations Commission remains silent.

Its work is shrouded in secrecy, but a Sunday Telegraph investigation can reveal that its 16 members are split, not over women bishops or same sex marriages, but the future of the Church itself.

A substantial number of people on the panel would like a man who will reform the structures, finance and strategies of the Church of England and help "re-imagine" it for the modern age.

Their favourite is the Rt Rev Justin Welby, Bishop of Durham, a 56-year-old former oil company executive, who is seen as the front-runner.

He is believed to have been chosen as the first of two names to be put to the Prime Minister and, ultimately, the Queen. However, the commission is divided about who the other man should be.

The plain-speaking Archbishop of York, Dr John Sentamu, has supporters who see him as a different kind of reformer, appealing to people beyond the Church and bringing energy and directness to the effort to arrest the decline in membership. The appointment to Canterbury of a man born in Uganda would also please many of the 77 million people in the worldwide Anglican Communion.

Other panel members argue for the steadying hand of a caretaker Archbishop who will keep the Church close to the Crown and state, such as the Rt Rev Graham James, Bishop of Norwich. "This is about whether we go for the establishment status quo or go for a radical vision of what the Church is and how it should work," said a source close to members of the commission.

The process is being kept so secret that Church officials cannot say whether, or when, the panel will meet again.

However, the Telegraph has learned that its work has been delayed by at least a fortnight.

At the end of last month, after three intense days of meetings at a retreat centre in Woking, Surrey, one member of the commission asked for time away.

And the leading candidate, Bishop Welby, is due to go away this week, making himself unavailable until mid-October.

The source said: "I know that they have abandoned meeting for at least a fortnight."

The process of choosing the new Archbishop began in March with a widespread appeal for people of all faiths and none to give their opinions. This was followed by a lockdown when the commission began to meet in May.

Members have now met for seven days over five months, although they have been ordered to reveal nothing about their discussions.

One former member of the panel said the new Archbishop was being chosen by a process of elimination. Once a number of candidates have been chosen, they are ranked in order of preference by members in a blind vote. The name with the least votes drops out. The panel then votes again, and again, until one man has the 11 votes necessary for a two-thirds majority.

By convention, the Prime Minister will propose that the Queen appoints the first name as the next Archbishop. But a second candidate must be supplied, in case the first cannot take the post or turns it down.

That means after the first name is chosen the process begins again, with all the others thrown back into the ring, as well as any candidates that members may wish to reconsider.

Some leading Anglicans are saying that if the deadlock continues, Downing Street will have to intervene.

Anthony Archer, a former commission member, said that would be "ignominious".

But he added: "If the commission remains deadlocked, the constitutional realities are that this is a Crown appointment. Only the Prime Minister can unlock it."

The 16 panel members include six from the General Synod, the governing body of the Church, and six from the diocese of Canterbury. The House of Bishops has two representatives but there is only one for the worldwide Anglican Communion, Dr Barry Morgan, the Archbishop of Wales.

His liberal views are hardly representative of the communion, which is dominated by evangelicals who take a hard line on issues such as homosexuality.

The chairman is Lord Luce, a former Tory cabinet minister who was appointed by Downing Street. There have been suggestions of the so-called Canterbury Six acting together to block or promote candidates. At least nine members of the commission seem likely to be in favour of a reformer,

"The Church of England is at a crossroads, but the roads do not fall according to the usual tribal lines of evangelicals, Anglo-Catholics and liberals," said one leading Anglican.

"They fall along the lines of who are those who want a safe pair of hands - the 'steady as she goes, let's just keep the ship afloat and heading in the same direction' view - and those who have a much bigger vision of what God might be doing."

The Church has agreed three goals for the coming century: to grow, in terms of congregations and spiritual depth; to focus resources where there is most need and opportunity; and "to reshape or re-imagine the Church's ministry" so there is a Christian witness in every local community.

However, the Church no longer has the priests, the people or the money to have a paid member of the clergy in every parish church. There are many who believe that it is time for a rethink.

The Bishop of Durham has already defined himself as a reformer, having begun to change the funding of his diocese in an innovative way.

Instead of telling the parishes how much they have to contribute to the diocese, Bishop Welby wants "a complete upending of the system" so that they say how much they can afford, which is used to set the budget.

His youth and education at Eton may count against him in some people's eyes, however.

As a second choice, the reformers have considered the Bishop of Liverpool, the Rt Rev James Jones, who is 63. A favourite of Tony Blair, he was also appointed by David Cameron to lead the Hillsborough inquiry.

He could be a "radical caretaker" able to begin the process of change before handing over to someone younger.

The Archbishop of York is the only candidate with a direct appeal to conservatives in the worldwide communion, whose views are shared by the Rt Rev Michael Nazir-Ali, former Bishop of Rochester, who says the new Archbishop must speak up for "marriage and family, justice and society".

But the need for change remains, he said. "The organisational structures of the Church need to be lightened so that it is flexible and able to respond to need."

For those who want a steadying hand, the Bishop of London, the Rt Rev Richard Chartres, is the candidate with the best establishment connections, as a close friend of the Prince of Wales. If he is considered beyond the pail because of his opposition to women priests, a popular choice for the role of steady caretaker is Bishop James, who said he was praying that God would not choose him.

It is possible the commission has chosen two names, and is secretly engaged in the formal processes that are necessary before an appointment can be made, such as a full medical examination.

Anthony Archer, a former member of the commission, said: "I think that's extremely unlikely. The announcement that they made was opaque, but it was code for saying. 'We haven't made our minds up.' If they had decided, they would not have made an announcement at that moment."

Mr Archer, who helped choose six bishops during his time on the commission, said: "The chairman has to knock heads together. If I was him I wouldn't have let the commission break up last week. I would have kept going for as long as necessary, until the job was done."

END

Sunday, September 23, 2012

ABC Williams and Bp. Nazir-Ali on Religion in Britain

http://www.virtueonline.org/portal/modules/news/article.php?storyid=16553

Archbishop Williams and Bishop Nazir-Ali on the place of religion in British public life
Paul Richardson
Church of England Newspaper
September 21st, 2012

With both Archbishop Rowan Williams and Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali producing books on the place of religion in Britain the press were bound to focus on the differences between them. Dr Nazir-Ali talks of a 'triple jeopardy for the West' from aggressive secularism, radical Islamism and multiculturalism and he criticises Dr Williams' suggestion that some kind of recognition be given to Sharia law. Dr Williams takes a more hopeful approach to Islam and worries less about the church being under attack by secularists.

The Archbishop distinguishes between procedural secularism and 'progammatic secularity' or secularism as an aggressive ideology and suggests not only that Christians can live with the former but that they have helped to shape it. He sees one of the dangers of secularism as being the adoption of a managerial, instrumental attitude to social policy but he does not think it actually sums up where we are as a nation.

Both Williams and Nazir-Ali claim that many of the values to which we are committed, such as belief in human equality and in the sanctity of human life, are rooted in Christianity. Nazir-Ali claims the common law was shaped by Christianity and warns that there are no free-standing moral values. He argues that the state must do more than balance the competing interests of different groups: it must provide a moral vision for the common good.

For Williams the situation is more complicated. He agrees that European culture has been heavily shaped by Christian culture but one aspect of this influence that he singles out is a readiness to look beyond appearances and to suspect any claim to final authority. People whose religion taught them to reject claims of inherited culture and to set the kingdom of God about the kingdoms of this world were bound to be seekers and sceptics. Moral values, including respect for human rights, can be traced back to Christian influence but so can the stress on the individual and on self-examination we see reflected in Western fiction and drama.

Like the Bishop, the Archbishop has questions about multiculturalism. He doesn't want to see people of different faiths and cultures isolated from each other. But unlike the Bishop, the Archbishop has a more dynamic understanding of culture that he understands as always growing and changing. We can't freeze British 'Christian' culture. We have reached a new situation in which people of different faiths and cultures want to join in the national dialogue and make their contribution to the development of our society.

Instead of a multiculturalism that seeks to keep the peace between separate groups with a minimum of government interference, Williams wants to see 'interactive pluralism' fostering dialogue and exchange between the communities. This is actually what many people mean by multiculturalism. For extremists and fundamentalists on all sides it is quite challenging but in the long run it is the only way to build up a sense of unity and national cohesion. 'Mutuality' is a key word for Dr Williams. He wants an 'argumentative democracy' in which people of all faiths and none participate. Secularists have to be ready to let believers call the state to account in the name of a higher authority.

Dr Nazir-Ali is more insistent on the dangers of militant Islamism and his warnings need to be heeded. But Dr Williams is more aware of the potential for Islam to make a contribution to public debate in Britain and in the long run the best way to defeat the people of violence is to ensure that this contribution is heard.

A crucial concept deployed by Dr Williams is that of irreversible moments in history in which changes take place, such as according equality to women or stopping child labour, that are no longer subject to discussion. Arguments about cultural relativity are not going to alter views on these topics. Dr Nazir-Ali is probably less convinced about this. His words about there being no 'free-standing values' suggest a danger that certain values that seem beyond debate today could be overturned in the future. Only time will tell who is right.

Williams and Nazir-Ali do not disagree about the importance of our Christian history or about the dangers in certain forms of multiculturalism but they see a different way forward. While there is shared ground in their discussion of religion and culture, there is less meeting of minds when it comes to economics and politics. The Bishop tells us it is not for religious leaders to say when a particular military mission is justified and how to conduct it; the Archbishop joined the Pope in criticising the Iraq War.

The Bishop is worried that a 'me-culture of personal fulfilment and gratification leaves no room for service, selflessness and sacrifice' and he agrees that moral values do not always influence the way the financial system operates but he is less critical of the capitalist system than the Archbishop. Two incisive Christian minds look at the Church and contemporary society. Both raise important question even if neither has all the answers. The Church of England should be grateful to have both as bishops.

(see Rowan Williams: Faith in the Public Square; and Michael Nazir-Ali: Triple Jeopardy; both published by Bloomsbury).
http://www.anglican-mainstream.net/2012/09/21/archbishop-williams-and-bishop-nazir-ali-on-the-place-of-religion-in-british-public-life/#more-64604

Tuesday, September 11, 2012

Anglican Head Rowan Williams Admits Mistakes in Handling Homosexual Issues

 
By Stoyan Zaimov, Christian Post Reporter
September 11, 2012|4:26 pm

Archbishop of Canterbury Dr. Rowan Williams, the spiritual head of the Anglican Communion, has admitted that he could have done more to stop the division that formed in the global body over the issue of homosexuality, and suggested that leading the church might be too much for one person to handle.

"Thinking back over things I don't think I've got right over the last 10 years, I think it might have helped a lot if I'd gone sooner to the United States when things began to get difficult about the ordination of gay bishops, and engaged more directly with the American House of Bishops," Williams, who is retiring from his position in December, shared with the Daily Telegraph.

The Anglican Communion experienced great divisional troubles over the ordination of Gene Robinson, the first openly gay bishop in the United States. Same-sex marriage has also been a controversial subject, with the American Episcopalian division of the Anglican community declaring its openness to include homosexual couples in the definition of marriage – something which Williams and the Church of England has strongly stood against in the U.K.

He was especially critical of Britain's Prime Minister David Cameron, whose push to legalize gay marriage in the country by 2015 has forced the church to stand up in defense of traditional marriage, but not without facing accusations of homophobia.

"Were we to accept same-sex marriage, that would be a doctrinal change – and the government doesn't do that for us. So I think it is a matter of reasonable anxiety," Williams said in the interview. He insisted that if the state's definition of marriage and the church's definition differ, then that would create a "tangle" for same-sex couples who want to get married at church.

The Archbishop of Canterbury highlighted, however, that the church has been wrong in the past to stand aside and not fight for the civil rights of gays and lesbians.
 
"We've not exactly been on the forefront of pressing for civic equality for homosexual people and we were wrong about that," Williams said. He added that he found one of the main problems in addressing tough issues to be the growing demands of the communion.

Williams suggested that some of his decisions as head of the Anglican Communion had disappointed both liberals and conservatives at times, and that there was a need for a "presidential figure" to be appointed in the Church of England so that they could share duties.

Elaborating on this "presidential figure," Williams said that this new role would allow someone to "travel more readily" when called to address important issues affecting the Anglican Communion, but the Archbishop of Canterbury would still remain the official head of the global body.

Despite these problems, the Anglican head reflected that he does not feel "glum" about the state of the church, as he gets ready for his retirement. "In fact, I feel rather positive about it. It's mattered immensely to me to be in a parish almost every Sunday, to be in the diocese regularly, to do the rounds, to be talking to people," he said.

Read more at http://global.christianpost.com/news/anglican-head-rowan-williams-admits-mistakes-in-handling-homosexual-issues-81460/#ifglK1bSHj5FyQYS.99